WBAUnofficial
Grady - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Grady (/showthread.php?tid=39429)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Grady - Ted Maul - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 09:14 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The fact we ended up with Mowbray proves the point. There's not a chance the same data model spits out Wicky first and then Mowbray. He deviated and went on feel and emotion and it bit us in the arse. Quite what data he looked at to arrive at Mason is another discussion entirely.

Parameter 1 Young
Parameter 2 Cheap
Parameter 3 Available
Parameter 5 Winning Football.

Parameter 4 Makes good lists?  Big Grin


RE: Grady - Derek Hardballs - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 09:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 07:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 12:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-23-2025, 11:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Considering we have people falling over themselves to praise shit like Molumby, I can't take any criticism of a footballer like Grady seriously.


Yeah, by using those statistics that all football clubs use to measure the impact of specific players, you can prove he was one of our best attacking players. 

You'll be arguing the earth is flat next because "you can prove anything with stats"

You don’t judge a player just on stats, but if it makes you happy ‘Grady was almost always the best attacking player for us on the pitch every time he played’.

You do, Dekka. It's how players are rated, judged, improved, trained, identified, valued and signed across the world.

Players should never just be judged on their stats, it will never give a rounded picture of a players contribution. I mean you can but that’s when you end up saying Grady was almost always the most effective attacking player on the pitch when he clearly wasn’t on many, many occasions. 

Also when you hide behind stats for decision making, you end up with Mowbray as manager for example. They aren’t infallible guides to a player or manager, they are just one tool by which some things can be measured.

You take a very black and white view to this Dekka. Obviously there are games where Grady contributed nothing. Guess what, you can prove that with statistics too. Stats get brought into it when people make demonstrably false statements about players who in their opinion are poor, when it can be proven that compared to the rest of our squad and their peers in this division, they are not. 

Out of interest, who was our most effective attacking player in the pitch in the 23-24 season?

The fact we ended up with Mowbray proves the point. There's not a chance the same data model spits out Wicky first and then Mowbray. He deviated and went on feel and emotion and it bit us in the arse. Quite what data he looked at to arrive at Mason is another discussion entirely.


Nestor talked specifically and at length about the stats that informed his decision making when employing Mowbray. It was in the interview on either WM or the official website. 

Stats are just one tool, they rely on humans to both measure and interpret and are therefore open to mistakes and bias just like any other judgment call. They also skew the reading of games and can be fad driven. An example of this is the Val Ball bullshit, where the entire tactics were lobbing the ball into the 18yard box as quickly as possible, because that’s where most goals are scored from. It took other teams about ten games to work out that if they just sat deep our algorithmic approach fell apart as we laboured with players like Diagana trying to break them down. 

Stats are a blunt tool, they lack nuance and can be used to prove and disprove pretty much any position someone takes on a subject.


RE: Grady - Vinebaggie - 11-24-2025

Are there stats on Grady that show how often he lost the ball in dangerous positions, passed the ball to the opposition leading to them scoring a goal, gifted free kicks on the edge of our box? just asking for a friend.


RE: Grady - Ted Maul - 11-24-2025

Not sure why you're going off on one about Val here, this is a discussion about Grady being underrated by our fans.

You've still not said, based off your Spidey senses, who had a significantly better attacking output than Grady for us over the last few seasons. I can think of perhaps one player.

(11-24-2025, 09:53 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Are there stats on Grady that show how often he lost the ball in dangerous positions, passed the ball to the opposition leading to them scoring a goal, gifted free kicks on the edge of our box? just asking for a friend.

There will be if you want to dig them out. 

The caveat to stats is that Grady in the position he played should be losing the ball more than most players. He's in the team to take players on and attempt higher risk passes. Eze and Saka gave the ball away most for Arsenal yesterday, didn't see any clamour from their fans to drag them off at HT.

Different positions will have a different set of metrics that clubs will use to assess a player's impact.


RE: Grady - Lurker#3 - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 09:05 AM)MrBater Wrote: Stats Smatsch
looking at the Coventry stats for their goals; 1st goal - xg 0.08, XG on target - 0.26... so from that Josh should have saved it?  goal 2; xg 0.14 on target xg- 0.51, again josh should save that 50% of the time.... Goal 3 xg 0.05, on target xg 0.27 so again he should have saved it... But nobody is saying he had a mare and should have saved 2 of the three, but the stats suggest otherwise.

In comparison Heggebo's first their keeper shouldn't (and didn't) save it, on target xg of 0.97, the second he should have....(xg on target 0.27)

Maybe Mason just looks at the stats and not the game and then makes changes from the stats, maybe MJ's stats weren't as good as 2 assists sound!?

1st - xg was so low as it was a header from 13 yards, from an angle with 3 players in between attacker and goal. It improved because it was on target but there was still risk. If you did that 100 times 75% of them would likely be blocked. It happens. 

2nd - Again low xG as it is a headed chance, but when he made contact it was made into a good chance with a good header. 

3rd - Such low xG as it was a volley from an angle with so many bodies blocking. Very similar to their first in terms of risk. 

This is why you have to apply nuance and logic to any stats and not use them in isolation. Especially xG in isolation.

IN regards to MJ's stats... in only 45 he had the most shot creating actions, most goal creating actions, most progressive carries, joint most actions into the penalty area, most key passes.


RE: Grady - backsidebaggie - 11-24-2025

Stats have become way overplayed.

Yes they’re useful. But football is a game of dynamic interaction and dozens of things that players do in games aren’t reflected in stats. They can’t be. Stats are a way of trying to break down an individual performance, but it can only go so far in football as so much relies on something another player does.

There are infinite examples of things that happen in games that aren’t reflected in stats and data.

It’s way too black and white a way of looking at players, and managers. But it’s a bit of a fad at the moment that is being way overplayed. Our “data” and stats this season have signed a right comical lot.


RE: Grady - yeoman lai - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 11:38 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Stats have become way overplayed.

Yes they’re useful. But football is a game of dynamic interaction and dozens of things that players do in games aren’t reflected in stats. They can’t be. Stats are a way of trying to break down an individual performance, but it can only go so far in football as so much relies on something another player does.

There are infinite examples of things that happen in games that aren’t reflected in stats and data.

It’s way too black and white a way of looking at players, and managers. But it’s a bit of a fad at the moment that is being way overplayed. Our “data” and stats this season have signed a right comical lot.

The inevitable fallout from Football Manager games. 

As heard/seen on radio/forums frequently.. "I've taken Sudbury Lane Paperboys 2nd XI to The Champions League Final, so I obviously know more than Amorim/Tomas Frank etc.."


RE: Grady - Derek Hardballs - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 09:57 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Not sure why you're going off on one about Val here, this is a discussion about Grady being underrated by our fans.

You've still not said, based off your Spidey senses, who had a significantly better attacking output than Grady for us over the last few seasons. I can think of perhaps one player.

(11-24-2025, 09:53 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Are there stats on Grady that show how often he lost the ball in dangerous positions, passed the ball to the opposition leading to them scoring a goal, gifted free kicks on the edge of our box? just asking for a friend.

There will be if you want to dig them out. 

The caveat to stats is that Grady in the position he played should be losing the ball more than most players. He's in the team to take players on and attempt higher risk passes. Eze and Saka gave the ball away most for Arsenal yesterday, didn't see any clamour from their fans to drag them off at HT.

Different positions will have a different set of metrics that clubs will use to assess a player's impact.

Because I was making a wider point about managers and (I’ve read some coaching books and listened to a few podcasts) fans putting far too much emphasis on stats. Val Ball is a great example of a manager boiling the game down into a formulaic tactic based on statistics … get the ball in the box as quickly as possible as that’s where the majority of goals are scored.

If we want to talk specifically about Grady, he is lightweight, he did get knocked off the ball too easily, he did make bad choice and run into blind alleys and he had become beset by jiggly injuries and the team struggled to score with and without his input. 

He has undoubted ability, he can be a match winner but his contribution to the team wasn’t as positive or at least effective as his stats suggests.


RE: Grady - Wednesburybaggie - 11-24-2025

Grady was made to look better than he actually was by Pereira. MP had the gift of being able to beat opponents easily and to give a pass leaving his teammates in space and in great positions. Telling that Gradys firm dropped off when MP left us.


RE: Grady - MrBater - 11-24-2025

(11-24-2025, 11:28 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 09:05 AM)MrBater Wrote: Stats Smatsch
looking at the Coventry stats for their goals; 1st goal - xg 0.08, XG on target - 0.26... so from that Josh should have saved it?  goal 2; xg 0.14 on target xg- 0.51, again josh should save that 50% of the time.... Goal 3 xg 0.05, on target xg 0.27 so again he should have saved it... But nobody is saying he had a mare and should have saved 2 of the three, but the stats suggest otherwise.

In comparison Heggebo's first their keeper shouldn't (and didn't) save it, on target xg of 0.97, the second he should have....(xg on target 0.27)

Maybe Mason just looks at the stats and not the game and then makes changes from the stats, maybe MJ's stats weren't as good as 2 assists sound!?

1st - xg was so low as it was a header from 13 yards, from an angle with 3 players in between attacker and goal. It improved because it was on target but there was still risk. If you did that 100 times 75% of them would likely be blocked. It happens. 

2nd - Again low xG as it is a headed chance, but when he made contact it was made into a good chance with a good header. 

3rd - Such low xG as it was a volley from an angle with so many bodies blocking. Very similar to their first in terms of risk. 

This is why you have to apply nuance and logic to any stats and not use them in isolation. Especially xG in isolation.

IN regards to MJ's stats... in only 45 he had the most shot creating actions, most goal creating actions, most progressive carries, joint most actions into the penalty area, most key passes.

Yes, but what were MJ's defensive stats, being SIJ is better at defending according to Mason and that was why he was put on...

(11-24-2025, 09:16 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 09:14 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The fact we ended up with Mowbray proves the point. There's not a chance the same data model spits out Wicky first and then Mowbray. He deviated and went on feel and emotion and it bit us in the arse. Quite what data he looked at to arrive at Mason is another discussion entirely.

Parameter 1 Young
Parameter 2 Cheap
Parameter 3 Available
Parameter 5 Winning Football.

Parameter 4 Makes good lists?  Big Grin

'Arf, nah Nestor's AI prompts messed up Big Grin