![]() |
|
HS2 - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: HS2 (/showthread.php?tid=28601) |
RE: HS2 - Borin' Baggie - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 06:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I take BurleyBaggie's point -particularly about capacity- but still have hefty misgivings over HS2. Firstly, the much vaunted "slashed" journey time shaves off a mere 10 minutes over the current speed, but it does drop you off 10 minutes from Brum City Centre. Next, the cost and under use of HS1 doesnt appear to have been considered before commiting to this huge spend up. Also, By hurtling between London, Brum and Manchester, it is catering for less people, surely a train stopping at all stations between would be more inclusive. Then again, inclusivity is hardly a government concern. The cynical side of me thinks it is all about getting people to London. I really think we need more East to West lines and much less focus on London and the SE. Birmingham-Central London drops from 1 hour 24 minutes to 48 minutes, that's more than 10 minutes. Also the tram is supposed to operate to link Curzon Street to Corporation Street if you don't want to walk 10 minutes. As grand as it would be to expand New Street 7 more underground platforms would cost billions more than using Curzon Street as well as add delays. As for the catering for more people issue, the more intercity routes that can be moved onto HS2 the more capacity is freed up at existing stations e.g. one fewer WCML intercity service per hour into New Street enables two additional hourly cross city line services up to 6 trains per hour, two additional trains per hour between Birmingham and Leicester, an additional train per hour from Birmingham to Hereford and an additional train per hour from Birmingham to Hereford. On top of that, more freight services can go through Coventry station going between Southampton and Immingham. There was also supposed to be the addressing the problem between Sheffield-Leeds and East Mids-Birmingham services but that's been scaled back by a lack of foresight in cutting the Eastern Leg. RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 06:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-29-2023, 06:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I take BurleyBaggie's point -particularly about capacity- but still have hefty misgivings over HS2. Firstly, the much vaunted "slashed" journey time shaves off a mere 10 minutes over the current speed, but it does drop you off 10 minutes from Brum City Centre. Next, the cost and under use of HS1 doesnt appear to have been considered before commiting to this huge spend up. Also, By hurtling between London, Brum and Manchester, it is catering for less people, surely a train stopping at all stations between would be more inclusive. Then again, inclusivity is hardly a government concern. The cynical side of me thinks it is all about getting people to London. I really think we need more East to West lines and much less focus on London and the SE. Absolutely this. It’s what I’ve been saying. The government has been an absolute shambles of actually selling HS2 for what it is: an enabler for better local and more frequent services. It’s not £98bn for a High Speed line it’s an investment into the future of the railways nationally. They’ve sunk the investment case though by cancelling the line to leeds. The irony is, if you don’t get the Y shaped line, some point in the future there will have to be tonnes more money ploughed in to increase capacity. RE: HS2 - Tom Joad - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 06:58 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:OK, I stand corrected and that makes sense, I really hope it's a success. Although calling it High Speed 2 is probably what misled me!(01-29-2023, 06:55 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(01-29-2023, 06:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I take BurleyBaggie's point -particularly about capacity- but still have hefty misgivings over HS2. Firstly, the much vaunted "slashed" journey time shaves off a mere 10 minutes over the current speed, but it does drop you off 10 minutes from Brum City Centre. Next, the cost and under use of HS1 doesnt appear to have been considered before commiting to this huge spend up. Also, By hurtling between London, Brum and Manchester, it is catering for less people, surely a train stopping at all stations between would be more inclusive. Then again, inclusivity is hardly a government concern. The cynical side of me thinks it is all about getting people to London. I really think we need more East to West lines and much less focus on London and the SE. RE: HS2 - ColliersWoodBaggie - 01-29-2023 As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023 They’ve fecked the Yorkshire towns though which is worse (I live 15 miles north of leeds) so of have a bias. The cancelling of HS2 Leeds is bad for West and South Yorkshire, as it kills proper regional rail investment. I’m lucky as I’ve a lovely regular electric line to leeds and can jump on an Azuma to London for work and be door to door in 3hrs 15. Journey times I don’t give a toss for so much - though 2hrs in a cramped cross country to Birmingham is rubbish - when HS2 promised nearer an hour. Most of this part of the country is served by piece meal infrastructure and shocking rolling stock (the latter is improving) so if there’s any issue on the line it is chaos across the board. The lack of capacity or alternative routing just creates passenger misery. RE: HS2 - Derek Hardballs - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 07:08 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. I wouldn’t be able to do my job, and my family wouldn’t be able to go anywhere without private transport. No amount of ‘progress’ in rail will solve this. If anything the changes that some want to make will make this even harder. A complete waste of money for millions of people in the country. RE: HS2 - ColliersWoodBaggie - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 07:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-29-2023, 07:08 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. Modal shift is needed, or we are screwed. I do see that people need Private Cars, but it isn't sustainable long term. RE: HS2 - BurleyBaggie - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 07:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-29-2023, 07:08 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. Which is absolutely fair we need a mixed economy of transportation. That said, there is still so much we can take off the roads but the alternative has to better…frankly because of everything else above for a lot of people the car works and feels better. RE: HS2 - Fulham Fallout - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 07:45 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:(01-29-2023, 07:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-29-2023, 07:08 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. Do families really need 2 cars? Most have. Why? Because there’s one for the husband and one for the wife as that’s how they’ve always lived. People need to consider their car needs now, with more home working. Then how many kids get driven 1 mile or less to school and back each day? Adding to road congestion and an obese lazy nation. Walk kids to school FFS sake. I know one bloke who drives his kids to their sixth form and back every day and they are aged 16-18. It’s less than 2 miles each way. That’s 30 mins max each way. If it’s pissing down fair enough, but every day regardless he drives them there and back. RE: HS2 - Borin' Baggie - 01-29-2023 (01-29-2023, 07:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(01-29-2023, 07:08 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: As usual the obsession with private motor vehicles has done for this. Shambolic selling of a scheme which frees up the WCML for local /regional passenger traffic as well as freight traffic. The fewer people who don't need to drive on the road the better it is for people who need to drive. Especially in dense metropolitan areas. That's not even getting into rail freight. |