WBAUnofficial
Gary's Economics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Gary's Economics (/showthread.php?tid=42041)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-13-2026

(07-13-2026, 12:01 PM)Øssian Wrote:
(07-10-2026, 03:37 PM)baggy1 Wrote: SO GIVE US AN ALTERNATIVE!!!

Morning, B1...

One of our problems (the UK, that is, not the pair of us!) is that there’s an understandable but unhelpful inclination to be tactically vague when floating arguments for radical reform. It’s unsurprising: there’s a whole machinery of hostile print and broadcast media, ready to go into attack mode the minute that words like redistributive enter the conversation; there’s little in the way of equivalent counterweight. Something Andy Burnham is going to need to have a strategy for dealing with. 

Just by way of an example, an idea that’s been discussed on here, and at length elsewhere, is a Land Value Tax; presumably one of the attractions being (coastal erosion aside) the immutability and permanence of landholdings. That said, ownership is obviously easier to offshore than the actual acreage itself… 

As a concept I can see the attractions (including some which go way beyond fiscal - but that’s for another post), but anyone floating the idea of LVT would need to be clear about the mechanisms (valuation, collection, et al) and how they fit into the existing tax framework. That, for me at least, would mean absolute clarity that this is a replacement concept, rather than just another slice on top of existing property taxes. Without that clarity from the outset the idea doesn’t get past first exposure to daylight. It’s not as if existing property taxation - business rates and council tax in particular - aren’t badly in need of overhaul; but be ready for the backlash and have the rebuttals well rehearsed.

It's pretty simple, and a huge opportunity for encoraging growth.

You base LVT on the value of land, not the property or activity that takes place on that land. That means every landowner is directly incentivised to maximise the after LVT return from their land = growth.

You abolish the awful anachronism of Business Rates. A whole industry has been built around rates mitigation and avoidance. It distorts landlord behaviour and disincentivises business formation.

You abolish Council Tax and rid us of the outrage that a 2 up 2 down in Washington Tyne & Wear pays more in Council Tax than the King does for the Royal Residence at Buck Palace.

You abolish Stamp Duty / SDLT which is essentially a tax on labour mobility, a tax on downsizing, a tax on the provision of rental property and a tax on increasing the value of land use.

It doesn't matter where the ownership of land is domiciled. You pay LVT or the land is sequestered by the State.

LVT is the only tax that unites the left and right.
https://www.thetimes.com/money/tax/article/what-is-land-value-tax-andy-burnham-labour-jdgn9pdtn


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 07-13-2026

I know what you mean Oss and I think this is the modern day problem with politics in general. Any idea is murdered at birth rather than given the time for discussion and exploration to get to a reasonable compromise of a solution. We've also become so divided between the left and right that anyone looking for that middle ground gets shot down by both sides for opposite reasons. I'm not certain where we go from here but there is a good argument to almost scrap the system and start again. Proth and I come at this from different angles but the tax system has become that convoluted, with add-ons and exemptions everywhere, we need a complete reset and simplification, it is tripping over itself now.


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 07-13-2026

(07-13-2026, 01:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I know what you mean Oss and I think this is the modern day problem with politics in general. Any idea is murdered at birth rather than given the time for discussion and exploration to get to a reasonable compromise of a solution. We've also become so divided between the left and right that anyone looking for that middle ground gets shot down by both sides for opposite reasons. I'm not certain where we go from here but there is a good argument to almost scrap the system and start again. Proth and I come at this from different angles but the tax system has become that convoluted, with add-ons and exemptions everywhere, we need a complete reset and simplification, it is tripping over itself now.

Most ideas around taxation are murdered at birth because they're ill conceived and counter productive. Even then many escape. When they do, the distortions they introduce become worse and worse over time - Council Tax, Business Rates, the new IHT / Income Tax raid on pensions, the Triple Lock, the £100K income tax cliff edge, the Child Benefit cap - I could go on.

The reason LVT appeals is that it would unleash growth and mobility whilst raising no more in net taxation than the Godawful things it replaces.


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 08-03-2026

This is worth a bump to save having the same discussion over and again. If someone can put the explanation of what this Wealth Tax will look like then I'm all ears. For those that have no idea but want to keep shouting 'Tax the wealthy' and have not seen the above challenges then please have a read.


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-03-2026

The best solution seems to come from Frech ecconomist Gabriel Zucman. His proposal is for thos that have assests of over 100m then a notional tax rate of 2 % of assets should be expected. So if they have 100m and pay 2m in tax then no extra - if they pay less then they make up the difference. This is protected by an extended capture period (10 years maybe) so if they leave they are still liable.


RE: Gary's Economics - Jacko - 08-03-2026

Problem with Zucman's proposal is that (among other major flaws) it is reliant on this being a 'global' tax. Which is of course, entirely unworkable.


RE: Gary's Economics - baggy1 - 08-03-2026

Fuck this, I’m packing this all in. What’s the point when I’m forced to agree with Jacko.  Big Grin


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-05-2026

How do you tax illiquid assets like business holdings? Why are you taxing them again when they’re taxed already? What does this do to incentives? Who values such assets? What is the basis for valuation?


RE: Gary's Economics - petty sniper - 08-05-2026

Zucmans idea is to attempt to equalise taxation and to stop the super rich from eventually swallowing up all the assets. The value is not that complicated as most assets are tangible like shares in publicly listed companies, gilts, govt bonds, land and property. Other stuff such as art and collecables can be valued by experts. Insuranxe does this everyday and a newspaper produes a list every year. As banks now share financial data internationaly it has become easier. If the indidual is asset rich and cash poor then I guess they copuld liquidate some assets? As for the argument that it needs to be worldwide that is why it has an extended payment period to discorage leaving. As wth income tax it is an idea that Zucman envisages that would become equalised around the globe eventually. The moral argument is that the extremely rich pay little or no tax (Bezos claimed child support one year as he paid himself so little) yet benefit from the social and physical infrastructure paid for from the tax income


RE: Gary's Economics - Protheroe - 08-05-2026

For the super rich most wealth is held in unlisted business assets. Id love to know how you value those.

And if you’re already taxing business profits, what is the justification for further taxation?