WBAUnofficial
Just back, Ratings. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Just back, Ratings. (/showthread.php?tid=39051)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Sliced - 10-19-2025

(10-19-2025, 09:42 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 09:00 AM)Sliced Wrote: Being completely honest, from what I've seen of Mepham so far he looks OK. I know a lot rate him highly, and he's not bad, but so far he looks like a 6 out of 10 championship centre back prone to a bit of a stinker. I don't think he's in the same league as Phillips.

I think he's a downgrade on Heggem. Heggem had one error a game in him but for the rest of the game he was class. 

Not saying Mepham isn't a decent player but imo he's a slight downgrade on what we had in his position before him.

I agree. A downgrade on Heggem, but an upgrade on anyone else we had in that position


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Tom Joad 25 - 10-19-2025

(10-18-2025, 05:37 PM)CIM Wrote: Griffiths 8
Campbell 7 (much better than recently)
Styles 8
Phillips 7
Mepham 6
Mowatt 9
Collyer 7
Price 7
Johnston 8
SIJ 7
Maja 7

Subs all all 7 bar an 8 for Heggebo

Apart from Maja (skillful as ever but ring rusty, 6) and SIJ (MIA a lot and poor decision making - similar to Diangana, 5), agree with this.
Campbell was quite decent, Mepham far better than most have rated him and would've been an 8 if not for 2 errors.
A game where Preston clearly had seen our Millwall horror show and tried to do the same. It took 15 minutes for us to either assert ourselves or them to not be able to sustain it. As for the 'hanging on at the end' I've heard about? It was mostly comfortable for the last 5 + 9 minutes. Credit Mason for game management.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Bob Fossil - 10-19-2025

(10-19-2025, 12:30 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 05:37 PM)CIM Wrote: Griffiths 8
Campbell 7 (much better than recently)
Styles 8
Phillips 7
Mepham 6
Mowatt 9
Collyer 7
Price 7
Johnston 8
SIJ 7
Maja 7

Subs all all 7 bar an 8 for Heggebo

Apart from Maja (skillful as ever but ring rusty, 6) and SIJ (MIA a lot and poor decision making - similar to Diangana, 5), agree with this.
Campbell was quite decent, Mepham far better than most have rated him and would've been an 8 if not for 2 errors.
A game where Preston clearly had seen our Millwall horror show and tried to do the same. It took 15 minutes for us to either assert ourselves or them to not be able to sustain it. As for the 'hanging on at the end' I've heard about? It was mostly comfortable for the last 5 + 9 minutes. Credit Mason for game management.

The ref should have to justify that 9 minutes, where the fuck did it come from? We only played 6 when we had a dead pigeon invasion for 5 of them.

No way Campbell was a 2 ffs. He has to score higher than Mepham as it was his error for the goal. Still 6 as a minimum with Mikey, Price, Mowatt and Styles all 7/8.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Tom Joad 25 - 10-19-2025

(10-19-2025, 02:11 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 12:30 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 05:37 PM)CIM Wrote: Griffiths 8
Campbell 7 (much better than recently)
Styles 8
Phillips 7
Mepham 6
Mowatt 9
Collyer 7
Price 7
Johnston 8
SIJ 7
Maja 7

Subs all all 7 bar an 8 for Heggebo

Apart from Maja (skillful as ever but ring rusty, 6) and SIJ (MIA a lot and poor decision making - similar to Diangana, 5), agree with this.
Campbell was quite decent, Mepham far better than most have rated him and would've been an 8 if not for 2 errors.
A game where Preston clearly had seen our Millwall horror show and tried to do the same. It took 15 minutes for us to either assert ourselves or them to not be able to sustain it. As for the 'hanging on at the end' I've heard about? It was mostly comfortable for the last 5 + 9 minutes. Credit Mason for game management.

The ref should have to justify that 9 minutes, where the fuck did it come from? We only played 6 when we had a dead pigeon invasion for 5 of them.

No way Campbell was a 2 ffs. He has to score higher than Mepham as it was his error for the goal. Still 6 as a minimum with Mikey, Price, Mowatt and Styles all 7/8.

Aye, actually Styles was close to M.O.M. for me. Really good display.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Squid - 10-19-2025

Maja looked like he was playing within himself, at around 70%. Some players are more affected mentally by injuries than others.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - HawkingsHalfpint - 10-19-2025

Maja looked confused and clumsy at times but positionally was always running the right channels and stretching the defence. Although he was a bit wasteful when he got the ball I felt we missed him when he was replaced by Heggebo.

Although MJ was soon to make way also, it almost looked as if our midfield played with more freedom with Maja up-top rather than the Norg. It was almost like he compressed them a bit, yesterday, after coming on. Fair enough, Mason’s ‘close-out-the-game’ tactics probably didn’t help here, but with Maja on you always feel like some magic will happen. With Heggebo, that magic seems to only come through graft.

With both fit and firing one has to start ahead of the other if you’re only going with the solo option.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Bob Fossil - 10-19-2025

(10-19-2025, 03:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Maja looked confused and clumsy at times but positionally was always running the right channels and stretching the defence. Although he was a bit wasteful when he got the ball I felt we missed him when he was replaced by Heggebo.

Although MJ was soon to make way also, it almost looked as if our midfield played with more freedom with Maja up-top rather than the Norg. It was almost like he compressed them a bit, yesterday, after coming on. Fair enough, Mason’s ‘close-out-the-game’ tactics probably didn’t help here, but with Maja on you always feel like some magic will happen. With Heggebo, that magic seems to only come through graft.

With both fit and firing one has to start ahead of the other if you’re only going with the solo option.

Agree 100%. Maja looked tentative but brought more balance. Think he set up Price’s early double chance? Gets the start for me.
Heggabo looked strong when he came on and gave their CH’s something else to worry about.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Josh1873 - 10-19-2025

Still loffin' at Campbell being awarded a 2! That's tickled me.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Tom Joad 25 - 10-19-2025

(10-19-2025, 03:44 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-19-2025, 03:24 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Maja looked confused and clumsy at times but positionally was always running the right channels and stretching the defence. Although he was a bit wasteful when he got the ball I felt we missed him when he was replaced by Heggebo.

Although MJ was soon to make way also, it almost looked as if our midfield played with more freedom with Maja up-top rather than the Norg. It was almost like he compressed them a bit, yesterday, after coming on. Fair enough, Mason’s ‘close-out-the-game’ tactics probably didn’t help here, but with Maja on you always feel like some magic will happen. With Heggebo, that magic seems to only come through graft.

With both fit and firing one has to start ahead of the other if you’re only going with the solo option.

Agree 100%. Maja looked tentative but brought more balance. Think he set up Price’s early double chance? Gets the start for me.
Heggabo looked strong when he came on and gave their CH’s something else to worry about.

Yep, Maja's flick put Price in. Some of his fancy footwork was sublime too. Negative was he appeared a bit slow at times. Much of PNEs first 15 possession came from us not holding the ball up on the halfway line. Heggabo does hold the ball well. We unusually have good choices with both of these.


RE: Just back, Ratings. - Josh1873 - 10-19-2025

He's coming back from a long-term lay-off, of course he is going to be rusty. It'll take a little time for him to get up to true match speed.