![]() |
|
Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Post transfer deadline thoughts? (/showthread.php?tid=31079) |
RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Crossbar11 - 09-02-2023 (09-02-2023, 12:13 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Taking a positive out of the situation we are in is that we've not just sold anyone we've had bids for peanuts. I know it's clutching at straws but surely we would have excepted any offers if the situation at the club is critical. This brings me to think(hope)that maybe a takeover is in the pipeline over the next few months. Thats my take , club desperate for money doesn't sell players when the profit on BTA would have been huge for example . Something doesn't add up . RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Pragmatist - 09-02-2023 A takeover must be on the cards because there’s simply now no other way out for Lai. It must be close enough to not have to accept any cheap offer for players. My hunch is that CC will have been told that he could only strengthen through payment of fees if players were sold, but not at low prices. There does remain the possibility of course that we may receive an acceptable offer for Okay from Turkey in the next fortnight, which could force us into the free agent market, but that’s far from ideal as players without a club would not be anywhere near match-fit. Let’s hope that a sale of the club to suitable owners really is close. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Mr Nimbus - 09-02-2023 (09-02-2023, 07:57 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:(09-02-2023, 12:06 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:(09-01-2023, 11:31 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: So we have to continue paying OTT wages to a crop of players that noone was interested in signing. In the last few years we've over spent on transfer fees FAIL Then overpaid on wages for frees FAIL alongside this we've added experienced pros with terrible injury records. Regardless of who the owner is, and how much money they put in or take out, what is needed is a consistent and sensible recruitment strategy. More BTAs and less Kelly's. Better utilisation of foreign markets (why has it taken CC to bring in his own man to show what's available) and better utilisation of the loan markets to bring in young talent. The academy provides a steady income stream whilst trying to bring through the next Dara. It worked for us before, when we didn't have years of PL money behind us, but the blueprint was ripped up and thrown away. If the financial restrictions we have in place lead us to being a smarter club again I'll take it. In the right market place we are still seen as a big club regardless of cash in the bank. We may have uninterested and despicable owners, and the loan is a worry, but we are again being run by an Albion man. Gourlay never felt right and he did a poor job within keeping of his reputation. MM may not have the profile some would like but he knows the club inside out. The doom mongers can now take a break for a few months, I'm sure they'll be back out again in force come January. But until then, let's stop worrying about the owners and finances, and see what a half decent chump squad and a good manager can do. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - WorcsWBA - 09-02-2023 (09-02-2023, 08:25 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: A takeover must be on the cards because there’s simply now no other way out for Lai. It must be close enough to not have to accept any cheap offer for players. My hunch is that CC will have been told that he could only strengthen through payment of fees if players were sold, but not at low prices. Let's hope so indeed. Whilst Carlos will be pleased on the playing side that no more senior players have left, the drain on our finances remains and, if things are in dire straits to the extent that ITKers here have reported, then things could become very tricky by January if the club isn't sold. In the meantime, Carlos knows what he's got now until January (assuming Yokuslu doesn't sign for a Turkish club), so can cut his cloth accordingly. I hope he finds a way to start Sarmiento in games sooner rather than later, as it looks like he'll add an extra dimension for us. I also fully expect Pipa to be in the starting XI as soon as he's match-fit, as Carlos knows and trusts him. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - baggie93 - 09-02-2023 Im not sure that not selling BTA to Stoke paints a brighter picture of our finances. It seemed that Stoke wanted to pay in instalments which wouldnt have helped our problem much. Isnt this why Dara went a bit cheaper..we had the 7m straight away..rather than instalments. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Fulham Fallout - 09-02-2023 (09-02-2023, 08:41 AM)baggie93 Wrote: Im not sure that not selling BTA to Stoke paints a brighter picture of our finances. It seemed that Stoke wanted to pay in instalments which wouldnt have helped our problem much. Isnt this why Dara went a bit cheaper..we had the 7m straight away..rather than instalments. Correct re Dara. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Derek Hardballs - 09-02-2023 We have a decent squad, a very good manager and a realistic chance of promotion and the sale of the club. I don’t profess to know anything about the financial state the club is in, I think the plan to sell any saleable asset was an exercise in putting off the inevitable based on what others have said, I’d be very happy if this transpires not to be the case for whatever reason. RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Atomic - 09-02-2023 I think the biggest feeling overall is one of relief. Going into this transfer window we knew it was going to be a challenging one and we were aware of the financial restraints. Fans are powerless and we had to place our trust into the hands of people running the operations within the club and that's not easy for fans to do given the recent history. My biggest fear was us selling the (relative) quality that we had within last seasons squad and the sake of Dara O'Shea early on in this window did nothing to ease those fears. However, Dara is the only one we have sold that I'd put in that "quality" bracket. That's a very good result in terms of our onfield position given the position we are in off the field. Taylor Gardner-Hickman's departure for Bristol City is not a transfer I'm particularly pleased about but I do appreciate something has to give. If you look at our squad now for this coming season you can certainly argue that it's better than last seasons squad. Mowatt, Kipre, Taylor and Fellows have all returned from loans and Josh Maja is a much needed addition to our attack. Added to that Jeremy Sarmiento is a loanee that looks full of promise and Pipa joins as right back competition for Furlong and given that he's played under Corberan twice before, he's obviously got something about him that the head coach likes. The squad isn't as thin as some people make out. We actually have a squad of 25 players all of whom have Championship experience and we do have two players for each position: Palmer Griffiths Furlong Ajayi Kipre Townsend Pipa Bartley Pieters Reach Taylor Kelly Molumby Yokuslu Mowatt Chalobah Wallace Phillips Fellows Diangana Swift Sarmiento Thomas-Asante Maja Dike That is by no means bad by Championship standards. There's probably one too many centre backs in there and one too few midfielders but it's a well balanced squad. Whether we have enough quality in a couple of areas is open to debate but though it wouldn't be our strongest squad in the last twenty years it's a perfectly respectable one at this level. I think those running operations deserve credit for compiling this squad under the circumstances. In terms of finances it's very hard for any fan to offer a strong opinion on the progress made because none of us are privy to the information we'd require to form that opinion. On the face of it I'd say the club would've been extremely keen to offload the likes of Diangana, Grant, Kelly, Bartley had the opportunity arisen and they'll probably be disappointed not to have brought more money into the club. What this means regarding the desperation of our finances I don't know. The club don't appear to be desperate indicated by turning down offers for Thomas-Asante, so hopefully we're getting by which is all we can reasonably expect at the moment and of course there may be stuff going on behind the scenes that none of us fans are currently aware of, in fact I suspect there probably is. In summary, all in the garden is far from rosy, but I'm happy with the way West Bromwich Albion have handled this transfer window and we can all relax for the time being at least knowing that things could've been far, far worse, certainly on the playing front RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Mr Nimbus - 09-02-2023 Yep agree with that, although it is more a squad of players being paid, rather than available. Will we really get much game time this year out Kelly, Grady, Dike and now Reach? If these guys come back in and give us serious game time it will be a bonus. Even so, at least we do have a resemblance of balance (certainly compared to the wonderful window where we ended up with £30 million plus of left sided attackers).Lets be optimistic and include the hydropool hoggers. In Maja and DD we have two proper CFs, BTA is still learning that trade but doing a damn good job. Out wide we have a good mix and match across left and right. The arrival of Sarmiento adds to that but I can see him playing as much in the number 10 role once bedded in (better him than JW). I'd also be interested to see BTA playing wide of Maja at some point. If we just accept Mowatt as a tidy CM then he will be an asset. Chalobah is concern as cover for OY, which is obviously shared by CC as he tried to move him on, but let's give him the benefit until Jan. Molomby and an up to pace OY is as good a combination as any in the league surely? Same can be said for Barts. CC would replace him with a better footballing LCB but his wages must be difficult to move on, so we have to fudge it with Pieters and/or potentially CT in that spot? Its tells you a lot how much CC is concerned about his footballing ability as a back three of Kipre, Semi and Barts would offer a real attacking threat. Full/Wing backs. I thought CC was talking sht about Reach the other day, but the fact we haven't strengthened on the left suggest he does genuinely see him as a potential WB. In the meantime Phillip's covers at LWB, LW, RW and CF until his inevitable injury. GK. Better for the removal of a player. So yep. Apart from LCB I think we are stocked with a decently balanced group of chump footballers, certainly as good as we can hope for in the circumstances, and Ecertainly enough to put out a competitive team. Most have a mistake in them and suffer indifferent runs of form, but that's why they haven't joined Dara in the PL. One caveat; OY is still key, even when slightly off the pace/out of form, as he glues the team together so i'll be glad when the Turkush window shuts (although I'm guessing his salary is comparable). RE: Post transfer deadline thoughts? - Shabby Russian - 09-02-2023 For a championship club the squad still seems a little bloated, disguised by the injuries to Dike, Diangana and Reach. It should allow us to be very competitive , but perhaps a little short of the necessary quality. That said, if everyone performs to their highest standard...including the manager, there's no reason why we can't be involved in the promotion race. |