WBAUnofficial
Spam Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Spam Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=43194)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Spam Ratings - Lurker#3 - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 11:29 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Even the most knowledgeable football fans have blind spots and irrational opinions. Lurker would mark Molumby down if he kept Arsenals midfield quiet, scored a hat trick, assisted another 4 and had time to save someone's life at half time. He'd have picked up a yellow card, or one pass went astray. Just the way it is.

I was similar with Semi Ajayi, it happens.

Arf... As I say to my old man. Molumby could break into a lot of peoples houses, shag their missus, pinch their car and they would still let him off. It's all balance  Big Grin

Molumby did fine yesterday. But didn't do anything on top of that. That's why he got a 6. There wasn't anything which stood out in his game to get that extra mark. 6 is solid. And he should play v Southampton too. 

Compared to Diakite who had the second most duels won after Price, the second most accurate attacking third passes behind Styles and the most defensive contributions of any player not a CB.

Oh and I gave our Jays MOTM on my Preston ratings Fred.


RE: Spam Ratings - Birdman1811 - 11-01-2026

I refuse to believe anyone yesterday only gets a 6, we kept the strongest, most expensive team in the league quiet and dominated them, that doesn't happen if a midfielder only just does their job.


RE: Spam Ratings - Lurker#3 - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 11:49 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I refuse to believe anyone yesterday only gets a 6, we kept the strongest, most expensive team in the league quiet and dominated them, that doesn't happen if a midfielder only just does their job.

That's a matter of scoring preferences I think, mate. 6 to me is a solid performance, where you've done everything expected of you. Jays did that yesterday. In fact being so passive isn't always a bad thing for him because he doesn't make as many mistakes. 

We needed his experience and work rate yesterday. We will need it on Tuesday. We won't need him and Diakite next weekend. Horse and courses and all that.


RE: Spam Ratings - Birdman1811 - 11-01-2026

Oh I agree about not needing Molumby for every game.

For me 7 is a good, did what was needed performance, years of football manager I guess, 6 is, was a bit disappointing but not bad sort of mark.


RE: Spam Ratings - Bob Fossil - 11-01-2026

No-one lower than 7.


RE: Spam Ratings - Albionmad - 11-01-2026

Molumby was immense. Several times he went into tackles and came off worst.
Got up and carried on. 

He's also good at housery which these days every team needs.

I'd say he and Diakite are possibly the best defensive midfield pairing in the division.

Whilst not quite box to box he does get forward which creates problems for the opposition.

I think he's great.


RE: Spam Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 03:55 PM)Albionmad Wrote: Molumby was immense. Several times he went into tackles and came off worst.
Got up and carried on. 

He's also good at housery which these days every team needs.

I'd say he and Diakite are possibly the best defensive midfield pairing in the division.

Whilst not quite box to box he does get forward which creates problems for the opposition.

I think he's great.

Yeah, for most posters the old "Molumby never plays a forward pass" or "Molumby never creates anything" notions are dying out. Not quite for everyone though  Big Grin


RE: Spam Ratings - Majas magic - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 03:55 PM)Albionmad Wrote: Molumby was immense. Several times he went into tackles and came off worst.
Got up and carried on. 

He's also good at housery which these days every team needs.

I'd say he and Diakite are possibly the best defensive midfield pairing in the division.

Whilst not quite box to box he does get forward which creates problems for the opposition.

I think he's great.

When you add Collyer we do have 3 solid top end champ players in 5he centre of the park.


RE: Spam Ratings - Josh1873 - 11-01-2026

Has O'Leary had a bad game for us? Has he made a massive error that has led to a goal? I assume he has, but nothing springs to mind.

FWIW, maybe I'm being harsh, as it happened super fast in real time, but I do feel he should have done better for their goal. I wouldn't say it was a massive error, or anything, but certainly a save I'd expect him to make when seeing the replay. It did take a deflection off Styles, but it wasn't a huge deflection.

Let's say I'm right, he's human, so fuck it. It happens. I'm probably being overly critical, and wrong, though. Plus, he's set himself high standards now, sk a shot at the near post should be expected to be saved by a top Championship GK - which he is.


RE: Spam Ratings - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-01-2026

(11-01-2026, 05:52 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Has O'Leary had a bad game for us? Has he made a massive error that has led to a goal? I assume he has, but nothing springs to mind.

FWIW, maybe I'm being harsh, as it happened super fast in real time, but I do feel he should have done better for their goal. I wouldn't say it was a massive error, or anything, but certainly a save I'd expect him to make when seeing the replay. It did take a deflection off Styles, but it wasn't a huge deflection.

Let's say I'm right, he's human, so fuck it. It happens. I'm probably being overly critical, and wrong, though. Plus, he's set himself high standards now, sk a shot at the near post should be expected to be saved by a top Championship GK - which he is.

If you’re gonna beat a well-positioned ‘keeper at the near post, that type of chance 99% of the time gets deflected enough to take it wide enough to strike the post full-face or in slender enough an increased element that it hits him on the way back and goes down as an OG anyway. 

My first instinct is he won’t want to see it again. But the striker was very lucky. Especially if MOL has based his exact position on the shape of the striker’s boot (which is what 99.9% of decent keepers do when facing a penalty).

There was more than a slice of good fortune. Hopefully, the spotlight isn’t on that one moment, because we won. 

I’ve gone from being unsure on MOL (not due to poor performance, just due to Albion inexperience) to thinking he’s the best we’ve had since Palmer in his prime. Long may it continue - the lad is more than in credit. And the few detractors that remain will hopefully shut their traps also because anything that came within 12 yards of his goalline he came out and claimed.