WBAUnofficial
v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats (/showthread.php?tid=32055)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Lurker#3 - 12-19-2023

(12-19-2023, 02:15 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 01:58 PM)yeoman lai Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 01:33 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 11:38 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Statistics? Pah!

Although he does a decent enough job, Furlong could not pass water.

Four times in 5 FH mins he gave the ball away with awful passing, and not difficult passes either, one was literally a 3 yard pass to Jed that he managed to pass behind him and out of play for a throw in.

Love this, in the same way statistics cannot be used without context, you also can't just spout bollocks when the statistics prove otherwise.

Eh?

"Spouting bollocks" when I saw it with my own 2 eyes?

A couple of isolated incidents across 90 minutes that your own bias (conscious or unconscious) has remembered does not = "Furlong could not pass water" - the OP in this thread disproves that with actual, tangible, measurable facts.

To be fair to YL, he does make silly, unforced errors. Such as playing the ball behind people, he does also give the ball away at times. But that's because he's so involved in the game which is why its noticeable. Similar shade used to get thrown at Jimmy Morrison. People regularly calling for him to be dropped. Only to realise how much you miss his general involvement in play when he's not there.  

Below is a summary of his stats v the other fullback in the league...
[attachment=843]

It cleary shows his ability/eagerness to pass progressively, and with that comes an element of low percentage balls. But he also does give it away cheaply at times. It also shows his lack of cutting edge. It is what it is.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Squid - 12-19-2023

Furlong put in some superlative hard graft towards our equaliser so it seems somewhat churlish to be insulting him.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Johnnykayeengland - 12-19-2023

I never understand this need to spacegoat. There's always someone... Brunt, Morrison, Darton, now Furlong.
He's a better than average championship full back. Committed to the team, works his socks off, puts in some great balls, and some poor ones.
As above, if you want to avoid making mistakes, don't make anything, play safe.
More importantly, CC rates him.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Bob Fossil - 12-19-2023

(12-19-2023, 03:38 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I never understand this need to spacegoat. There's always someone... Brunt, Morrison, Darton, now Furlong.
He's a better than average championship full back. Committed to the team, works his socks off, puts in some great balls, and some poor ones.
As above, if you want to avoid making mistakes, don't make anything, play safe.
More importantly, CC rates him.

I never understand the misuse of the word spacegoat. To spacegoat means to blame someone for the wrongdoings of others. That has rarely been the case with any of those mentioned.

For what it's worth I agree with the second sentence. At their best both Furlong and Townsend are more than adequate and are as much a reason for our lofty league position as anyone else. You don't keep as many clean sheets as we do if your fullbacks are crap. They are, however, both prone to errors and so are just as susceptible to criticism as others.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Shabby Russian - 12-19-2023

(12-19-2023, 09:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Whilst the marks were generous, hard to disagree with the excellent comments Lurker.
It's pretty clear that Townsend has become chief spacegoat for a while now. Jed had taken the mantle but after a few good performances either side of injury, he's now in the "he's great" section. (Players are either great or shit according to a lot of our support)

Townsend had a really good game Sunday, especially 2nd half where some of his angled passing were superb. Yet on social media he has been roasted yet again for his performance driven mainly by the goal. Yet his position for the goal was about right. If the cross had been hit conventionally, it would have hit CT. But it was misfit by about 30 degrees, so it wasn't blocked.

Some of the stick he gets is ridiculous. He's a middle to top end championship left back. He has good games, average games and below average ones. He is where we are as a club.

(12-19-2023, 04:28 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 03:38 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I never understand this need to spacegoat. There's always someone... Brunt, Morrison, Darton, now Furlong.
He's a better than average championship full back. Committed to the team, works his socks off, puts in some great balls, and some poor ones.
As above, if you want to avoid making mistakes, don't make anything, play safe.
More importantly, CC rates him.

I never understand the misuse of the word spacegoat. To spacegoat means to blame someone for the wrongdoings of others. That has rarely been the case with any of those mentioned.

For what it's worth I agree with the second sentence. At their best both Furlong and Townsend are more than adequate and are as much a reason for our lofty league position as anyone else. You don't keep as many clean sheets as we do if your fullbacks are crap. They are, however, both prone to errors and so are just as susceptible to criticism as others.

My view is that both Furlong and Townsend have improved under Corberan.

Full back was an area of weakness for us , not now.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Jerry - 12-19-2023

(12-19-2023, 01:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 12:42 PM)Jerry Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 11:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 11:38 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Statistics? Pah!

Although he does a decent enough job, Furlong could not pass water.

Four times in 5 FH mins he gave the ball away with awful passing, and not difficult passes either, one was literally a 3 yard pass to Jed that he managed to pass behind him and out of play for a throw in.

I know... Imagine how good he would be if he had that extra ability on the ball? 

Furlongs average stats put him as in the top 25% of fullbacks in the league in terms of his progressive passing and general possession statistics. He is also in the top 9% in terms of his 'front foot defending', eg. Interceptions/blocks (both passes and shots), he also makes an average of 0 defensive errors per game. 
Sadly, his final ball and attacking contribution is lower than it should be given his involvement (top 25% in terms of touches in the final third/attack penalty area). But if his execution was more consistent, he wouldn't be playing for us. He'd be in the Prem.

Furlong has only this season developed consistency to his game aided by the arrival of Pipa. To say an improvement in passing in the last third would make him a premier player is a massive jump. It is alway said ‘there are lies, dam lies, and statistics’.

I would argue he has developed consistency as a result of quality, structured, detailed and consistent coaching. Unlike the 12/18 months prior under Mr Bruce. Furlong also shone when he played for Val, as, regardless of what we all thought of the tactics/approach, he has a clear and analytical coaching style. 

Furlong has some real attributes, namely his athleticism, long throw, ability to strike the ball and he's a genuinely intelligent bloke by all accounts, so he takes on instructions well and is able to perform well within a solid system.

His weaknesses are all around his natural ability and appreciation of the ball.

(12-19-2023, 12:42 PM)Jerry Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 11:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 11:38 AM)yeoman lai Wrote: Statistics? Pah!

Although he does a decent enough job, Furlong could not pass water.

Four times in 5 FH mins he gave the ball away with awful passing, and not difficult passes either, one was literally a 3 yard pass to Jed that he managed to pass behind him and out of play for a throw in.

I know... Imagine how good he would be if he had that extra ability on the ball? 

Furlongs average stats put him as in the top 25% of fullbacks in the league in terms of his progressive passing and general possession statistics. He is also in the top 9% in terms of his 'front foot defending', eg. Interceptions/blocks (both passes and shots), he also makes an average of 0 defensive errors per game. 
Sadly, his final ball and attacking contribution is lower than it should be given his involvement (top 25% in terms of touches in the final third/attack penalty area). But if his execution was more consistent, he wouldn't be playing for us. He'd be in the Prem.

Furlong has only this season developed consistency to his game aided by the arrival of Pipa. To say an improvement in passing in the last third would make him a premier player is a massive jump. It is alway said ‘there are lies, dam lies, and statistics’.

So a full back that is athletic, doesn't make many mistakes, is in the top 9-25% in many metrics, couldn't play in the league above if he regularly added a few goals/assists to his game?  Huh

I would say a slight hop, personally. As Rich said above, for some strange reason ,people seem to make judging a player very black and white. Lets look at the likes of Gareth McCauley, had no right to be a premier league player when you looked at his career. 2 years playing under Roy and he suddenly developed all the attributes we all loved.

Having statistics is no good if the facts are wrong. Furlong has been here under 5 full managers and a few temp ones and has only just this season added consistency to his game. It may be just that the penny has dropped and he understands his game. It was not the fault of Bruce. Maybe the same can be said about McCauley as Ipswich fans said he had an error every match in his game, and couldn’t believe we had signed him. 
The comment on his bad passing was correct as during the first half I said to those by me that he had his boots on the wrong feet .
As for your comment about being athletic, Brian Clough said ‘if he want someone to run he would have played a horse’, said about Colin Bell.
I am not having a go at Furlong as I think he is having his best season at the club, but am questioning statistics overruling what your eyes see, not that statistics don’t have some uses.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Tom Joad - 12-19-2023

Furlong has improved hugely over the last few months. I have no gripe with anything said here. He is athletic, competitive, decent in the air and almost everything comes from his side. It is also true to say his final ball is often poor and he never backs himself to actually go through on goal, instead preferring to pass. In our position as a club, he is fine. On the other hand, Townsend has been consistently poor for a long time. He had a good 2nd half Saturday, no doubt, but no one can in all honesty tell me he wasn't our worst player by a country mile, 1st half., stopping every move and constantly passing backwards when there were other options on. It isn't spacegoating, just a simple observation. CT has me puzzled as he was one of our better performers in that Prem year but has been disappointing since.
I'd also say, both full backs have upped their game since Pipa arrived.


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Jerry - 12-19-2023

(12-19-2023, 07:25 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Furlong has improved hugely over the last few months. I have no gripe with anything said here. He is athletic, competitive, decent in the air and almost everything comes from his side. It is also true to say his final ball is often poor and he never backs himself to actually go through on goal, instead preferring to pass. In our position as a club, he is fine.  On the other hand, Townsend has been consistently poor for a long time. He had a good 2nd half Saturday, no doubt, but no one can in all honesty tell me he wasn't our worst player by a country mile, 1st half., stopping every move and constantly passing backwards when there were other options on.  It isn't spacegoating, just a simple observation.  CT has me puzzled as he was one of our better performers in that Prem year but has been disappointing since.
I'd also say, both full backs have upped their game since Pipa arrived.

I agree with your post except them being ‘spacegoating’ Wink


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Cuzer - 12-20-2023

I need to stop reading these stats = player markes threads, drives me insane

How anybody or anything could give Townsend an 8 for Sunday's game needs putting in the recycle bin with immediate effect

For the record I don't blame him for the goal in the slightest, yes he could have got tighter but it was a total fluke

First half he killed us, first touch was so poor, always back towards our goal, slowing down our build up, playing back to Bartley/Kipre when he could open his body up and look forward to JS or BTA, second half with CC's tweak of dropping the Turk deeper he was alllowed to get forward better but anything above a 6 would be mental

Cuzer


RE: v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats - Lurker#3 - 12-20-2023

(12-20-2023, 10:22 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I need to stop reading these stats = player markes threads, drives me insane

How anybody or anything could give Townsend an 8 for Sunday's game needs putting in the recycle bin with immediate effect

For the record I don't blame him for the goal in the slightest, yes he could have got tighter but it was a total fluke

First half he killed us, first touch was so poor, always back towards our goal, slowing down our build up, playing back to Bartley/Kipre when he could open his body up and look forward to JS or BTA, second half with CC's tweak of dropping the Turk deeper he was alllowed to get forward better but anything above a 6 would be mental

Cuzer

Don't drive yourself insane Cuz... Its nearly Christmas, family and excessive booze will do that for you.

First half he was effectively playing as a 3rd CB with Sarmiento playing as wide forward so he was more reserved as a result. but still played more progressive passes than the other 2 CB's combined!  

I had him as a 7, when i noted down my "what my eyes saw" scores, which is what I always start with. But when you add the stats into that I had to bump him up.