RE: Mogga - Winners and Losers? - Sliced - 01-19-2025
(01-19-2025, 06:33 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Oh yes we did. Just a couple on here thought it was boring. I always felt we were more likely to win than lose under CC.
Agreed. So many times I thought "We should've won that" as opposed to "We got away with one there"
RE: Mogga - Winners and Losers? - Birdman1811 - 01-19-2025
(01-19-2025, 06:33 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Oh yes we did. Just a couple on here thought it was boring. I always felt we were more likely to win than lose under CC.
Not what I saw across our fanbase, in fact a common comment when he left was that hopefully next manager won't be so desperate to defend al the time.
RE: Mogga - Winners and Losers? - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-19-2025
(01-19-2025, 06:33 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Oh yes we did. Just a couple on here thought it was boring. I always felt we were more likely to win than lose under CC.
But we didn't win, did we? Not after that crazy start to the season that gave us all such high hopes! Not losing gets you just above the relegation zone. Scoring goals wins you matches.
RE: Mogga - Winners and Losers? - SW4Baggie - 01-19-2025
(01-19-2025, 07:27 PM)Sliced Wrote: (01-19-2025, 06:33 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Oh yes we did. Just a couple on here thought it was boring. I always felt we were more likely to win than lose under CC.
Agreed. So many times I thought "We should've won that" as opposed to "We got away with one there"
Great point.
Corberan may have been more appreciated if we'd played worse and nicked the draws than playing well and not taking our chances, even though it results in the same number of points
RE: Mogga - Winners and Losers? - sickParrot - 01-19-2025
(01-19-2025, 07:29 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Not what I saw across our fanbase, in fact a common comment when he left was that hopefully next manager won't be so desperate to defend al the time.
100% this season especially
|