WBAUnofficial
Toby Collyer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Toby Collyer (/showthread.php?tid=42427)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


RE: Toby Collyer - SW4Baggie - 08-17-2026

(08-17-2026, 08:40 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-17-2026, 08:22 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-17-2026, 08:13 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-17-2026, 06:40 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(08-17-2026, 06:29 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Totally agree about Smallbone. Collyer offers less than Molumby for me: no real vision and tends to play short passes, not as good ball winner as Molumby or Diakite and zero goal threat.

Really strange we are going for another CM when we are so clearly lacking on the right. I’d prefer Ogbene on loan.

Spot on that first para

Ogbene would be a real gamble - just wonder if we can aim higher
Seems to be a dearth of right wingers mate - other than the Norwegian lad that Ipswich bought last summer I can’t think of any we could go for other than SIJ inexperienced types.

Aye pal. I know we are well down the pecking order from our yoyo years but 
I was hoping for a quality loan from the promoted sides - ie someone who was a regular starter last year.  Ipswich must have Clarke, Philogene, Mehmeti and the Norwegian as wide options - irrespective of their summer business
You would imagine so mate. They also have Ogbene, McAteer, Fatawu, Enciso….

Problem is, all the promoted sides will have wage increases so they’ve gone from earning decent Championship money to PL money. A good player from Ipswich’s team last season would likely be on about 20k/wk and just about in reach for us on a one year loan, but that will usually have doubled upon promotion.

As the window goes on, the PL sides will be more accommodating in subsidising, but right now they’ll be waiting to see how desperate teams become.

We just have to be patient. I think we’ll get a couple more in yet.


RE: Toby Collyer - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-17-2026

There are some rose-tinted memories of Toby Collyer in this fred. It's hard to make any serious analysis of his potential based on the few minutes we saw last season. For the right fee, it's a risk that might pay off - if it doesn't we're in Dike or Bany territory, with the crucial difference that we should have seen it coming.

Can Collyer be the Mowatt replacement if he stays fit? Maybe. My fear is that we'll sign a midfielder of some sort, then Molumby will leave on deadline day, as he probably won't be a regular starter for us. So think of the new midfield signing as a Molumby replacement and ask yourself if Toby Collyer is that guy.


RE: Toby Collyer - Josh1873 - 08-18-2026

Are we in a position to take risks given what little funds we have available, or do we need to take risks due to what little funds we have available?


RE: Toby Collyer - SW4Baggie - 08-18-2026

(08-18-2026, 05:35 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Are we in a position to take risks given what little funds we have available, or do we need to take risks due to what little funds we  have available?

It’s a fair point Josh, but until we can either get promoted and receive parachute money, or highest increase our commercial revenue the only way we can make money and compete is by selling players profitably. If Collyer stays fit he could be worth £10-15M next summer, or he could play 10 games and leave us light in midfield all season again. 

Personally I prefer taking the risk on an unproven player that’s demonstrated they’re fit and will be available than those with undisputed quality but have fitness issues and would be stepping down, but I also get the point that if you fill your team with players from League One you tend to end up in League One.


RE: Toby Collyer - Gzbaggy - 08-18-2026

(08-17-2026, 09:25 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are some rose-tinted memories of Toby Collyer in this fred. It's hard to make any serious analysis of his potential based on the few minutes we saw last season. For the right fee, it's a risk that might pay off - if it doesn't we're in Dike or Bany territory, with the crucial difference that we should have seen it coming.

Can Collyer be the Mowatt replacement if he stays fit? Maybe. My fear is that we'll sign a midfielder of some sort, then Molumby will leave on deadline day, as he probably won't be a regular starter for us. So think of the new midfield signing as a Molumby replacement and ask yourself if Toby Collyer is that guy.

He is 22 and has yet to play a full match in either the Premier League or The Championship. Hull have more money than us so if they are not interested after his loan last season why should we be? His fitness record is also a concern.

As you say "it's hard to make any serious analysis of his potential"


RE: Toby Collyer - Bob Fossil - 08-18-2026

I don’t know how anyone can say either way on this lad as he’s barely kicked a ball. Fits very firmly into the “highly rated” category but we’ve had plenty of them before, two from the seals last year along with Mason at the helm.

Not saying Colyer couldn’t work I’d just rather see someone come in who has some games under his belt. CM is too important to take a risk on an unproven player with a poor injury record.


RE: Toby Collyer - Josh1873 - 08-18-2026

(08-18-2026, 06:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-18-2026, 05:35 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Are we in a position to take risks given what little funds we have available, or do we need to take risks due to what little funds we  have available?

It’s a fair point Josh, but until we can either get promoted and receive parachute money, or highest increase our commercial revenue the only way we can make money and compete is by selling players profitably. If Collyer stays fit he could be worth £10-15M next summer, or he could play 10 games and leave us light in midfield all season again. 

Personally I prefer taking the risk on an unproven player that’s demonstrated they’re fit and will be available than those with undisputed quality but have fitness issues and would be stepping down, but I also get the point that if you fill your team with players from League One you tend to end up in League One.

I think I'm on the side of taking a risk, for what it's worth. I liked the glimpses of what I saw last season. Tidy player, and what we needed on Saturday, in Mowatt's absence. 

The alternative is buying cheaply on bang average players, who appear to be fully fit, but may well get unlucky injuries anyway. I'd rather gamble on a quality player, and hope his injury troubles are behind him. It's not ideal, but that's where we are as a club.

It's tough, either way.


RE: Toby Collyer - Fido - 08-18-2026

(08-18-2026, 07:06 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I don’t know how anyone can say either way on this lad as he’s barely kicked a ball. Fits very firmly into the “highly rated” category but we’ve had plenty of them before, two from the seals last year along with Mason at the helm.

Not saying Colyer couldn’t work I’d just rather see someone come in who has some games under his belt. CM is too important to take a risk on an unproven player with a poor injury record.

Same here and agree that Smallbone would be a preferable option.


RE: Toby Collyer - SW4Baggie - 08-18-2026

(08-18-2026, 07:34 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-18-2026, 06:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-18-2026, 05:35 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Are we in a position to take risks given what little funds we have available, or do we need to take risks due to what little funds we  have available?

It’s a fair point Josh, but until we can either get promoted and receive parachute money, or highest increase our commercial revenue the only way we can make money and compete is by selling players profitably. If Collyer stays fit he could be worth £10-15M next summer, or he could play 10 games and leave us light in midfield all season again. 

Personally I prefer taking the risk on an unproven player that’s demonstrated they’re fit and will be available than those with undisputed quality but have fitness issues and would be stepping down, but I also get the point that if you fill your team with players from League One you tend to end up in League One.

I think I'm on the side of taking a risk, for what it's worth. I liked the glimpses of what I saw last season. Tidy player, and what we needed on Saturday, in Mowatt's absence. 

The alternative is buying cheaply on bang average players, who appear to be fully fit, but may well get unlucky injuries anyway. I'd rather gamble on a quality player, and hope his injury troubles are behind him. It's not ideal, but that's where we are as a club.

It's tough, either way.

I guess my downer on Collyer is that I just don't think he's similar to Mowatt. 

First half at least on Saturday we were hitting the ball long and watching it come back at us because we didn't have a player capable of picking the ball up from O'Leary or from a CB and progressing it. Collyer is very good at winning the ball and playing the simple pass, but I'm not sure he has the same visibility and range of passing Mowatt possessed.

For me, Smallbone is a much better option - and crucially he scores goals from MC, something we are really short of.


RE: Toby Collyer - Vinebaggie - 08-18-2026

On the twitter united fans are saying he shouldn’t be sold for anything less than, it’s a range, between £10M and £25M. Others don’t want him sold at all and only offered out on loan. They all seem to rate him based on a 45 minute performance against Leeds in Dublin. If he does come here they’ll be v v disappointed with the fee, shades of us and Periera