![]() |
|
NI Fund Surplus - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: NI Fund Surplus (/showthread.php?tid=38175) |
RE: NI Fund Surplus - Jacko - 08-07-2025 (08-07-2025, 08:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It’s pointless to debate. It’s clear that if Labour had called for raised taxes before the election they would have lost votes in the same way that Corbyn lost votes. It’s lovely to think that there could be a better way but we have to stabilise before we can move further left. You moaning that things aren’t right is like moving into a new house and expecting it to be finished. They aren't going to move left. If anything they'll go further right using their current appeasement tactics. It's been a shit show from start to finish and it's now a toss up whether the Tories staying in power would have been any worse. RE: NI Fund Surplus - CarlosCorbewrong - 08-07-2025 (08-07-2025, 08:39 PM)Jacko Wrote:(08-07-2025, 08:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It’s pointless to debate. It’s clear that if Labour had called for raised taxes before the election they would have lost votes in the same way that Corbyn lost votes. It’s lovely to think that there could be a better way but we have to stabilise before we can move further left. You moaning that things aren’t right is like moving into a new house and expecting it to be finished. The consequences of them staying in power would have been that Starmer, Reeves would have been fired, Labour would be treated as the genuine alternative at the GE, under new leadership, not Reform. RE: NI Fund Surplus - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2025 (08-07-2025, 08:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It’s pointless to debate. It’s clear that if Labour had called for raised taxes before the election they would have lost votes in the same way that Corbyn lost votes. It’s lovely to think that there could be a better way but we have to stabilise before we can move further left. You moaning that things aren’t right is like moving into a new house and expecting it to be finished. Labour won because the Tories were appalling, it wasn’t because people thought they wouldn’t raise taxes. They just wanted some hope for better, all they’ve had is joyless, hopeless Tory-lite policies and divisive rhetoric around working and non-working people. You keep telling yourself that they are building a better house, all they are doing is wallpapering over the cracks. (08-07-2025, 08:37 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:(08-07-2025, 06:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I know that it has gone under the radar but adding pensions into inheritance tax is taxing the 'rich'. And as for taxing 'wealth' - good luck with that, how wealth is measured is impossible to tax effectively and it's been tried and failed many times. It's a myth that the rich aren't being taxed. He sounds like a Tory whether he realises it or not. RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-07-2025 I love the ‘he’s a Tory’ line that you keep coming out with. I wanted a Corbyn government, the one you were afraid to vote for remember. We really are in a situation of starting again and asking everything to be fixed after years of neglect is simply naive. Voting for Starmer was the 1st step in a very long journey. RE: NI Fund Surplus - Derek Hardballs - 08-07-2025 (08-07-2025, 09:06 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I love the ‘he’s a Tory’ line that you keep coming out with. I wanted a Corbyn government, the one you were afraid to vote for remember. We really are in a situation of starting again and asking everything to be fixed after years of neglect is simply naive. Voting for Starmer was the 1st step in a very long journey. You wanted Corbyn’s government… erm I don’t recall you being a big fan. Now you want to cut £5bn from those on disability benefits, avoid a wealth tax, not upset the well off, defend divisive rhetoric and think Tory-lite Sunak style politics is the way to go. Sounds quite Tory tbh. RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-07-2025 All of that is made up Dekka. I voted for Corbyn and subsequently realised afterwards that he would not be accepted so made the pragmatic decision in voting for Starmer. The PIP system needs reform and there is abuse of the system - most have seen it but you have been sheltered from it apparently. You opposed the changes without understanding them from what you showed. I’m all for a wealth tax but they simply don’t work in the way you want. Adding pensions into inheritance tax is a wealth tax (taxable wealth at a measureablr and definite point) - that will cost my kids dependent on how long I live. If you are reading my posts as not upsetting the rich then you are daft - I’m simply saying a wealth tax has been tried many times and failed many times. It’s simple really - how would you measure wealth. You’d like it sound Tory because it’s not telling you you’re right. You simply don’t have any realistic proposals that will work in the real world. We all need to face up to the long haul ahead of us instead of wanting unicorns today RE: NI Fund Surplus - man in the corner shop - 08-08-2025 (08-07-2025, 09:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All of that is made up Dekka. I voted for Corbyn and subsequently realised afterwards that he would not be accepted so made the pragmatic decision in voting for Starmer. The PIP system needs reform and there is abuse of the system - most have seen it but you have been sheltered from it apparently. You opposed the changes without understanding them from what you showed. I’m all for a wealth tax but they simply don’t work in the way you want. Adding pensions into inheritance tax is a wealth tax (taxable wealth at a measureablr and definite point) - that will cost my kids dependent on how long I live. If you are reading my posts as not upsetting the rich then you are daft - I’m simply saying a wealth tax has been tried many times and failed many times. It’s simple really - how would you measure wealth. This is Proth's line. Proth either has 2 log ins or you are a rabid Hayekian Thatcherite. From voting for Corbyn to spouting this.....you seem very very confused. Let's get back to political choices. As Tony Benn said, if money can be found for war it can be found for peace. It can be found to bail out banks and for Covid. If £80bn can be found to get people on a train from London to Brum 20 mins quicker, £100bn can be found for a national housebuilding programme. The UK has an Independent bank and there is no limit on what money it can produce, hence the amount of QE that has been going on for so long. The argument that a national economy needs to be managed like a household budget is nonsense. RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-08-2025 Fucks sake, that just about sums up the reason we have councils paralysed and inoperable through having a large chunk of their money going to pay interest and PPI agreements - a scandal in itself. "Just spend the money", never has it been clearer that this is a football message board. RE: NI Fund Surplus - Derek Hardballs - 08-08-2025 (08-07-2025, 09:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All of that is made up Dekka. I voted for Corbyn and subsequently realised afterwards that he would not be accepted so made the pragmatic decision in voting for Starmer. The PIP system needs reform and there is abuse of the system - most have seen it but you have been sheltered from it apparently. You opposed the changes without understanding them from what you showed. I’m all for a wealth tax but they simply don’t work in the way you want. Adding pensions into inheritance tax is a wealth tax (taxable wealth at a measureablr and definite point) - that will cost my kids dependent on how long I live. If you are reading my posts as not upsetting the rich then you are daft - I’m simply saying a wealth tax has been tried many times and failed many times. It’s simple really - how would you measure wealth. I voted for Corbyn knowing that he would lose. If Andy Burnham for example was proposing those policies he would have had a far better chance of winning. It was bloody obvious that Corbyn and Momentum were a hinderance not a vote winner. Starmer has shown he has no convictions, he’s u-turned and contradicted himself on most of the policies he’s voted on, developed and delivered. His lack of convictions mean know one trusts him, no one has a clue what Labour stand for and the principles it once stood for have been thrown out the window to appease voters who will never go back to voting for him or Labour. Labour for elected because the Tories were abysmal nothing more. You continually ignore what I write, I have said the welfare system around disability needs reform. However you slavishly follow the party line that £5bn cuts were reform. The reforms were written on a vape packet after Reeves and the treasury realised they’d ran out of wriggle room. You cite fraud and yet cannot produce any proper research, I’m sure there is fraud as there is in any system but you want it to be significant because it justifies picking on the most vulnerable in society to shoulder the financial burden for a lack of growth in the economy. The fact the government would have lost the vote if they hadn’t rowed back on its ‘reforms’ shows how badly thought out, disingenuous and communicated it was. You sound like a Tory because the party you still defend are following broadly Tory led policies that have failed miserably for over a decade. You don’t get politics it’s about the story, and personality you tell as much as the policies. Labours story is one of five years of more of the same drudgery as the last 15yrs, very little hope, divisive language around working people and non working people, how about just people, no real vision, condescension and hypocrisy and some vague our hearts not in it, Reform style rhetoric around immigration. Meanwhile Reform hold the narrative around immigration, crime, and hope for change. It’ll be awful I’m sure if they win power, but with a vacuum of personality and hope at the heart of this Labour government that’s what you get. Things can only get perhaps slightly better but probably worse! Is not what people want to hear. RE: NI Fund Surplus - baggy1 - 08-08-2025 (08-08-2025, 08:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You don’t get politics it’s about the story, and personality you tell as much as the policies. Considering you've spent the last few years bemoaning populist governments this statement really does raise an eyebrow. |