WBAUnofficial
West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) (/showthread.php?tid=31143)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Birdman1811 - 09-08-2023

My family are all from West Bromwich, even suggest they are brummies and they go nuts.

I grew up in Worcestershire, most football fans that didn't glory hunt were Villa. At school there were 4 of us in the entire school at most who supported West Brom, one Wolves fan, and lots of Aston Villa fans, hence my detest of them.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - baggie_ray - 09-09-2023

(09-08-2023, 06:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Darlaston and Willenhall are in Walsall

Having never lived out that way I'd always taken it as read that Coseley, Darlaston and Willenhall came under Wolverhampton. I was quite surprised to find out that Coseley came under Dudley, courtesy of the road sign by Coseley railway station.

The road sign for Wolverhampton round that point mentions it being the capital of the Black Country, or some such shit.

Wasn't the Black Country named such because of the open coal seem, meaning the fields were black rather than green? Anywhere that didn't fall within that area are Black Country only by association, as I understand it.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Tom Joad - 09-09-2023

(09-09-2023, 08:09 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(09-08-2023, 06:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Darlaston and Willenhall are in Walsall

Having never lived out that way I'd always taken it as read that Coseley, Darlaston and Willenhall came under Wolverhampton. I was quite surprised to find out that Coseley came under Dudley, courtesy of the road sign by Coseley railway station.

The road sign for Wolverhampton round that point mentions it being the capital of the Black Country, or some such shit.

Wasn't the Black Country named such because of the open coal seem, meaning the fields were black rather than green? Anywhere yesthat didn't fall within that area are Black Country only by association, as I understand it.
Yes Ray, c'rect, it's the coal seam and Wolvo is not Black Country. And don't forget the quote, Black by day, red by night.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - baggiebloke - 09-09-2023

Dudley is the "Capital of the Black Country"


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - ColliersWoodBaggie - 09-10-2023

Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s, moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - HWBaggie - 09-10-2023

(09-08-2023, 11:53 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-08-2023, 11:27 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Quite recently (and even more so since the Crooked House Fire), when I have the chance I have delved into some research and podcasts about the Black Country, it's border with Brum and other boundaries, plus the dialect & accent. I'm from Tipton, myself, pretty much in the heart of it. I don't live there now (Bentley Heath for Horseley Heath), but my folks still do, in the house I grew up in. Re podcasts, Adrian Goldberg did a good one 10 years back, which is still available on BBC Sounds. And there was one on Radio 3 a year or so back, still available. Worth a listen. 

For those outside the West Midlands, the Black Country (obviously) isn't Birmingham. "Ar bay a Brummie" etc. But there are debates over whether Wolverhampton should be or not. The Dingles neighbours do sing that "The Black Country is theirs", we tell them "f**k off to Stafford". Dudley is now seen as capital of the Black Country, but Wolverhampton was in the 19th Century. However, this does not include large northern and western areas of Dingletown. Which had not been built on until the 1930s or later. 

For me, I'd say the South Eastern areas are - the bits leading into Willenhall, Bilston and Coseley. That's it. It doesn't include the Town Centre. Molineux isn't, either. Or Fordhouses, Bushbury etc. 

Most seem to agree it is the South Staffs Coalfield, which has a gap near Bentley and west of Walsall, before beginning again around Cannock and Hednesford. I wouldn't class these areas as part of the Black Country mind; but I wonder if our 20th Century perspective of it (ie. being in the West Midlands Metropolitan area and the conurbation) colour the view? And then places between Walsall and Aldridge, are not part of the BC either. There's also debate over Stourbridge and part of Smethwick. 

But being 'Black Country' is different to being anything else - a Brummie being the obvious thing. There's a cultural difference, that even outsiders can pick up on. Some say it goes back to the 17th Century and possibly the religious differences earlier in the Reformation. Birmingham was Parliamentarian in support, the Black Country, Royalist. But recently, there is an urge to 'reclaim' the Black Country again - The 2012 Flag, and the Crooked House Fire (S Staffs) another. I guess political boundaries don't reflect mental or cultural ones.  

But it got me thinking about fanbases of the Midlands clubs. Albion is a Black Country club first and foremost. From hearsay, and looking at post match trains/trams/buses/pedestrians, I would imagine our support  is 75% or more BC . 20% Brummie? The rest - possibly M5 corridor and Solihull-Warwick-Banbury corridor. 

As for Wolves, I'd say mainly Wolverhampton areas and Shropshire, with a lot of BC. With Cannock and Stafford.

Walsall, well I'd imagine, quite localised to that town. 

As for the Birmingham clubs,; Villa have a fair number of BC support. . Albion and Villa probably overlap around the Scott Arms, to Kingstanding and around Handsworth. But, until I worked with Brummies at the age of 20, I never knew a Blues fan None over our way. 

It would be interesting to map where the support comes from. The best way would be to 'map' season ticket holders, I would think. Data on addresses would give you that info. 

As for Black Country boundaries, this is an interesting linked article below:

https://www.blackcountrysociety.com/post/blackcountryman-article-by-matt-mills-corrected-article-and-response-by-nick-moss#:~:text=This%20study%20has%20focused%20on,certain%20areas%20that%20were%20never

Having lived in Birmingham for the last 6 years I would say there's a North/South divide on Blues- Villa roughly speaking. 

Villa are very strong around Sutton Coldfield, Erdington and Perry Barr coming into Aston and the City Centre, and then Blues take the South side of the City into Digbeth, Yardley, Hall Green and into Moseley and KH. With the growth of Solihull over the last 40-50years it's a mixed bag of Villa and Bluenoses, and then Villa pick up a lot of support out in Redditch and Worcestershire and Warwickshire, filling the void that should be filled by Coventry, but most of their locals prefer to support Man United and Liverpool. Would also say Villa have been successful in growing into Tamworth and the new towns areas up towards Atherstone, Lichfield and Cannock.

There's obviously a Villa/Albion border going into Handsworth and Edgbaston way.

Growing up In Redditch in the 70s I's say the support was overwhelmingly Blues, due to the mass migration from South Birmingham when Redditch became a new town.  Virtually all of my mates were bluenoses-I can remember the Villa fans by name and I can only recall 2 Wolves fans and zero Cov.  For our part we could always raise at least one coach from in front of the old fire station and later on from the supporters coach linked to the old British Aluminium club.    Bagpuss may well fill in a few gaps for me.

That said, I haven't lived there since 1983 and they've pretty much had the run of it since then so things may well have changed.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Tom Joad - 09-10-2023

(09-10-2023, 11:00 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s,  moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.

Agree with much of this but remember, Dudley has also been in Staffs previously. I'm still convinced Wolvo has never been BC although accept that the towns it engulfed (Bilston etc) were. Re the OP, my area of Dudley was a straight  split of Baggies/ Dings. My schooldays job, as a milkmon's mairt, meant we covered areas of Tipton. This seemed slightly more Albion. As you got to Coseley it tended to be more Dingle. Obviously though, the side in the ascendancy tends to be the more obvious. The real bodyblow for me is the Premier influence, one day wolves will once again be a minor, noisy, dirty  inconvenience but Villa definitely have a foothold now where they have no right and worse IMO, is the Asian love for Liverpool and Man U.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Borin' Baggie - 09-10-2023

(09-10-2023, 11:24 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:00 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s,  moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.

Agree with much of this but remember, Dudley has also been in Staffs previously. I'm still convinced Wolvo has never been BC although accept that the towns it engulfed (Bilston etc) were. Re the OP, my area of Dudley was a straight  split of Baggies/ Dings. My schooldays job, as a milkmon's mairt, meant we covered areas of Tipton. This seemed slightly more Albion. As you got to Coseley it tended to be more Dingle. Obviously though, the side in the ascendancy tends to be the more obvious. The real bodyblow for me is the Premier influence, one day wolves will once again be a minor, noisy, dirty  inconvenience but Villa definitely have a foothold now where they have no right and worse IMO, is the Asian love for Liverpool and Man U.

Dudley was in Worcs. I don't know about the north end of the town that was absorbed but the town centre was always in Worcs dating to the Domesday Book.

I think Tipton was split between Worcs and Staffs, I know it was Worcs though when my Granddad came over (his letters from the 1950s and 1960s have Worcestershire as the postal county).

Smethwick is the funny one, the borough used to contain Harborne (before that was annexed into Warwickshire as it was absorbed into Birmingham) and until the 1960s I believe it was in Staffordshire for its entirety - probably why I saw more Albion fans round there than Villa and Blues when I lived nearby for uni. Then Smethwick was briefly in Worcestershire as it was absorbed into Warley which was a borough of Worcestershire. Which means that if you look at the OS maps in the late 1960s/early 1970s The Hawthorns transcended 3 counties (part of the East Stand was in Warwickshire, part of the Smethwick End was in Worcestershire).


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Tom Joad - 09-10-2023

(09-10-2023, 02:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:24 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(09-10-2023, 11:00 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Apparently, in the 19th Century, Wolverhampton was considered 'capital of Black Country' and Dudley was not. It was a Market town which grew economically because of the coal and iron ore nearby. Rather as Walsall and Birmingham did by the 18th-19th Cent. I think it is because traditionalists see the 'Black Country' as part of the South Staffs coal seams (surface and deep). Dudley was Worcestershire pre-1974, and it sits on a limestone cliff, so technically not part of it. Wolverhampton town centre isn't, and suburbs built in the 1930s & 1950s onwards to the north of the centre are not either.

As for the tribalism mentioned by Tom Joad- this is correct. There's footage on You Tube of people being interviewed in Wednesbury, sometime in the 60s,  moaning that all the attention and funding went to West Bromwich once the District /Town Council of West Brom absorbed Wednesbury. And this morning on a Tipton FB site, someone moaned "all the money in Sandwell goes to West Brom".

OP was about BC Boundaries, but also about where the support for each of the 5 West Mids comes from, particularly ours. Overlaps etc. My argument was that we are a mainly BC club, not a Brummie one, due to where our support comes from; and Wolves are less so. Despite the proximity of the ground to Birmingham.

Agree with much of this but remember, Dudley has also been in Staffs previously. I'm still convinced Wolvo has never been BC although accept that the towns it engulfed (Bilston etc) were. Re the OP, my area of Dudley was a straight  split of Baggies/ Dings. My schooldays job, as a milkmon's mairt, meant we covered areas of Tipton. This seemed slightly more Albion. As you got to Coseley it tended to be more Dingle. Obviously though, the side in the ascendancy tends to be the more obvious. The real bodyblow for me is the Premier influence, one day wolves will once again be a minor, noisy, dirty  inconvenience but Villa definitely have a foothold now where they have no right and worse IMO, is the Asian love for Liverpool and Man U.

Dudley was in Worcs. I don't know about the north end of the town that was absorbed but the town centre was always in Worcs dating to the Domesday Book.

I think Tipton was split between Worcs and Staffs, I know it was Worcs though when my Granddad came over (his letters from the 1950s and 1960s have Worcestershire as the postal county).

Smethwick is the funny one, the borough used to contain Harborne (before that was annexed into Warwickshire as it was absorbed into Birmingham) and until the 1960s I believe it was in Staffordshire for its entirety - probably why I saw more Albion fans round there than Villa and Blues when I lived nearby for uni. Then Smethwick was briefly in Worcestershire as it was absorbed into Warley which was a borough of Worcestershire. Which means that if you look at the OS maps in the late 1960s/early 1970s The Hawthorns transcended 3 counties (part of the East Stand was in Warwickshire, part of the Smethwick End was in Worcestershire).
I think you'll find that Dudley, although having much the most of it's history-as you say from the Domesday Book on- in Worcs  has spent a small part of it's history in Staffs. (Even a small part of my childhood).  I think it was because the Castle area may have been in Staffs and the centre of the town and beyond was Worcs.  I'm sure I saw a relative's geneology study as describing some of my ancestors as being from Dudley, Staffs and others, Dudley, Worcs. Somehow Dudley and Warley became an island in Worcs surrounded by Staffs. 
Of course, there is no point in going to war over this now as we are all West Midlanders....

Also, edit, I read once that Worcestershire incorporated much of what is now Pershore Rd. B'ham including Edgbaston Cricket Ground. Think on that, Bears.


RE: West Mids fanbases and boundaries (Brum & BC) - Gzbaggy - 09-10-2023

Two of England's finest sportsmen from Staffordshire S F Barnes and Duncan Edwards