WBAUnofficial
Natalie Elphicke MP - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Natalie Elphicke MP (/showthread.php?tid=33635)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Derek Hardballs - 05-11-2024

(05-11-2024, 07:36 PM)baggy1 Wrote: This is probably one of the big turning points for Labour and will lose them a lot of support. I voted for Starmer to give Labour a chance at being electable but this decision worries me a lot. Really not happy with the direction of the party.

I agree but it’s been coming for at least twelve months as I pointed out a fair few times. It’s sheer arrogance by Starmer and those advising him. There is no reason for going to the lengths they are currently going to to appease Tory right voters. They are taking their traditional voters and I’m not talking about Momentum types for granted or imo even contempt. They seem to be forgetting they are doing well in the polls due to the ineptitude, grubbiness and dubious dealings of the Tories not because of their Tory light policies. They are offering no hope to millions of people, using the same tropes as the Tories and now allowing crass stunts like allowing Elphick into the party just to point score. A broad church is one thing but they have walls and some should be not welcomed. 

Time will tell but I am getting more and more reluctant to trust them or think they are a party who has a moral or intellectual compass past ‘winning’.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Protheroe - 05-11-2024

In what world is accepting Natalie Elphicke into his ranks going to "appease Tory right voters"? Can you explain please?

You're betraying your naivety again. Every political party exists to win elections. A moral or intellectual compass is worth nothing without power. It's why people like you enjoy being in opposition. You can wrap yourself up in your self righteous safe space knowing full well you don't have to face the difficult decisions of governance.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Shabby Russian - 05-12-2024

(05-11-2024, 11:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In what world is accepting Natalie Elphicke into his ranks going to "appease Tory right voters"? Can you explain please?

You're betraying your naivety again. Every political party exists to win elections. A moral or intellectual compass is worth nothing without power. It's why people like you enjoy being in opposition. You can wrap yourself up in your self righteous safe space knowing full well you don't have to face the difficult decisions of governance.

I am surprised by your opinion, I thought you were better than this, although there is a part of me that believes you always take a contrary position to Derek.

I think Starmer treats democracy with total contempt. Everything he does either intentionally or not, undermines the electorates faith and belief in our electoral system.
A man with no personal conviction in any political principles or philosophy. His political rationale seems wholly based on his belief in his ability to manage. Well that's important, but as an electorate I think we deserve an answer, manage to what end. Starmer doesn't seem able or willing to answer that.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Protheroe - 05-12-2024

That's spot on. All politics is simply managerialism these days. There's no soaring oratory, no attempt to win philosophical arguments. Those days are gone, for now.

Starmer is as much a victim of the system that created the opportunity for him as Major, Blair, Brown, Cameron, May or Sunak. I'm not sure what he's doing that so upsets you beyond trying to get elected.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - chasetownbaggie - 05-13-2024

Very questionable decision to allow her in which could lose Labour more votes than it will earn. Can't help but feel she's a Trojan Horse.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Pontificator - 05-13-2024

(05-11-2024, 11:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In what world is accepting Natalie Elphicke into his ranks going to "appease Tory right voters"? Can you explain please?

You're betraying your naivety again. Every political party exists to win elections. A moral or intellectual compass is worth nothing without power. It's why people like you enjoy being in opposition. You can wrap yourself up in your self righteous safe space knowing full well you don't have to face the difficult decisions of governance.

You've never been more right than this. This is why Labour First exists and it is why Starmer is leader. If you don't want Tories stfu and vote Labour.

The main objective of the Labour Party is to be elected and to stay in power and to govern in the interests of everyone

Purity - makes me sick

I welcome Natalie into the Labour Party and hope she finds a home amongst us good people where she can be rehabilitated. On that note Mr P is also welcome, he too, could begin his journey


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Borin' Baggie - 05-13-2024

(05-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-11-2024, 11:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In what world is accepting Natalie Elphicke into his ranks going to "appease Tory right voters"? Can you explain please?

You're betraying your naivety again. Every political party exists to win elections. A moral or intellectual compass is worth nothing without power. It's why people like you enjoy being in opposition. You can wrap yourself up in your self righteous safe space knowing full well you don't have to face the difficult decisions of governance.

You've never been more right than this. This is why Labour First exists and it is why Starmer is leader. If you don't want Tories stfu and vote Labour.

The main objective of the Labour Party is to be elected and to stay in power and to govern in the interests of everyone

Purity - makes me sick

I welcome Natalie into the Labour Party and hope she finds a home amongst us good people where she can be rehabilitated. On that note Mr P is also welcome, he too, could begin his journey

Why are you welcoming an apologist for a rapist and someone that lobbied in an attempt to prevent the course of justice? How can you possibly trust that they believe in the rule of law?


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Bromley Baggie 2 - 05-13-2024

Couldn't Starmer have just told her "Bugger off, We don't want your sort in our party" when she crossed the floor?


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Fido - 05-13-2024

(05-13-2024, 10:17 AM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: Couldn't Starmer have just told her "Bugger off, We don't want your sort in our party" when she crossed the floor?

I don't get this either. Surely the upside of doing something like this would have had a far better effect than an albeit brief "1-0er" for crossing the floor?


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Ossian - 05-13-2024

(05-13-2024, 10:17 AM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: Couldn't Starmer have just told her "Bugger off, We don't want your sort in our party" when she crossed the floor?

Two things, both in agreement...

Firstly, I think Labour should have applied a simple test: is this someone who we would even consider, let alone select, as a parliamentary candidate? The second being that she is then politely advised that her protests would be better and more comfortably registered from the benches where the Independents sit.