WBAUnofficial
Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell (/showthread.php?tid=29924)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Peachy - 05-09-2023

Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Pragmatist - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Peachy Wrote: Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?

Any deal is possible if buyer and seller agree the commercial terms. Another option is for a buyer to acquire a (say) 40% stake with an option to buy the balance.  The Czech investor at West Ham has done something similar.

(05-09-2023, 08:43 AM)spudgun Wrote: An interesting viewpoint, and I apologise in advance for only picking up on a small point of this. I've always wondered why the term 'investment' is used in relation to football clubs as nearly all of them don't even get close to breaking even.

To me, football, especially at our level, can never be an investment as you have very little chance of getting your money back and unless you are looking to have losses on your books so you can offset gains in other profitable areas, why on earth would someone want to 'invest' in football.

Again, apologies for going off on a bit of a tangent as it grinds my gears when fans ask for an 'investment' in their club as the owners might as well burn the money in the street as they have next to no chance of getting any of it back if they 'invest' in the club.


Correct.  Money can only be made by buying an underpriced club because of its circumstances.  There has to be upside, and buying at full value in the Premier League like Yunyai did had no upside whatsoever.  At our correct current value we are probably now an attractive proposition, assuming that a purchaser can buy at that value.  Wolves and Villa were both acquired cheaply because of their huge debts at that time. 

Only a sustained spell in the Premier League MIGHT generate an investment return.  So there have to be other reasons for buying, ie brand development.  The strong US Dollar and weak pound help at present to provide potential upside via currency gains.   And then of course there are some buyers who are just looking to launder money, and for whom any loss is the laundering cost.  

I’m actually struggling to think of many “investors” who will have made money out of buying a UK football club in the top two divisions in the last 20 years.  Brentford might. The Glazers obviously have.  Any others?


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Tambag - 05-09-2023

The only positive I can find about us not going up is Lai can't take anymore parachute payments out of our club for his other companies.

The big worry now is where does the MSD money end up ?

If we were to sell any of our assests (like Dara), would the money stay in the club ?


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Peachy - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 11:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Peachy Wrote: Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?

Any deal is possible if buyer and seller agree the commercial terms. Another option is for a buyer to acquire a (say) 40% stake with an option to buy the balance.  The Czech investor at West Ham has done something similar.

Yep. Like you say it requires both parties wanting to actually do a deal. The long and the short of it though is that Lai will have to deal with the fact that he WILL lose money. Lots of it. And one would presume a big loss to his reputation, should he have one, within his own business community. 

Thats why when you build an upside into the sale it muddies the waters and can give investors hope of money down the line.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Jerry - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 11:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Peachy Wrote: Great thread this and an interesting read Prag.

I know nothing about football deals but all through my 20's I worked on land deals for both residential and commercial developers. It was common practice in lots of deals that upsides were built into the land price. The selling party would insert clauses that gave them a second pay day should the purchaser achieve a larger number of units on their land at a later date.

Could this not be a way of making the deal happen quickly? Everyone knows we are only worth ©£50m and Lai and his investors paid £200m. Maybe there could be a structured deal whereby another £10m or so could be paid for each year we spend in the prem up to a maximum of 5 years or something?

Any deal is possible if buyer and seller agree the commercial terms. Another option is for a buyer to acquire a (say) 40% stake with an option to buy the balance.  The Czech investor at West Ham has done something similar.

(05-09-2023, 08:43 AM)spudgun Wrote: An interesting viewpoint, and I apologise in advance for only picking up on a small point of this. I've always wondered why the term 'investment' is used in relation to football clubs as nearly all of them don't even get close to breaking even.

To me, football, especially at our level, can never be an investment as you have very little chance of getting your money back and unless you are looking to have losses on your books so you can offset gains in other profitable areas, why on earth would someone want to 'invest' in football.

Again, apologies for going off on a bit of a tangent as it grinds my gears when fans ask for an 'investment' in their club as the owners might as well burn the money in the street as they have next to no chance of getting any of it back if they 'invest' in the club.


Correct.  Money can only be made by buying an underpriced club because of its circumstances.  There has to be upside, and buying at full value in the Premier League like Yunyai did had no upside whatsoever.  At our correct current value we are probably now an attractive proposition, assuming that a purchaser can buy at that value.  Wolves and Villa were both acquired cheaply because of their huge debts at that time. 

Only a sustained spell in the Premier League MIGHT generate an investment return.  So there have to be other reasons for buying, ie brand development.  The strong US Dollar and weak pound help at present to provide potential upside via currency gains.   And then of course there are some buyers who are just looking to launder money, and for whom any loss is the laundering cost.  

I’m actually struggling to think of many “investors” who will have made money out of buying a UK football club in the top two divisions in the last 20 years.  Brentford might. The Glazers obviously have.  Any others?

Jeremy Peace WBA


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - MGalea - 05-09-2023

Good opening post. Fingers crossed!

I have always been of the opinion that rather than completely selling all of the family china (excuse the pun!) and asset stripping everything that eventually there becomes a line where they will not be able to afford to lose anymore.

If they continue to take out millions in cash from the club it will be reported and any buyer will factor that into their offers.

The worst thing about this scenerio is that they could be so desperate to off load that we could end up with some really really extra dodgy bastards next time.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Mr vertical - 05-09-2023

Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - BurleyBaggie - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.

In many ways the MSD loan forces sale: the debt for shares obligation means any default further increases losses and the terms prohibit any further cash leaving the business.

Therefore, they need to sell now to minimise any further losses.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 12:53 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.

In many ways the MSD loan forces sale: the debt for shares obligation means any default further increases losses and the terms prohibit any further cash leaving the business.

Therefore, they need to sell now to minimise any further losses.

I'm not aware of any debt for equity swap option being announced? Surely the only way that could happen would be if the loan was in default? S4A have completely missed the point and the structure of these types of loans, as evidenced by some of the questions they asked in the letter recently published.

The club has insufficient cashflow to meet it's day to day obligations, so this loan will most likely be structured with a bullet repayment, possibly with interest rolling up. Asking about what the repayment term is (we know it is 4 years) and the split between capital and interest misses the point.

So if the loan is payable in 4 years time, then pressure from MSD won't be the catalyst for something to happen. It will be when we can't afford to pay the wages, or our committed transfer fees (like the remaining instalments on Grant's loan) that will likely force MSD into action. As Prag suggested in the opening post, Lai will want the club gone before then, otherwise the investors will lose everything.

The only thing we don't know is when will happen? I said early I thought Lai might have one more season, but I'm starting to agree with Prag. I say this because our Turnover in the year ended June 2022 with TV/Parachute monies stripped out was £13.7M. A typical Chump club would receive £5M, so let's round it up to £20M for us in the EFL. Our wage bill in 2022 was £42.7M. And we owe a further £10.7M to other league clubs in transfers(reduced by £2M in the last 12 months). Even with the MSD £20M, I think something has to give. Our monthly outgoings have to be c£4M a month, possibly more.


RE: Why I think Yunyai will now look to sell - Remi_Moses - 05-09-2023

(05-09-2023, 02:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 12:53 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:
(05-09-2023, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.

In many ways the MSD loan forces sale: the debt for shares obligation means any default further increases losses and the terms prohibit any further cash leaving the business.

Therefore, they need to sell now to minimise any further losses.

I'm not aware of any debt for equity swap option being announced? Surely the only way that could happen would be if the loan was in default? S4A have completely missed the point and the structure of these types of loans, as evidenced by some of the questions they asked in the letter recently published.

The club has insufficient cashflow to meet it's day to day obligations, so this loan will most likely be structured with a bullet repayment, possibly with interest rolling up. Asking about what the repayment term is (we know it is 4 years) and the split between capital and interest misses the point.

So if the loan is payable in 4 years time, then pressure from MSD won't be the catalyst for something to happen. It will be when we can't afford to pay the wages, or our committed transfer fees (like the remaining instalments on Grant's loan) that will likely force MSD into action. As Prag suggested in the opening post, Lai will want the club gone before then, otherwise the investors will lose everything.

The only thing we don't know is when will happen? I said early I thought Lai might have one more season, but I'm starting to agree with Prag. I say this because our Turnover in the year ended June 2022 with TV/Parachute monies stripped out was £13.7M. A typical Chump club would receive £5M, so let's round it up to £20M for us in the EFL. Our wage bill in 2022 was £42.7M. And we owe a further £10.7M to other league clubs in transfers(reduced by £2M in the last 12 months). Even with the MSD £20M, I think something has to give. Our monthly outgoings have to be c£4M a month, possibly more.

I believe the MSD loan has already been tapped into or the club would have waited to see if we were going to get promoted. A £20m loan could have been repaid in a single year with PL money. 
I roughly guess we will be out of cash by Xmas.
I've said many times £25m needs to come from investments or loans to balance the books of a championship club.
Sadly because of the standing of WBA our running costs outway our income even when we were getting parachute payments. We are not geared up to run on a budget of £25m.
It's obvious we have to save at least what the parachute payments have been just to survive.
The question is do we sell what we can (players) as a short term solution to financially survive. Resulting in a lingering nightmare or go into administration quickly and rid ourselves of our Chinese owners.
Either one doesn't sit well.
IMO I'd rather opt for the admin new owner option while we still have a few good players. 
I would be very surprised if the club is sold, it's not the Chinese way to sell up.