WBAUnofficial
Who would you vote for? Genuine question - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Who would you vote for? Genuine question (/showthread.php?tid=40578)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - Duffers - 02-10-2026

I've historically voted Labour and whilst I'm not overly enamored with them at the moment they still represent the least worst option to me.

I wouldn't vote Reform if my life depended on it and as someone who lost a parent to Covid I can never bring myself to vote Tory either (never liked them before but fucking loathe them now).


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - richbaggie - 02-10-2026

(02-10-2026, 10:04 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here is a good example of how the lies can become reality for some and how racism is being used and normalised.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUcwBj_in9Y/?igsh=MTYxbDg0em5rdHl4NQ==

Along the same lines, regarding the pushing of the narrative that things are so bad, me and friends were talking recently about how much violence there was in the 80s and 90s. There was constant rucks between schools when I grew up between all the Sandwell schools around me. Rival gangs scrapping like the Brandhall Bootboys and Smethwick Hill Top which was mad at times. Local pubs would see scraps most weekends with some pubs being avoided at all costs because of it. Football violence made most Saturdays home and away like tip toeing through a minefield.

I know knife crime is horrendous these days but let's not pretend the 80s and 90s were a period of love and harmony.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - Protheroe - 02-10-2026

(02-10-2026, 10:21 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Farage led Brexit, which to all but the most stubborn and deluded is clearly the most stupid decision for this country in decades.
Reform is a hot potch of hate fuelled morons and far right Tories(the same Tories that had over a decade ruining the country and getting cast into the wilderness. To vote for them as a change is utterly bonkers. I'm also deeply suspicious of their backers.
As for the mess, if you want one catch all blame it's the banks. I've read a fair bit on this and clearing up the crash and saving the banking system in 2008 has fallen on all us. It's seen a generation of inflation eating at our incomes and austerity ruining the infrastructure.
Add the cost of Covid, the mess of Brexit, and dealing with a lunatic in America it's made running the country extremely difficult.
I hope Labour can turn it around in the next couple of years as they are the most stable solution to the mess we find ourselves in.

It's not "the banks", it's how the banking system was bailed out through the wholesale nationalisation of private debt.

As I said at the the time, and ever since - it is one thing protecting modest depositors, it is wholly another thing creating the moral hazard of encouraging risk without consequence.

Private debt markets now carry even more risk than the banks ever did, which will be the next crisis.

(02-10-2026, 10:28 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-10-2026, 10:04 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here is a good example of how the lies can become reality for some and how racism is being used and normalised.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUcwBj_in9Y/?igsh=MTYxbDg0em5rdHl4NQ==

Along the same lines, regarding the pushing of the narrative that things are so bad, me and friends were talking recently about how much violence there was in the 80s and 90s. There was constant rucks between schools when I grew up between all the Sandwell schools around me. Rival gangs scrapping like the Brandhall Bootboys and Smethwick Hill Top which was mad at times. Local pubs would see scraps most weekends with some pubs being avoided at all costs because of it. Football violence made most Saturdays home and away like tip toeing through a minefield.

I know knife crime is horrendous these days but let's not pretend the 80s and 90s were a period of love and harmony.

That said, I felt safer in spotlessly clean downtown Detroit than I ever do in Birmingham or London. The data will tell you I should have felt otherwise of course.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - Spandaubaggie - 02-10-2026

I think Proth, I should have said bailing out the banks. However, it was them who loaned money irresponsibly to people without money.
I pretty much agree with what you've said elsewhere. As ever, you're worth listening to, even if some disagree.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - baggy1 - 02-10-2026

One thing worth pointing out from above is Proth's comparison of Detroit (pop: 650k) with Birmingham (pop: 2.7m) and London (pop 10m). Having been to a bigger but comparable city recently, Nashville, I would agree that it is cleaner but the safety is a perceived one due to the locations and knowledge of the areas. Detroit was praised in the press for having less than 200 homicides during 2025 (the 1st time in 6 decades) which when compared to c.500 for the whole of the UK says statistically you are much safer anywhere in the UK than anywhere in the US.

One of the big things that you have to recognise in the US is space - Tenessee is roughly the size of England with approx 10% of the population. Michigan is the size of the UK with about 15% of the population. Safety may be perceived from not being as densely populated but isn't a reality.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - HawkingsHalfpint - 02-10-2026

(02-10-2026, 11:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: One thing worth pointing out from above is Proth's comparison of Detroit (pop: 650k) with Birmingham (pop: 2.7m) and London (pop 10m). Having been to a bigger but comparable city recently, Nashville, I would agree that it is cleaner but the safety is a perceived one due to the locations and knowledge of the areas. Detroit was praised in the press for having less than 200 homicides during 2025 (the 1st time in 6 decades) which when compared to c.500 for the whole of the UK says statistically you are much safer anywhere in the UK than anywhere in the US.

One of the big things that you have to recognise in the US is space - Tenessee is roughly the size of England with approx 10% of the population. Michigan is the size of the UK with about 15% of the population. Safety may be perceived from not being as densely populated but isn't a reality.

That difference in safety risk is embodied in one simple question asked by any travel insurance company - would you like your cover Worldwide excluding US and Caribbean, or including. If the risk were the same, they simply wouldn’t ask.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - Hudds2 - 02-10-2026

(02-10-2026, 10:28 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-10-2026, 10:04 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here is a good example of how the lies can become reality for some and how racism is being used and normalised.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUcwBj_in9Y/?igsh=MTYxbDg0em5rdHl4NQ==

Along the same lines, regarding the pushing of the narrative that things are so bad, me and friends were talking recently about how much violence there was in the 80s and 90s. There was constant rucks between schools when I grew up between all the Sandwell schools around me. Rival gangs scrapping like the Brandhall Bootboys and Smethwick Hill Top which was mad at times. Local pubs would see scraps most weekends with some pubs being avoided at all costs because of it. Football violence made most Saturdays home and away like tip toeing through a minefield.

I know knife crime is horrendous these days but let's not pretend the 80s and 90s were a period of love and harmony.
I have said this a lot.  The"aggro" from the late 60s onwards was palpable.  In the early to mid-70s, you always watched your back and had to be ready for violence to break out at any time.  This was time when the "Skinhead" paperbacks were very popular as a cultural phenomenon.  (Did you see I used the singular, not the plural "phemonena"?  We learned stuff at school between the boot being put in.  Kids today need to be be given a bit of aggro with their education.)


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - man in the corner shop - 02-10-2026

(02-10-2026, 11:20 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(02-10-2026, 11:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: One thing worth pointing out from above is Proth's comparison of Detroit (pop: 650k) with Birmingham (pop: 2.7m) and London (pop 10m). Having been to a bigger but comparable city recently, Nashville, I would agree that it is cleaner but the safety is a perceived one due to the locations and knowledge of the areas. Detroit was praised in the press for having less than 200 homicides during 2025 (the 1st time in 6 decades) which when compared to c.500 for the whole of the UK says statistically you are much safer anywhere in the UK than anywhere in the US.

One of the big things that you have to recognise in the US is space - Tenessee is roughly the size of England with approx 10% of the population. Michigan is the size of the UK with about 15% of the population. Safety may be perceived from not being as densely populated but isn't a reality.

That difference in safety risk is embodied in one simple question asked by any travel insurance company - would you like your cover Worldwide excluding US and Caribbean, or including. If the risk were the same, they simply wouldn’t ask.

They've also got to factor in risk in US of ICE detention.

https://www.limerickleader.ie/news/national-news/2011464/a-modern-day-concentration-camp-irish-man-locked-up-by-ice-in-us-fears-for-his-life.html


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - chasetownbaggie - 02-12-2026

I've voted for all 3 main parties left of the Tories. In 2024, I gave my vote to Labour for several reasons: tactically to get rid of the Tories and our cock MP Michael Fabricant; I saw in Keir the potential for sobre stable leadership; and I liked the policies they had for young people who have been ignored for too long.

So far, I have no regrets, and would vote for them again tomorrow. Our new MP is working hard for ALL his constituents. Keir has performed very well on the international stage IMO. Domestically, less so, but they are delivering on much of their manifesto and I think they deserve more than 18 months to do so.

Assuming there's an election in 2 or 3 years time, I suspect I'll be voting tactically to keep Reform out.


RE: Who would you vote for? Genuine question - SW4Baggie - 02-12-2026

My seat has been a very, very safe Labour seat for a long time, although the pro-Palestine candidate pushed it very close last time round.

I'll absolutely vote tactically at the next election... I think there's a decent chance Hall Green & Moseley could go LD or Green next time round, especially if the Palestine issue is less front of mind, so it'll be whichever party stands the best chance of preventing any Reform or Independent coming in.

LD or Green would probably best fit my politics these days, which is an odd combination, but both have interesting approaches to the economy even if slightly different and both are the only parties sensible enough to have the bollocks to undo the clusterfuck that is Brexit.

Then again, by the time the next election comes round, I may well be voting for Pedro Sanchez again!