WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=35716)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Ratings - Mr Nimbus - 11-24-2024

Watching MOTD this morning, just out of sheer curiosity to see Man City being spanked at home, was a good reminder of the difference in quality of finishing between the divisions.

Some thoughts.

Mikey getting better each week, a goal could spark him. Follows back to doing what he does best but would love to see him ping a left footer in the top corner before end of season. Maja is a beast but needs back up. If CC doesn't want to give Cole mire minutes we need to go to the loan market in Jan. Grant, that goal stands and he's MOM.

M&M are a great combo in the middle. Mowatt not quite hitting the heights but just tick, tick, ticks

Defence is doing a sterling job considering we are on our fourth and fifth choice CBs. Heggem!! Be interesting to see what CC does against Sunderland.

Subs. Oh dear. Cole though needs more minutes surely.


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 11-24-2024

(11-23-2024, 07:12 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Bonkers score for Holgate, pal.

Palmer - 6

Furlong - 6
Holgate - 6
Heggem - 6
Styles - 7

Fellows  - 8
Molumby - 8
Mowatt - 7
MJ - 7

Maja - 8
Grant - 8

Subs:

Racic - 6
Wallace and Bobbins - 4
Cole and Swift - nothing to report.
That is closer to how I saw it.
Palmer 7. Some game-changing saves
Furlong 6. Decent, occupied with the Norwich breaks and unable to make his usual contribution to our attack.
Holgate 6. I like the lad but realistically, that goal spared him a 5.
Heggem 7. Decent against lively opponents. Great tackle 2nd half.
Styles 7. Bags of energy and does carry the ball forward at pace. 
Mowatt 6. Metronomic in reliability, faded a little (by his own standards).
Molumby 8. Everywhere. Drives forward with the ball like no one else in the squad.
Mikey 7. Even when not scoring he creates enough space for others plus not afraid to shoot. Ought to have hit the
               target with that one though.
Fellows 8. I got to 5 great crosses before I lost count. Uses both feet and can shoot. 
Grant 8.  Superb energy balanced with a goal threat. Robbed of a goal (and a 9) by a clueless ref.
Maja 7. Great finish, tired and ended up playing in deep mid 2nd half?
Subs.
Wallace 5
Dobbins 5
Racic 6
Cole Barely got a touch.
Swift . Pointless sub at that stage.

Carlos 6. Tried to win it, lots of tinkering, tweaking and waving us forward but ultimately, mainly poor substitutions.

Ref 4.  Got the flow of the game right but those inconsistancies? Sainz goes down screaming like a 3 y/o and gets Furlong on a card. Foul probably, I thought he wanted the free kick, booking absolutely not. TLater, Heggem puts his head on the ball and gets a clout, no booking, then is left off the field for an eternity while Norwich attack. A bounce up "awarded" to the opposition after one of their players goes down dramatically after a shadow fell across him? Plus, that Grant shot that hit the net with no one seeing anything wrong?

All in all, a very entertaining game that we shaded but could also have gone either way. Carlos really won't be happy with their 1st, a most un-Albion goal to concede. We have probably seen the Championship player of the season yesterday although I wouldn't have fancied his chances in the Wolvo Amateur Saturday league or much less in the Sandwell Sunday Morning.


RE: Ratings - Bob Fossil - 11-24-2024

(11-24-2024, 01:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-23-2024, 07:12 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Bonkers score for Holgate, pal.

Palmer - 6

Furlong - 6
Holgate - 6
Heggem - 6
Styles - 7

Fellows  - 8
Molumby - 8
Mowatt - 7
MJ - 7

Maja - 8
Grant - 8

Subs:

Racic - 6
Wallace and Bobbins - 4
Cole and Swift - nothing to report.
That is closer to how I saw it.
Palmer 7. Some game-changing saves
Furlong 6. Decent, occupied with the Norwich breaks and unable to make his usual contribution to our attack.
Holgate 6. I like the lad but realistically, that goal spared him a 5.
Heggem 7. Decent against lively opponents. Great tackle 2nd half.
Styles 7. Bags of energy and does carry the ball forward at pace. 
Mowatt 6. Metronomic in reliability, faded a little (by his own standards).
Molumby 8. Everywhere. Drives forward with the ball like no one else in the squad.
Mikey 7. Even when not scoring he creates enough space for others plus not afraid to shoot. Ought to have hit the
               target with that one though.
Fellows 8. I got to 5 great crosses before I lost count. Uses both feet and can shoot. 
Grant 8.  Superb energy balanced with a goal threat. Robbed of a goal (and a 9) by a clueless ref.
Maja 7. Great finish, tired and ended up playing in deep mid 2nd half?
Subs.
Wallace 5
Dobbins 5
Racic 6
Cole Barely got a touch.
Swift . Pointless sub at that stage.

Carlos 6. Tried to win it, lots of tinkering, tweaking and waving us forward but ultimately, mainly poor substitutions.

Ref 4.  Got the flow of the game right but those inconsistancies? Sainz goes down screaming like a 3 y/o and gets Furlong on a card. Foul probably, I thought he wanted the free kick, booking absolutely not. TLater, Heggem puts his head on the ball and gets a clout, no booking, then is left off the field for an eternity while Norwich attack. A bounce up "awarded" to the opposition after one of their players goes down dramatically after a shadow fell across him? Plus, that Grant shot that hit the net with no one seeing anything wrong?

All in all, a very entertaining game that we shaded but could also have gone either way. Carlos really won't be happy with their 1st, a most un-Albion goal to concede. We have probably seen the Championship player of the season yesterday although I wouldn't have fancied his chances in the Wolvo Amateur Saturday league or much less in the Sandwell Sunday Morning.
Good shout re the ref. Convinced he didn’t see the handball and, as the linesman didn’t flag, could only be the Norwich players that convinced him. He definitely didn’t see the Furlong foul and just reacted to Sainz screaming.