WBAUnofficial
Change badly needsd - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Change badly needsd (/showthread.php?tid=40451)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Change badly needsd - CA Baggie - 02-02-2026

The problem isn't 3 or 4 at the back it's the midfield. We can't play with 2 in there. 352 system would, imo be ok, it just means dropping Johnson.

People say we're missing a RWB, we've just signed one. and have Alex Williams coming back. I believe Gilchrist polayed therre for Sheff U for half a season too.

A flat back has makeshift Left & Right backs.


RE: Change badly needsd - backsidebaggie - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It was already broken... It was just slowly falling to pieces. I would still rather us smash it to pieces, try and find a new identity which could work and have a 10 game mini season to save our asses.

The change needs to be from a "vision" perspective. It needs to be firm, unmistakable and not for discussion. Hopefully Nestor and his appointments of Mowbray and Mason were a lesson learned for Patel that not having a firm identity/DNA is damaging. Ur doesn't matter what league we are in, this has to be the absolute minimum we see.

We really don’t need a ‘vision’ at this time, we need a manager to get the best out of the squad they have, get organised, play, players in the positions they understand and give them simple instructions as to what is expected of them individually and collectively. Going down will set the club back years on and off the pitch.

Visions, philosophies are for managers who talk a great game, if you like football management speak, which is getting more cliched every year it seems. We’ve gone from philosophies to visions, DNA and moments and it’s all meaningless drivel. By all means in the future have a preferred way of playing and recruit accordingly but the pseudo  intellectual drivel that surrounds football currently is just an endless list of buzz words and catchphrases.

Correct! The amount of bullshit talked in football these days (by managers, and on forums like this) is extraordinary.

An identity? A vision? Fuckin hell, how about a 5 year plan with an 8 point progressive ambition matrix. Any other words that mean precisely fuck all?

Our identity is our navy blue and white stripes, a throstle etc. Waffle like this in relation to managers is bollocks. We need to concede less and score more. We need players in their right positions. We need not not nullify our most attacking threat (MJ). We don’t need any more catchphrases that mean precisely fuck all.

(02-02-2026, 10:36 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The problem isn't 3 or 4 at the back it's the midfield.  We can't play with 2 in there.  352 system would, imo be ok, it just means dropping Johnson.

People say we're missing a RWB, we've just signed one. and have Alex Williams coming back.  I believe Gilchrist polayed therre for Sheff U for half a season too.

A flat back has makeshift Left & Right backs.

Ok to drop our most threatening player of the season? I swear I’m in a parallel universe. 3 at the back has made us miles worse. Miles!


RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026

Our squad is just an unbalanced mess.

Why recall Whitwell? Why is Bostock not even being seen? What does Dike have to do for a chance? Not like him.getting injured again causes us any problems. How have Mepham and Phillips dropped off so badly? Why has Price lost all form? Why nullify Johnston, the one bright spark at times this season? Why has Heggebo gone back to being barely involved and chasing pointless balls over and over again?

I'm not normally one for saying stuff like 'fans could do better' and such, but honestly, some of our decisions this season have been truly baffling and have no sensible answer that I can see.


RE: Change badly needsd - Duffers - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 10:41 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It was already broken... It was just slowly falling to pieces. I would still rather us smash it to pieces, try and find a new identity which could work and have a 10 game mini season to save our asses.

The change needs to be from a "vision" perspective. It needs to be firm, unmistakable and not for discussion. Hopefully Nestor and his appointments of Mowbray and Mason were a lesson learned for Patel that not having a firm identity/DNA is damaging. Ur doesn't matter what league we are in, this has to be the absolute minimum we see.

We really don’t need a ‘vision’ at this time, we need a manager to get the best out of the squad they have, get organised, play, players in the positions they understand and give them simple instructions as to what is expected of them individually and collectively. Going down will set the club back years on and off the pitch.

Visions, philosophies are for managers who talk a great game, if you like football management speak, which is getting more cliched every year it seems. We’ve gone from philosophies to visions, DNA and moments and it’s all meaningless drivel. By all means in the future have a preferred way of playing and recruit accordingly but the pseudo  intellectual drivel that surrounds football currently is just an endless list of buzz words and catchphrases.

Correct! The amount of bullshit talked in football these days (by managers, and on forums like this) is extraordinary.

An identity? A vision? Fuckin hell, how about a 5 year plan with an 8 point progressive ambition matrix. Any other words that mean precisely fuck all?

Our identity is our navy blue and white stripes, a throstle etc. Waffle like this in relation to managers is bollocks. We need to concede less and score more. We need players in their right positions. We need not not nullify our most attacking threat (MJ). We don’t need any more catchphrases that mean precisely fuck all.


I'm not interested in "projects" or "philosophies" or any of that nonsense, but I would like the coaching team and key decision makers inside the club to sit down and decide how they want the team to play, what they need in terms of players and resources to so and come up with a plan to achieve it.

If we can bumble through to survival this year then that meeting needs to take place the day after the last game.


RE: Change badly needsd - backsidebaggie - 02-02-2026

It also strikes me how many posters who have been saying we should play a back 3 for the last few months are now saying formation doesn’t matter. Well how come so many were pushing for a back 3 every week under Mason if it doesn’t matter?

It does matter, massively. The gaps Portsmouth exploited are very much to do with the formation, and the fact we haven’t got a squad suited to it. The fact we were shit for the full 90 is partly to do with the formation.


RE: Change badly needsd - Peachofacross - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 10:44 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Our squad is just an unbalanced mess.

Why recall Whitwell? Why is Bostock not even being seen?  What does Dike have to do for a chance? Not like him.getting injured again causes us any problems. How have Mepham and Phillips dropped off so badly? Why has Price lost all form? Why nullify Johnston, the one bright spark at times this season? Why has Heggebo gone back to being barely involved and chasing pointless balls over and over again?

I'm not normally one for saying stuff like 'fans could do better' and such, but honestly, some of our decisions this season have been truly baffling and have no sensible answer that I can see.

Agree Birdy. I genuinely think a sensible fan could do better. Round pegs in round holes and inject a bit of life into it. I really wanted us to go for Hasstenhuttl or someone of similar standing and had reservations about Ramsay. Then I saw Ramsays interviews etc and he came across really well. Focused, determined, clear and concise. He also spoke about being adaptable etc so when he was appointed I was fairly optimistic that we would be ok.

The Ramsay that has turned up has so far not been adaptable at all and he is showing clear signs that he is well out of his depth in what is a very pressurised situation in the table.

We would look stupid to the outside world to pot him so soon however sometimes you just have to make very brave decisions. Celtic did it with Nancy after 33 days as they realised the club were falling away and the fans were not having him.

Anything but a win against Stoke and I think we need to make that decision.


RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026

We do need to decide how we want the club to play long term, since that process and working towards it is literally the DoF's job. We can't keep changing with every manager, as Man Utd have found, that simply doesn't work. Brentford for example have a very clear set way of playing that every player, coach and anyone else football side knows and can work in and with.

We did under Ashworth, defensively solid, quick transition into counter attack, danger on the flanks with a forward that acted as a focal point and target man. Dangerous at set pieces and overall, a way that was thought was best to use our meagre resources compared to others. Then we hired Pepe Mel and we all know what happened.

Football is both a short term and long term game, you can't just think long term and work towards it thinking the short term will look after itself, you need to make sure the team is prepared every season while working towards a longer vision. We don't seem to be doing that at all, just hoping we can finally get there if we find the right coach, or the right players. No real plan, no real thought.


RE: Change badly needsd - Lightnin - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 09:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 09:15 AM)Lightnin Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 08:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-02-2026, 07:37 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Or we could just change to a formation that suits the squad and put the round pegs in the round holes whilst working on patterns and moments in training.

Hello Ryan.

Hello, but I think you’ll find this is a new approach where we’re not going to use the square pegs. They can sit on the bench next to Daryl Dike.

What is the team and approach that you think suits the players, Lightnin?

Our squad is unbalanced. We’ve arguably sold one of the best right sides in the division and we’ve signed nobody that fits into these positions. The formation of 4-2-3-1 worked for us, especially at home but injuries plus chopping and changing ruined our rhythm in between games. Stick to what we know but improve the coaching or the personnel. It’s not the time for radical change, it’s like watching someone run a china shop when all the staff are bulls.

We’ve filled in the best we can with resources available but now should’ve been when we corrected it.


RE: Change badly needsd - CA Baggie - 02-02-2026

It's being over run in midfield that is the issue. We can't play 442 because of the inabilities of our midfield.

Mowatt - too slow and pondoerous - doesn't have the legs to get up and down. But can sit in a 3.
Molumby - lacks any sort of positional discipline or quality on the ball. Shouldn't be the player getting ahead of the forwards as lacks ability, yet can't be trused to sit and hold the midfield. Only effective in a 3 to run around a lot, press and be a link between a holder and more attacking midfielder.
Diakite - just seems to want to sit and break up play, Doesn't get up and down, lacks Mowatt's passing ability.
Price - I know he's a little gobsite after the weekend, I've still no idea what he is as a footballer. Could sill maybe be the attacking threat in a 3 or the legs alongside a sitter.
Styles - probably our most all round midfielder. Has Molumby's energy but can control the ball as well, has some passing ability and overall positional sense to him.
Whitwell - ?

It has to be 3 in the middle, but not 2 sitters. beyond that 3 or 4 at the back is less important. I think we actually have defenders who would be better in a 3, they're just injured. If a 3 means Charlie Taylor then got to a back 4.

And jusy play Dike. What are we saving him for? He'll only get match fit by playing and Maja wants to be anywhere bar our club and Heggey can't do it on his own.

For those not paying attention, 451 saw us lose 10 in a row away from home, and sinking towards relegation. We have to try something else.


RE: Change badly needsd - Birdman1811 - 02-02-2026

(02-02-2026, 10:51 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: It also strikes me how many posters who have been saying we should play a back 3 for the last few months are now saying formation doesn’t matter. Well how come so many were pushing for a back 3 every week under Mason if it doesn’t matter?

It does matter, massively. The gaps Portsmouth exploited are very much to do with the formation, and the fact we haven’t got a squad suited to it. The fact we were shit for the full 90 is partly to do with the formation.

I wasn't, not a fan of a back three if a team is struggling defensively, another centre back just causes more mistakes imo. It's the equivalent to Irvine and just throwing on another striker to score more goals,.it doesn't work like that.