WBAUnofficial
Our style - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our style (/showthread.php?tid=33778)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Our style - Derek Hardballs - 05-18-2024

(05-18-2024, 08:43 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(05-17-2024, 11:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-17-2024, 11:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ll get hammered for this, but who cares… in the last 5 years or so, the one manager who I’ve agreed with the most has been Val. I think for a team of our resources the high press, high fitness approach is the best way of us being successful. Whilst we cannot spend the money of the top clubs, there is no reason why we cannot have their fitness or desire… for all the advancements of football since the 1990s, Steve Coppell and Lou Macari’s quotes how about whilst we may not have the quality of Man Utd, there’s no excuse we can’t have the fitness reign true.

No hammering from me.

I rate CC very highly, but I really, really wish we'd been able to back Val fully. Sadly he is his own worst enemy as seen everywhere else since fans never get onside and too many players fall out with him.

Ishmael has been sacked twice since. 
Whatever is the question Valball isn’t the answer.

We spent was it £7m on Dike at his request? In a season where barely any money in the division was spent by other clubs. Valball was truly abysmal binary football. He was backed, he was shite.


RE: Our style - Brentbaggie - 05-18-2024

We really can't go over this again. If Some feel CC's approach is dull then explain why so many fans - me included - stopped watching, never mind going, within around ten games of Val being in charge. Even in our worst seasons it never prevented me from attending or watching when I couldn't get to games. The last time we were at the Hawthorns is the only time my daughter has asked if we could leave way before the end - and we weren't losing either.


RE: Our style - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-18-2024

Some entertaining stuff on this thread. The old support for Val and his awful one-dimensional style showing its face. Bruce being some sort of genius in the transfer market.

The No 9 question is the big one. We never replaced prolific goal-scorers in JRod and Gayle. Austin and HRK chipped in with a respectable number and Grant scored 18 in a season without making any friends at all. But goals from midfield kept us on track.

It was madness to put all our eggs in the Dike basket, try to struggle along with Hugill until DD became available. That was what finished Ismael, long before Dike's first injury. Once the extent of his injury and his slow recovery time became clear, why did no-one try to sign a replacement? The fact that he's broken down twice since, and we're still saying "If only Dike had been fit - - - " or "It'll be fine when Dike's fit - - - " is beyond comedy in my opinion.

Maja is another strange case. Yes, he was the victim of two very bad challenges, but he was unable to contribute when we needed him - or maybe his contribution wasn't what the coach wanted. Either way, both he and Dike have been expensive disasters for the club. I know we're skint and all that, but I would hope that CC is looking to sign a proper centre forward, and regarding Dike and Maja as bonus players if they ever get fit and firing.

In the end, I'm not sure I know what our "style" really is. I understand that it's about shape, I get that building up from the back creates pressure and opportunities, but so often good runs aren't spotted and the pass never comes. It is almost Pulis without the set-piece threat on a bad day. Is it caution that makes them turn back towards their own goal when Fellows, Wallace or Johnston has made a dangerous run? Do they get a bollocking for taking "risks" in losing possession? The way we played at Leicester was so very different from what we've seen throughout most of 180 minutes against Southampton. I wish I understood why the confidence and swagger is so often subdued or absent.


RE: Our style - Squid - 05-18-2024

(05-18-2024, 09:15 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Some entertaining stuff on this thread. The old support for Val and his awful one-dimensional style showing its face. Bruce being some sort of genius in the transfer market.

The No 9 question is the big one. We never replaced prolific goal-scorers in JRod and Gayle. Austin and HRK chipped in with a respectable number and Grant scored 18 in a season without making any friends at all. But goals from midfield kept us on track.

It was madness to put all our eggs in the Dike basket, try to struggle along with Hugill until DD became available. That was what finished Ismael, long before Dike's first injury. Once the extent of his injury and his slow recovery time became clear, why did no-one try to sign a replacement? The fact that he's broken down twice since, and we're still saying "If only Dike had been fit - - - " or "It'll be fine when Dike's fit - - - " is beyond comedy in my opinion.

Maja is another strange case. Yes, he was the victim of two very bad challenges, but he was unable to contribute when we needed him - or maybe his contribution wasn't what the coach wanted. Either way, both he and Dike have been expensive disasters for the club. I know we're skint and all that, but I would hope that CC is looking to sign a proper centre forward, and regarding Dike and Maja as bonus players if they ever get fit and firing.

In the end, I'm not sure I know what our "style" really is. I understand that it's about shape, I get that building up from the back creates pressure and opportunities, but so often good runs aren't spotted and the pass never comes. It is almost Pulis without the set-piece threat on a bad day. Is it caution that makes them turn back towards their own goal when Fellows, Wallace or Johnston has made a dangerous run? Do they get a bollocking for taking "risks" in losing possession? The way we played at Leicester was so very different from what we've seen throughout most of 180 minutes against Southampton. I wish I understood why the confidence and swagger is so often subdued or absent.

I don't think that's fair.

Admittedly, I only go to home matches, but what I've seen, more often than not, is a well drilled team, who most of the time simply takes the game out of the hands of the opposition. The other team might huff and puff and their fans will claim that we're nothing special, but everyone knows that they could play us all night and they still wouldn't win. The 3 - 1 against Hull was a perfect example of this. We completely nullified them second half and scored two lovely goals, while they just couldn't touch us. 

For me, it all comes down to: No Number 9, No Outlet. It's been an issue all season.

The poster upthread who mentioned about attendances dropping under Val is right. I liked Val more than most, but seats started emptying at an alarming rate post Peterborough away. 

Some fans may not like Corberán's style, but we've had good attendances all season.


RE: Our style - Sliced - 05-18-2024

(05-17-2024, 11:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ll get hammered for this, but who cares… in the last 5 years or so, the one manager who I’ve agreed with the most has been Val. I think for a team of our resources the high press, high fitness approach is the best way of us being successful. Whilst we cannot spend the money of the top clubs, there is no reason why we cannot have their fitness or desire… for all the advancements of football since the 1990s, Steve Coppell and Lou Macari’s quotes how about whilst we may not have the quality of Man Utd, there’s no excuse we can’t have the fitness reign true.

Good post. Val left us in the top 5, Bruce came in, and then we returned to the top 5 after he left. Of course all we had to do was get rid of Val and everything would be rosy again......then it was "oh it's all a hangover from ValBall" ......now it's "Val was backed" despite the fact we had a next spend of something like -25 million in the summer, us losing 15 players in the summer and the only player that we spent a transfer fee on didn't come in until January.

Bruce comes in, gives 3 of the biggest contracts in the league to Okay, Swift and Wallace and genuinely almost made us the League One team with the biggest wage budget in history. He's not a genius in the transfer market because his neighbour turned out to be a decent championship player.


RE: Our style - Derek Hardballs - 05-18-2024

(05-18-2024, 10:01 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(05-17-2024, 11:10 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ll get hammered for this, but who cares… in the last 5 years or so, the one manager who I’ve agreed with the most has been Val. I think for a team of our resources the high press, high fitness approach is the best way of us being successful. Whilst we cannot spend the money of the top clubs, there is no reason why we cannot have their fitness or desire… for all the advancements of football since the 1990s, Steve Coppell and Lou Macari’s quotes how about whilst we may not have the quality of Man Utd, there’s no excuse we can’t have the fitness reign true.

Good post. Val left us in the top 5, Bruce came in, and then we returned to the top 5 after he left. Of course all we had to do was get rid of Val and everything would be rosy again......then it was "oh it's all a hangover from ValBall" ......now it's "Val was backed" despite the fact we had a next spend of something like -25 million in the summer, us losing 15 players in the summer and the only player that we spent a transfer fee on didn't come in until January.

Bruce comes in, gives 3 of the biggest contracts in the league to Okay, Swift and Wallace and genuinely almost made us the League One team with the biggest wage budget in history. He's not a genius in the transfer market because his neighbour turned out to be a decent championship player.

Val still had a decent squad to utilise and the direction of travel under him was going backwards. It wasn’t difficult to work out that if you sit deep his brand of football failed miserably. I don’t have a set way of playing I can appreciate Pulis and Ossie but I do expect more from tactics than to get the ball in the box asap and feed off scraps.


RE: Our style - WorcsWBA - 05-18-2024

With regard to assessing what Carlos did last night, it's worth taking into account what he said after the game:

"The team showed a lot of discipline in defence, but we did not attack in the level that we needed to attack in order to play better and be the more dominant team. We tried to play the game in the attacking half and we managed to break through a couple of times, but, in general, we couldn’t break their press and they were using our mistakes to create opportunities and goals.

We did have one big chance when Alex Mowatt’s effort was cleared after we broke the press from the right side. This chance could have changed the game. In football you have to analyse the game and the result, but there are also these moments where you can score and change the belief and the possibilities you have. After that chance, we didn’t find the right level in attack and we kept on making mistakes which added difficulty. The things that we want to do on the pitch don’t always happen, and unfortunately, today is one of those days. We didn’t show the game we wanted to show."

To my mind, this suggests that the (not entirely defensive) plan was there but it wasn't executed properly on the night.


RE: Our style - Squid - 05-18-2024

(05-18-2024, 11:47 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: With regard to assessing what Carlos did last night, it's worth taking into account what he said after the game:

"The team showed a lot of discipline in defence, but we did not attack in the level that we needed to attack in order to play better and be the more dominant team. We tried to play the game in the attacking half and we managed to break through a couple of times, but, in general, we couldn’t break their press and they were using our mistakes to create opportunities and goals.

We did have one big chance when Alex Mowatt’s effort was cleared after we broke the press from the right side. This chance could have changed the game. In football you have to analyse the game and the result, but there are also these moments where you can score and change the belief and the possibilities you have. After that chance, we didn’t find the right level in attack and we kept on making mistakes which added difficulty. The things that we want to do on the pitch don’t always happen, and unfortunately, today is one of those days. We didn’t show the game we wanted to show."

To my mind, this suggests that the (not entirely defensive) plan was there but it wasn't executed properly on the night.

I do find, with CC's post-match interviews they are usually spot on in terms of what happened and that's he's always fairly open about what worked and what didn't. Yet these rather tend to get overlooked in favour of certain poster's agendas.


RE: Our style - It's Only a Game - 05-18-2024

"The team showed a lot of discipline in defence, but we did not attack in the level that we needed to attack in order to play better and be the more dominant team. We tried to play the game in the attacking half and we managed to break through a couple of times, but, in general, we couldn’t break their press and they were using our mistakes to create opportunities and goals."


With all due respect Carlos, that's bollocks.   We didn't try to play the game in the attacking half,  we passed it pointlessly in our own half waiting for something to happen. 

Your comment about them "using our mistakes" is spot on.  Grady's pass was to no one in particular and served no purpose.  It wasn't moving the game into their half, it wasn't opening up space for a forward ball,  it wasn't giving the intended recipient an opportunity to do either of these, it was just a pointless pass to add to the previous sideways passes that was likely to put him under pressure, with no option other than to pass it pointlessly back to Grady, or back to a defender and back to the keeper and rinse and repeat.  Of course there will be mistakes because the pattern gets repetitive, and even dim footballers start to see the next likely pass, and start to close the space down in anticipation.  And that's what happened last night. 

Had we been playing in their half it would have mattered less possibly.  But we gave them nothing to worry about. We played in front of them with all 21 players on the pitch facing our goal.   That's why we couldn't "break their press". We were facing the wrong way.  A fuck up was inevitable.

We had two wingers on the pitch.  Why wasn't one camped on the half way line a la Willie Johnson or Clive Clark?  A simple out ball to a player in  that position immediately puts us in their half and their whole team is now facing the wrong way.   I was no fan of Graham Taylor at Watford.  But he would leave two players on the half way line when the opposition had a corner to occupy three defenders and give his own defence an out ball.  Mick Shannon used to do it for Man City in what was one of the fastest counter attacking sides I have ever seen. Last night we used our wingers as full backs.  That's not playing the game in the attacking half Carlos. 

As for taking a goal kick and passing it to your left back, who is just outside the six yard box who is immediately closed down, is in my view suicidal.
We don't have the calibre of player to execute that style.   We nearly went one down due to this nonsense. 

Bomber Brown would have been lucky to get into double figures in goal terms in the modern day.  Having found himself with a yard of space on the edge of the area,  he would just blast it.  In this day and age he would now be  expected to find a pass sideways then another out to the wing and another back to the centre and another back to Brown who by this time would have lost all momentum and be closed down.  Passes in the opposition area is now a major statistic on SKY.  Big deal.  I once saw one for Arsenal.  Passes in the opposition area 32.  Shots on goal 0. 

To finish my rant I'll just say that football is not a game of chess.  The modern obsessive over-analysis courtesy of people like Alan fucking Shearer and that dickhead Micah Richards, plus the Spanish obsession with possession at all costs, is stifling creativity and the wonderful spontaneous moments that make the game great to watch. 

 I'll avoid watching the Man City machine win their 4th title in a row tomorrow.   It's so boring.


RE: Our style - TartanRug - 05-18-2024

(05-18-2024, 05:37 PM)It's Only a Game Wrote: "The team showed a lot of discipline in defence, but we did not attack in the level that we needed to attack in order to play better and be the more dominant team. We tried to play the game in the attacking half and we managed to break through a couple of times, but, in general, we couldn’t break their press and they were using our mistakes to create opportunities and goals."


With all due respect Carlos, that's bollocks.   We didn't try to play the game in the attacking half,  we passed it pointlessly in our own half waiting for something to happen. 

Your comment about them "using our mistakes" is spot on.  Grady's pass was to no one in particular and served no purpose.  It wasn't moving the game into their half, it wasn't opening up space for a forward ball,  it wasn't giving the intended recipient an opportunity to do either of these, it was just a pointless pass to add to the previous sideways passes that was likely to put him under pressure, with no option other than to pass it pointlessly back to Grady, or back to a defender and back to the keeper and rinse and repeat.  Of course there will be mistakes because the pattern gets repetitive, and even dim footballers start to see the next likely pass, and start to close the space down in anticipation.  And that's what happened last night. 

Had we been playing in their half it would have mattered less possibly.  But we gave them nothing to worry about. We played in front of them with all 21 players on the pitch facing our goal.   That's why we couldn't "break their press". We were facing the wrong way.  A fuck up was inevitable.

We had two wingers on the pitch.  Why wasn't one camped on the half way line a la Willie Johnson or Clive Clark?  A simple out ball to a player in  that position immediately puts us in their half and their whole team is now facing the wrong way.   I was no fan of Graham Taylor at Watford.  But he would leave two players on the half way line when the opposition had a corner to occupy three defenders and give his own defence an out ball.  Mick Shannon used to do it for Man City in what was one of the fastest counter attacking sides I have ever seen. Last night we used our wingers as full backs.  That's not playing the game in the attacking half Carlos. 

As for taking a goal kick and passing it to your left back, who is just outside the six yard box who is immediately closed down, is in my view suicidal.
We don't have the calibre of player to execute that style.   We nearly went one down due to this nonsense. 

Bomber Brown would have been lucky to get into double figures in goal terms in the modern day.  Having found himself with a yard of space on the edge of the area,  he would just blast it.  In this day and age he would now be  expected to find a pass sideways then another out to the wing and another back to the centre and another back to Brown who by this time would have lost all momentum and be closed down.  Passes in the opposition area is now a major statistic on SKY.  Big deal.  I once saw one for Arsenal.  Passes in the opposition area 32.  Shots on goal 0. 

To finish my rant I'll just say that football is not a game of chess.  The modern obsessive over-analysis courtesy of people like Alan fucking Shearer and that dickhead Micah Richards, plus the Spanish obsession with possession at all costs, is stifling creativity and the wonderful spontaneous moments that make the game great to watch. 

 I'll avoid watching the Man City machine win their 4th title in a row tomorrow.   It's so boring.

Regarding Gradys pass, he was trying to get it over to the other side of the pitch which was the right thing to do as we were outnumbering them on that side and a promising break was on.  Unfortunately the execution of the pass was appalling. Then to make matters worse he got attracted to the ball which meant we had 3 players on Brooks (I think) and noone near Smallbone .

I thought we set up in a similar way to the Leicester game where we did well but a combo of Southampton playing well and us poorly meant we didn't create anything much