WBAUnofficial
Sycamore Lumberjacks... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Sycamore Lumberjacks... (/showthread.php?tid=38077)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - Bob Fossil - 07-17-2025

The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - Brentbaggie - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

I agree with your sentiment but wasn't it a 100 years old?


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - ChamonixBaggie - 07-17-2025

Feels like they've been made an example of which - while maybe a bit harsh on the face of it - should hopefully deter future dickheads from engaging in tree-based dickheadry


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - MrBater - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 08:03 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

I agree with your sentiment but wasn't it a 100 years old?

100-150, I'll be honest, I'd never even heard of it til it came down.

It was a historic thing, what would we do if they'd pushed Stonehenge over?

It's vandalism pure and simple. In this case vandalism that can't be corrected, unlike say graffiti on a wall that can be cleaned off.

In a World where a post online can get you in prison, this sentence is fine by me. We've let people off for worse crimes in the past, e.g. that female student who killed her boyfriend and the judge said it would affect her future if he imprisoned her! For me sentencing needs to get tougher again, even if prisons are over crowded etc...


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - Remi_Moses - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 08:12 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 08:03 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

I agree with your sentiment but wasn't it a 100 years old?

100-150, I'll be honest, I'd never even heard of it til it came down.

It was a historic thing, what would we do if they'd pushed Stonehenge over?

It's vandalism pure and simple. In this case vandalism that can't be corrected, unlike say graffiti on a wall that can be cleaned off.

In a World where a post online can get you in prison, this sentence is fine by me. We've let people off for worse crimes in the past, e.g. that female student who killed her boyfriend and the judge said it would affect her future if he imprisoned her!  For me sentencing needs to get tougher again, even if prisons are over crowded etc...

Simple way of reducing prison numbers.
Deport any successful asylum people who are in prison.
No debate - immediately. They can object only when they are in the country of birth. Simples.
Remenomics.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - Duffers - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 08:29 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 08:12 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 08:03 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

I agree with your sentiment but wasn't it a 100 years old?

100-150, I'll be honest, I'd never even heard of it til it came down.

It was a historic thing, what would we do if they'd pushed Stonehenge over?

It's vandalism pure and simple. In this case vandalism that can't be corrected, unlike say graffiti on a wall that can be cleaned off.

In a World where a post online can get you in prison, this sentence is fine by me. We've let people off for worse crimes in the past, e.g. that female student who killed her boyfriend and the judge said it would affect her future if he imprisoned her!  For me sentencing needs to get tougher again, even if prisons are over crowded etc...

Simple way of reducing prison numbers.
Deport any successful asylum people who are in prison.
No debate - immediately. They can object only when they are in the country of birth. Simples.
Remenomics.

Alright Nigel.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - PatelsPlatoon - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

The 'it's just a tree' argument is pretty stupid. Anyone who can't argue beyond that shouldn't be engaged with as there's really no point in arguing with someone with such simplistic thoughts.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - CarlosCorbewrong - 07-17-2025

Somebody might push Stonehenge over.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - WorcsWBA - 07-17-2025

(07-17-2025, 09:27 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(07-17-2025, 07:53 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The trouble with the "It's just a tree" rhetoric is that, that could be applied to any inanimate object. If someone burned down your house, knowing full well no-one was in it, you wouldn't say "It's only a house, send em on a bricklaying course"
This tree was a thing of real beauty that has lived through 400 years of history, just to be ended by two swivel eyed loons. Fuck em, they deserve the Evil Dead treatment.

The 'it's just a tree' argument is pretty stupid. Anyone who can't argue beyond that shouldn't be engaged with as there's really no point in arguing with someone with such simplistic thoughts.

People have had their ashes scattered at the foot of the tree, got married/engaged there, spent time there to improve their mental health etc etc. It was a widely known, iconic landmark and also a symbol of the resilience of the natural world, which humans are increasingly undermining. 

I actually don't know why Graham and Currthers weren't also found guilty of perjury, given they lied that they had nothing to do with it during the trial and then later admitted that they did it. They've shown no contrition or remorse whatsoever. I have no problem with the sentences these morons were given.


RE: Sycamore Lumberjacks... - baggiebloke - 07-17-2025

Was the idiotic motivation for this act ever revealed?

I'm picturing a Beavis and Butt-Head type scene when the plan was first thought up.