RE: HS2 - KRO - 06-18-2025
You’ve quoted me and replied to not what I’ve said. Plus you don’t understand what capacity means in this instance.
Well done tbf
RE: HS2 - SausEggBaton - 06-18-2025
(06-18-2025, 01:27 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 01:09 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (06-18-2025, 12:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: A slightly faster train to nearly London. Money would have been better spent building a standard parallel line to the WCLM to alleviate some of the capacity issues.
4-tracking Rugby-Wolverhampton would dwarf the cost of HS2 and be significantly more disruptive for the same capacity benefits and little scope for fixing other cities which HS2 at least offers in theory if they decide to actually build it in full at some point. Realistically the only practical 4-tracking is between Stechford and Berkswell where works were started prior to WWII already, that doesn't address the issues into New Street, congestion into Wolverhampton and the shitshow that is Coventry and it's also reliant on HS2 to enable capacity to be relieved to mitigate the disruption to services.
I was only complaining, I didn't want any practical solutions, thank you very much.
Nothing like an expert to make one feel well and truly told.
I thoroughly enjoyed the explanation. It confirmed to me that this countries rail system (and national projects in general) am shit.
RE: HS2 - Borin' Baggie - 06-18-2025
(06-18-2025, 08:04 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.
If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.
Is it really rocket science?
One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.
We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.
(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.
Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.
With all due respect literally no-one I know or work with would agree with that view and that includes people who work on or have worked in the HS2 project. We have a relatively cheap and numerous options to get between Birmingham and London already.
There's nearly 1 train per minute that passes through Rugby at peak time, most onwards to Coventry which is a two-track line. There has been capacity issues on that section of track going back nearly 100 years which is why work was started to 4-track the WCML prior to WWII and obviously halted because of the war. And we've lost a relief line since the 1960s with the Grand Central mainline closing, they had to reverse the Chiltern Line closure and even that wasn't enough.
With all due respect, this really isn't up for debate. There is a huge capacity issue and something needs to address it, that section of track goes through a major freight interchange between the WCML and on the Immingham-Southampton route and it severely limits what local services can run due to conflicts with faster services in-turn messing with local rail services around the second biggest city in the UK. It's the busiest mixed-use railway line in Europe and it was built to service the 19th century when the population and demand was significantly lower and there was an extra relief line then as well.
Ask the people you work with how they would facilitate just a single extra stopper service between Birmingham International and Wolverhampton, something that's needed due to poor transport service patterns with much of East Birmingham and you're limited to a half-hourly service connecting the Birmingham to some of the most densely populated areas of the Black Country. Or more freight patterns to connect West Midlands manufacturing to the ports at Immingham and Southampton. This isn't just about "London to Birmingham".
RE: HS2 - KRO - 06-18-2025
Borin’ Baggie knows
RE: HS2 - baggiebloke - 06-19-2025
I blame Beeching.
RE: HS2 - Derek Hardballs - 06-19-2025
Is there any incentive for those employed to finish the job? Are those working on the project likely to see a more lucrative and long term contract? Genuine questions.
RE: HS2 - AnelkasBeard - 06-19-2025
(06-18-2025, 08:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 08:04 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.
If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.
Is it really rocket science?
One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.
We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.
(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.
Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.
With all due respect literally no-one I know or work with would agree with that view and that includes people who work on or have worked in the HS2 project. We have a relatively cheap and numerous options to get between Birmingham and London already.
There's nearly 1 train per minute that passes through Rugby at peak time, most onwards to Coventry which is a two-track line. There has been capacity issues on that section of track going back nearly 100 years which is why work was started to 4-track the WCML prior to WWII and obviously halted because of the war. And we've lost a relief line since the 1960s with the Grand Central mainline closing, they had to reverse the Chiltern Line closure and even that wasn't enough.
With all due respect, this really isn't up for debate. There is a huge capacity issue and something needs to address it, that section of track goes through a major freight interchange between the WCML and on the Immingham-Southampton route and it severely limits what local services can run due to conflicts with faster services in-turn messing with local rail services around the second biggest city in the UK. It's the busiest mixed-use railway line in Europe and it was built to service the 19th century when the population and demand was significantly lower and there was an extra relief line then as well.
Ask the people you work with how they would facilitate just a single extra stopper service between Birmingham International and Wolverhampton, something that's needed due to poor transport service patterns with much of East Birmingham and you're limited to a half-hourly service connecting the Birmingham to some of the most densely populated areas of the Black Country. Or more freight patterns to connect West Midlands manufacturing to the ports at Immingham and Southampton. This isn't just about "London to Birmingham".
Not that Borin' Baggie needs the support, but this is absolutely on the money. This is a capacity issue, and it just isn't up for debate. The original messaging around speed and saving time was always the problem. So many people don't care about 10/15 mintues here or there. But being able to put on X number of additional trains? Improving the freight infrastructure? That's something I think a much higher % of the population could get behind.
However, let's assume for arguments sake that HS2 was seen as kinda not needed in terms of time saving or capacity. It doesn't really matter. We are running our national transport network on 100+ year old infrastructure?!?! How can anyone disagree we need vast and continued investment in our transport, water, power etc etc networks. Look at so many other countries and they're all ahead of us. Go to places like Japan and it's like you're on a different planet. Yet any infrastructure upgrade here is met with comments like "nah we don't need it, what a waste of money". Look at how the 5G network was received. The mindset in this country is depressing.
Now flip the argument, and agree HS2 is required, and everyone is happy to crack on. A big infrastructure project was decided on, and as a country we have continually fucked it up for years. It's pathetic and utterly embarrasing.
RE: HS2 - Derek Hardballs - 06-19-2025
(06-19-2025, 08:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-18-2025, 08:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 08:04 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 06:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Couldn't that money have been used to invest in the Network Rail infrastructure so that current trains run more reliably, on time, and maybe, just maybe, if you get those two fundamentals correct, invest in more services and more carriages to solve overcrowding. Finally, invest in fast WiFi.
If you do the above, people don't care about getting to London a few mins quicker, particularly if they have seats on a spacious carriage and can connect to fast reliable broadband, because customers can work on the train or stream games/movies etc to pass those extra few mins.
Is it really rocket science?
One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.
We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.
(06-18-2025, 06:31 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: The fact is that HS2 is trying to find a solution to a question which was never asked.
Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.
With all due respect literally no-one I know or work with would agree with that view and that includes people who work on or have worked in the HS2 project. We have a relatively cheap and numerous options to get between Birmingham and London already.
There's nearly 1 train per minute that passes through Rugby at peak time, most onwards to Coventry which is a two-track line. There has been capacity issues on that section of track going back nearly 100 years which is why work was started to 4-track the WCML prior to WWII and obviously halted because of the war. And we've lost a relief line since the 1960s with the Grand Central mainline closing, they had to reverse the Chiltern Line closure and even that wasn't enough.
With all due respect, this really isn't up for debate. There is a huge capacity issue and something needs to address it, that section of track goes through a major freight interchange between the WCML and on the Immingham-Southampton route and it severely limits what local services can run due to conflicts with faster services in-turn messing with local rail services around the second biggest city in the UK. It's the busiest mixed-use railway line in Europe and it was built to service the 19th century when the population and demand was significantly lower and there was an extra relief line then as well.
Ask the people you work with how they would facilitate just a single extra stopper service between Birmingham International and Wolverhampton, something that's needed due to poor transport service patterns with much of East Birmingham and you're limited to a half-hourly service connecting the Birmingham to some of the most densely populated areas of the Black Country. Or more freight patterns to connect West Midlands manufacturing to the ports at Immingham and Southampton. This isn't just about "London to Birmingham".
Not that Borin' Baggie needs the support, but this is absolutely on the money. This is a capacity issue, and it just isn't up for debate. The original messaging around speed and saving time was always the problem. So many people don't care about 10/15 mintues here or there. But being able to put on X number of additional trains? Improving the freight infrastructure? That's something I think a much higher % of the population could get behind.
However, let's assume for arguments sake that HS2 was seen as kinda not needed in terms of time saving or capacity. It doesn't really matter. We are running our national transport network on 100+ year old infrastructure?!?! How can anyone disagree we need vast and continued investment in our transport, water, power etc etc networks. Look at so many other countries and they're all ahead of us. Go to places like Japan and it's like you're on a different planet. Yet any infrastructure upgrade here is met with comments like "nah we don't need it, what a waste of money". Look at how the 5G network was received. The mindset in this country is depressing.
Now flip the argument, and agree HS2 is required, and everyone is happy to crack on. A big infrastructure project was decided on, and as a country we have continually fucked it up for years. It's pathetic and utterly embarrasing.
Perhaps it wouldn’t be seen as a huge waste of money if those large corporations that get the tenders delivered on budget and on time. I’m sure some things are down to bureaucracy at national and local level but the productivity in the UK is not great. We have teams of five or six people at a time fixing potholes, Cadent and others seem to dig up the same stretches of road every month, go past most HS2 sites and the surrounding areas have miles of cones and no workers doing anything and profit is always put before the quality of service it seems these days by most big companies in the UK.
RE: HS2 - SausEggBaton - 06-19-2025
(06-19-2025, 07:07 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: I blame Beeching.
Oh that's right, take it out on the overworked underpaid Doctors why don't ya!
RE: HS2 - AnelkasBeard - 06-19-2025
(06-19-2025, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-19-2025, 08:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-18-2025, 08:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (06-18-2025, 08:04 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (06-18-2025, 07:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: One of the worst railway bottlenecks in Europe is the Rugby-Wolverhampton spur of the West Coast Main Line, it's critical to relieve capacity there and HS2 is the significantly cheaper and quicker option to four-tracking the line. HS2 is primarily about capacity relief, not speed.
We also need to improve regional connectivity between Birmingham and Manchester and Birmingham and Nottingham/Sheffield/Leeds but that's been dropped so it's moot.
Fundamentally disagree with this, it's a problem that's needed a solution for 100 years. Initial capacity upgrade plans were put in place in the 1930s before WWII, high speed rail plans have been looked at for London-Birmingham since the 1970s. Our problem is that we're reliant on Victorian infrastructure for a major national and local connection but can't build anything.
With all due respect literally no-one I know or work with would agree with that view and that includes people who work on or have worked in the HS2 project. We have a relatively cheap and numerous options to get between Birmingham and London already.
There's nearly 1 train per minute that passes through Rugby at peak time, most onwards to Coventry which is a two-track line. There has been capacity issues on that section of track going back nearly 100 years which is why work was started to 4-track the WCML prior to WWII and obviously halted because of the war. And we've lost a relief line since the 1960s with the Grand Central mainline closing, they had to reverse the Chiltern Line closure and even that wasn't enough.
With all due respect, this really isn't up for debate. There is a huge capacity issue and something needs to address it, that section of track goes through a major freight interchange between the WCML and on the Immingham-Southampton route and it severely limits what local services can run due to conflicts with faster services in-turn messing with local rail services around the second biggest city in the UK. It's the busiest mixed-use railway line in Europe and it was built to service the 19th century when the population and demand was significantly lower and there was an extra relief line then as well.
Ask the people you work with how they would facilitate just a single extra stopper service between Birmingham International and Wolverhampton, something that's needed due to poor transport service patterns with much of East Birmingham and you're limited to a half-hourly service connecting the Birmingham to some of the most densely populated areas of the Black Country. Or more freight patterns to connect West Midlands manufacturing to the ports at Immingham and Southampton. This isn't just about "London to Birmingham".
Not that Borin' Baggie needs the support, but this is absolutely on the money. This is a capacity issue, and it just isn't up for debate. The original messaging around speed and saving time was always the problem. So many people don't care about 10/15 mintues here or there. But being able to put on X number of additional trains? Improving the freight infrastructure? That's something I think a much higher % of the population could get behind.
However, let's assume for arguments sake that HS2 was seen as kinda not needed in terms of time saving or capacity. It doesn't really matter. We are running our national transport network on 100+ year old infrastructure?!?! How can anyone disagree we need vast and continued investment in our transport, water, power etc etc networks. Look at so many other countries and they're all ahead of us. Go to places like Japan and it's like you're on a different planet. Yet any infrastructure upgrade here is met with comments like "nah we don't need it, what a waste of money". Look at how the 5G network was received. The mindset in this country is depressing.
Now flip the argument, and agree HS2 is required, and everyone is happy to crack on. A big infrastructure project was decided on, and as a country we have continually fucked it up for years. It's pathetic and utterly embarrasing.
Perhaps it wouldn’t be seen as a huge waste of money if those large corporations that get the tenders delivered on budget and on time. I’m sure some things are down to bureaucracy at national and local level but the productivity in the UK is not great. We have teams of five or six people at a time fixing potholes, Cadent and others seem to dig up the same stretches of road every month, go past most HS2 sites and the surrounding areas have miles of cones and no workers doing anything and profit is always put before the quality of service it seems these days by most big companies in the UK.
Yep can't disagree, and this is included in the embarrassment. Proper governance, assurance and penalties for poor performance to the contractors. Otherwise they're going to take the piss, as they have.
The ethos seems to be "how can we do as little as possible, for as much money as possible, for as long as possible."
|