WBAUnofficial
Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club (/showthread.php?tid=39002)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - CA Baggie - 10-18-2025

(10-18-2025, 08:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: What's the actual argument here? Are we really criticising people with a higher profile managing to flog their books to more people because they're more well known? Who'd have thunk it! 

Fair play to anyone that uses their platform and profile to increase their revenue and/or publicise a project they're proud of. 

I can only image the time, effort, and hard work it takes to write for novels, and in today's age of social media poison, I think it's a nice change to see someone get a lot of praise for doing something positive. Regardless if that platform is deserved, or not. 

What would people rather see? People using their fame to actually do something, work 'ard, and be proactive in working, or go off the rails, and become a burden to society?

I think the point here Josh is that if they weren’t already famous the quality of the work would not get past the publishers.  Therefore the books are shite and maybe taking uo the space that genuinely good authors, or up and coming, do not get their chance.

It’s the equivalent of boy bands getting the record deals, because the girls will scream at them, as opposed to the genuine musicians who can’t seem to get a break.

Or maybe even signing a loan kid from a top club just because of their association with that club at the detriment to your own youths development.

As for Richard Osman, he seems a sound enough guy to me, would imagine you could have a laugh with him and his sarcasm can be quite cutting.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Josh1873 - 10-18-2025

That's just the way of the world, isn't it? In any walk of life talented people don't always get the breaks they deserve, whereas people who aren't as talented do. It's always been, and always will be, about who you know. It's frustrating, but I'm not sure it should be used as a stick to beat a specific person with.

In Osman's case his first book was good, I'm about 1/3rd through the second, which is probably better (so far) than the first, and I'm enjoying it very much. I'm not for one second claiming to be some literature expert who knows what makes a great book, but I get the impression Osman is a good author. It's not as if he's poor, and has fluked his way through a good book.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - CA Baggie - 10-18-2025

(10-18-2025, 09:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: That's just the way of the world, isn't it? In any walk of life talented people don't always get the breaks they deserve, whereas people who aren't as talented do. It's always been, and always will be, about who you know. It's frustrating, but I'm not sure it should be used as a stick to beat a specific person with.

In Osman's case his first book was good, I'm about 1/3rd through the second, which is probably better (so far) than the first, and I'm enjoying it very much. I'm not for one second claiming to be some literature expert who knows what makes a great book, but I get the impression Osman is a good author. It's not as if he's poor, and has fluked his way through a good book.

It is indeed the way of the world, it’s just seeped more and more into the old of literature in recent years, which is a shame and there’s nothing wrong with trying to resist it as much as possible.  The most you used to get from a celeb was a ghost written bio, now they all think they can write a novel.  And they get away with it.

I’ve not read Richard’s books, not my thing.  So I’m not really commenting on his work, more the theme that is appearing.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Josh1873 - 10-18-2025

I wouldn't know about his pork, either Big Grin


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - CA Baggie - 10-18-2025

(10-18-2025, 11:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I wouldn't know about his pork, either Big Grin

Cool Dunno what you’re on about… he’s a big, tall lad so I’d expect he’d provide a banquet!


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - baggiebloke - 10-18-2025

CA Baggie is right.

I buy a lot of books every month and even in places like Hatchards there is a creep of "celebrity" author titles.

Go to the supermarket and the book shelves are dominated by the really big output "novelists" and the "celebs".

However, the better "celeb" titles are generally worth reading, it just feels like those authors with a lesser profile (not Clare Balding) are being squeezed out by this new phenomenon.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Tom Joad 25 - 10-18-2025

(10-18-2025, 09:25 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 08:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: What's the actual argument here? Are we really criticising people with a higher profile managing to flog their books to more people because they're more well known? Who'd have thunk it! 

Fair play to anyone that uses their platform and profile to increase their revenue and/or publicise a project they're proud of. 

I can only image the time, effort, and hard work it takes to write for novels, and in today's age of social media poison, I think it's a nice change to see someone get a lot of praise for doing something positive. Regardless if that platform is deserved, or not. 

What would people rather see? People using their fame to actually do something, work 'ard, and be proactive in working, or go off the rails, and become a burden to society?

I think the point here Josh is that if they weren’t already famous the quality of the work would not get past the publishers.  Therefore the books are shite and maybe taking uo the space that genuinely good authors, or up and coming, do not get their chance.

It’s the equivalent of boy bands getting the record deals, because the girls will scream at them, as opposed to the genuine musicians who can’t seem to get a break.

Or maybe even signing a loan kid from a top club just because of their association with that club at the detriment to your own youths development.

As for Richard Osman, he seems a sound enough guy to me, would imagine you could have a laugh with him and his sarcasm can be quite cutting.

Spot on CA, and put more coherently than I could but exactly what I meant.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Jacko - 10-18-2025

In a nutshell Josh, if you had written the Osman books, you would be the only person in the world who had read them.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Josh1873 - 10-24-2025

I've finished the second book today, it's better than the first - I thought it was great.

I was going to have a break after the second, but I think I'll move straight onto the third.

Really enjoyable reading.


RE: Richard Osman (Not RIP) Thursday Murder Club - Josh1873 - 11-13-2025

Finished the third book. I didn't enjoy this one as much as the first two, but I'm putting that down to some sort of book fatigue (is that a thing?) reading a series back-to-back-to-back is a little too much and gets very samey. 

One thing I'd like to touch on is the Alzheimer's storyline with Stephen, and how advanced it gets in this book. It's just a horrible vile disease. I'm going to phrase this sentence so horribly, and I apologise in advance. Cancer, rightly so, is hated and often seen as the worst disease, but Alzheimer's is worse than any cancer, or any illness. It's the worst thing I can imagine. Physical illness and death I can kind of accept (in terms of happening to me or my loved ones), but losing your mind and not being compos mentis is something I can't comprehend, it's the thing I personally fear most, it's the illness I'd find most devastating to see. 

It's a really poignant and touching aspect of a lighthearted series.