WBAUnofficial
Would promotion be a good thing? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Would promotion be a good thing? (/showthread.php?tid=29717)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - TartanRug - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 10:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Agree with the sentiments on here, football wise, the greed league is a horrible prospect, but probably required from a financial perspective.

Personally, not bothered, hate the greed league with a passion so wouldn't mind a reset as it's the only way we will see a transition from giving final paydays to ageing, disinterested has-beens and giving youth a chance.

People talk about doing a "Bolton, Portsmouth, Derby" etc. but they are all doing ok and their fans still have a team to support. Previous to that it was doing a "Sunderland", but that seems to have gone quiet now.
Whatever happens, it is highly unlikely that we will EVER have the funds to compete in the greed league, so what's the point. I'm a football fan not an accountant, so I'd rather see us skint and competitive than "rich" and getting, not just hammered every week, but derided by the likes of Danny fucking Murphy!

If you mean ever finishing near the top of it then that applies to nearly every club. Clubs can compete up to the midtable in the Prem without vast sums of cash, we've done it for several seasons but some got bored of this. I still enjoyed it (well maybe not the Pulis bit) and we had our fair share of beating nearly all the top clubs at some point and it gives us the best possible chance of winning a cup (still unlikely I know) if we've got players at that level. I'd love to see us back at that level again though its a million miles away with this owner. 

I'd be embarrassed to see us go down to the 3rd tier again.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Bob Fossil - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 02:57 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(04-24-2023, 10:02 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Agree with the sentiments on here, football wise, the greed league is a horrible prospect, but probably required from a financial perspective.

Personally, not bothered, hate the greed league with a passion so wouldn't mind a reset as it's the only way we will see a transition from giving final paydays to ageing, disinterested has-beens and giving youth a chance.

People talk about doing a "Bolton, Portsmouth, Derby" etc. but they are all doing ok and their fans still have a team to support. Previous to that it was doing a "Sunderland", but that seems to have gone quiet now.
Whatever happens, it is highly unlikely that we will EVER have the funds to compete in the greed league, so what's the point. I'm a football fan not an accountant, so I'd rather see us skint and competitive than "rich" and getting, not just hammered every week, but derided by the likes of Danny fucking Murphy!

If you mean ever finishing near the top of it then that applies to nearly every club. Clubs can compete up to the midtable in the Prem without vast sums of cash, we've done it for several seasons but some got bored of this. I still enjoyed it (well maybe not the Pulis bit) and we had our fair share of beating nearly all the top clubs at some point and it gives us the best possible chance of winning a cup (still unlikely I know) if we've got players at that level. I'd love to see us back at that level again though its a million miles away with this owner. 

I'd be embarrassed to see us go down to the 3rd tier again.

Each to their own. No embarrassment from me if we went down, wouldn't be my fault!  Smile
The greed league is a corrupt cesspit so, getting beat week in week out in an unfair contest, does nothing for me. Celebrating a midtable finish, when you lose more than you win, is not exciting for more than a season or two. I wouldn't swap any of our promotions for a 16th place in the Prem.
I'd rather be in a league where the competition, is, in the main, genuine and you go into every game with a chance of winning along with a fear of losing. If that's league 2, so be it. If it gets rid of these owners and resets some of our values, then I'll probably quite enjoy it. What's options do we have, FODTW? Never going to happen, I would rather be a Baggie in the Gorilla Glue Sunday League - Southern Section!  Wink

None of that means I don't want us to win the next 6 games though. Promotion is great, it's just the prize that's shit.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Dial M for Mick - 04-24-2023

Are people really saying they prefer finishing mid table in a lower division than a higher one?


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Pragmatist - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 01:02 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-24-2023, 12:17 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: If we knew that Lai would sell to a better owner if we don’t go up, then I’d be all in favour of a rebuild from the Championship so that if and when we might go up again, we are better prepared for it.

Going up does fill me with fear, because the reality is that the bill of the extra money would go on wage increases (already cemented into player contracts), promotion bonuses, agents fees, transfer fees and higher wages of newer signings. Lai wouldn’t see much of it at all, so I think he’ll sell either way as there is no upside for him to remain - unless he somehow bought in a JV partner prepared to inject cash.

Lol!

I’m assuming that Lai would want to spend some of the TV money, otherwise why not sell straight away upon winning promotion if the club was guaranteed to get relegated. 

I see him selling this summer either way.  He’s run out of road.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Cunninghamismagic - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 03:50 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Are people really saying they prefer finishing mid table in a lower division than a higher one?

Seems that way. Bizarre


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Birdman1811 - 04-24-2023

It's the final stage of turning shit, when fans start saying "Well, I prefer us being shit if I'm honest."

We could get promoted and compete well enough to be mid-table up there, at least for a season or two, be better than mid-table in the Champ for sure.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Spandaubaggie - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 03:50 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Are people really saying they prefer finishing mid table in a lower division than a higher one?

Yes. Do you get it? I certainly understand why, but not certain I fully agree.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Duffers - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 03:54 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's the final stage of turning shit, when fans start saying "Well, I prefer us being shit if I'm honest."

We could get promoted and compete well enough to be mid-table up there, at least for a season or two, be better than mid-table in the Champ for sure.

Albion are just following the prevailing trends of 90's nostalgia by going back to the period circa 94-99 when we were a shit Championship club.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Bob Fossil - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 03:50 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Are people really saying they prefer finishing mid table in a lower division than a higher one?

I’m saying I’m a Baggie no matter what league we are in. Every good time we have had has been preceded by disaster so, whatever happens I’ll buckle up and wait for the good times to roll around again.


RE: Would promotion be a good thing? - Cunninghamismagic - 04-24-2023

(04-24-2023, 03:56 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-24-2023, 03:54 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's the final stage of turning shit, when fans start saying "Well, I prefer us being shit if I'm honest."

We could get promoted and compete well enough to be mid-table up there, at least for a season or two, be better than mid-table in the Champ for sure.

Albion are just following the prevailing trends of 90's nostalgia by going back to the period circa 94-99 when we were a shit Championship club.

They will look forward to us getting tanked 5 by Crewe and Grimsby then