WBAUnofficial
A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame (/showthread.php?tid=37428)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Birdman1811 - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 01:50 PM)KRO Wrote: I’ve read that you’ve won 5 out of 17 since Mowbray was officially in the dug out v Boro. But you’d only won 4 out of 22 before that game. Just how big has this drop off been and was it a shock considering the style of play/coaching between CC and TM?
Btw I’m actually amazed at those stats if true

We always looked like turning the draws into wins, and rarely looked second best, we couldn't score or create enough, but it was a fine margin of improvement needed. Under Mowbray we couldn't defend, couldn't score, looked disorganised and generally just very poor.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - KRO - 04-22-2025

True. Just amazed at 9 wins in 39 tbh and still being so near the top 6.
Will nextvyears aim be top 6 or is a drop off expected or is it all recruitment and managerial appointment dependent?


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Sandking - 04-22-2025

We set out to nullify the opposition under CC. Why? Because he was obsessed with doing his homework on the opposition. In fine detail. This is a percentage game. How much do you want to accommodate the opposition on match day. CC was mostly, if not entirely all in.

TM, probably did jack shit, or at best very little.

An example of going from one extreme to the other. Another example of a big seachange for the players.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - KRO - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 01:58 PM)Sandking Wrote: We set out to nullify the opposition under CC. Why? Because he was obsessed with doing his homework on the opposition. In fine detail. This is a percentage game. How much do you want to accommodate the opposition on match day. CC was mostly, if not entirely all in.

TM, probably did jack shit, or at best very little.

An example of going from one extreme to the other. Another example of a big seachange for the players.

In fairness we have a manager who in previous jobs analysed the opposition and still does now.
Our aim is to control possession and games. Has worked but will be interesting to see how he goes about things against better teams


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Tom Joad - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 01:52 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 01:50 PM)KRO Wrote: I’ve read that you’ve won 5 out of 17 since Mowbray was officially in the dug out v Boro. But you’d only won 4 out of 22 before that game. Just how big has this drop off been and was it a shock considering the style of play/coaching between CC and TM?
Btw I’m actually amazed at those stats if true

Key difference is that we barely lost under Corberan either, just drew every week.

Mowbray we now just lose.

I never saw a game under Corberan when we didn't try to win and we almost never looked like losing. It was frustrating when the opposition packed their area and our possession based football (for that's exactly what it was, Tony), didn't allow for anyone to take a chance and hit it.  In answer to KRO, Mowbray lost as many games in a week as Corberan did in 3 months, the difference is like night and day.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Ada - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 01:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't get this criticism of the players at all. Just look at how we defended and threw bodies on the line during the last ten minutes of the recent Bristol defeat.

They may not process quality, but that's not the sign of players who are trying to get a manager sacked, or don't care about their performances, and whatever lazy analogy you want to throw out there.

Agree at Bristol it was all down to Mowbray and a bizarre formation to start with Price up front. You could tell in the first half he’d lost the players. John Swift was anonymous. Then individual mistakes by Holgate, Molumby, Bartley and Griffiths cost us. However the players did battle hard at Bristol.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Derek Hardballs - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 04:26 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 01:52 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 01:50 PM)KRO Wrote: I’ve read that you’ve won 5 out of 17 since Mowbray was officially in the dug out v Boro. But you’d only won 4 out of 22 before that game. Just how big has this drop off been and was it a shock considering the style of play/coaching between CC and TM?
Btw I’m actually amazed at those stats if true

Key difference is that we barely lost under Corberan either, just drew every week.

Mowbray we now just lose.

I never saw a game under Corberan when we didn't try to win and we almost never looked like losing. It was frustrating when the opposition packed their area and our possession based football (for that's exactly what it was, Tony), didn't allow for anyone to take a chance and hit it.  In answer to KRO, Mowbray lost as many games in a week as Corberan did in 3 months, the difference is like night and day.

Because it’s easier to accept than the Emperor hasn’t and never did have any clothes.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Chrisalbionfan - 04-22-2025

Well i heard Kyle Bartley had a massive smile in training today


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Vinebaggie - 04-22-2025

Think most have us have been in work situations where our performance and morale dropped when we found ourselves working for a shit boss who didn't have a clue what he was doing. You always try to be professional and do your best, but when you see yourself and colleagues just generally being fucked about by someone who doesn't know what they're doing it really hits performance and it's no different for footballers. Leadership is everything and I wouldn't criticise these players performance under Mowbray because his management was just terrible.


RE: A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame - Mullers - 04-22-2025

(04-22-2025, 01:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't get this criticism of the players at all. Just look at how we defended and threw bodies on the line during the last ten minutes of the recent Bristol defeat.

They may not process quality, but that's not the sign of players who are trying to get a manager sacked, or don't care about their performances, and whatever lazy analogy you want to throw out there.

And yet we still allowed their lad to stroll into the box unmarked with time and space to shoot in the 96th minute. The defending has been woeful of late, but worse than that, the Coventry and Derby matches genuinely looked like some weren’t up for it. Someone else has said it but the error & jogging back for Derby’s third goal was near identical to Hogan’s third when we lost 3-1 to Blues.

The sacking was sadly the right decision, but the players aren’t blameless. Mowbray was spot on about some in his post-match comments.

FWIW, I’m optimistic about next year - we’re building a good core of young, valuable lads in Fellows, Heggem, Bany, Price and Griffiths. And even if Fellows leaves, we should pocket a good fee to help us further strengthen the group.