WBAUnofficial
Seven Bins Sunak - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Seven Bins Sunak (/showthread.php?tid=31260)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Derek Hardballs - 09-23-2023

(09-23-2023, 10:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-23-2023, 08:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It is honestly pathetic that you are attributing an article in the Times - before the Conference speech has even been made, might I add - as anywhere near comparable as the Prime Minister arguing straw men and bypassing democratic accountability and institutions at a press conference instead of the despatch box.

If you want people to stop calling you a Tory, have you tried not going with false equivalences in attempt to underplay what a Tory has done?

Rubbish. It looks like your party is going to enter an election campaign appealing to the lowest common denominator of NIMBY-ism. They know their market, clearly. Send Dekka an application form to join.

Said by the man who campaigned for the worst most dodgy, lying political party the country has seen in most people’s lifetime.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 09-23-2023

(09-23-2023, 10:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-23-2023, 08:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It is honestly pathetic that you are attributing an article in the Times - before the Conference speech has even been made, might I add - as anywhere near comparable as the Prime Minister arguing straw men and bypassing democratic accountability and institutions at a press conference instead of the despatch box.

If you want people to stop calling you a Tory, have you tried not going with false equivalences in attempt to underplay what a Tory has done?

Rubbish. It looks like your party is going to enter an election campaign appealing to the lowest common denominator of NIMBY-ism. They know their market, clearly. Send Dekka an application form to join.

I'm sorry, is this the same person that campaigned for the Tories to scrap the Lib Dems garden cities in 2015?

Also, the Lib Dems are literally having a vote on Monday on a policy led by Baroness Thornhill to legally block councils from prioritising NIMBY planning objections. On top of land market reforms and Neighborhood Plans. I await an equivalent grassroots Tory campaign for more houses to be as successful.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Protheroe - 09-23-2023

Indeed

"8.1.4 Liberal Democrats would create a system where everyone gets a say in the future of their community, not just a vocal minority."

How on Earth will they do that? The Local Planning process is open to all online, as are all residential planning applications - how are "millions left voiceless"?

Are the Lib Dems going to get Council's to provide funding for planning consultants and planning lawyers for sections of the community who want to argue the case in favour of development?

All sounds (typically) a bit confused and lacking a grounding in reality if you ask me. Much as I'd prefer otherwise Top Down is the only way out of the housing crisis we're in. There should be huge fines on Council's who refuse to meet targets in a Local Plan, bigger ones for those who delay a Local Plan and summary consent for all residential applications that comply with the plan and design guidelines. Not very liberal admittedly - but far more effective.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 09-23-2023

Neighborhood plans and community votes.

AKA the thing they're doing in Eastleigh, which is working.

Also, they literally spell out addressing local plans with integrated planning and moving away from the market providing most housing to government and local authorities having an obligation to provide over a third, in other words "top down".

Also, garden cities? You know, the thing the Lib Dems have wanted to get done for two decades? That's also in the policy paper.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Protheroe - 09-24-2023

Talking of straw men, loving this Davey chat about "Developer Led schemes without proper amenities". Has he never heard of s106 or s278?


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 09-24-2023

Were you not just complaining about the limited capacity of current planning legislation (which covers the T&CPA 1990) restricting the output of new developments? Integrated planning is a pretty big step towards rolling planning laws back to what they were in the 1930s in enabling large scale developments, like garden cities.

Unfortunately, not every LA is like Eastleigh as I am sure you are aware.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Protheroe - 09-24-2023

Local Plan led development delivers all that is necessary. The only areas where developers take liberties are where local authorities are too useless or politically motivated to not produce a Local Plan.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 09-24-2023

But they aren't delivering all that is necessary across the country, otherwise there wouldn't be a housing deficit in the millions and the required housebuilding rate wouldn't have risen from 300,000 in 2015 to 380,000 now. And you know this as you have complained in this very thread about the situation of Local Plans stifling housebuilding - planning priorities are a huge part of this and you know it is. Need only look at the South Warwickshire Plan, the Tories bungled that with failing to plan it out properly through integrated infrastructure planning - how do you build houses without coordinating the expansion of an already at capacity sewage works? Not to mention neglecting to utilise the fucking railway line that goes through two sections of earmarked development and build stations there. Not that it matters much because the local Greens are now trying to torpedo it and are using the infrastructure oversights as an excuse to do that.

As I said, not every LA is like Eastleigh. And you don't get large scale housing developments - as in new towns size which is what hopefully the Lib Dem members pass as federal policy tomorrow (as well as bloody the noses of the federal board trying to water down housing targets) - without integrated planning whether that be LA led (Eastleigh), national led (Welwyn) or private sector led (Bournville and Letchworth). In all three of those examples encompassing the 19th, 20th and 21st century they were only successful with coordinated and integrated planning. And unfortunately the only person in the private sector trying to do that is the King.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Protheroe - 09-24-2023

That's why we need a top down demand for allocations from local authorities without political interference at a local level. It is the *only* way to deal with this situation. If I'm honest I'd prefer to take planning off local authorities completely and centralise it.


RE: Seven Bins Sunak - Borin' Baggie - 09-24-2023

I wouldn't because Westminster has a remarkable knack of screwing over places outside of London with centralised redevelopment as I type this just south of the city of Coventry with its stupid, constricting ring road and loads of council-owned farmland that the government banned them from building houses on. As well as being completely ignorant of local infrastructure needs, as we both know having spent time living in Birmingham. Need I mention the shitshow that is zoning laws in the US and Canada being used by various political groups to restrict housing developments? And Westminster is very happy going along with political interference on infrastructure planning, HS2 anyone? Hell, only 8 years ago the Tories literally scrapped a massive, centrally-led housing development from the coalition for "political reasons".

I would much rather just have the government focus on building the grand, national projects like garden cities and have them set quotas on social housing onto LAs, and just copying what is working well right now in Eastleigh or Eastbourne or Oadby/Whigston to all the other LAs in England.