WBAUnofficial
What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? (/showthread.php?tid=34039)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - baggy1 - 06-12-2024

(06-12-2024, 02:25 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(06-12-2024, 12:19 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-12-2024, 07:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The biggest challenge at this election is for the parties to show us how they are going to reform our welfare system and NHS to future proof it against an ageing population with hoarded wealth.

I would like to see state pension fall into a UC style model. Where it tops up income when you get to retirement age. So if you have a private pension/non earned income, annually of 40k, you frankly don't need that benefit.

Also, the NHS needs serious reform in the face of a growing, ageing and generally more unhealthy population. I never want to see the principle of "free at the point of use" taken away for those that need it, but I think some careful tax breaks for the middle classes if they have private medical insurance should be considered in line with salary sacrifice schemes that not everyone has access to.

As much as this sounds like sense there are a few holes - what are you calling non-earned income and how would you measure it? Are you talking about drawing down from savings and if that is the case then people will just stop saving and either give it to their kids or spend it. And I think you'd be surprised about how few people have pensions that give them £40k.

And as for the salary sacrifice schemes, private medical insurance route, you are mainly looking at employed people in that bracket and by definition probably under 65 which is exactly the demographic that tend not to use it that much. The ones that use it are the elderly who may not have access to PMI. Otherwise are you saying that people who have cancer treatment should be making sure they have adequate insurance - i have an example of a colleague that is terrified of losing her job because of the medical insurance that looks after her husband who is terminal, she has to travel away from her husband who needs very personal care a lot of the time because she feels pressured, that's not how the system should work.

Non-earned income; rent from second properties, dividends, capital gains, interest in savings etc. 

Regarding your colleague; no, I am not afraid all saying they should bankrupt themselves for care. In fact that's the exact reason why "free at the point of use" is so important. But the more people you can incentivise to use PMI, the less general demand there is on the NHS. Meaning they can focus their funds care and attention in those who require the nationalised care. 

You mention those 65+, but what about the millions of routine surgeries such at musculoskeletal and skin surgeries that could be hoovered up by people's PMI, releasing thousands of operating slots.

(06-12-2024, 12:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Means testing the state pension will merely result in a collapse in private pension savings.

The NHS needs root and branch reform, one aspect of which is to incentivise people not use it - instead of taxing PMI as a benefit if it's provided through an employer.

There should definitely be sanctions for failing to turn up to an appointment too.

Why's this, Proth?

I can see the argument for non-earned income in that context L3 but each one of those is a taxed income anyway and for any capital gains that would cause a problem as it will generally be a one off amount. That leaves you in a situation where you could qualify one year and not the next, which would mean a repayment of amounts received or reduction of those paid the next year (when there isn't the one off amount coming in). It adds a whole heap of complication if you include capital gains, for example - you need an operation and cash in an investment that you've made money on over time - that gain would be taxed and then you'd also potentially lose your pension as well. That feels wrong. Ongoing income such a rental income I can see the argument, the rest are potentially too volatile and would mean potentially being in and out of scope in different years which is a nightmare to administer.

And I have to agree with Proth the unintended consequence of means testing anything is that the individual will change their behaviour. Instead of having an extra £4k per year in a annuity of £100k, the individual is likely to give the money to the kids if it costs the £15k in state pension. Especially if that amount takes them over the means tested threshold.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Derek Hardballs - 06-12-2024

From Led Bu Donkey’s…

REVEALED: the campaigners who dreamed up the contents of Liz Truss’s mini-budget have given the Conservative Party £35m. Guess which address this leads back to in London. Proth this is where you argue it’s perfectly normal and healthy to have opaque and unaccountable bodies and individuals funding and informing the governments policies recently and now bank rolling the same parties campaign.

Don’t forget to use ludicrous phrases like ‘visceral hatred’ when arguing unaccountable libertarian think tanks and similar should have such an influence on U.K. politics.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Borin' Baggie - 06-12-2024

(06-12-2024, 04:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-12-2024, 01:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Your preferred system is a 19th century system that already failed.

I do not see how changing the funding model will make a lick of difference, it's not like NICs being on your paycheck (a holdover from when we had a social insurance system) makes a difference and the amount of public money spent on the NHS and on HSC in general is already publicly available. The two biggest chokepoints are two systems that are from when we only had the social insurance system.

It's the relationship between the individual and the state that needs to change, however you dress up the funding. Are there many other civilised European countries who'd put up with the shit we do? And then treat it as a national religion?

We're insanely deferential to an institution that's failed as much as the system it replaced. Just yesterday I found out a great friend of mine has been given a terminal diagnosis having been give the all clear after a scan 6 months ago.

And how does that change with a social insurance model? 

I want something tangible, not hope.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Protheroe - 06-12-2024

Hypothecating funding and removing the NHS from day to day political control is an integral part of changing our relationship with it IMO.

I know you'll never agree, so there's little point in you and I ever discussing it further.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Borin' Baggie - 06-12-2024

You can't ignore that the issues we have with the NHS don't exist in other Beveridge Model countries.

And I've said multiple times that we need to spend less money on the NHS and more on primary and social care, that has nowt to do with the funding model though, so clearly I also believe that the NHS gets to much attention - I just have seen zero evidence that changing the funding model with fix that, given what's been happening in Germany with more money being poured into hospital care at the expense of other areas of care that seems to be a very strong parallel to our issues even with a social insurance model.


RE: What is the difference between Truss and Sunak’s tax cuts? - Protheroe - 06-12-2024

Yes, I hear that BB. And I'm in complete agreement with you about the fixation on hospitals and a greater emphasis on primary and social care (though social care needs individual funding from the wealthy). I like what I hear from Streeting, in fact I shall be in touch with him soon about an abject market failure we've found across multiple trusts' procurement.