RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.
The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.
We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.
My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.
Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.
These are the majority of people that have not witnessed a Labour shit show. They are now, and they are changing their opinions in the masses.
It's a shame that it takes a once in a generation event for the idealists to be welcomed to the real world, which is happening now.
Stagflation, coming to the UK in 2025. A electoral mandate based on economic growth? My arse. FGK & Thieves kill the economy.
It's already been fucked over, for the thoughts on that I refer you back to your own and Proths posts from before the election. You've got a hard on after 6 months of a 5 year parliament, let's see where we are in 12 months.
RE: Council By Elections - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.
The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.
We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.
My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.
Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.
The article you linked was based on exit polls not facts, it was also clearly comparing a high point in the younger vote which will skew any results.. You'll need to engage with BB on why he considers that is true.
Can you tell me who that is please?
The CBI have called it. Labour is crashing the economy with their ill thought out budget.
This isn't stability, it's a crisis that is approaching Truss proportions.
RE: Council By Elections - Protheroe - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:37 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.
That's not what I said
What did you say then?
RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:38 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.
The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.
We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.
My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.
Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.
The article you linked was based on exit polls not facts, it was also clearly comparing a high point in the younger vote which will skew any results.. You'll need to engage with BB on why he considers that is true.
Can you tell me who that is please?
The CBI have called it. Labour is crashing the economy with their ill thought out budget.
This isn't stability, it's a crisis that is approaching Truss proportions.
Hysterical. Chunk you lose any credibility you have left with that sort of rhetoric. Truss's budget had global connotations, 45Bn of unfunded tax cuts and caused panic.
RE: Council By Elections - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:45 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:38 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
(12-23-2024, 11:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 09:12 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The major problem with these statistics is that they are not based on fact, they are based on opinion polls, exit polls mainly. I'm not denying there may be some substance to the basis of the point the actual detail is based on supposition. Also there is a major fault in the way it is measured, especially if you are looking at 'core vote', and that is 2019 was probably an outlier in GE voting because of 'Oh Jeremy Corbyn' fever that mobilised the younger vote. This in itself makes the headline probably correct but it doesn't give the full picture as the better measure would have been against 2015, 2010 or 2005.
The actual results from the elections do not have results measured by age groups, from what I can see, but it would be interesting to see this broken down. The article is flawed and also skewed which doesn't make it very plausible I'm afraid. It seems to be based on confirmation bias with the author identifying the angle before looking for the stats. It also the seeps into the mainstream where people like Proth will use it for their own confirmation bias.
We live in strange times, I'm afraid, where facts are secondary to opinions.
My confirmation bias? You don't agree with it so you think it's flawed.
Show me the evidence of BB's contention that Labour's core vote is "working class under 45s" then, or some other evidence.
The article you linked was based on exit polls not facts, it was also clearly comparing a high point in the younger vote which will skew any results.. You'll need to engage with BB on why he considers that is true.
Can you tell me who that is please?
The CBI have called it. Labour is crashing the economy with their ill thought out budget.
This isn't stability, it's a crisis that is approaching Truss proportions.
Hysterical. Chunk you lose any credibility you have left with that sort of rhetoric. Truss's budget had global connotations, 45Bn of unfunded tax cuts and caused panic.
When you have no answer, you call me hysterical. Your stance is laughable, my friend. The CBI are calling a potential recession. Labour have tanked in the ratings. The city have forced up bond market prices due to economic fears. That isn't rhetoric, those are facts.
Tell me one thing that Labour has done in the last 6 months that has benefitted the economy - which was the cornerstone of their paper thin election manifesto.
RE: Council By Elections - Protheroe - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
Anyone making a judgement on "failure" after a few months is reaching tbh.
There is no doubt that taxes had to rise and debt brought under control. If you didn't know this then you weren't looking and listening. Liz Kendall, for instance has a clear target to remove £3.5bn from the welfare budget.
My concern for growth is that by needlessly tying itself up in a fiscal straitjacket Labour's tax rises are hugely counterproductive. You cannot rely on distant planning reform, a bit of capital investment when you have cancelled more and the "promise" of cheaper energy (which Labour is retreating from at pace) to give you the growth you need to even maintain public services in the their current state let alone satisfy Dekka.
I genuinely wish them well, because the alternative downward doom loop does not bear thinking about.
RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024
Comparing the current situation to Truss's budget is hysterical nonsense. We are 6 months into a parliament and they're getting the shit news out of the way 1st because of the state that was left. The media frenzy for Labour negative focus will always be harder than the Tories, taking away a WFA from people that didn't need it after years of good pension increases and falling fuel costs was the right move, taxing farmers in line with the rest of the country was the right move (even if they still get a better deal). These are tough decisions that needed to be made to bring finances back into some form of reality. Kicking the can down the road had to stop somewhere.
Let's see where we are in 12 months.
Things that are hopeful for the next year - possible end to the conflict in Ukraine; better trade deal with the EU.
(12-23-2024, 11:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
Anyone making a judgement on "failure" after a few months is reaching tbh.
There is no doubt that taxes had to rise and debt brought under control. If you didn't know this then you weren't looking and listening. Liz Kendall, for instance has a clear target to remove £3.5bn from the welfare budget.
My concern for growth is that by needlessly tying itself up in a fiscal straitjacket Labour's tax rises are hugely counterproductive. You cannot rely on distant planning reform, a bit of capital investment when you have cancelled more and the "promise" of cheaper energy (which Labour is retreating from at pace) to give you the growth you need to even maintain public services in the their current state let alone satisfy Dekka.
I genuinely wish them well, because the alternative downward doom loop does not bear thinking about.
This is very close to where I am Proth, I can see the problems caused by the NI rise but there was no alternative after the Tory's had forced the situation throughout the campaign hoping for a Labour gaffe 'we will need to raise taxes', or a straightjacket when they got in. Labour knew it wouldn't take a lot to lose that wafer thin majority so were tied up in politics rather than what was best.
RE: Council By Elections - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 12:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Comparing the current situation to Truss's budget is hysterical nonsense. We are 6 months into a parliament and they're getting the shit news out of the way 1st because of the state that was left. The media frenzy for Labour negative focus will always be harder than the Tories, taking away a WFA from people that didn't need it after years of good pension increases and falling fuel costs was the right move, taxing farmers in line with the rest of the country was the right move (even if they still get a better deal). These are tough decisions that needed to be made to bring finances back into some form of reality. Kicking the can down the road had to stop somewhere.
Let's see where we are in 12 months.
Things that are hopeful for the next year - possible end to the conflict in Ukraine; better trade deal with the EU.
Answer the question, you brainwashed fool, don't rant with rhetoric.
What have Labour done in the past 6 months that will improve economic growth? I'm waiting for your answer.
(12-23-2024, 12:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Comparing the current situation to Truss's budget is hysterical nonsense. We are 6 months into a parliament and they're getting the shit news out of the way 1st because of the state that was left. The media frenzy for Labour negative focus will always be harder than the Tories, taking away a WFA from people that didn't need it after years of good pension increases and falling fuel costs was the right move, taxing farmers in line with the rest of the country was the right move (even if they still get a better deal). These are tough decisions that needed to be made to bring finances back into some form of reality. Kicking the can down the road had to stop somewhere.
Let's see where we are in 12 months.
Things that are hopeful for the next year - possible end to the conflict in Ukraine; better trade deal with the EU.
(12-23-2024, 11:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (12-23-2024, 11:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Here's the problem Dekka, you throw insults around about being insulated from problems without knowing the status and motivation of people so expect some piss taking back. Likening the current government speakers to Mel 'they left a note' Stride is just simply bullshit. Comparing someone who used a moment of dark humour to the current situation of highlighting how shit things really are is daft.
The reality is that because of the state of the country there are steps to take to get us back on track and solving all of the solutions at once isn't viable. On one hand you've spent the last few years arguing against populist politicians offering sunlit uplands and cake with every serving, rightly btw, but when you get politicians that are trying to deal with the shit you moan they are not offering enough cake.
You might not agree but we are better off simply by having a stable party in place taking the problems seriously rather than the last mob who were more focussed on flawed ideology and self promotion. There are some serious tasks ahead but talk of a failed government and Starmer being replaced are both far from the truth and wildy misunderstanding of how the Labour party works.
Anyone making a judgement on "failure" after a few months is reaching tbh.
There is no doubt that taxes had to rise and debt brought under control. If you didn't know this then you weren't looking and listening. Liz Kendall, for instance has a clear target to remove £3.5bn from the welfare budget.
My concern for growth is that by needlessly tying itself up in a fiscal straitjacket Labour's tax rises are hugely counterproductive. You cannot rely on distant planning reform, a bit of capital investment when you have cancelled more and the "promise" of cheaper energy (which Labour is retreating from at pace) to give you the growth you need to even maintain public services in the their current state let alone satisfy Dekka.
I genuinely wish them well, because the alternative downward doom loop does not bear thinking about.
This is very close to where I am Proth, I can see the problems caused by the NI rise but there was no alternative after the Tory's had forced the situation throughout the campaign hoping for a Labour gaffe 'we will need to raise taxes', or a straightjacket when they got in. Labour knew it wouldn't take a lot to lose that wafer thin majority so were tied up in politics rather than what was best.
Put far better than I could, Proth. LVT or Income Tax should have been the key drivers, together with tying the Public Sector into productivity improvements in return for pay rises.
RE: Council By Elections - baggy1 - 12-23-2024
This is where you let yourself down chunk. You are that short sighted you can’t see that the restoration of our economy will take longer than six months, all I see when you post is someone threatening to scweem and scweem until they give me what I want.
Six months in a minimum wage has been increased, junior doctor strikes ended, increased protection for abuse victims, railways being taken back into public ownership, water companies being proposed, breakfast clubs rolled out, proposals for registers of kids not in schools. Rebuilding a fucked economy takes years and not months.
RE: Council By Elections - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2024
(12-23-2024, 12:25 PM)baggy1 Wrote: This is where you let yourself down chunk. You are that short sighted you can’t see that the restoration of our economy will take longer than six months, all I see when you post is someone threatening to scweem and scweem until they give me what I want.
Six months in a minimum wage has been increased, junior doctor strikes ended, increased protection for abuse victims, railways being taken back into public ownership, water companies being proposed, breakfast clubs rolled out, proposals for registers of kids not in schools. Rebuilding a fucked economy takes years and not months.
This is where your rhetoric and sanctimonious rubbish shows you up for what you are.
Answer the question. What has Labour done in the past 6 months to encourage economic growth? Nothing.
Minimum wage wont increase growth - just hamper businesses who will cut back on staff due to increased costs, a fundamental error along with Employers NI which is strangling the economy. Junior Doctors are threatening strikes again, and NHS waiting lists aren't reducing any time soon to make a difference. Increased protection for victim abuse - very noble and necessary but won't improve growth. Railways - did you try and get a train at The Hawthorns yesterday? Water Companies - OFWAT needs to be scrapped but Labour don't have the balls to do it. Breakfast Clubs - That's really going to lead to the Economic growth that Labour have trumpeted. Kids not in schools - Are labour going to send them up chimneys at 14 to earn a few quid?
Rebuilding an economy might take years. Fucking up the fastest growing economy in the G7 (fact prior to the election) takes around 6 months.
|