WBAUnofficial
Our new manager - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our new manager (/showthread.php?tid=2947)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Our new manager - Derek Hardballs - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

Just checked and the average outlay per club was 8.6m and the average out going player was worth £565,000. Income per club was 13m and expenditure per player was £391,000.


RE: Our new manager - Remi_Moses - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.


RE: Our new manager - albion_pigeon - 03-26-2019

Groundhog day.


RE: Our new manager - Derek Hardballs - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/championship/transfers/wettbewerb/GB2Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Figures I have

Foster wanted to leave, Evans wanted to leave, Nyom wanted to leave, McClean, Chadli (whoever he was) wanted to leave, Rondon wanted to leave but we came to a compromise. The others had very little sell on value. 

Clubs are gambling their future trying to get back up, we are trying to keep ourselves competitive within FFP rules for not just this season but next etc.


RE: Our new manager - Pragmatist - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Where do you get £70m from?

Foster went for around £3m
Evans went for £3m (was a contractual obligation)
Nyom is out on loan and is still our player
Yacob was out of contract
McAuley was out of contract 
McClean went for £6m
Rondon is out on loan and is still our player 
Chadli went for £10m

So we actually sold 4 players, not 8. The actual value of the 4 sold players was £22m. The 2 players out  of contract literally had no value.  

If you’re going to include the two players who are out on loan, then surely you need to also include the 
6 players that we’ve taken on loan? 

Transfer fees are only a limited guide to player values these days. The true value is re wages. Transfer values are distorted by remaining lengths of contract but every players insists on a “going rate” wage


RE: Our new manager - Derek Hardballs - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 08:20 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Where do you get £70m from?

Foster went for around £3m
Evans went for £3m (was a contractual obligation)
Nyom is out on loan and is still our player
Yacob was out of contract
McAuley was out of contract 
McClean went for £6m
Rondon is out on loan and is still our player 
Chadli went for £10m

So we actually sold 4 players, not 8. The actual value of the 4 sold players was £22m. The 2 players out  of contract literally had no value.  

If you’re going to include the two players who are out on loan, then surely you need to also include the 
6 players that we’ve taken on loan? 

Transfer fees are only a limited guide to player values these days. The true value is re wages. Transfer values are distorted by remaining lengths of contract but every players insists on a “going rate” wage

Exactly.


RE: Our new manager - Remi_Moses - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 08:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/championship/transfers/wettbewerb/GB2Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 imillion that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Figures I have

Foster wanted to leave, Evans wanted to leave, Nyom wanted to leave, McClean, Chadli (whoever he was) wanted to leave, Rondon wanted to leave but we came to a compromise. The others had very little sell on value. 

Clubs are gambling their future trying to get back up, we are trying to keep ourselves competitive within FFP rules for not just this season but next etc.

Here we go again, Dek I am not starting a debate on who did or didn't want to leave? 
Competitive with FFP ? are you joking ? We are allowed a £13 Million loss / season as you well know. But with Jenkins and Lai policy our loss is ZERO or NEGATIVE as is well known.  
Dek you continue to throw anything / everything into a debate, for what reason?  
I was responding to what a new manager would be needing to do and how the side has already weakened by leavers who have simply not been replaced. Not the why's or FFP's

(03-26-2019, 08:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:20 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Where do you get £70m from?

Foster went for around £3m
Evans went for £3m (was a contractual obligation)
Nyom is out on loan and is still our player
Yacob was out of contract
McAuley was out of contract 
McClean went for £6m
Rondon is out on loan and is still our player 
Chadli went for £10m

So we actually sold 4 players, not 8. The actual value of the 4 sold players was £22m. The 2 players out  of contract literally had no value.  

If you’re going to include the two players who are out on loan, then surely you need to also include the 
6 players that we’ve taken on loan? 

Transfer fees are only a limited guide to player values these days. The true value is re wages. Transfer values are distorted by remaining lengths of contract but every players insists on a “going rate” wage

Exactly.

The asset value is not what they were sold for, but what it would cost to replace them with equal quality players - yes I did included Nyom and Rondon as I don't believe they will come back - I didn't include any loans who came in as I don't believe for a minute they will stay.


RE: Our new manager - Baggiejacko - 03-26-2019

Does anyone remember the poor Polar Bear at Dudley Zoo that used to swing his head to and fro all day long?


RE: Our new manager - Derek Hardballs - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 08:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/championship/transfers/wettbewerb/GB2Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 06:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The biggest issue with getting any manager in is the size of the rebuild of the squad that's required?
The rough average investment in clubs within the championship is £20 million / season.
Where does that leave us with our current ZERO or NEGATIVE investment policy and a major rebuild already upon us.
Selecting a manager that fits this criteria is tricky to say the least :SS

The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 imillion that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Figures I have

Foster wanted to leave, Evans wanted to leave, Nyom wanted to leave, McClean, Chadli (whoever he was) wanted to leave, Rondon wanted to leave but we came to a compromise. The others had very little sell on value. 

Clubs are gambling their future trying to get back up, we are trying to keep ourselves competitive within FFP rules for not just this season but next etc.

Here we go again, Dek I am not starting a debate on who did or didn't want to leave? 
Competitive with FFP ? are you joking ? We are allowed a £13 Million loss / season as you well know. But with Jenkins and Lai policy our loss is ZERO or NEGATIVE as is well known.  
Dek you continue to throw anything / everything into a debate, for what reason?  
I was responding to what a new manager would be needing to do and how the side has already weakened by leavers who have simply not been replaced. Not the why's or FFP's

(03-26-2019, 08:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:20 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Where do you get £70m from?

Foster went for around £3m
Evans went for £3m (was a contractual obligation)
Nyom is out on loan and is still our player
Yacob was out of contract
McAuley was out of contract 
McClean went for £6m
Rondon is out on loan and is still our player 
Chadli went for £10m

So we actually sold 4 players, not 8. The actual value of the 4 sold players was £22m. The 2 players out  of contract literally had no value.  

If you’re going to include the two players who are out on loan, then surely you need to also include the 
6 players that we’ve taken on loan? 

Transfer fees are only a limited guide to player values these days. The true value is re wages. Transfer values are distorted by remaining lengths of contract but every players insists on a “going rate” wage

Exactly.

The asset value is not what they were sold for, but what it would cost to replace them with equal quality players - yes I did included Nyom and Rondon as I don't believe they will come back - I didn't include any loans who came in as I don't believe for a minute they will stay.

We are in the Championship we aren’t going to spend £70m on players of that quality.   
Those players on loan are still our players and I imagine we are still paying a percentage of their salary
We are laying a percentage of those Prem / top half Championship players wages so you can’t just ignore the loans in or out. 

You’re not been realistic with the reality of the Championship.

(03-26-2019, 08:47 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Does anyone remember the poor Polar Bear at Dudley Zoo that used to swing his head to and fro all day long?

Yes I used to turn up and annoy him!


RE: Our new manager - Baggiejacko - 03-26-2019

(03-26-2019, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:27 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/championship/transfers/wettbewerb/GB2Remi_Moses Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The club has invested by keeping most of the squad together, it has bought two notable players and the best of the loans in the Championship. 

Average investment per season by Championship squads is £20m? Is it? Does that include wages as well?

That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 imillion that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Figures I have

Foster wanted to leave, Evans wanted to leave, Nyom wanted to leave, McClean, Chadli (whoever he was) wanted to leave, Rondon wanted to leave but we came to a compromise. The others had very little sell on value. 

Clubs are gambling their future trying to get back up, we are trying to keep ourselves competitive within FFP rules for not just this season but next etc.

Here we go again, Dek I am not starting a debate on who did or didn't want to leave? 
Competitive with FFP ? are you joking ? We are allowed a £13 Million loss / season as you well know. But with Jenkins and Lai policy our loss is ZERO or NEGATIVE as is well known.  
Dek you continue to throw anything / everything into a debate, for what reason?  
I was responding to what a new manager would be needing to do and how the side has already weakened by leavers who have simply not been replaced. Not the why's or FFP's

(03-26-2019, 08:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 08:20 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 07:50 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: That's not how I see it? with the number who left (Foster/Evans/Nyom/Yacob/McAuley/McClean/Rondon/Chadli), it was Jenkins who said quote "We don't need to sell anyone" - That's 8 players we owned with an asset value of approx £70 million that left and we spent £10 million on replacements. 
And yes £20 million is the average investment / season made by clubs in the championship over and above the clubs income.. As published this week in the FFP figures?  
Please don't start with your leading questions again.

Where do you get £70m from?

Foster went for around £3m
Evans went for £3m (was a contractual obligation)
Nyom is out on loan and is still our player
Yacob was out of contract
McAuley was out of contract 
McClean went for £6m
Rondon is out on loan and is still our player 
Chadli went for £10m

So we actually sold 4 players, not 8. The actual value of the 4 sold players was £22m. The 2 players out  of contract literally had no value.  

If you’re going to include the two players who are out on loan, then surely you need to also include the 
6 players that we’ve taken on loan? 

Transfer fees are only a limited guide to player values these days. The true value is re wages. Transfer values are distorted by remaining lengths of contract but every players insists on a “going rate” wage

Exactly.

The asset value is not what they were sold for, but what it would cost to replace them with equal quality players - yes I did included Nyom and Rondon as I don't believe they will come back - I didn't include any loans who came in as I don't believe for a minute they will stay.

We are in the Championship we aren’t going to spend £70m on players of that quality.   
Those players on loan are still our players and I imagine we are still paying a percentage of their salary
We are laying a percentage of those Prem / top half Championship players wages so you can’t just ignore the loans in or out. 

You’re not been realistic with the reality of the Championship.

(03-26-2019, 08:47 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Does anyone remember the poor Polar Bear at Dudley Zoo that used to swing his head to and fro all day long?

Yes I used to turn up and annoy him!

Some things never change  Big Grin