WBAUnofficial
What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… (/showthread.php?tid=30815)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Protheroe - 08-12-2023

It’s all part of the same problem B1. If decent housing were not so scarce there would not be the same political pressure to be seen to be doing something as crass as the Bibby Stockholm.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - baggy1 - 08-12-2023

Let’s address one thing at a time shall we - the Bobby Stockholm is a sham covering up god knows how many thousands that are being put up in hotels. Rwanda is a sham to take the focus away from the contracts with companies to house the asylum seekers. Calling them illegal immigrants is a sham because they simply aren’t, they are just immigrants taking advantage of a broken system that they know can’t process applications, there is no such thing as an illegal immigrant.

Housing is a separate, also broken, discussion.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Protheroe - 08-13-2023

No it’s not. If housing wasn’t such an issue in this country then neither would migration ~ legal or otherwise.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - baggy1 - 08-13-2023

Ok, I'll rephrase. Housing is a separate but linked, also broken, discussion.

Immigration wouldn't be anywhere near as bad as it is if we hadn't closed asylum centres around the world and cut the staffing in the Home Office of those that process the applications. Both of those under the guise of austerity.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Protheroe - 08-13-2023

Wouldn’t it? Hmm. I think the global movement of people is far more complex than issues with the Home Office.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - baggy1 - 08-13-2023

It’s impossible to have any sort of discussion with you due to your defensive position when it comes to issues you have supported in the past, in this case austerity.

We closed our regional centres where people could claim asylum. This meant that the only way they could claim asylum is by rocking up on our shores and making the claim on arrival. This in turn means that when they arrive we cannot differentiate between the real asylum seekers and the economic migrants or criminals so we have to treat them all the same. This situation is getting abused by criminals who don’t give a flying about gimmicks to deter that will never work.

We’ve also, at the same time, cut the number of officers dealing with these claims doubling down on the mistake of closing asylum centres. This means that the increased numbers arriving on our shore are taking longer to process, both individually and collectively. This leads to increased numbers waiting longer times and higher costs in accommodation.

It’s a failed policy that can be seen to be causing more damage and cost. Time too accept that and take a different path to solving it, not right wing headline grabbing ideas like boats that aren’t meant for that number or purpose, sending them to islands with no infrastructure, sending them to another country that is happy to take our cash, or getting wave machines installed in the channel.

Just deal with the issue in the proper way. Asylum centres and staffing the administration around it.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Protheroe - 08-13-2023

Again I think we’ll have to agree to disagree on the causes of the current numbers of arrivals.

I think we can agree that our management of it is lamentable, and dog whistle politics surrounding it depressing. The mood music from the Labour Party isn’t any better.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - CaptainFantastico - 08-13-2023

The cause of arrivals is as simple as it will be for the years to come. The dual crumbling of phoney capitalism and the environment. It’s a simple recipe with predictable outcomes


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Shabby Russian - 08-13-2023

(08-13-2023, 10:27 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The cause of arrivals is as simple as it will be for the years to come. The dual crumbling of phoney capitalism and the environment. It’s a simple recipe with predictable outcomes

This.

Add in expected  massive population increases in countries like Nigeria, Niger etc.

Heard an astonishing stat the other day. Only 2% of Nigers population is over 60, 50% 15 or under.
Leading to an expected population increase  from 27 m today to 70m by 2050.


RE: What we have learnt over the last couple of weeks… - Protheroe - 08-13-2023

Most of the countries immigrants (outside Europe) are coming from lack markets, the rule of law or property rights so I don’t think a failure of capitalism there is to blame - it never existed. The vast majority of actual climate refugees (are there more than a handful yet?) will migrate to cities within the countries they reside.