WBAUnofficial
The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector (/showthread.php?tid=35835)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-06-2024

(12-06-2024, 09:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one hand you say there aren’t enough GPs, Dentists, or decent schools etc, but then you advocate building proper towns - who is going to be the GP, Dentist or teacher in these new towns if there aren’t enough anyway?

So the Labour solution is to build new estates with no new schools, shops, GPs, public transport on the edges of towns with already failing infrastructure.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-06-2024

You avoided the question I see, if you think converting retail space into residential is cheaper than building new houses you might be surprised. There has to be a combination of the different approaches, not building new estates on the edges of existing infrastucture is not something that should be dismissed so easily.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Borin' Baggie - 12-06-2024

(12-06-2024, 09:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one hand you say there aren’t enough GPs, Dentists, or decent schools etc, but then you advocate building proper towns - who is going to be the GP, Dentist or teacher in these new towns if there aren’t enough anyway?

So the Labour solution is to build new estates with no new schools, shops, GPs, public transport on the edges of towns with already failing infrastructure.

Are you completely unaware of the concept of planning orders and S106 or something?


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-06-2024

(12-06-2024, 09:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You avoided the question I see, if you think converting retail space into residential is cheaper than building new houses you might be surprised. There has to be a combination of the different approaches, not building new estates on the edges of existing infrastucture is not something that should be dismissed so easily.

I don’t care about the cheapest solutions they are invariably the poorest and laziest option that store up problems for the medium to long term. 50s and 60s tower blocks for example having to be torn down barely 30 years after being built creating huge problems with crime and living conditions and judging by many social houses I’ve seen put up in the early 2000’s they are going the same way. 

I appreciate this current Labour incarnation have seemingly zero imagination or ability to anticipate what problems their policies will bring about but, building cheap poor quality shoebox homes on on the edges of towns, rather than creating new well thought out towns offering genuinely decent and affordable houses in decent areas with proper infrastructure, services, leisure and public transport will create the same problems 50s and 60s town planners created. You used to argue for long term solutions, building on the outskirts of already struggling towns is a sticking plaster solution.

(12-06-2024, 10:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one hand you say there aren’t enough GPs, Dentists, or decent schools etc, but then you advocate building proper towns - who is going to be the GP, Dentist or teacher in these new towns if there aren’t enough anyway?

So the Labour solution is to build new estates with no new schools, shops, GPs, public transport on the edges of towns with already failing infrastructure.

Are you completely unaware of the concept of planning orders and S106 or something?

I used to think your user name was ironic. In answer to your question I’ve seen lots of new shoebox, poor quality estates built and a couple of shop units tagged on as a tick box exercise. Or a ‘park’ also known as a patch of grass with a poorly maintained kids playground that falls to pieces after a few years as no one wants to take responsibility for it.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-06-2024

What makes you think building houses on edges of towns is sticking plaster short termism? You only have to look at developments like Dickens Heath, built 25 years ago and still growing, as a long term solution on the edges of a town. You appear to have got in your head that there is only one solution when there will be many different ways of meeting the goals. Arguing for perfection will only result in nothing getting done.

Here you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dickens_Heath


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Borin' Baggie - 12-06-2024

(12-06-2024, 10:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 10:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one hand you say there aren’t enough GPs, Dentists, or decent schools etc, but then you advocate building proper towns - who is going to be the GP, Dentist or teacher in these new towns if there aren’t enough anyway?

So the Labour solution is to build new estates with no new schools, shops, GPs, public transport on the edges of towns with already failing infrastructure.

Are you completely unaware of the concept of planning orders and S106 or something?

I used to think your user name was ironic. In answer to your question I’ve seen lots of new shoebox, poor quality estates built and a couple of shop units tagged on as a tick box exercise. Or a ‘park’ also known as a patch of grass with a poorly maintained kids playground that falls to pieces after a few years as no one wants to take responsibility for it.

So you don't understand the concept of planning orders and S106 then.

And one of the S106 orders my local council has agreed regarding developments to the south of Leamington and Warwick related to the funding of a new country park. Or is 49 hectares too small for you?


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-07-2024

(12-06-2024, 10:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 10:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 10:07 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-06-2024, 09:12 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one hand you say there aren’t enough GPs, Dentists, or decent schools etc, but then you advocate building proper towns - who is going to be the GP, Dentist or teacher in these new towns if there aren’t enough anyway?

So the Labour solution is to build new estates with no new schools, shops, GPs, public transport on the edges of towns with already failing infrastructure.

Are you completely unaware of the concept of planning orders and S106 or something?

I used to think your user name was ironic. In answer to your question I’ve seen lots of new shoebox, poor quality estates built and a couple of shop units tagged on as a tick box exercise. Or a ‘park’ also known as a patch of grass with a poorly maintained kids playground that falls to pieces after a few years as no one wants to take responsibility for it.

So you don't understand the concept of planning orders and S106 then.

And one of the S106 orders my local council has agreed regarding developments to the south of Leamington and Warwick related to the funding of a new country park. Or is 49 hectares too small for you?

I don’t live in a leafy MCW area that has 49 hectares of land to put aside. I live in a built up, working class area with limited greenbelt that people in the area use for leisure and is also farmed. Those are the areas that developers will target around the Black Country and they are the areas where the infrastructure and access to health, good schools and public transport are already struggling or missing entirely.

B1 a point about Dickens Heath is another example of well meaning but completely out of touch middle class professionals telling other what’s good for the them, the average house price in Dickens Heath is £180- £350k not affordable to millions of people, it’s a commuter belt  area where people have options when it comes to leisure, health, shops and financial autonomy it’s not an area that a struggling local authority will try and fill every bit of land with poor quality, stacked high housing on already crumbling infrastructure.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-07-2024

So what are you asking for? You live in a built up area with no space that you want redeveloped. You don’t want people to have to move out to the town outskirts? How would that be possible? And what numbers are you talking about?


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Pipkins - 12-07-2024

(12-06-2024, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just test the logic there a bit, if you build 1000 houses does that mean that 2000 cars appear from nowhere?, Do the people using the services just start to use those services when the houses are built, as if they have not been using services before? Will there be more children for schools or the same amount of children moved from an overcrowded school to the new school? Is the land really agricultural or just land that is being sat on whilst the value increases? Maybe the reason for the building on flood planes (that bit I agree) is that the better areas are being restricted by NIMBYs.

Road and Rail is generally already in place but there will be improvements needed but again you are not creating new motorists, you are just moving them from one congested area to a less congested area.

The council tax payers numbers will be increased obviously meaning more funds for the council.

Your argument has holes.

If people are moving from one area to another where there a B roads compared to dual carriageways 
If people are relocating say from Birmngham to Staffordshire where population will increase significantly 
If a school or GP practice is currently full with the numbers it has 
If you live in an area where road rail services are nonn existent 
The council funds will increase but the money doesnt pay for extra service 
GP practices come from NHS budgets 
Schools from educations budgets
Central Governnment make decisions on other big projects 

Its a politicians promises with no thought to how it will work 
Thats because they listen to advisors & the like lobbyists

Not local people whom they are supposed to represent 

THe new super hospital in Smethwick for example
Issues around lack of parking & transport for users & staff

The NHS are leasing offices from Sandwell Council as all the capacity is full already


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-07-2024

So you are suggesting they stay where they are in overcrowded areas and not move out to new developments?