WBAUnofficial
Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile (/showthread.php?tid=4999)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - EastMidsBaggie - 06-11-2019

Unfortunately I posted pre and post the Villa games about the divergence of the two clubs depending upon the winners and it seems this is another unforeseen consequence.


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - GunsOfNavarone - 06-11-2019

(06-11-2019, 10:06 AM)Peachy Wrote: This is an absolutely massive blow and a real sign that all is not well. Harrison is the mastermind of that academy and along with Hopcroft have been instrumental in bring through all this quality.

If Hopcroft leaves as well (He turned down Man Utd and Everton not long back) we might as well give up the academy.


I honestly believe his decision is down to how the club is being run and how the contracts of good youngsters have been left to dwindle.

I really do fear for our club at the moment.

Gutted about this.

Oh and losing him to that lot too........

I wonder if giving up the academy and heading down the Brentford route of gambling on other club's cast offs is/has become our long term 'development' strategy?


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - billybassett - 06-11-2019

Not saying the guys not good at his job but in 13 years we've seen very little evidence of talent. Now maybe they're all about to hit the first team and so well done but I'd hardly call it catastrophic. In fact there's an argument to say after that long that a change is no bad thing


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - MGalea - 06-11-2019

(06-11-2019, 12:29 PM)billybassett Wrote: Not saying the guys not good at his job but in 13 years we've seen very little evidence of talent. Now maybe they're all about to hit the first team and so well done but I'd hardly call it catastrophic. In fact there's an argument to say after that long that a change is no bad thing

Starts watch..


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - Shabby Russian - 06-11-2019

There is no doubt that our production of youth players has improved over the past 13 years.

We seem to have developed some that have gone onto make a career in the game.

And the further we have gone into Harrison's tine in charge the more there seems to be coming through.

My quibble with youth development at the club may have nothing to do with him. But it is this, what happens to them when they reach the age of 18, they appear to stall. And sometimes this is just stalling at the club, both Roofe and Sawyers had to leave the club and take a step backwards before their careers seem to get back on track (for want of a better expression).

We seem to struggle with the final step with our youngsters that of assimilation into the first team.


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - Spandaubaggie - 06-11-2019

(06-11-2019, 09:50 AM)Squid Wrote:
(06-11-2019, 09:24 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I was only thinking last night about posting a long and detailed post about what a mess the club is in. A post that is derived from genuine insight rather than conjecture.

This is terrible news and compounds my view. The outcome of that play off game would only have delayed the inevitable.

The club will go a long way backwards before we can come forwards.

This is a blow for the club, undoubtedly.

It is also someone leaving a role which may have become slightly stale for more money elsewhere, which is something that happens all the time.

The determination to turn everything at the club to a Shakespearean tragedy is very unhelpful. Particularly when it's clear they see the solution to everything is to spend, spend, spend.
Very similar to my thoughts. It's unfortunate, but maybe the guy just needs a new challenge.


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - baggiebloke - 06-11-2019

(06-11-2019, 12:51 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There is no doubt that our production of youth players has improved over the past 13 years.

We seem to have developed some that have gone onto make a career in the game.

And the further we have gone into Harrison's tine in charge the more there seems to be coming through.

My quibble with youth development at the club may have nothing to do with him. But it is this, what happens to them when they reach the age of 18, they appear to stall. And sometimes this is just stalling at the club, both Roofe and Sawyers had to leave the club and take a step backwards before their careers seem to get back on track (for want of a better expression).

We seem  to struggle with the final step with our youngsters that of assimilation into the first team.

Yes, absolutely. Snagging as they transition from youth to first team football.


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - Hopalong - 06-11-2019

(06-11-2019, 02:47 PM)baggiebloke Wrote:
(06-11-2019, 12:51 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There is no doubt that our production of youth players has improved over the past 13 years.

We seem to have developed some that have gone onto make a career in the game.

And the further we have gone into Harrison's tine in charge the more there seems to be coming through.

My quibble with youth development at the club may have nothing to do with him. But it is this, what happens to them when they reach the age of 18, they appear to stall. And sometimes this is just stalling at the club, both Roofe and Sawyers had to leave the club and take a step backwards before their careers seem to get back on track (for want of a better expression).

We seem  to struggle with the final step with our youngsters that of assimilation into the first team.

Yes, absolutely. Snagging as they transition from youth to first team football.

Is it not the reality that a succession of managers going back to Megson if not longer have not seen them as being good enough for the first team (Saido excepted)?  

The adage is that if they are good enough they're young enough and will force their way in.  Why wouldn't they?  

However, there may be other factors?

For the past 20 years at least,  there has been an almost constant pressure (financial?) of either getting promotion or surviving in the prem and therefore not really the right conditions to blood young players.   

Another possibility is a 'diktat' from the top that the players who have cost millions and on high wages must be played?  (Burke excepted!)   So e.g. we sign Krychowiak  and pay him £106,000 a week.  Are we going to play Field or Harper?  Megson did against Spurs and Toon but he was soon gone!  

And I suppose if a Manager has signed and paid a lot of money for players it is potentially going to damage his reputation if he doesn't play them.  Look at Pulis season before last - playing Livermore, Krychowiak and Barry when it patently wasn't working!


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - Babel - 06-11-2019

Is there a tangible "buzz" aroud the club, a spirit of big things a-coming?

There was, for a few weeks under Moore and the "we, not me" parole allied with Barnes' trickery.


RE: Our Academy Manager is going to the Vile - TETLEY74 - 06-11-2019

personally I think the club is long overdue a complete root & branch reform/rebuild ,academy through coaching staff, manager team & owner we've become stale & stagnant if not regressing no one in authority seems to have(or project) any sort of strategy or long term plan for the club other than cut costs & hope someone pulls a rabbit out of the hat, and ask for the academy other than Saido name one player who has become an Albion regular in the 1st XI and/or who we've sold on for a tidy profit since its formation there's been plenty who have showed promise then dropped like a stone off the radar, you do have to ask is it as good as we think it is? Next season and the appointment of our next manager is absolutely massive for the long term future of this club fugg it up again and I fear a long return to the wilderness may just be around the corner those of us of a certain age have been here before and it wasn't a happy time, Jenkins & Dowling need to earn their corn now and us as fans have to get 100% behind however our next manager is and however pulls on the stripes no ranting & raving "fuck off your shit "at the first miss placed pass or mistake it needs to total support from first whistle till last if your just going to turn up to moan & groan fugg off we don't need you. Ok rant over as you where.