![]() |
|
2 shot dead .. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: 2 shot dead .. (/showthread.php?tid=31472) |
RE: 2 shot dead .. - Fido - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) +1. And as for the "ten commandments" comment from Spandau, the following book in the Bible actively encourages genocide and slavery of others, FFS sake. In short, we don't need it. It's bullshit. RE: 2 shot dead .. - SuperBob2002 - 10-17-2023 I'd argue religion, in some form, has been around as long as man. It's basically stories of how earth came to be, and was basically created to explain the stars in the sky and nature before humanity understood it, as well as to control the easily led via brain washing and fear (if you don't live your life according to this made up code you'll go to hell. Live and abide by it, however, and you'll go to heaven. Obviously that's a very basic analogy, but you get the point). It's high time we grew out of such fanciful ideologies and leave those for best selling novels and films where such fairy tale rubbish belongs. The notion that as a species we now know how the universe itself, as we know it, began, we have pictured the earliest galaxies, the farthest (earliest) stars, sent space craft onto other planets and outside the solar system. We have truly discovered and learned about how wonderful nature and the universe is. We have learned about the tiniest atoms. We have discovered evolution and have mapped out the majority of life that has ever existed. Yet vast amounts of people still cling onto the ridiculous stories that each religion tells us. It's ridiculous to me. There's that great quote "if you destroyed all religious texts, in 10,000 years completely new fantasies and stories would be written. However, destroy all science texts, in 10,000 years the exact same events, theories and knowledge would be written about.". Never a truer word spoken. RE: 2 shot dead .. - Spandaubaggie - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) I'm not advocating religion as the answer. I'm not religious, but my point is there's millions of decent people who believe in a God or whatever. Really in our society aren't we entitled to believe what we want and deeper types will look for a bigger meaning in life. You're never going to expunge religion so it's probably better look at a better way of working with it. RE: 2 shot dead .. - DemonicBaggie - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) Don't disagree, but what do people replace it with? It's difficult if not impossible to live a meaningful life without some sort of belief system, encompassing a moral code, even in a supposedly secular society. (Devotion to Albion, TikTok or Emmerdale don't count.) RE: 2 shot dead .. - SuperBob2002 - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:39 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) If someone (or a group of people) chose to live their life according to the Harry Potter books, you'd say they were completely bonkers, wouldn't you. What's the difference? Religion is made up fantasy written by someone thousands of years ago. Harry Potter is made up fantasy written recently. RE: 2 shot dead .. - Spandaubaggie - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'd argue religion, in some form, has been around as long as man. It's basically stories of how earth came to be, and was basically created to explain the stars in the sky and nature before humanity understood it, as well as to control the easily led via brain washing and fear (if you don't live your life according to this made up code you'll go to hell. Live and abide by it, however, and you'll go to heaven. Obviously that's a very basic analogy, but you get the point). It's high time we grew out of such fanciful ideologies and leave those for best selling novels and films where such fairy tale rubbish belongs.Good post Bob. It adds much more flesh to the bones of your argument. Sadly though religion is ground in culture too. Many can't separate it from their part of the world. I think Proth has said it didn't do much good with communism, as is true. I don't think getting rid of it is the magic bullet. RE: 2 shot dead .. - Bob Fossil - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:33 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'd argue religion, in some form, has been around as long as man. It's basically stories of how earth came to be, and was basically created to explain the stars in the sky and nature before humanity understood it, as well as to control the easily led via brain washing and fear (if you don't live your life according to this made up code you'll go to hell. Live and abide by it, however, and you'll go to heaven. Obviously that's a very basic analogy, but you get the point). It's high time we grew out of such fanciful ideologies and leave those for best selling novels and films where such fairy tale rubbish belongs.Saved me a post mate, agree 100%. Religion is a man-made concept in order to control the masses through fear. Even now, in 2023, people are still scared to question it, however, for fear of repercussion, and that's part of the problem, there is very little open debate, around religion, as questioning someone's religious belief's is classed as offensive or even hateful. This allows the brainwashing of the young to continue ad-infinitum and the ingrained divisions to transverse generations. Even America, so called land of the free, is still governed by religion and has never had an openly atheist president. That's why I see no end to this conflict, or any other with religion at it's core, as there will never be a true reconciliation or even compromise, only temporary cease fire. RE: 2 shot dead .. - Fido - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:39 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) It'll never go away. People will always be scared about dying and wishfully thinking that there is an afterlife. You're also never going to stop people being born as sociopaths or psychopaths for whom the golden rule, by which most people live their lives (do as you would wish to have done unto you), is irrelevant. Discuss ethics in schools instead of searching for answers in a book that gives you examples of both the right and wrong way to lead your lives, in equal measure. RE: 2 shot dead .. - fuzzbox - 10-17-2023 It's not religion that is the problem. If you took away religion, there would still be genocide and wars. In fact, the biggest atrocities so far, have had nothing to do with religion. If I was playing devils advocate, I could say that maybe if Stalin and Hitler were more religious, 60 million people would never have died. I'm not religious, but I'm willing to bet there are far more people who are 'moderated' by religion, than those who are turned violent by it. If you are going to be cynical, you could argue that religion was designed by those in control as 'the opiate of the people' and that those in power general want society to stay as it is with them on top. Revolution and violent change are to be avoided at all costs because it endangers the profitable status quo. Therefore, war is to be discouraged and religion plays is designed to play its part. If you were going to be idealistic, you could argue that religion keeps many wars from starting. It's logical that nobody ever gets to hear about that because if they succeed, the newsworthy events are prevented from occurring. Ironically, by the very religion that people are blaming. It really is a 'no-win' for religion. If an evil man does something - he and we blame religion. if the man is stopped or positively influenced by his religion - we don't get to hear about it. btw, if anyone wants to live their life by Harry Potter - let them, it's got nothing to do with me. I'm not sure there is a path for living life proscribed within it, though... RE: 2 shot dead .. - Spandaubaggie - 10-17-2023 (10-17-2023, 12:58 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:39 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:30 PM)Fido Wrote:(10-17-2023, 12:25 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Morality has feck all to do with religion. I know some religious types who got divorced or walked out on families. Some people cheat and lie and go to church and confess away their sins.(Savile springs to mind) This is turning into a good high brow debate and I don't blame anyone's frustration with religion. The biggest issue I see is a chasm between the West and its liberalism and more conservative communities and parts of the world, where there is less wealth. I had a somewhat disturbing encounter with a Muslim guy last week in which he was saying very homophobic stuff about them having sex on the street and no morals and how Islam gives you such a code. He was a bloke only about 35 and his disgust and anger was visible. Bridging the chasm between our secular society and religion, especially Islam IMHO, is increasingly difficult. It really is walking on egg shells. (10-17-2023, 01:01 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: It's not religion that is the problem. As ever Fuzzbox your contribution is top stuff. An excellent post. |