WBAUnofficial
Are we a boring team now? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Are we a boring team now? (/showthread.php?tid=35291)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Lurker#3 - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 04:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 03:43 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 03:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 03:22 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 03:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s a bit of cliche to say you need a tricky/fast footed number 10 to perform a moment of skill to unlock a defence sitting deep and putting men behind the ball. Particularly if we are saying Diangana is that player to be able to do this consistently, something he’s not achieved since he signed permanently. 

One of best opportunities to unlock a stubborn team showing little sign of attacking ambition is to make the most of set pieces and we are not great at them despite having some big and powerful players in the team. More should be done on this aspect of our game no matter how unfashionable it is. Also patiently building from the back hoping forlornly that a team suddenly abandons its game plan and piles players forward inevitably leads to ludicrous levels of possession but very little in dangerous areas. 

This isn’t a criticism of CC really, it’s more about the formulaic, group think around contemporary coaching. There is very little variety of play, teams play out from the back, playing little triangles with the keeper, when that fails to produce any space ideas dry up as teams fail to have any other way of playing.

I don't particularly disagree with both of these points. It's interesting to see however that we have the 6th lowest number of players being fouled which count as a shot creating action. Which shows we are not drawing enough fouls in dangerous areas, when teams are sat in deep. 

We are also 15th in the league for 'Takes Ons Attempted', and 14th in terms of general number of fouls against. 

So whilst we need to improve our output from set pieces we need to increase the number of offensive dead ball opportunities we create. And it is this which calls for 'tricky, fast footed, forwards'. 

Number of fouls against our players this season per 90:

Grady - 2.38
Fellows -1.69
Wallace - 1.58
Furlong - 1.56

You can’t draw those fouls in attacking areas if the majority of your possession is in your own half, waiting, hoping, praying the opposition decide to abandon their defensive tactics and shape. 

We have many technically good players in Mowatt, Swift, Diangana, Johnson, Racic, Fellows etc but they aren’t going to draw many fouls of any use if we are relying on slowly building from the back and failing to get the ball forward into more dangerous areas of the pitch. I’m not suggesting aimless long balls but currently we aren’t offering anything different for the opposition to think about or act upon. The tempo is slow, possession is intricate, passing 80/90% of the time short and shooting outside the box is limited both in number and technique.

I think we agree on the issues for what's it's worth. 

But I think you may be over simplifying the solutions. You can't just press a button and 'play quicker', it's pointless going more direct when there's no space behind or down the sides of defences, there's not much value in just shooting more from distance if there's 2 lines of defenders and a keeper between the shooter and the goal. 

You need to find better balance in the XI. You need to get good players closer to each other to allow easy link ups, you need to have players who instinctively make threatening movements and get into areas of the pitch that creates uncertainty amongst the opposition defenders. 

For all of Fellows ability and threat and output this season, his movement is predictable and simple, as is Grants, as is Molumby and Mowatt. 

Swift, Grady, MJ and Maja are all abit cuter and more aware of their positioning. But then Swift can't really do it with his back to goal higher up the pitch.

I’m not suggesting we can just launch the ball into two banks of 4/5 players or look for space that isn’t there but the players you mentioned are really not that cute with the ball. Diangana loses possession too easily in every position he’s asked to play, Johnson consistently cuts inside and if this doesn’t work there’s not much to his game that unlocks stubborn well organised defences. It might work on the training pitch/sports science but as we saw on Saturday it didn’t work in reality. 

Tempo is one thing that can be quickened as can the pace of passing, similarly cutting down on the navel gazing with endless passing between the centre halves and goalkeeper only to end up in the same place you started ten passes earlier. This serves a purpose when you’re looking to bring the opposition on to you but if they aren’t willing to you’re just wasting your own time with the ball. 

Saying all this we’ve seen ourselves how far you can get with limited players if they are well organised and defensively sound at a far higher level than we are currently playing. Millwall were brilliant at what they set out to do so hats off to them.

Only with the right personal. 

Mowatt takes loads of time on the ball when he drops between the 2 CBs. The difference is when he does pick a pass it's progressive and often beats a line of press. 

In the same position, Bart's, Heggem, Molumby etc often play a simple square ball. Ajayi and Furlong in all fairness do try and play penetrative passes through the lines. 

So whilst I agree that we need to 'play at a higher tempo', the root of that solution is in the personnel during those phases of games (or whole games in some cases) where the opponent show no threat or ambition.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Tom Joad - 10-06-2024

The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Lurker#3 - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 04:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was  when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.

Semi has the ability to pass the ball progressively, through the lines. He also has the ability to pass it poorly and recklessly. They are usually closely linked with non elite players. 

Bart's rarely gives away possession has a great range of passing, but rarely if ever plays a risky, 'vertical' pass. This is the same with Heggem at fullback. I think he could play better passes from CB if he was recieving the ball facing forwards with time. 

To vary the tactics you need to vary the personnel first. Having Dike back, if he can stay fit, would be a huge boost as we would have a target man to hit early and play off.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Sliced - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 05:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 04:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was  when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.

Semi has the ability to pass the ball progressively, through the lines. He also has the ability to pass it poorly and recklessly. They are usually closely linked with non elite players. 

Bart's rarely gives away possession has a great range of passing, but rarely if ever plays a risky, 'vertical' pass. This is the same with Heggem at fullback. I think he could play better passes from CB if he was recieving the ball facing forwards with time. 

To vary the tactics you need to vary the personnel first. Having Dike back, if he can stay fit, would be a huge boost as we would have a target man to hit early and play off.

If you're going to attempt more progressive passes then inevitably you're going to give the ball away more often. Bartley's pass accuracy is 88% compared to Ajayi's 87% despite the former almost exclusively playing short passes and the latter one playing a combination of short passes and progressive ones.

Neither of our centre backs are elite but it's pretty clear that Ajayi's strengths are more in ball playing, tackling and general athleticism, Bartley's strengths are in blocks and being probably the best header of the ball in the league.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Tom Joad - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 05:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 04:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was  when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.

Semi has the ability to pass the ball progressively, through the lines. He also has the ability to pass it poorly and recklessly. They are usually closely linked with non elite players. 

Bart's rarely gives away possession has a great range of passing, but rarely if ever plays a risky, 'vertical' pass. This is the same with Heggem at fullback. I think he could play better passes from CB if he was recieving the ball facing forwards with time. 

To vary the tactics you need to vary the personnel first. Having Dike back, if he can stay fit, would be a huge boost as we would have a target man to hit early and play off.

I don't disagree with a lot of what you say. I simply think our usual game of keeping possession can be varied a little. Yesterday's opponents didn't want the ball, or even to commit to attack. So a few balls hit hard through the channels risking losing possession, would not have been the end of the world. Overall, I have few complaints, you get these games in a 46 match slog. I've seen enough to suggest we'll be in the mix at the right end of the table so don't get too troubled at dropping the odd point.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Lurker#3 - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 05:27 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 05:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(10-06-2024, 04:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: The reason our centre backs have the ball a lot is because the other side are content with it. I know a guy that coached at a decent level, from a family with more than one pro footballer in and schooled in tactics etc. He pointed out things I had never considered. One of which was  when watching Micah Richards, (for England or at villa), he said the opponents let him have the ball knowing everyone else likely to hurt them is covered. They just let him have the ball. No disrespect to Barts or Ajayi but this week when we have been chasing the game at the death, who has the ball the most? All the flair players are well marked and all 11 opponents compressed ahead of the danger area. That is why we need to mix up the tactics more.

Semi has the ability to pass the ball progressively, through the lines. He also has the ability to pass it poorly and recklessly. They are usually closely linked with non elite players. 

Bart's rarely gives away possession has a great range of passing, but rarely if ever plays a risky, 'vertical' pass. This is the same with Heggem at fullback. I think he could play better passes from CB if he was recieving the ball facing forwards with time. 

To vary the tactics you need to vary the personnel first. Having Dike back, if he can stay fit, would be a huge boost as we would have a target man to hit early and play off.

If you're going to attempt more progressive passes then inevitably you're going to give the ball away more often. Bartley's pass accuracy is 88% compared to Ajayi's 87% despite the former almost exclusively playing short passes and the latter one playing a combination of short passes and progressive ones.

Neither of our centre backs are elite but it's pretty clear that Ajayi's strengths are more in ball playing, tackling and general athleticism, Bartley's strengths are in blocks and being probably the best header of the ball in the league.

Bart's has the second most total progressive passing distance in the team actually behind Palmer obviously. Semi has completed more individual progressive passes though and attempted more long passes. But Bart has a huge number of short and medium length passes. 

But you're right Semi plays more vertical, penetrative passes, as is shown by the fact that Semi has played as many passes into the final third as Swifty and nearly a third more than Barts. 

I don't think our issues are from CB at all to be honest. I think it's from CM and Fullback (especially with DFs poor last 2 games).


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Birdman1811 - 10-06-2024

Furlong going off the boil is very bad for us. It's why Fellows has struggled more, which means the attack as a whole struggles.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Derek Hardballs - 10-06-2024

How can Furlong be effective in a game such as yesterday’s? He can’t be waltzing down the wing swapping passes with Fellows or feed balls through to TF or whipping in crosses all match with so many players in front of him. I don’t think there has been a drop of form, just the nature of the games we have played.

Btw this is the first time in months there’s been a really interesting WBA thread that’s about erm the actual game not finances or behaviour of fans etc.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Birdman1811 - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 06:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How can Furlong be effective in a game such as yesterday’s? He can’t be waltzing down the wing swapping passes with Fellows or feed balls through to TF or whipping in crosses all match with so many players in front of him. I don’t think there has been a drop of form, just the nature of the games we have played.

Btw this is the first time in months there’s been a really interesting WBA thread that’s about erm the actual game not finances or behaviour of fans etc.

And that's how Milwall stifled us.

It's always difficult against teams who plan for a draw like Millwall did yesterday, even the very best teams struggle with it. There isn't a slider that CC can switch to 'up the tempo' it's worked on all week every week the only impact that changes it is certain players being quicker in tempo naturally. CC has shown he clearly dislikes long balls down the channels hoping someone runs onto it, so asking for it isn't going to change that, same way Pulis refuses to have defence pass out, the same way Megson won't allow more than one player to be able to do anything progressive, the same way Roy wouldn't have full-backs overlapping. Coaches have certain principles that are worked on all week every week, in a professional game of football, players rarely look to make a pass if the tempo increases, they have an instinctive knowledge of where teammates will be from the week of training due to the speed of the modern game.

People ask for Plan B and as I said so many times before, they simply do not exist in modern football, every coach has Plan A, anything else is arranging deckchairs to do Plan A better, the game is too quick to have various styles and shapes during a game.


RE: Are we a boring team now? - Lurker#3 - 10-06-2024

(10-06-2024, 06:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How can Furlong be effective in a game such as yesterday’s? He can’t be waltzing down the wing swapping passes with Fellows or feed balls through to TF or whipping in crosses all match with so many players in front of him. I don’t think there has been a drop of form, just the nature of the games we have played.

Btw this is the first time in months there’s been a really interesting WBA thread that’s about erm the actual game not finances or behaviour of fans etc.

DF isnt a marauding wingback. He's a traditional style fullback, but in recent times he's added a real ability to pass effectively and progressively. 

He normally has the most, or nearly the most progressive passes in the team. The last 3 games he's not been anywhere near that. He has been dispossesed more, has taken poor touches and has taken up poor positions at times off the ball. All things he normally doesn't. He will of course be fine, though. 

Regarding this thread, I was thinking exactly the same. How refreshing to have a good old debate about football!