RE: Has he got a point ? - johntoewba - 09-30-2023
(09-30-2023, 05:13 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: My word, this has turned into a thread about Jeremy Peace. Who'd have thought it? Nobody ever threatened Peace or his family, which is what has allegedly happened to the Wednesday owner. IMO their fans have crossed a line which Baggies fans have never got close to.
What this thread demonstrates is that the "average footie fan" will probably always dislike and/or resent the owner of their club. It's "the sport of the people", but the people (who could never own a football club) are likely to resent the owners (who can and do).
Saint Gary Megson got rid of Paul Thompson for his own selfish reasons. We'll never know what would have happened if Thompson had won that particular pissing contest. That put Jeremy Peace in the hot seat. Remember, Peace soon tired of Megson's megalomaniac dinosaur approach to the game and moved us forward.
Yes, he focused on the sale, he made money out of the club, he brought Pulis in (for me one of the worst decisions he made), he colluded in the appointment of the useless John Williams. But we had some good seasons in between. If he wanted to buy back West Brom as a retirement project I'd be delighted.
Lost for words
RE: Has he got a point ? - Huggybear - 09-30-2023
Paul Thompson turned our football club around completely.He had a plan and then used the money in selling Enzo Maresca to back Megson.Without doubt Thompson was the start of our turn around.
As for Peace he was an accountant running a football club and he was good at it but he certainly wasn’t the start of our successful period.
RE: Has he got a point ? - Spandaubaggie - 09-30-2023
(09-30-2023, 07:52 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Whoever said above they don’t want to turn this thread into a JP one really jinxed it!
Nonetheless, it’s interesting to see after all these years where people sit on this issue. Some will credit him for everything good of the last couple of decades; others nothing at all. For me, as is often the case, the truth is somewhere in the middle.
It’s easy to simply put the success down to DA. He was still appointed however by JP, and given the license to operate. If replacing (or even finding in the first place) a DA replacement was quite so easy, we’d have done it; and undoubtedly so would countless others have. Let’s not forget however that our success (and neither first nor second promotion) didn’t ultimately begin in 2007, when Ashworth was promoted to Technical Director, although it is more than fair to say he presided over our best spell. That’s somewhat undeniable, and perhaps does quite legitimately encourage some to look more fondly at the Peace period than it otherwise most likely would have been historically confined.
Before and after that, we had the ingredients and indeed the (somewhat penny-pinching, at times) investment, and despite lurching about with no-marks like Robson, Mel, AFI, Garlick, Williams et al. - not to mention some crap signings to boot - at least under JP there was a sense of underlying trust in that, if it wasn’t working, he wouldn’t countenance it for long. He did seem to appear to know how to protect his (well, our) investment, at least until the bitter end; at which point the acquiescence to TP’s desire for complete control over certain previously-delegated or less-centralised responsibilities had become somewhat a window-dressing exercise to give the ostensible illusion of a sound-footing; and thereby conducive to a quick, lucrative sale.
I also think it’s easy to overlook the value he added - and quite how quick/successful we were in adopting certain transfer policies (loan to perm for example) and remuneration approaches (flex down, survival bonuses) - that weren’t commonplace at the time, and are now. Then there were stilecards, improvements to what was previously a woeful ticketing operation, the academy to name but a few. It would be wrong to suggest that the overall infrastructure of the club wasn’t massively enhanced during his tenure. And - for all of the Udezes, Moores (Luke), and Ideyes, we did sign more than quite a few legends still fondly remembered to this day.
But it wouldn’t work again now. In many ways we punched above our weight, because that value was there to be added; and he added it. Arguably at the expense of greater investment that at times he could and should have made - certainly we were financially sound enough to. Since then, so many others have caught up, and simply running a business efficiently isn’t enough to cut it anymore. It needs more than that, and I think the ‘more than that’ required he was acutely aware of, and wasn’t comfortable with.
And that was always my biggest problem with JP. I think he was well aware of the fact that the once-often quoted ‘doing a Charlton’ (ironically where the fuck are they now) was the best we could hope to achieve, and that the investment required per place aimed-for above say 8th position merited an investment that would simply never justify itself in terms of payback. As others caught up, it became an increasing headache fending off the vultures while maintaining superiority over those beneath us with deeper pockets and/or loftier ambitions and momentum. Much easier just to cash out. So he did.
I don’t necessarily think it’s also right to criticise him for the sins of this lot whom nobody saw coming. They made the right noises, at a time Chinese uptake wasn’t the geopolitical complication it is now. Couple their naivety with a very poor transfer window or two, the understated impact of the retirement of some very wise heads (Brunt and Mozza chiefly), a head coach who engineered his own dismissal for a payout to settle his own financial woes, and the rest is history.
Certainly he’s no saint, but it was - for the most - good while it lasted. We’ve made plenty of our own mistakes since then.
Jesus Hawks, the JP era post to end all posts. A truly spellbinding bit of inspiration that nails it for those with an ability to look at the character in-depth and the effect on our club.
Post of the year certainly, post of the 2020s so far certainly. Have a pint and bask in your brilliance. Well done.
(09-30-2023, 09:42 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (09-30-2023, 07:52 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Whoever said above they don’t want to turn this thread into a JP one really jinxed it!
Nonetheless, it’s interesting to see after all these years where people sit on this issue. Some will credit him for everything good of the last couple of decades; others nothing at all. For me, as is often the case, the truth is somewhere in the middle.
It’s easy to simply put the success down to DA. He was still appointed however by JP, and given the license to operate. If replacing (or even finding in the first place) a DA replacement was quite so easy, we’d have done it; and undoubtedly so would countless others have. Let’s not forget however that our success (and neither first nor second promotion) didn’t ultimately begin in 2007, when Ashworth was promoted to Technical Director, although it is more than fair to say he presided over our best spell. That’s somewhat undeniable, and perhaps does quite legitimately encourage some to look more fondly at the Peace period than it otherwise most likely would have been historically confined.
Before and after that, we had the ingredients and indeed the (somewhat penny-pinching, at times) investment, and despite lurching about with no-marks like Robson, Mel, AFI, Garlick, Williams et al. - not to mention some crap signings to boot - at least under JP there was a sense of underlying trust in that, if it wasn’t working, he wouldn’t countenance it for long. He did seem to appear to know how to protect his (well, our) investment, at least until the bitter end; at which point the acquiescence to TP’s desire for complete control over certain previously-delegated or less-centralised responsibilities had become somewhat a window-dressing exercise to give the ostensible illusion of a sound-footing; and thereby conducive to a quick, lucrative sale.
I also think it’s easy to overlook the value he added - and quite how quick/successful we were in adopting certain transfer policies (loan to perm for example) and remuneration approaches (flex down, survival bonuses) - that weren’t commonplace at the time, and are now. Then there were stilecards, improvements to what was previously a woeful ticketing operation, the academy to name but a few. It would be wrong to suggest that the overall infrastructure of the club wasn’t massively enhanced during his tenure. And - for all of the Udezes, Moores (Luke), and Ideyes, we did sign more than quite a few legends still fondly remembered to this day.
But it wouldn’t work again now. In many ways we punched above our weight, because that value was there to be added; and he added it. Arguably at the expense of greater investment that at times he could and should have made - certainly we were financially sound enough to. Since then, so many others have caught up, and simply running a business efficiently isn’t enough to cut it anymore. It needs more than that, and I think the ‘more than that’ required he was acutely aware of, and wasn’t comfortable with.
And that was always my biggest problem with JP. I think he was well aware of the fact that the once-often quoted ‘doing a Charlton’ (ironically where the fuck are they now) was the best we could hope to achieve, and that the investment required per place aimed-for above say 8th position merited an investment that would simply never justify itself in terms of payback. As others caught up, it became an increasing headache fending off the vultures while maintaining superiority over those beneath us with deeper pockets and/or loftier ambitions and momentum. Much easier just to cash out. So he did.
I don’t necessarily think it’s also right to criticise him for the sins of this lot whom nobody saw coming. They made the right noises, at a time Chinese uptake wasn’t the geopolitical complication it is now. Couple their naivety with a very poor transfer window or two, the understated impact of the retirement of some very wise heads (Brunt and Mozza chiefly), a head coach who engineered his own dismissal for a payout to settle his own financial woes, and the rest is history.
Certainly he’s no saint, but it was - for the most - good while it lasted. We’ve made plenty of our own mistakes since then.
Jesus Hawks, the JP era post to end all posts. A truly spellbinding bit of inspiration that nails it for those with an ability to look at the character in-depth and the effect on our club.
Post of the year certainly, post of the 2020s so far certainly. Have a pint and bask in your brilliance. Well done.
PS- It was me who said don't let it be a Jeremy Peace thread, but reading your post I'm glad you ignored me. 
RE: Has he got a point ? - Tom Joad - 10-01-2023
(09-30-2023, 09:17 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Paul Thompson turned our football club around completely.He had a plan and then used the money in selling Enzo Maresca to back Megson.Without doubt Thompson was the start of our turn around.
As for Peace he was an accountant running a football club and he was good at it but he certainly wasn’t the start of our successful period.
Exactly. Thompson planned the East Stand, Peace pulled the plug on developing the Halfords. It sort of sums up the difference in ambition. If Peace had genuinely passed on the club for it's own betterment, not his own, he would be respected. Instead, he chased down every last dollar, even to the mysterious loan he hasn't paid back or offered any reasonable explanation for- even to other shareholders.
RE: Has he got a point ? - foreveralbion - 10-01-2023
Some good replies on here.
Peace could have done a lot more to leave a legacy but chose not to so he could maximise his sale price. Even rebuilding the halfords would have left something behind but he decided not to because it wasnt in his best interests.
For Peace then to walk out with anything up to £170m in his back pocket does grate with me.
I dont blame him for Lais failings at all. Im still amazed that Lai saw any value at all in us at that price.
|