WBAUnofficial
Seals - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Seals (/showthread.php?tid=33234)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Seals - Duffers - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 03:16 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:05 PM)Bristolbion Wrote: We’ve got a shit defence. No amount of managerial tweaking is going to turn our lumbering back 4 and keeper into a unit that will cope at the very highest level without being helped out by a defensively minded midfield.
If we go all-out attack, we’ll just get picked off by the best teams …. again

And herein lies the issue. The elephant in the room. Our back 4 and keeper lack concentration against the big boys and drop at least one bollock per game.

As a squad we have the best midfield and attacking group going to the tournament. It's the defence and keeper that are the weak link when up against the savvy sides.

I've never rated Pickford. Always struck me as an arrogant sort. A good shot stopper but lacks that special ingredient to be a great keeper imo. That said with Pope out and Ramsdale lacking games I don't see a top quality alternative at present. Henderson and Johnstone are miles off it. And as for Trafford he's league 1 at best.

A defence wins you the tournament. I'm not sure we can score our way to the trophy as that goes against Southgate s philosophy in the "big games".

This must be the weakest pool of keepers we've ever had.

Pickford is our number one by default, and has been for years, nobody else has done anything to challenge him.


RE: Seals - Sliced - 04-04-2024

But surely all of our back 4 would get into the Brazil defence!?


RE: Seals - Psalm23 - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 03:33 PM)Sliced Wrote: But surely all of our back 4 would get into the Brazil defence!?

Big Grin Big Grin


RE: Seals - wba13 - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 03:16 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:05 PM)Bristolbion Wrote: We’ve got a shit defence. No amount of managerial tweaking is going to turn our lumbering back 4 and keeper into a unit that will cope at the very highest level without being helped out by a defensively minded midfield.
If we go all-out attack, we’ll just get picked off by the best teams …. again

And herein lies the issue. The elephant in the room. Our back 4 and keeper lack concentration against the big boys and drop at least one bollock per game.

As a squad we have the best midfield and attacking group going to the tournament. It's the defence and keeper that are the weak link when up against the savvy sides.

I've never rated Pickford. Always struck me as an arrogant sort. A good shot stopper but lacks that special ingredient to be a great keeper imo. That said with Pope out and Ramsdale lacking games I don't see a top quality alternative at present. Henderson and Johnstone are miles off it. And as for Trafford he's league 1 at best.

A defence wins you the tournament. I'm not sure we can score our way to the trophy as that goes against Southgate s philosophy in the "big games".

I don’t rate Pickford but he has only made 1 mistake for England that has led to a goal, in 60 appearances. That’s impressive.For me Jack Butland is by far the best keeper in Britain now he has his confidence and form back. Playing better now than when he was picked for England 6 or 7 years ago.


RE: Seals - Malcolm Tucker - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 03:49 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:16 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:05 PM)Bristolbion Wrote: We’ve got a shit defence. No amount of managerial tweaking is going to turn our lumbering back 4 and keeper into a unit that will cope at the very highest level without being helped out by a defensively minded midfield.
If we go all-out attack, we’ll just get picked off by the best teams …. again

And herein lies the issue. The elephant in the room. Our back 4 and keeper lack concentration against the big boys and drop at least one bollock per game.

As a squad we have the best midfield and attacking group going to the tournament. It's the defence and keeper that are the weak link when up against the savvy sides.

I've never rated Pickford. Always struck me as an arrogant sort. A good shot stopper but lacks that special ingredient to be a great keeper imo. That said with Pope out and Ramsdale lacking games I don't see a top quality alternative at present. Henderson and Johnstone are miles off it. And as for Trafford he's league 1 at best.

A defence wins you the tournament. I'm not sure we can score our way to the trophy as that goes against Southgate s philosophy in the "big games".

I don’t rate Pickford but he has only made 1 mistake for England that has led to a goal, in 60 appearances. That’s impressive.For me Jack Butland is by far the best keeper in Britain now he has his confidence and form back. Playing better now than when he was picked for England 6 or 7 years ago.

Butland is playing at the equivalent of League 1 level.


RE: Seals - Shabby Russian - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 02:17 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 01:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Baffling that people don't see Southgate as an excellent international manager.
The most successful England have had bar Ramsey.
But "he's not won anything"... Well that goes for all the others.
Mind you, Rooney is available...

Not said he’s not been successful, I just think he’s been shown up in 3 big games when up against managers who are better tacticians. You only have to look at his win record against the top sides.

He’s done a very good job as England boss, but a bit more nous would have probably seen him have a trophy. It was the same at Boro where he managed to relegate a decent side.

Those 3 big games presumably were

Croatia  they had a better team, certainly a far better midfield

Italy   a game decided on penalties, after 2 well matched teams could not be separated after 120 mins of football. 

France    a game between 2 very good international teams, which was decided by individual player error and brilliance, nit strategy. We may have been the better team in that game, but that's a subjective opinion.

It was only discussed last week. He's got a low twenties percent win record against teams in the top 10 of the FIFA ranking across nearly 30 matches.

He's a nice guy/yes man but a rubbish coach. Hence Middlesbrough.

How many games with consequence do international managers have ... and unless you win the tournament...the last one is always going to be a defeat. 
I judge Southgate on his tournament record and it is good, we have been very competitive in all the tournaments he has managed in, going further than we usually do. Even the defeats have been close run things.
The squad has got stronger under his tenure, not something he can control or take credit for. As a consequence expectation for this tournament will be justifiably high. Probably he needs to deliver a trophy this time.


RE: Seals - Duffers - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 04:36 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 02:17 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 01:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Baffling that people don't see Southgate as an excellent international manager.
The most successful England have had bar Ramsey.
But "he's not won anything"... Well that goes for all the others.
Mind you, Rooney is available...

Not said he’s not been successful, I just think he’s been shown up in 3 big games when up against managers who are better tacticians. You only have to look at his win record against the top sides.

He’s done a very good job as England boss, but a bit more nous would have probably seen him have a trophy. It was the same at Boro where he managed to relegate a decent side.

Those 3 big games presumably were

Croatia  they had a better team, certainly a far better midfield

Italy   a game decided on penalties, after 2 well matched teams could not be separated after 120 mins of football. 

France    a game between 2 very good international teams, which was decided by individual player error and brilliance, nit strategy. We may have been the better team in that game, but that's a subjective opinion.

It was only discussed last week. He's got a low twenties percent win record against teams in the top 10 of the FIFA ranking across nearly 30 matches.

He's a nice guy/yes man but a rubbish coach. Hence Middlesbrough.

How many games with consequence do international managers have ... and unless you win the tournament...the last one is always going to be a defeat. 
I judge Southgate on his tournament record and it is good, we have been very competitive in all the tournaments he has managed in, going further than we usually do. Even the defeats have been close run things.
The squad has got stronger under his tenure, not something he can control or take credit for. As a consequence expectation for this tournament will be justifiably high. Probably he needs to deliver a trophy this time.

There’s a lot of truth in this post.

The problem is that prejudices form and narratives take hold to suit agendas. People always talk about Southgate being negative and applying “handbrakes” and whilst that may have been true in earlier tournaments there’s little actual evidence to show it’s still the case. We were the third highest scorers at the World Cup and didn’t get past the quarters (only the finalists Argentina and France scored more than us). You’d be hard pressed to argue that our exit from Qatar was down to Southgate or any fault of his system or lineup picks. We simply came out the wrong side of a tight game between two very good sides.


RE: Seals - CA Baggie - 04-04-2024

Maybe a better question re Southgate would be - How many games as he won when we've been the underdog? He wins the games we should, which hasn't always been the case for other managers, but I can't ever really think of a time when he's pulled something out the bag with tactical nous or an inspired substitution.

We're always on the wrong end of these 50:50 games. Maybe that is to do with having a defence that isn't top class, although 2 of the back 4 play for the best team in the world!

The majority of the England squad would be taken by almost any club in the world and yet the manager\coach wouldn't. I think that points to where the weak link of the whole England set-up is.


RE: Seals - SW4Baggie - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 01:57 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 11:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Baffling that people don't see Southgate as an excellent international manager.
The most successful England have had bar Ramsey.
But "he's not won anything"... Well that goes for all the others.
Mind you, Rooney is available...

Not said he’s not been successful, I just think he’s been shown up in 3 big games when up against managers who are better tacticians. You only have to look at his win record against the top sides.

He’s done a very good job as England boss, but a bit more nous would have probably seen him have a trophy. It was the same at Boro where he managed to relegate a decent side.

Those 3 big games presumably were

Croatia  they had a better team, certainly a far better midfield

Italy   a game decided on penalties, after 2 well matched teams could not be separated after 120 mins of football. 

France    a game between 2 very good international teams, which was decided by individual player error and brilliance, nit strategy. We may have been the better team in that game, but that's a subjective opinion.

I disagree Croatia had a better team than us - admittedly their midfield passed through us, but whilst this was absolutely obvious to anyone watching, we failed to put another body in there to help.

Italy, similar story… he was outmanoeuvred by Mancini who ran absolute rings around him.

France were a better side than us, there’s no shame in that exit, but we really should have picked up the Euros at Wembley.

As I’ve said many times before on here, GS deserves huge amounts of credit for building a likeable England side that are capable of progressing through tournaments, but he has been helped by some very fortunate draws in his tournaments, and his record against big sides is poor.

(04-04-2024, 05:24 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Maybe a better question re Southgate would be - How many games as he won when we've been the underdog?  He wins the games we should, which hasn't always been the case for other managers, but I can't ever really think of a time when he's pulled something out the bag with tactical nous or an inspired substitution.

We're always on the wrong end of these 50:50 games.  Maybe that is to do with having a defence that isn't top class, although 2 of the back 4 play for the best team in the world! 

The majority of the England squad would be taken by almost any club in the world and yet the manager\coach wouldn't.  I think that points to where the weak link of the whole England set-up is.

Just saw this. Well put.


RE: Seals - wba13 - 04-04-2024

(04-04-2024, 04:18 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:49 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:16 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-04-2024, 03:05 PM)Bristolbion Wrote: We’ve got a shit defence. No amount of managerial tweaking is going to turn our lumbering back 4 and keeper into a unit that will cope at the very highest level without being helped out by a defensively minded midfield.
If we go all-out attack, we’ll just get picked off by the best teams …. again

And herein lies the issue. The elephant in the room. Our back 4 and keeper lack concentration against the big boys and drop at least one bollock per game.

As a squad we have the best midfield and attacking group going to the tournament. It's the defence and keeper that are the weak link when up against the savvy sides.

I've never rated Pickford. Always struck me as an arrogant sort. A good shot stopper but lacks that special ingredient to be a great keeper imo. That said with Pope out and Ramsdale lacking games I don't see a top quality alternative at present. Henderson and Johnstone are miles off it. And as for Trafford he's league 1 at best.

A defence wins you the tournament. I'm not sure we can score our way to the trophy as that goes against Southgate s philosophy in the "big games".

I don’t rate Pickford but he has only made 1 mistake for England that has led to a goal, in 60 appearances. That’s impressive.For me Jack Butland is by far the best keeper in Britain now he has his confidence and form back. Playing better now than when he was picked for England 6 or 7 years ago.

Butland is playing at the equivalent of League 1 level.
But his performances, handling and decision making is all premiership level.
Anyone who watches keepers can see it a mile away he is better for me than any other British keeper.