WBAUnofficial
Phillips and Mepham - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Phillips and Mepham (/showthread.php?tid=40297)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Tom Joad 25 - 01-22-2026

Agree with much of this. I think Phillips could be a hero but he doesn't trust whoever is alongside him thus making bad decisions. I'm also not sure we need 3 centre backs mainly as it means playing 3 of our worst players at the expense of a better one.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 08:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I pin the blame for this seasons defensive frailties on the fact we regularly line up with a RB wearing 6, 2 and 3 at CB and a LB wearing 4. Makes me so cross even before we've kicked off.

As a follower of South American football, I can say that is how Argentina / Uruguay line up , with 5 being the defensive midfield / thug / hatchet man / Claudio Yacob type.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Fido - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 11:19 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(01-22-2026, 08:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I pin the blame for this seasons defensive frailties on the fact we regularly line up with a RB wearing 6, 2 and 3 at CB and a LB wearing 4. Makes me so cross even before we've kicked off.

As a follower of South American football, I can say that is how Argentina / Uruguay line up , with 5 being the defensive midfield / thug / hatchet man / Claudio Yacob type.

I prefer this in a 4-1-4-1 set-up to 3-5-1 any day of the week. Gives the option for full-backs to push on when the 5 drops plus they are in front of the centre halves to cut out fuggin long range shots that always seem to go in at the moment. 

The thing that worries me about 3-5-1 is I fear we might be playing it just to accommodate SIJ, he doesn't attack enough in wide areas to warrant his own formation and we don't have anyone who can really do that role on the right.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Bob Fossil - 01-22-2026

Phillips looks like a leader, but he just isn't. He's a decent but limited defender who needs a Bartley next to him doing some pointing! Mepham should be the leader, instead he seems a bit like the OP says, disinterested and too good for us. This fractures the entire back 5 ad I'm including Griffiths in that. They need a run without Mepham because a disinterested leader is counter productive. Campbell may not have the pedigree, but he has fight and enthusiasm so must come in. Bielik has also been disappointing but is another who hasn't had a run in his best position. Styles is also a positive influence so should immediately revert to LB now that we have fit CM's.

There's only one place Charlie Taylor should be and that's Southampton.

If we can get this right, then we are right back in it so just hope Ramsay wakes up and realises his experiment ended around 20:50 on Tuesday. If we get through this season and stay up then, maybe, with different personnel and a full pre-season, it will be a decent option, but, for the here and now, he needs to rip it up and adapt quickly.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - HeggebøsBarnDoor - 01-22-2026

I agree with that.

I also think between the four of them Campbell, Phillips, Beilik and Styles, playing as a back 4, there is less need for a stand out leader. I think that requirement comes more into play with you have younger players such as Gilchrist in the back line or when they are playing a less familiar 5 at the back.

I also think we would benefit from a period of stability and Ramsay somewhat nailing his colours to the mast on who he is going with for the foreseeable.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - MrBater - 01-22-2026

Liverpool said Phillips would run through brick walls for the cause, I've seen nothing like that from him.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - WorcsWBA - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 02:29 PM)MrBater Wrote: Liverpool said Phillips would run through brick walls for the cause, I've seen nothing like that from him.

He actually was doing that for us when we going well at the start of the season. It makes is all the more puzzling as to why he's gone so completely off the boil.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Duffers - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 11:19 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(01-22-2026, 08:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I pin the blame for this seasons defensive frailties on the fact we regularly line up with a RB wearing 6, 2 and 3 at CB and a LB wearing 4. Makes me so cross even before we've kicked off.

As a follower of South American football, I can say that is how Argentina / Uruguay line up , with 5 being the defensive midfield / thug / hatchet man / Claudio Yacob type.

Always wondered why Yacob wore 5.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Man from delmonte - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 02:29 PM)MrBater Wrote: Liverpool said Phillips would run through brick walls for the cause, I've seen nothing like that from him.

I don't doubt that Phillips is a warrior-type defender who will throw himself about, we have seen that at times, but his distribution is terrible, there's a lot of finger pointing from him and he seems to have an error in him pretty much every game. In differing ways I think he's just as bad as Mepham.

Whilst Ajayi no doubt was prone to errors he had the physical attributes to clean up after himself. I may be wrong but I don't think there were that many times when he dropped a clanger which directly led to the opposition scoring. Him and Bartley look like world beaters in comparison to Phillips and Mepham who must be two of our most disappointing signings for a long time.


RE: Phillips and Mepham - Hudds2 - 01-22-2026

(01-22-2026, 11:50 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Phillips looks like a leader, but he just isn't. He's a decent but limited defender who needs a Bartley next to him doing some pointing! Mepham should be the leader, instead he seems a bit like the OP says, disinterested and too good for us. This fractures the entire back 5 ad I'm including Griffiths in that. They need a run without Mepham because a disinterested leader is counter productive. Campbell may not have the pedigree, but he has fight and enthusiasm so must come in. Bielik has also been disappointing but is another who hasn't had a run in his best position.  Styles is also a positive influence so should immediately revert to LB now that we have fit CM's.

There's only one place Charlie Taylor should be and that's Southampton.

If we can get this right, then we are right back in it so just hope Ramsay wakes up and realises his experiment ended around 20:50 on Tuesday. If we get through this season and stay up then, maybe, with different personnel and a full pre-season, it will be a decent option, but, for the here and now, he needs to rip it up and adapt quickly.
I'm not biting.  Ypou know what I mean.