WBAUnofficial
Keeper scenario!? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Keeper scenario!? (/showthread.php?tid=36630)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Keeper scenario!? - wba13 - 02-13-2025

(02-13-2025, 08:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:23 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 07:18 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: We'd have lost last night with Palmer in goal. The GK position is not the issue.

Are we seriously writing off Wildsmith after two games, one of which he made two excellent saves to keep us in the game, which we went on to win!

He's been directly at fault for each of the last three goals we've conceded Josh.

That's not correct, is it. Even if it was, it's two games FFS. And are you conveniently ignoring the fact he kept us in the Sheffield U game with two superb saves?

It is correct. Go and watch the highlights. 

Sheff W - punched the ball straight back into danger.
Blackburn - threw the first in. Second cause chaos in the defence by coming, stopping and then retreating.

I've seen all 3 goals. I'm not sure he's at fault for either the Sheffield Wednesday goal (I can see why people see the initial save and see it fall to a striker and say it's poor 'keeping, but that initial save is a very good save, and it's on the defenders to not ball watch and stand still allowing a striker to have a free shot at goal) or the second Blackburn goal (hesitant, yes, but Blackburn had numbers, he didn't stand a chance, that goal is due to us giving the ball away too sloppily and not getting back quick enough. It was poor defending). I'd firmly point to the defence for both of those, rather than the GK. He should have done better for Blackburn's opener, granted. But that was a good finish from their point of view, too. 

Again, you have ignored the fact he had a good game v Wednesday and pulled off two very good saves to keep the score at 0-0 and then 1-0. Why won't you acknowledge that?

Don't get me wrong, I'd much prefer to have Griffiths between the sticks. I'm really not sure what Mowbray is playing at. That being said I'm not going to write off a GK who has had one good game and an average game in his first two games. That's ridiculous. 

There's plenty for Mowbray to work on. He's come into a very good team, has tried to tweak too much too fast, and we're looking far worse for it. Defeats to Plymouth, Boro and Blackburn, a win v the worst side I've seen at the Hawthorns for many a year, and a below par performance and a get-out-of-jail win v Wednesday. It's not encouraging, but he, of course, will need time to figure things out.
For all he did right against Wednesday the palm out of the cross was a mistake a bigger and more dominant keeper would claim or push the ball away from danger.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Jacko - 02-13-2025

He plays for struggling Championship teams. That's his level, they concede a lot of goals anyway so his errors don't really get highlighted.

The lad seems to be a good pro, and is a decent no.2 for a Championship club where resources are very tight. But there is no way he should be starting games unless absolutely necessary.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - MrBater - 02-13-2025

Wildsmith was golden gloves last year for Derby wasn't he? Am I right in thinking that JG has been getting rave reviews at that same level??

I honestly don't think we'll see much difference between them, but JG has to be given a chance to prove me wrong now.

Watching last night's clip, I still can't work out how the first goal went in.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Shabby Russian - 02-13-2025

(02-13-2025, 12:11 PM)Jacko Wrote: He plays for struggling Championship teams. That's his level, they concede a lot of goals anyway so his errors don't really get highlighted.

The lad seems to be a good pro, and is a decent no.2 for a Championship club where resources are very tight. But there is no way he should be starting games unless absolutely necessary.

He played in a promotion winning side last season.

I think mistakes would be very noticeable.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Kit Kat Chunky - 02-13-2025

(02-13-2025, 12:50 PM)MrBater Wrote: Wildsmith was golden gloves last year for Derby wasn't he? Am I right in thinking that JG has been getting rave reviews at that same level??

I honestly don't think we'll see much difference between them, but JG has to be given a chance to prove me wrong now.

Watching last night's clip, I still can't work out how the first goal went in.

Return of the hologram  Big Grin


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Ada - 02-13-2025

Wildsmith didn’t do enough last night. I thought Mowbray said in the press he’d let the keepers fight it out for a starting place, so on the basis of last night, Griffiths should start the next game.  I’m not writing Wildsmith off as a number 1 at the moment, I thought he did well against Sheffield Wednesday. 

My memory of Griffiths spell under CC, when Palmer was injured, was he did a decent job but wasn’t quite as good as Palmer at that stage. Palmer developed in my view since he came back from that spell out, and we should now give Griffiths that same chance, albeit behind are less organised defence.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Tom Joad - 02-13-2025

(02-12-2025, 10:57 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-12-2025, 10:54 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-12-2025, 10:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's fine, he's the "senior pro" who's been in the squad as the first team number 2. He's had his go, and in both games he's been vulnerable and made errors.

Josh should be in on Saturday. But don't think he will.

After the two games we've seen from Wildsmith, there should rightly be serious questions of Mowbray if Griffiths doesn't start on Saturday.

(02-12-2025, 10:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: Just wait for the meltdown when JG turns out to be no / not much better.

How do you find out if the idiot manager doesn't put him on the pitch.

I'm going the last time he played for us and was dodgy as fuck. Just hoping he has improved a lot.

Really? Griffiths played 2 games for us last season, Aldershot and wolves. I don't remember him being any kind of dodgy.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Josh1873 - 02-13-2025

Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - B68baggy2 - 02-13-2025

Wildsmith had his chance. Unless I'm missing something that first goal was almost a resignation letter. On the second his indecision made it much easier for their front two.


RE: Keeper scenario!? - Man from delmonte - 02-13-2025

(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Agreed Josh. There was 1 game (it was at home - he did an air kick - v Blackburn maybe?) where he screwed up but Griffiths was very good on the whole when he stepped in for Palmer a couple of years ago. Where this narrative has come in that he was dodgy or a liability is just odd. The only reason he didn't become our firm No.1 is because of Palmer's ability and reliability.