WBAUnofficial
I don’t agree with this - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: I don’t agree with this (/showthread.php?tid=31067)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: I don’t agree with this - BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine - 09-01-2023

(09-01-2023, 09:58 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 09:12 PM)HugeHons Wrote: There were regular German soldiers and then there were Nazis. He was involved with the Nazis. How can they let him off, so to speak? What if say, they found someone that killed a relative of yours many years ago?

Schindler was a member of the Nazi party and profited from the war, until he saw the light and changed his ways.

Schindler was more than just a member of the Nazi party - he was one of their top intelligence agents in Poland before the invasion.


RE: I don’t agree with this - Morley - 09-01-2023

(09-01-2023, 10:56 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 10:03 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 10:03 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I don't want to get into the politics nature of this discussion, but what is the point in punishing a 98 year old? Without sounding brutal, he hasn't got long and has lived his life, so even if he deserves the harshest of sentences, what's the point?

Because he’s a Nazi?

You can spend (I'm guessing millions?) bringing this to trial and convicting the guy, and I'm not saying he shouldn't be convicted and I'm not Nazi sympathiser, but there's a scenario here where you could spend all this time, money and resources on getting justice, only for the 98 year old to die naturally within days. It just seems a bit pointless to me. 

Due to the age of those involved there has to be a point where you 'let it go' as such (the monstrosities of what happened in WWII (before and beyond) should never be let go, the story and importance should always be taught, but punishing nearly 100 year olds won't achieve anything other than waste resources that are better spent elsewhere. I'm sorry, I just don't see the point. It's 60 years too late.

My Mom is 89, she was too young to be evacuated and so her earliest memories are of air raids and bomb shelters. To this day 80 plus years later if she hears an air raid in a film or a dog howl (the cadence is similar) she will cover her ears. One morning she went round to see a friend only to watch the fire brigade carry the family out of the cellar.  Instead of going to the community shelter they went into cellar. The only problem with that is that the bomb that caused the house to collapse also ruptured the water main.  I'll let you come round and tell her to 'let it go'.


RE: I don’t agree with this - SuperBob2002 - 09-01-2023

(09-01-2023, 11:32 PM)Morley Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 10:56 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 10:03 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-01-2023, 10:03 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I don't want to get into the politics nature of this discussion, but what is the point in punishing a 98 year old? Without sounding brutal, he hasn't got long and has lived his life, so even if he deserves the harshest of sentences, what's the point?

Because he’s a Nazi?

You can spend (I'm guessing millions?) bringing this to trial and convicting the guy, and I'm not saying he shouldn't be convicted and I'm not Nazi sympathiser, but there's a scenario here where you could spend all this time, money and resources on getting justice, only for the 98 year old to die naturally within days. It just seems a bit pointless to me. 

Due to the age of those involved there has to be a point where you 'let it go' as such (the monstrosities of what happened in WWII (before and beyond) should never be let go, the story and importance should always be taught, but punishing nearly 100 year olds won't achieve anything other than waste resources that are better spent elsewhere. I'm sorry, I just don't see the point. It's 60 years too late.

My Mom is 89, she was too young to be evacuated and so her earliest memories are of air raids and bomb shelters. To this day 80 plus years later if she hears an air raid in a film or a dog howl (the cadence is similar) she will cover her ears. One morning she went round to see a friend only to watch the fire brigade carry the family out of the cellar.  Instead of going to the community shelter they went into cellar. The only problem with that is that the bomb that caused the house to collapse also ruptured the water main.  I'll let you come round and tell her to 'let it go'.

You know that's not what I meant. Hence the air quotes.


RE: I don’t agree with this - baggiebloke - 09-01-2023

Age should not be a barrier to bringing people to justice.

The cunt (if found guilty) might live to a hundred and twenty.

Am staggered at the Nazi defenders on here.


RE: I don’t agree with this - Birdman1811 - 09-01-2023

Schindler realised his error and quite publicly tried to repair the damage done.

From the looks of it, this guy didn't, which would suggest he was fully onboard with the plan, and possibly still thinks it was right, people with that attitude exist still.


RE: I don’t agree with this - albion_pigeon - 09-02-2023

I'll be in Auschwitz next weekend for the second time purely because a mate I'm going to Krakow with wants to go and visit, I swore I'd never go again but can't deny anyone the chance to go and see just how inhumane and evil the human race can be. Anyone on here moaning about the cost of prosecutions and "moving on", I highly suggest you go and visit there yourself, walk down into the blown up gas chambers, spend a few moments in front of the lake next to them where lots of ashes were dumped. Or you know, just shut the fuck up?


RE: I don’t agree with this - Brentbaggie - 09-02-2023

There is no statute of limitations for murder under British law. Nor is there one for taking part or assisting in genocide under German law. As Morley has pointed out there are almost no examples of German soldiers being executed for refusing to take part in acts of genocide or refusing to work as a camp guard.

If people want to argue that time passed should curtail the exercise of justice I’m afraid the law is against them. If on the other hand they feel that money expended should be the principle reason not to effect justice then may I ask just how much money expended is sufficient for the administration of justice to be withheld? What figure specifically? Is there a sliding scale? A thousand Euros? Ten thousand? A hundred thousand? A million?

If anyone can weigh the balance of a life lived to an advanced age, free and unjudged, against those millions whose lives were snuffed out - in many instances as infants and children - without judgement, without reparation, without the right to a life of any kind, then please let me know how you arrived at your conclusion, I’m intrigued to find out.


RE: I don’t agree with this - Fulham Fallout - 09-02-2023

(09-02-2023, 12:01 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote: I'll be in Auschwitz next weekend for the second time purely because a mate I'm going to Krakow with wants to go and visit, I swore I'd never go again but can't deny anyone the chance to go and see just how inhumane and evil the human race can be. Anyone on here moaning about the cost of prosecutions and "moving on", I highly suggest you go and visit there yourself, walk down into the blown up gas chambers, spend a few moments in front of the lake next to them where lots of ashes were dumped. Or you know, just shut the fuck up?

Likewise.  I first went with two mates in 2005.  When I subsequently went to Krakow with my brother a few times he kept asking me to go to Auschwitz with him and each time I’d refuse.  Some years later we went to Krakow again with two other friends and my brother went to Auschwitz with one of them.  When they returned the first thing my brother said was “I’m  ever going there again. I always thought you never wanted to go again because you’d been there before”.

A few years ago I took my son to Krakow and he wanted to go to Auschwitz and so I decided to grit my teeth and go again. 

This time I noticed something in the gas chamber in Auschwitz that I hadn’t spotted the first time.  Half way down the wall on the right hand side (with the door to outside behind you pidge) theres scratch marks on the wall that have clearly been made by human nails.  Have a look for them Pidge and put your fingers in the position on the scratch marks and you will see they were made with fingers wide apart.


RE: I don’t agree with this - SuperBob2002 - 09-02-2023

I 'want' to visit Auschwitz. The idea of walking around and hearing the vile stories and seeing the evidence of all that went on makes me feel sick, but I think it's an experience everyone should have.


RE: I don’t agree with this - ColliersWoodBaggie - 09-02-2023

It is a philosophical question to begin with. 'What would you have done under such a regime'? You could debate this all day and all week. The history of Germany at the time, a young nation with militaristic origins plays an important role in this. Plus the anger at Versailles, the economic recession following 1929. Then the laws which were brought in after 1933, in most areas of life, gradually, then rapidly made the environment easier for persecution. . It might have made it easier to coerce the population into acceptance, although clearly not all did accept this. I studied the period at University and A Level in the early to mid 90s. My (German) lecturer in the University had parents who hid their Jewish friends and neighbours when the time came for them to be rounded up. I think their family was questioned, but somehow got away with it. I never asked enough. But it shows that there were brave people who had the cojones to stand up for what they saw as the right thing to do, even if these may have been the minority. Many disagreed with the Nazis but said nothing out of fear.

I suppose in this case, what the court are doing (trying at a juvenile court) is the correct thing to do. It is part of German Law, so I have no issue with the man facing justice. Again, it is another philosophical and legal question - but justice needs to be done, no matter how long ago it happened.