WBAUnofficial
Molomby - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Molomby (/showthread.php?tid=38959)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13


RE: Molomby - Lurker#3 - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 12:49 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:18 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:04 PM)Atomic Wrote: Molumby is one of the best midfielders of his type in the league. God only knows what some of our fans see. Eyes must be made of marbles, brains made of ......

........ answers on a postcard.

Correct. I think partly some forget half the game is played out of possession.

And his passing is fine anyway. Lurker could probably find the stats. Think his odd running style works against him in some fans eyes.

His pass to Hegg in the game he was fouled (and Mason was sent off) is the best pass of the season from our midfield.

One of my first names on the team sheet.

JM is good at running around and keeping it simple in the middle of the pitch. But when you actually need any real contribution in any other area of the pitch he comes up short.  

Possession: 


Creativity: 


Defensive Work:


Other:


The big concern is, if you main skill is running about being a shit house and you don't win enough tackles or pick up enough second balls, whats the point? Molumby, like Diakite has a part to play, in very few, specific scenarios. But it is a sign of how poorly we have balanced our squad that he is still a first choice

All I see are shades of Green, White and Orange.

Snippets updated. 

But basically is shows what percentile he is in for each metric when compared with his positional peers in the Championship so far this year


RE: Molomby - backsidebaggie - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 12:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:18 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:04 PM)Atomic Wrote: Molumby is one of the best midfielders of his type in the league. God only knows what some of our fans see. Eyes must be made of marbles, brains made of ......

........ answers on a postcard.

Correct. I think partly some forget half the game is played out of possession.

And his passing is fine anyway. Lurker could probably find the stats. Think his odd running style works against him in some fans eyes.

His pass to Hegg in the game he was fouled (and Mason was sent off) is the best pass of the season from our midfield.

One of my first names on the team sheet.

JM is good at running around and keeping it simple in the middle of the pitch. But when you actually need any real contribution in any other area of the pitch he comes up short.  

Possession: 


Creativity: 


Defensive Work:


Other:


The big concern is, if you main skill is running about being a shit house and you don't win enough tackles or pick up enough second balls, whats the point? Molumby, like Diakite has a part to play, in very few, specific scenarios. But it is a sign of how poorly we have balanced our squad that he is still a first choice

There are other things the stats don’t tell us (not knocking you, the stats do provide valuable insight).

Positional sense is massive in football. And I think this is his strength. Being in the right place defensively can stop attacks in itself, stopping through balls being played, delaying the opposition, making them change their mind and play a different pass. That sort of positional play doesn’t show up in the stats as an interception, or a tackle, or anything. But it’s important. And he is a nightmare to play against for that reason IMO.

In terms of stuff in other areas, I don’t think that’s his job tbh.

I’m not surprised every manager picks him. He’s miles better than Diakite IMO.


RE: Molomby - Lurker#3 - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 12:53 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:18 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:04 PM)Atomic Wrote: Molumby is one of the best midfielders of his type in the league. God only knows what some of our fans see. Eyes must be made of marbles, brains made of ......

........ answers on a postcard.

Correct. I think partly some forget half the game is played out of possession.

And his passing is fine anyway. Lurker could probably find the stats. Think his odd running style works against him in some fans eyes.

His pass to Hegg in the game he was fouled (and Mason was sent off) is the best pass of the season from our midfield.

One of my first names on the team sheet.

JM is good at running around and keeping it simple in the middle of the pitch. But when you actually need any real contribution in any other area of the pitch he comes up short.  

Possession: 


Creativity: 


Defensive Work:


Other:


The big concern is, if you main skill is running about being a shit house and you don't win enough tackles or pick up enough second balls, whats the point? Molumby, like Diakite has a part to play, in very few, specific scenarios. But it is a sign of how poorly we have balanced our squad that he is still a first choice

There are other things the stats don’t tell us (not knocking you, the stats do provide valuable insight).

Positional sense is massive in football. And I think this is his strength. Being in the right place defensively can stop attacks in itself, stopping through balls being played, delaying the opposition, making them change their mind and play a different pass. That sort of positional play doesn’t show up in the stats as an interception, or a tackle, or anything. But it’s important. And he is a nightmare to play against for that reason IMO.

In terms of stuff in other areas, I don’t think that’s his job tbh.

I’m not surprised every manager picks him. He’s miles better than Diakite IMO.

Standing in the right place is what I would expect from a non league or league 2 CM. You need to add more to a team at teh elite level rather than just making the opponent occasionally pick another pass. 

This isn't a perosnal thing against JM, as how can anybody knock a player who works that hard, too much? Its ust sad that his footballing brain doesn't support his natural appreciation of the ball and tenacity.


RE: Molomby - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-08-2025

Difficult to know what to make of this thread. We have stats to prove how average Molumby is, we have people jumping on to diss him, some long-term agendas floating around about the quality of our CM options or perceptions of his character, we have people who appreciate his effort at least and we have those who can see his qualities and his importance to the team (at last in the mind of the man who picks it).

What's very saddening is the OP who starts the thread by being offensive then doubles down when others disagree. When did abusing our own players, either on match day or on-line, ever achieve anything? Abuse isn't debate, otherwise I'd be calling the OP a complete cunt. Which I'm not doing. Please spell his name correctly, whatever you have to say about him FFS sake!


RE: Molomby - backsidebaggie - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 12:57 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:53 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:47 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:18 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 12:04 PM)Atomic Wrote: Molumby is one of the best midfielders of his type in the league. God only knows what some of our fans see. Eyes must be made of marbles, brains made of ......

........ answers on a postcard.

Correct. I think partly some forget half the game is played out of possession.

And his passing is fine anyway. Lurker could probably find the stats. Think his odd running style works against him in some fans eyes.

His pass to Hegg in the game he was fouled (and Mason was sent off) is the best pass of the season from our midfield.

One of my first names on the team sheet.

JM is good at running around and keeping it simple in the middle of the pitch. But when you actually need any real contribution in any other area of the pitch he comes up short.  

Possession: 


Creativity: 


Defensive Work:


Other:


The big concern is, if you main skill is running about being a shit house and you don't win enough tackles or pick up enough second balls, whats the point? Molumby, like Diakite has a part to play, in very few, specific scenarios. But it is a sign of how poorly we have balanced our squad that he is still a first choice

There are other things the stats don’t tell us (not knocking you, the stats do provide valuable insight).

Positional sense is massive in football. And I think this is his strength. Being in the right place defensively can stop attacks in itself, stopping through balls being played, delaying the opposition, making them change their mind and play a different pass. That sort of positional play doesn’t show up in the stats as an interception, or a tackle, or anything. But it’s important. And he is a nightmare to play against for that reason IMO.

In terms of stuff in other areas, I don’t think that’s his job tbh.

I’m not surprised every manager picks him. He’s miles better than Diakite IMO.

Standing in the right place is what I would expect from a non league or league 2 CM. You need to add more to a team at teh elite level rather than just making the opponent occasionally pick another pass. 

This isn't a perosnal thing against JM, as how can anybody knock a player who works that hard, too much? Its ust sad that his footballing brain doesn't support his natural appreciation of the ball and tenacity.

Totally disagree.

Positional sense, or “standing in the right place”, is hugely important at the top level. A lot of the best centre backs don’t make that many tackles, as they don’t need to due to superior positioning.

It’s no coincidence our best spells in the prem involves Molumbu and/or Yacob. They may be better than Mulumby, but they were in the prem. They did a similar job. A pain to play against.

I think he’s hugely important and that’s why three managers in a row, plus Brunt as caretaker, all keep picking him.


RE: Molomby - wba13 - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 01:12 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Difficult to know what to make of this thread. We have stats to prove how average Molumby is, we have people jumping on to diss him, some long-term agendas floating around about the quality of our CM options or perceptions of his character, we have people who appreciate his effort at least and we have those who can see his qualities and his importance to the team (at last in the mind of the man who picks it).

What's very saddening is the OP who starts the thread by being offensive then doubles down when others disagree. When did abusing our own players, either on match day or on-line, ever achieve anything? Abuse isn't debate, otherwise I'd be calling the OP a complete cunt. Which I'm not doing. Please spell his name correctly, whatever you have to say about him FFS sake!

Thank you Cheshire a lot more eloquently put than I could do. But I will never understand why our own fans would put up a thread like this he plays for the Albion and he does him best he doesn’t deserve the abuse that the poster starting this thread gave him.


RE: Molomby - Tom Joad 25 - 10-08-2025

I'm with BB here. Another thing stats won't show is grim determination. JM ,as stated elsewhere, is a nightmare to play against. He offers what he can, the fact he isn't Cole Palmer shouldn't be the judgement or the stick to beat him. He is a valuable squad member and if the manager can find better then he should bench him. No different to any other player but quite often he is vital to how we play.


RE: Molomby - Lurker#3 - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 02:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Totally disagree.

Positional sense, or “standing in the right place”, is hugely important at the top level. A lot of the best centre backs don’t make that many tackles, as they don’t need to due to superior positioning.

It’s no coincidence our best spells in the prem involves Molumbu and/or Yacob. They may be better than Mulumby, but they were in the prem. They did a similar job. A pain to play against.

I think he’s hugely important and that’s why three managers in a row, plus Brunt as caretaker, all keep picking him.

Standing in the right place is a skill no doubt. But you have to make tackles, pick up second balls, make interceptions and blocks, if your job is to keep it tight in CM. That's what Yacob did. Molumby is more in the Molumbu mould in the fact he carries the ball and draws foul, but Molumbu was always a goal/assist threat and made more ball recoveries of any player I have ever seen. 

The big thing is, and I keep mentioning it is the balance of the squad. If we had 2 flying full backs who got up the pitch and chipped in with shots, crosses, key passes etc, we could facilitate JM more. But we dont. Its the fault of the club who have put the squad together as much as it is JMs lack of output.


RE: Molomby - Derek Hardballs - 10-08-2025

So in summary Molumby is picked by every manager since he arrived at the club in a central midfield role. He is picked to win the ball, do the dirty work and allow others to play. He isn’t in the team to create goal scoring chances, long raking passes or to offer deadly accuracy from set pieces.

Stats are meaningless unless they are used in context, I doubt a manager is judging his inclusion on his creativity or all round play, he’s chosen to do a specific job. It’s not judging him against his peers because players and squads are different and these stats only show the individual in isolation not against another midfielder being asked to do the same job as he is in a similar set-up team, using similar tactics.

The old adage you can prove any old shite with stats is still true.


RE: Molomby - Tom Joad 25 - 10-08-2025

(10-08-2025, 02:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-08-2025, 02:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Totally disagree.

Positional sense, or “standing in the right place”, is hugely important at the top level. A lot of the best centre backs don’t make that many tackles, as they don’t need to due to superior positioning.

It’s no coincidence our best spells in the prem involves Molumbu and/or Yacob. They may be better than Mulumby, but they were in the prem. They did a similar job. A pain to play against.

I think he’s hugely important and that’s why three managers in a row, plus Brunt as caretaker, all keep picking him.

Standing in the right place is a skill no doubt. But you have to make tackles, pick up second balls, make interceptions and blocks, if your job is to keep it tight in CM. That's what Yacob did. Molumby is more in the Molumbu mould in the fact he carries the ball and draws foul, but Molumbu was always a goal threat and made more ball recoveries of any player I have ever seen. 

The big thing is, and I keep mentioning it is the balance of the squad. If we had 2 flying full backs who got up the pitch and chipped in with shots, crosses, key passes etc, we could facilitate JM more. But we dont. Its the fault of the club who have put the squad together as much as it is JMs lack of output.

That last paragraph is more to the point.