WBAUnofficial
CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) (/showthread.php?tid=27361)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Bob Fossil - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 10:05 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 09:34 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 08:36 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 08:17 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Controversial view but I'm really not onboard with the Phillips hate. There have been plenty worse culprits in our demise over the past couple of seasons.

He's getting more and more injury prone as he gets older and like Furlong he's never in a million years a wingback, but he's far from awful.

This. I find the hate for him absolutely laughable.

Those expecting CC to make too many changes are also out their head... how many chnages can he actually make?! How about we just... wait and see? Yeah? Cool.

Who hates him? Does anyone even know him?

Not rating him as a footballer is not hate.

I hate paedophiles and people who hurt animals. I don't hate Matt Phillips. Do I think he's shit? Yes. There's a difference.

That's it, stick to a semantical argument instead of addressing the point at hand.
What's the point at hand?


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Babel - 10-27-2022

I explect CC to be pragmatic for the first couple of games in terms of selections. I hope we can squeeze a few points out that way. I also expect the team to be better drilled as to the competition's strengths and weaknesses. I hope that CC demonstrates in-game awareness in terms of tactical changes when needed.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Lurker#3 - 10-27-2022

I know it goes against the rhetoric with Matty Phillips. But even in the last 2 years which have been a shit show and he been played in various positions, under different managers, in different systems, normally from the bench... He has a 1 in 3 in terms of goal contributions when averaged/90mins.

Matty is not the issue unfortunately as trendy as it may be to think so.

Comparison (90mins/GC):

Callum Robinson - 1.71
Grant - 1.8
Swift - 2.48
Wallace - 2.6
Phillips - 3.17
Grady - 4.33
*These stats are only based on minutes played for us during our shit champo years!

Having that sort of contribution over a season from deeper positions would probably yield 10 GC from Matty (Averaging 60ish minutes per game), which shouldn't be sniffed at.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Squid - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 11:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I know it goes against the rhetoric with Matty Phillips. But even in the last 2 years which have been a shit show and he been played in various positions, under different managers, in different systems, normally from the bench... He has a 1 in 3 in terms of goal contributions when averaged/90mins.

Matty is not the issue unfortunately as trendy as it may be to think so.

Comparison (90mins/GC):

Callum Robinson - 1.71
Grant - 1.8
Swift - 2.48
Wallace - 2.6
Phillips - 3.17
Grady - 4.33
*These stats are only based on minutes played for us during our shit champo years!

Having that sort of contribution over a season from deeper positions would probably yield 10 GC from Matty, which shouldn't be sniffed at.

When averaged 90 minutes is key here. He's always injured and very rarely plays at his best.

Phillips never should have been given a contract extension and the fact that he is still around the first team on one of the biggest player contracts is a massive symbol of the atrocious decision making and the decline to the club it has caused.

No hate. Just facts.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Hopalong - 10-27-2022

The only three players who merit a start Saturday based on performances this season are Wallace, TGH and Asante.   It's then 8 from the rest of the wastrels.  Or 8 cones,  probably doesn't make much difference.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Stillclem4england - 10-27-2022

For me we need a solid defence for a low block and to keep things tight:

Palmer

Furlong (sadly) Kelly O'Shea Pieters

Okay or LIvermore

Molumby (or Swift if he gets fit) TGH

Wallace BTA Diangana

Practise set pieces every day and let's try and nick a winner in a Pulis stylee.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - MassDebater - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 11:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I know it goes against the rhetoric with Matty Phillips. But even in the last 2 years which have been a shit show and he been played in various positions, under different managers, in different systems, normally from the bench... He has a 1 in 3 in terms of goal contributions when averaged/90mins.

Matty is not the issue unfortunately as trendy as it may be to think so.

Comparison (90mins/GC):

Callum Robinson - 1.71
Grant - 1.8
Swift - 2.48
Wallace - 2.6
Phillips - 3.17
Grady - 4.33
*These stats are only based on minutes played for us during our shit champo years!

Having that sort of contribution over a season from deeper positions would probably yield 10 GC from Matty (Averaging 60ish minutes per game), which shouldn't be sniffed at.

How does grant score so low on that list? He's the only fecker who scores for us! or don't goals count towards goal contributions?


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Birdman1811 - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 12:03 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: For me we need a solid defence for a low block and to keep things tight:

Palmer

Furlong (sadly) Kelly O'Shea Pieters

Okay or LIvermore

Molumby (or Swift if he gets fit) TGH

Wallace BTA Diangana

Practise set pieces every day and let's try and nick a winner in a Pulis stylee.

Sad thing, even if we win 4 games in a row, he'll get booed by some fans playing like that.


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - AnelkasBeard - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 12:39 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 11:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I know it goes against the rhetoric with Matty Phillips. But even in the last 2 years which have been a shit show and he been played in various positions, under different managers, in different systems, normally from the bench... He has a 1 in 3 in terms of goal contributions when averaged/90mins.

Matty is not the issue unfortunately as trendy as it may be to think so.

Comparison (90mins/GC):

Callum Robinson - 1.71
Grant - 1.8
Swift - 2.48
Wallace - 2.6
Phillips - 3.17
Grady - 4.33
*These stats are only based on minutes played for us during our shit champo years!

Having that sort of contribution over a season from deeper positions would probably yield 10 GC from Matty (Averaging 60ish minutes per game), which shouldn't be sniffed at.

How does grant score so low on that list? He's the only fecker who scores for us! or don't goals count towards goal contributions?

I think it's the other wya round. Low is good.

1 goal contribution for every 1.71 90 minutes (in Robbo's case).


RE: CC's first XI (edited my full guess) - Bob Fossil - 10-27-2022

(10-27-2022, 01:01 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 12:39 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-27-2022, 11:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I know it goes against the rhetoric with Matty Phillips. But even in the last 2 years which have been a shit show and he been played in various positions, under different managers, in different systems, normally from the bench... He has a 1 in 3 in terms of goal contributions when averaged/90mins.

Matty is not the issue unfortunately as trendy as it may be to think so.

Comparison (90mins/GC):

Callum Robinson - 1.71
Grant - 1.8
Swift - 2.48
Wallace - 2.6
Phillips  - 3.17
Grady - 4.33
*These stats are only based on minutes played for us during our shit champo years!

Having that sort of contribution over a season from deeper positions would probably yield 10 GC from Matty (Averaging 60ish minutes per game), which shouldn't be sniffed at.

How does grant score so low on that list? He's the only fecker who scores for us! or don't goals count towards goal contributions?

I think it's the other wya round. Low is good.

1 goal contribution for every 1.71 90 minutes (in Robbo's case).
Exactly, so pretty much proves what most of us think and that's that Phillips is not very good. As a winger a GC every 3.17 games is pretty poor, with Wallace showing significantly better, because, he is significantly better.

It also shows what a luxury Grady is.

The upshot, however, is that everyone else on that list is at an age where they still have potential to improve, whereby Phillips will, in all likelyhood, deteriorate.
No hatred, just recognising that, if we are looking forward, we need to move on from these older, deteriorating players.