WBAUnofficial
The Next Bailout - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The Next Bailout (/showthread.php?tid=27495)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-08-2022

Are you taking the piss here? I'm willing to bet that mortgages weren't 9 times the median salary when you took out your first one.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-08-2022

(11-08-2022, 02:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Are you taking the piss here? I'm willing to bet that mortgages weren't 9 times the median salary when you took out your first one.

My first house was 6 times the then median salary at an interest rate of of 6.25%

You can still find plenty of houses in the same town for 6 times the current median salary albeit not so big.

And your preferred option of suppressed interest rates and loose lending criteria is largely to blame for the increase in house prices. Make up your mind. The market needs to find equilibrium.


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-08-2022

6 times is 50% less than 9 times. 6 times vs 9 times doesn't sound that big a difference but it actually is.

My "preferred option" is not to suppress interest rates. I have genuinely no idea where you've got that from, especially when I thought I made it clear that interest rates should have risen gradually to 6% by now from 2015 onwards. My preferred option is manage inevitable fallout of the inevitable interest rate rises over the next 3 to 6 months to avoid worsening the demographic crisis we are on the path to and, in-turn, not screw up productivity in turn causing yet another lost decade in this country - my country. You can't handwave away that issue, you need to mitigate against the inevitable to limit the impact where it will hit productivity the most.

As for what I "blame" for house price rises, I think I'll blame other factors as the turning point with respect to the contributing most in the trend in unaffordability can be pinpointed to January 1987 and I don't recall interest rates being suppressed when I was a kid by virtue of my savings actually growing instead of losing value as they are now.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-08-2022

Did you miss the bit where I said you could still buy a house in the same town for 6 times today's median salary?

There's no need to invent a crisis when there are actual ones to deal with.


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-08-2022

No, I ignored it because it's cherry-picked nonsense by virtue of it being a statistical outlier and statistical outliers are only ever brought up to distract from the actual point because the person bringing them up has no answers to the point being addressed.

We've just had a lost decade, we have a demographic crisis (20% of the population is over 65 which is the highest it's ever been and it's growing), we're facing a period of stagflation - quite frankly I do not think any sensible government should be looking at worsening the productivity crisis because markets don't tend to correct themselves without repercussions and the risks likely need to be balanced by distributing it across lenders (who were bailed out in 2008) and people with mortgages where necessary.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-08-2022

I don't agree with your premise nor your prescription.

It literally screams entitlement and will only serve to support house prices and the overleveraged (again).


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-08-2022

Entitlement to what? I don't have a mortgage let alone a housing asset so I wouldn't be entitled to it. Low interest rates have screwed people like me as we have little to no assets and are putting money away in savings accounts that is losing value in nominal terms.

All I'm pointing out is that market corrections do not occur in a vacuum and what you want to happen will impact productivity. I note you've failed to address how it won't affect productivity aside from handwaving the problem away. Please, explain to me how contributing to an already developing demographic crisis won't affect productivity?

As for house prices, the issue is clearly predominantly driven by a supply problem both in the private sector and in the social housing sector. Brexit impacting imports of materials by increasing red tape on top of restricting free movement of labour to address severe labour supply issues is a bigger problem than transferring some risk of repayment to lenders. The trend on that goes back to the 80s, it covers periods of high interest rates. I fail to understand why you think that suppressed interest rates are the biggest factor in house price rises, in fact they've been quite flat in trend in nominal terms since 2009.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-09-2022

(11-08-2022, 04:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Entitlement to what? I don't have a mortgage let alone a housing asset so I wouldn't be entitled to it. Low interest rates have screwed people like me as we have little to no assets and are putting money away in savings accounts that is losing value in nominal terms.

All I'm pointing out is that market corrections do not occur in a vacuum and what you want to happen will impact productivity. I note you've failed to address how it won't affect productivity aside from handwaving the problem away. Please, explain to me how contributing to an already developing demographic crisis won't affect productivity?

As for house prices, the issue is clearly predominantly driven by a supply problem both in the private sector and in the social housing sector. Brexit impacting imports of materials by increasing red tape on top of restricting free movement of labour to address severe labour supply issues is a bigger problem than transferring some risk of repayment to lenders. The trend on that goes back to the 80s, it covers periods of high interest rates. I fail to understand why you think that suppressed interest rates are the biggest factor in house price rises, in fact they've been quite flat in trend in nominal terms since 2009.

Higher interest rates will improve the productivity by sending zombie companies into oblivion and finally enabling the creative destruction that should have commenced over a decade ago. If you genuinely cared about productivity you would never have agreed with the state nationalising corporate debt in 2008 nor unfettered FoM. The greatest brakes on productivity are low interest rates, suppressed wages and ample migrant labour.

Each of these dynamics are now reversing.

As for your latter point, yes you fail to understand. If you provide, literally, free money to invest in real assets then the price will only go one way. Lack of supply comes a very poor second in market dynamics when you inflate demand to such a huge extent.


RE: The Next Bailout - Borin' Baggie - 11-09-2022

Please, address the point. "Zombie companies "has literally nothing to do with what's been proposed. Why are you talking about that? Nobody is talking about preserving those debts and liabilities. Nobody is talking about stalling interest rate rises, it's about mitigating the effects of inevitable rises. You know, what I would have thought would have been obvious after the Whigs fucked up the response to dealing with the Irish famine.

As for FoM, that's the only thing that's propped up UK productivity due to a dearth in private and public sector investment into skills and technology. Also, as shown by several EU countries you can have freedom of movement for labour and increase your productivity, why do you think Germany has soared past us over the last 17 years? Or the Netherlands? Or Sweden? Or Switzerland? Or Denmark? Or Norway? Pitiful excuse. I would have thought the reality of skilled people being deterred from taking up jobs after Brexit by the new stupid visa fees that it would be patently obvious.

And it isn't "free money". The whole point of it is that the risk is being transferred from individuals to banks that were bailed out in 2008. There's no net change in supply nor demand, no extra borrowing is levied and no taxes outside of those select banks change. What are you on about?

It's like you've not even read what you were arguing against.


RE: The Next Bailout - Protheroe - 11-09-2022

(11-09-2022, 10:53 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Please, address the point. "Zombie companies "has literally nothing to do with what's been proposed. Why are you talking about that? Nobody is talking about preserving those debts and liabilities. Nobody is talking about stalling interest rate rises, it's about mitigating the effects of inevitable rises. You know, what I would have thought would have been obvious after the Whigs fucked up the response to dealing with the Irish famine.

As for FoM, that's the only thing that's propped up UK productivity due to a dearth in private and public sector investment into skills and technology. Also, as shown by several EU countries you can have freedom of movement for labour and increase your productivity, why do you think Germany has soared past us over the last 17 years? Or the Netherlands? Or Sweden? Or Switzerland? Or Denmark? Or Norway? Pitiful excuse. I would have thought the reality of skilled people being deterred from taking up jobs after Brexit by the new stupid visa fees that it would be patently obvious.

And it isn't "free money". The whole point of it is that the risk is being transferred from individuals to banks that were bailed out in 2008. There's no net change in supply nor demand, no extra borrowing is levied and no taxes outside of those select banks change. What are you on about?

It's like you've not even read what you were arguing against.

I think Germany has soared past us due to the Euro massively subsidising its exports and it's malign links with Russia (cheap energy) and China (Machine Tools). Nothing else. 

It's now well and truly in the shit as it's major manufacturing companies are moving out permanently, some - like Linde are delisting from the Dax which makes Frankfurt's wish to replace London well and truly laughable and outside a few Berlin basements it doesn't have a technology sector to speak of.

If you don't believe cheap labour supplied to barely solvent leveraged companies since 2008 has had a far more depressing effect on our productivity than Brexit ever will then I'm afraid I have nothing more to say to you on the subject. 

What you are suggesting undermines the principle of moral hazard, again. It's you who is suggesting we repeat the bizarre and destructive behaviour of the last 14 years, because at the end of the day WE pay for lower tax receipts from banks if they're subsidising the overleveraged. If you have made your bed, you lie in it. Your problems are not your lenders, nor the states, nor taxpayers. Grow a backbone FFS.