WBAUnofficial
Full backs - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Full backs (/showthread.php?tid=39103)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Full backs - AnelkasBeard - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 09:14 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: If Williams was fit he'd surely be starting games. He looks a player.

@AnelkasBeard - surely we should be picking a formation that best suits the sum of our parts, and if that means MJ misses out, then so be it. I really like him, he's had a very good start to the season, but I wouldn't say he's so good you'd build a team around him, or shoehorn him in. Is he? I mean, I could be wrong on that.

I don't disagree, but he's the only player we have with some proper pace and dribbling ability. Take him out and we're even more one-dimensional.


RE: Full backs - fuzzbox - 10-23-2025

I don't blame the club for selling Furlong. He wanted to go and we got a good price for him.
What I don't understand is why didn't we get a replacement? If it was meant to be illing, why isn't he playing there? 

Playing Campbell out of position doesn't make any sense and honestly, it's not fair on Campbell. He's new to the country, new to the club and I would imagine he wants and needs to make a good impression. How do we help our player settle? In a league he has no experience of, we play him in a position he doesn't really know.

How's he supposed to build confidence? If he gets through this, I'll be impressed. Patience is short in this league, he needs a chance to build it. The only way he can do that is by letting him play in the position he's been trained for - even if it's just for a couple of games.


RE: Full backs - Tom Joad 25 - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 09:22 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I like a back three, done right it can be devastating. Alas it's the only setup that would put even more pressure on our FB/WBs and at the moment that seems borderline suicidal.

I've said for a month or so I'd be keen to see Gilchrist (looks like it'll be Campbell now) playing as they were at RB, tucking in and making a three when we have the ball and SIJ playing in his natural role (LWB) getting high and wide into the space Johnston creates when he cuts in and drags defenders with him. This is the role Gilchrist would have played last season at Sheffield United with Burrows at LB, and at Chelsea with Cucurella doing the pushing forwards on the left.

This frees up Styles to play in midfield, I think he deserves a chance there and he's performed well for Hungary in that position recently. It will also afford Johnston and Price more space playing centrally.

It's nothing new, Ipswich with Leif Davis have been playing this way for three seasons and it's really effective with the right personnel. The thought of a back four with SIJ in it does make you want to shit the bed a little bit, but I honestly think it gets the best out of the attributes he's got - stay wide, be fast, cross when you can. I don't think he's tactically or technically good enough to play this inside forward role that Mason seems to want.

That makes a lot of sense. Anything that involves SIJ more needs considering as he appears to drift/lack concentration when not involved. I also think that unless you have confidence in your individuals as a whole in  whatever system you play (I'm thinking Hodgson, Corberan), then you need to be flexible with tactics and switch as often as necessary during the game.


RE: Full backs - Josh1873 - 10-23-2025

I honestly don't think Campbell has been as bad at full back as people make out. I completely get it's not ideal to have a centre half playing there, but he's been solid enough.

That being said, I do think it's time to give Gilchrist a fair crack and a run of games there.


RE: Full backs - Ted Maul - 10-23-2025

(10-23-2025, 09:43 AM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-23-2025, 09:22 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I like a back three, done right it can be devastating. Alas it's the only setup that would put even more pressure on our FB/WBs and at the moment that seems borderline suicidal.

I've said for a month or so I'd be keen to see Gilchrist (looks like it'll be Campbell now) playing as they were at RB, tucking in and making a three when we have the ball and SIJ playing in his natural role (LWB) getting high and wide into the space Johnston creates when he cuts in and drags defenders with him. This is the role Gilchrist would have played last season at Sheffield United with Burrows at LB, and at Chelsea with Cucurella doing the pushing forwards on the left.

This frees up Styles to play in midfield, I think he deserves a chance there and he's performed well for Hungary in that position recently. It will also afford Johnston and Price more space playing centrally.

It's nothing new, Ipswich with Leif Davis have been playing this way for three seasons and it's really effective with the right personnel. The thought of a back four with SIJ in it does make you want to shit the bed a little bit, but I honestly think it gets the best out of the attributes he's got - stay wide, be fast, cross when you can. I don't think he's tactically or technically good enough to play this inside forward role that Mason seems to want.

That makes a lot of sense. Anything that involves SIJ more needs considering as he appears to drift/lack concentration when not involved. I also think that unless you have confidence in your individuals as a whole in  whatever system you play (I'm thinking Hodgson, Corberan), then you need to be flexible with tactics and switch as often as necessary during the game.

I'm not sure our squad at the moment is good enough for a manager to make wholesale changes to a system each week. I'd kind of hoped that Mason was of the CC mould where he would have a strong plan that was consistent, but ultimately our lack of quality is what costs us, what I'm seeing is generally nothing what so ever.

One point I missed from my earlier post is that SIJ at LB will give us width, the only noticeable element of Mason's play so far is how suffocatingly narrow we are. Get SIJ high and wide on the left, Grant/Wallace/Bany (Fellows would be class here) wide on the right and allow MJ and Price to play against a single defensive midfielder.


RE: Full backs - Vinebaggie - 10-23-2025

Think last night proved we haven't got a full back and on Saturday the ex Villa lad Philogene will have a field day if he's fit against Gilchrist or Campbell, it's a pretty scary prospect. Think we have to go 3-5-2, I'd go

Griffiths

Campbell Phillips Mepham

MJ Diakite Mowatt Molumby Price

Maja Heggebo

With Diakite helping out MJ defensively and Molumby helping out Price. I know that leaves out SIJ, but I thought he was a passenger yesterday.


RE: Full backs - Gzbaggy - 10-23-2025

Why not try Wallace at right back/right wing back he is experienced and has a good footballing brain. He can also cross
from 30 yards out

Paddy Mulligan and Stephen Reid were not quick, but both had excellent footballing brains.