WBAUnofficial
Was JP right? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Was JP right? (/showthread.php?tid=39471)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Was JP right? - Tom Joad 25 - 11-27-2025

(11-27-2025, 06:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:57 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:16 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 04:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The more pertinent point is we will be if the owners don’t find ways of increasing our revenue and competing with our local rivals.

Precisely.

We have Birmingham with madly ambitious plans. Villa, who are now back to being one of the top clubs in the country, and the only crumb of comfort is watching Wolves implode after thinking they are ready to challenge the elite.

We have to think big. There is the fan base there and it has to be engaged with and buying into an exciting plan.

As far as I can tell currently there is no exciting plan… just flogging our best players at a profit in the hope we get better and if we don’t we bobble along in erm midtable Championship purgatory… a kind of glorified Crewe from the 1990s.

You keep saying this, despite being told repeatedly that we are under PSR restrictions. There's no point them laying out big plans for investment until those restrictions have gone. They've said they want us to be a PL club so I imagine achieving that aim is the priority.

I know we are under PSR restriction’s and every Championship club wants to be in the Prem. That doesn’t mean the club can’t can’t say what our plans are beyond this, it’s not Willy Wonka’s Chocolate Factory and we aren’t protecting the recipe for an ever lasting gobstopper. 

I will be delighted if we have proper plans in place to invest and will await the top secret plans to be revealed, if we don’t have any we will become the club JP described. Our two managerial appointments so far under Nestor are not making me optimistic.

I heard the proper plans include Premiership football, Europe, a sports village and to lord it over our nearest rivals who are shit. Oh, and a massive new ground with chimneys on. I think I read that.


RE: Was JP right - Derek Hardballs - 11-27-2025

(11-27-2025, 07:41 PM)Pie Fun Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 06:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:57 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-27-2025, 05:16 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: Precisely.

We have Birmingham with madly ambitious plans. Villa, who are now back to being one of the top clubs in the country, and the only crumb of comfort is watching Wolves implode after thinking they are ready to challenge the elite.

We have to think big. There is the fan base there and it has to be engaged with and buying into an exciting plan.

As far as I can tell currently there is no exciting plan… just flogging our best players at a profit in the hope we get better and if we don’t we bobble along in erm midtable Championship purgatory… a kind of glorified Crewe from the 1990s.

You keep saying this, despite being told repeatedly that we are under PSR restrictions. There's no point them laying out big plans for investment until those restrictions have gone. They've said they want us to be a PL club so I imagine achieving that aim is the priority.

I know we are under PSR restriction’s and every Championship club wants to be in the Prem. That doesn’t mean the club can’t can’t say what our plans are beyond this, it’s not Willy Wonka’s Chocolate Factory and we aren’t protecting the recipe for an ever lasting gobstopper. 

I will be delighted if we have proper plans in place to invest and will await the top secret plans to be revealed, if we don’t have any we will become the club JP described. Our two managerial appointments so far under Nestor are not making me optimistic.


You continue to fail to grasp the concept that Patel is an investor, and as such ROI is his goal. 

He will invest his money wherever generates the greatest ROI. Simples.   

We will find out this for sure next summer when PSR restrictions will be massively lifted and if Patel injects capital to pay off the the MSD loan.

Until then, feel free to continue to scream like the spoilt little girl in Charlie & the Chocolate factory.  “I WANT IT NOW”. Big Grin

But I do agree with you re Patel not managing expectations re a plan.  That’s something I kept going on about after the takeover, whilst the majority on this dump were having a group wank over his playlist. Even Lai managed fans’ expectations immediately, by stating the club would be ran on a self sufficient basis.  Patel has yet to state how the club will be ran.

With Nestor stating in the Summer, that we’d already spent the Fellows money, points towards a self sufficient basis. 

Yes, I’m grateful for Patel keeping the club afloat. But I think some need to re-adjust their expectations on how the club will be managed / financed going forwards.

I don’t have any expectations with regards to what the owners plans are. I’m just saying what I think will happen to the club if we don’t see investment and try and become self sufficient in the Championship without Prem money.


RE: Was JP right - Peachofacross - 11-27-2025

(11-27-2025, 07:41 PM)Pie Fun Wrote: With Nestor stating in the Summer, that we’d already spent the Fellows money, points towards a self sufficient basis. 

Yes, I’m grateful for Patel keeping the club afloat. But I think some need to re-adjust their expectations on how the club will be managed / financed going forwards.

The issue I have with that is I can no longer see many players of value. Price maybe. Griffiths? I am certain one of Masons mandates given to him by Nestor would have been to integrate our best youngsters into the side. Other than a couple of cameos from young Alex Williams before he got injured and 5 minutes from Bostock the youth have been left out of the squads now.

Half hope that we bring back Whitwell as a number 10 in January. If we ain't going up or down then it's a perfect opportunity to get some Championship minutes into him and see how he looks. Especially if he ain't going to pick Bany. We need some creativity from somewhere other than MJ.


RE: Was JP right? - Gzbaggy - 11-28-2025

"Integrate our best youngsters"
We seem to have little interest in doing that, we will give them a few minutes as a sub then let them go to succeed elsewhere, Cleary being the latest.
Which youngsters have we picked to start a league match? The most recent are Griffiths, Palmer, O'Shea, Field.
We would far rather give ageing players one last go in the name of "experience", Taylor being the latest on that list.


RE: Was JP right? - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-28-2025

To me, all of this pseudo-intellectual wailing and gnashing of teeth over the absence of a publicised plan is almost as amusing as the sense of entitlement the same expect of it. It’s also oddly ironic that the very man referenced to (and, in a way, owing to the manner with which our relatively modest successful spell aligned completely with the not-so-modest lining of his pockets, is still revered by some) didn’t really broadcast much about his plan either. Nor indeed the inner workings of his dealings, save for those exposed by S4A. In fact, the detail that he did broadcast at much greater volume was the sad (and somewhat derogatory) reality that we are indeed landlocked club; fighting for loyalty revenue amid a locally competitive market. What I can’t recall him referencing - but is increasingly much more pertinent to the challenge - is the overwhelming growth of the larger clubs, and their own self-sustaining national and global appeal. In summary, an already unlevel playing field is becoming one of much steeper gradient for clubs like ours, and - from where I sit at least - the mechanics underpinning any semblance of ‘plan’ relies completely (as said above) upon two things - overarching PSR (a finite restriction) and the prospect of promotion (a less likely eventuality).

To me, this ‘plan’ everyone pines for is remarkably straightforward. It doesn’t really need stating, any more than any self-respecting owner would want to nail his colours to fleshing it out in any greater detail; heaven forbid the likely eventuality he fails to achieve it. But let’s say that he does, well… what do people want to see in it? Shilen saying we WILL be an established EPL club in 2, 3, or maybe 5 years? That we will invest x, y or z in the first team squad? That 3 or 4 youth players a year will make it? How can he with so many variables?

Or what else? That we will invest in land we don’t have or won't repurpose (beyond a shitty Greggs) to build an expensive, shiny new commercial megaplex on the shitty side of a comparatively impoverished city that doesn’t need it, in the vain hope of moving jobs from one location to another to attract these golden unicorn ‘extra revenues’ that will only become another major millstone should we fail to attract them, or worse still another vessel via which to siphon funds? Or maybe that fabled extra tier, when we fail to sell out anyway, all the while streaming continues to be a piece of piss, affordability continues to dwindle, meanwhile matchday revenues continue to play second fiddle to broadcast incomes (by some considerable margin)? At what point does it go from being a lofty ambition, to an utter delusion?

I think it’s pretty simple what the plan needs to be, really. When I was growing up it was simply called ‘doing a Charlton’, and - for a 3 or 4 year period - we transitioned from being a yo-yo club to actually somehow achieving it (largely thanks to stealing a march in terms of transfer innovation and amortisation, investing ~75% wisely in players more or less at the pinnacle of their ability, and reaping the massive fortune of an excellent incumbent DoF and head coach pairing in place at the time). That is before JRP realised that for every position higher attained in the league, the investment required had to increase exponentially, and that it was perhaps best to remain a cash cow before selling high while he still could. The rest is much-debated history.

Nowadays, I’d call it (and simply aspire to) ‘doing a Bournemouth’, and worry about everything else, chimneys and all, at a later date. So much depends upon the two immediate factors above, and until we sort those out (which is looking increasingly like it might require a change in senior management; and if so, so be it) I think the rest is just fantasy. So why write and publish a 'plan' which is hopefully anything but, not least whilst we are still clearing the decks of the last lot. I agree that next summer will be when we really do learn a lot more about how he intends to play it, and so of course until then it remains to be seen if Shilen good/bad, the real deal or just a naive hopeful. But in spite of his reluctance to publish this or pay off that in a manner which some squeal about, for now at least he isn’t Lai and pals; and if Nestor really is the chump he is beginning to appear then sooner or later our good/bad* brilliant/twattish* saviour/pennypincher* owner will realise the who, the how and the why his returns are rapidly diminishing, sooner or later.


*delete as appropriate come September 2 next year.


RE: Was JP right? - Derek Hardballs - 11-28-2025

(11-28-2025, 07:29 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: To me, all of this pseudo-intellectual wailing and gnashing of teeth over the absence of a publicised plan is almost as amusing as the sense of entitlement the same expect of it. It’s also oddly ironic that the very man referenced to (and, in a way, owing to the manner with which our relatively modest successful spell aligned completely with the not-so-modest lining of his pockets, is still revered by some) didn’t really broadcast much about his plan either. Nor indeed the inner workings of his dealings, save for those exposed by S4A. In fact, the detail that he did broadcast at much greater volume was the sad (and somewhat derogatory) reality that we are indeed landlocked club; fighting for loyalty revenue amid a locally competitive market. What I can’t recall him referencing - but is increasingly much more pertinent to the challenge - is the overwhelming growth of the larger clubs, and their own self-sustaining national and global appeal. In summary, an already unlevel playing field is becoming one of much steeper gradient for clubs like ours, and - from where I sit at least - the mechanics underpinning any semblance of ‘plan’ relies completely (as said above) upon two things - overarching PSR (a finite restriction) and the prospect of promotion (a less likely eventuality).

To me, this ‘plan’ everyone pines for is remarkably straightforward. It doesn’t really need stating, any more than any self-respecting owner would want to nail his colours to fleshing it out in any greater detail; heaven forbid the likely eventuality he fails to achieve it. But let’s say that he does, well… what do people want to see in it? Shilen saying we WILL be an established EPL club in 2, 3, or maybe 5 years? That we will invest x, y or z in the first team squad? That 3 or 4 youth players a year will make it? How can he with so many variables?

Or what else? That we will invest in land we don’t have or won't repurpose (beyond a shitty Greggs) to build an expensive, shiny new commercial megaplex on the shitty side of a comparatively impoverished city that doesn’t need it, in the vain hope of moving jobs from one location to another to attract these golden unicorn ‘extra revenues’ that will only become another major millstone should we fail to attract them, or worse still another vessel via which to siphon funds? Or maybe that fabled extra tier, when we fail to sell out anyway, all the while streaming continues to be a piece of piss, affordability continues to dwindle, meanwhile matchday revenues continue to play second fiddle to broadcast incomes (by some considerable margin)? At what point does it go from being a lofty ambition, to an utter delusion?

I think it’s pretty simple what the plan needs to be, really. When I was growing up it was simply called ‘doing a Charlton’, and - for a 3 or 4 year period - we transitioned from being a yo-yo club to actually somehow achieving it (largely thanks to stealing a march in terms of transfer innovation and amortisation, investing ~75% wisely in players more or less at the pinnacle of their ability, and reaping the massive fortune of an excellent incumbent DoF and head coach pairing in place at the time). That is before JRP realised that for every position higher attained in the league, the investment required had to increase exponentially, and that it was perhaps best to remain a cash cow before selling high while he still could. The rest is much-debated history.

Nowadays, I’d call it (and simply aspire to) ‘doing a Bournemouth’, and worry about everything else, chimneys and all, at a later date. So much depends upon the two immediate factors above, and until we sort those out (which is looking increasingly like it might require a change in senior management; and if so, so be it) I think the rest is just fantasy. So why write and publish a 'plan' which is hopefully anything but, not least whilst we are still clearing the decks of the last lot. I agree that next summer will be when we really do learn a lot more about how he intends to play it, and so of course until then it remains to be seen if Shilen good/bad, the real deal or just a naive hopeful. But in spite of his reluctance to publish this or pay off that in a manner which some squeal about, for now at least he isn’t Lai and pals; and if Nestor really is the chump he is beginning to appear then sooner or later our good/bad* brilliant/twattish* saviour/pennypincher* owner will realise the who, the how and the why his returns are rapidly diminishing, sooner or later.


*delete as appropriate come September 2 next year.

Doing a Bournemouth was thanks to the owner spending millions in the Championship. Ourselves getting to the Prem was thanks to Megson the Magician… all of our success thereafter was down to Prem TV money.


RE: Was JP right? - Spandaubaggie - 11-28-2025

Firstly Hawks, what an excellent and intelligent post. Really can’t praise it high enough. You’ve nailed it.
I think what you succinctly said is something many overlook, which is the level of wealth that the giant clubs now have.
Also clubs like West Ham, who I saw as similar in terms of support to us as a kid, now have a 55,000 stadium in a global city, where Liu Liu and his mates over from Beijing can see a game on a Saturday.
The football tourist thing is becoming a bigger deal.
I think the Jeremy Peace landlocked mid Champ club is something that has really got under our skin. It has been taken out of factual reality and it deserves little attention. After all historically it has shown that we have been a top tier club and until very recently we had 8 seasons in a row in the Prem.
I caught up with the Liquidator podcast a couple of days back where Chris Lepkowski said that we have to find ways to compete in the W Mids, and this is a very important point, in the light of the ambition Blues are showing.He mentioned we are a town competing v city clubs, which I disagree with.
I personally have barely ever been to West Bromwich in my life.
Much of our supporter base is all over the densely populated W Mids conurbation and right onto the edges and beyond of Brum.
Sandwell, Dudley, parts of Worcestershire are all in our zone.
I think in the big scheme Patel knows simply it’s about getting us into the Prem. It’s the only thing that matters.
As has been said, we’ll start seeing how ambitious he is soon enough.
For now though, I personally think a mid table season is likely/ acceptable and we then will kick on and have a better clue of the club’s future.


RE: Was JP right? - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-28-2025

Yes, family ties play a big part in our attendance. I grew up in Wolves but my grandparents lived in Carter’s Green, my folks grew up in West Brom and Warley. Like many boomers they moved west. Agreed that the M5 corridor makes for a lot of other further-afield Baggies.

Football tourism has to start somewhere, and that is on the pitch. Spending millions in the championship has for a while been difficult recently (still amazed we were able to fund the Johnson and Heggebø transfers but thankfully both appear very good business); next year will be whether or not and if so the extent to which we see Patel’s appetite for it.


RE: Was JP right? - MrBater - 11-28-2025

if Luton can play in the Prem, most teams can. You just need one really good season in the Champ and your club's fortunes can change massively, look at fuggin' Brighton, Brentford etc... I bet even JP would have listed them as below mid table Champ teams.

(11-27-2025, 10:29 AM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Do a graph of our end of season league position using 44 positions (top of champ would be pos 21) since we were promoted at Wembly v Port Vale and highlight when JP joined and left us. I'm sure someone could and stick it on here

JP is statistically wrong, as since 1993/94 our average finishing position in the top 2 divisions comes in at 23. So we're a top 3 Champ team, in the last 31 years.
That covers 1993-94 to 2023-24, worst was 41, best was 8.

Going up to 2016-17 when he sold us, the average is actually not too different, 24 seasons, average finish was 22.3 (so more like a top 2 Champ team)
HOWEVER, Peace took over in 2002, so had us for about 14 seasons, and in that time period our average finish was 19.3, so actually a relegated Prem team.

And here's the requested chart....
[Image: finish.png]