WBAUnofficial
So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: So who do we want to replace Bruce? (/showthread.php?tid=26866)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Remi_Moses - 10-01-2022

(10-01-2022, 10:49 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: So the general opinion is,  the only reason we are keeping Bruce is that we can't afford to sack him? That doesn't make sense in any way. 
 Of the candidates mentioned;
 Robins probably wouldn't come, we have a reputation for sacking managers and financially he  is almost certainly more secure at Cov.  
  Edwards,  we barely gave Ismael half a season, a dingle would have no chance. 
  Dyche, not a fan of his style and not sure he won't get better offers but we should be making the call, best CV out there currently.   
Critchley, I'd like this one but simply can't see it happening. 
 Clarke, no chance, why would he?
 Big Dave has now asked Jimmy Shan to assist him at Wednesday, currently 3rd in L1.

I would seriously be asking if Beale would step in temporarily and try to get SGM to work helping him. I've scoffed at the idea of a Megson return but we are now exactly where we were when he first came. Yes, the idea was ridiculous when folks previously mentioned it but an out of touch Megson is probably more clued up than Bruce has ever been.

Megson as a DOF would be a smart move. He could oversee a complete restructure.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - BeijingBaggie - 10-02-2022

I'm never convinced that X as a DOF would be what we need. We usually think an old boss who is well thought of would slot into that position but usually they have never done it before. To be honest I have little idea what the job description of DOF at WBA entails. Do we just think it would be implementing a play style that goes beyond one manager (similar to Swansea a decade ago?) or would they be responsible for sourcing players like dashworth was? He was in a role that went through a number of managers with different playing styles.

 Also if I was up for head coach how appealing would it be for me to know I've got a 70/80year old club legend breathing down my neck and offering his "advice". The second I don't take it I'm on the shit list and if I do then he's the one calling all the shots.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Hopalong - 10-02-2022

(10-01-2022, 11:28 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-01-2022, 10:49 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: So the general opinion is,  the only reason we are keeping Bruce is that we can't afford to sack him? That doesn't make sense in any way. 
 Of the candidates mentioned;
 Robins probably wouldn't come, we have a reputation for sacking managers and financially he  is almost certainly more secure at Cov.  
  Edwards,  we barely gave Ismael half a season, a dingle would have no chance. 
  Dyche, not a fan of his style and not sure he won't get better offers but we should be making the call, best CV out there currently.   
Critchley, I'd like this one but simply can't see it happening. 
 Clarke, no chance, why would he?
 Big Dave has now asked Jimmy Shan to assist him at Wednesday, currently 3rd in L1.

I would seriously be asking if Beale would step in temporarily and try to get SGM to work helping him. I've scoffed at the idea of a Megson return but we are now exactly where we were when he first came. Yes, the idea was ridiculous when folks previously mentioned it but an out of touch Megson is probably more clued up than Bruce has ever been.

Megson as a DOF would be a smart move. He could oversee a complete restructure.

Megson would be a disaster.   He simply can't get on with anyone and we lost our best chance of really building something for the future when he forced Paul Thompson out.  

Maybe Roy until we find a long-term DoF (or whatever Gourmet calls the role).  

I would give Enzo Maresca - currently Asst Manager at Manchester City - the opportunity to build a new young exciting team.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Tom Joad - 10-02-2022

Hopalong Wrote:
Remi_Moses Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:So the general opinion is,  the only reason we are keeping Bruce is that we can't afford to sack him? That doesn't make sense in any way. 
 Of the candidates mentioned;
 Robins probably wouldn't come, we have a reputation for sacking managers and financially he  is almost certainly more secure at Cov.  
  Edwards,  we barely gave Ismael half a season, a dingle would have no chance. 
  Dyche, not a fan of his style and not sure he won't get better offers but we should be making the call, best CV out there currently.   
Critchley, I'd like this one but simply can't see it happening. 
 Clarke, no chance, why would he?
 Big Dave has now asked Jimmy Shan to assist him at Wednesday, currently 3rd in L1.

I would seriously be asking if Beale would step in temporarily and try to get SGM to work helping him. I've scoffed at the idea of a Megson return but we are now exactly where we were when he first came. Yes, the idea was ridiculous when folks previously mentioned it but an out of touch Megson is probably more clued up than Bruce has ever been.

Megson as a DOF would be a smart move. He could oversee a complete restructure.

Megson would be a disaster.   He simply can't get on with anyone and we lost our best chance of really building something for the future when he forced Paul Thompson out.  

Maybe Roy until we find a long-term DoF (or whatever Gourmet calls the role).  

I would give Enzo Maresca - currently Asst Manager at Manchester City - the opportunity to build a new young exciting team.
No, the disaster is happening. We need a short term strategy to stop conceding goals and get this team fit  or we are down.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - baggie_ray - 10-02-2022

(10-02-2022, 12:08 AM)BeijingBaggie Wrote: I'm never convinced that X as a DOF would be what we need. We usually think an old boss who is well thought of would slot into that position but usually they have never done it before. To be honest I have little idea what the job description of DOF at WBA entails. Do we just think it would be implementing a play style that goes beyond one manager (similar to Swansea a decade ago?) or would they be responsible for sourcing players like dashworth was? He was in a role that went through a number of managers with different playing styles.

 Also if I was up for head coach how appealing would it be for me to know I've got a 70/80year old club legend breathing down my neck and offering his "advice". The second I don't take it I'm on the shit list and if I do then he's the one calling all the shots.

Absolutely.

Ashworth took on the DOF role with no defined description of what it entailed. For us, he created the role, which was basically watching football matches around the world non-stop on the telly. If he, or his team, thought a player played well in any of those games, he'd watch them again.

A bloke in India with a betamax could do that same job.

The only plus point for Megson taking that job is he knows a decent player when he sees one. Not always a given with some people.

Also Megson, when manager, railed against someone "selecting" his players for him, which is why he fell out with Thompson. I couldn't see him imposing that philosophy on another manager, or "head coach".


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Calgary_Baggie - 10-02-2022

The New Manager interview process is very binary. 

When we interview any prospective candidates are we asking them:

Will you keep us up?

Will you take us up?

Given that automatic has now gone - we were never going to trouble the top two anyway - and the playoffs are like the bagpiper at the Queen's funeral (disappearing into the distance) - the question probably is more the latter; which pretty much strikes a number of candidates from the list.

That's if Bruce goes, that is.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - aj21 - 10-02-2022

Anyone that hasn’t been in the game 30 years and is after their last pay check…aka Pardew, Big Sam, Pulis and Bruce.

The season is already done, just get someone intelligent in and give them some time. Someone like Val but doesn’t play shite football like Val


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Psalm23 - 10-02-2022

TBF, Barney McGrew, Cuthbert, Dibble, & Grubb couldn't do any worse than Bruce, Bruce, Clemence, & Agnew.    Rolleyes


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Pragmatist - 10-02-2022

There are lots of candidates immediately available - all with very differing backgrounds. Do we want to build something over 2-3 years or do we want a Red Adair to keep us up?

Liam Rosenoir
Michael Carrick
Scott Parker
Rob Edwards
Neil Warnock
Michael O’Neill
Mark Warburton
Sean Dyche
Roy Hodgson
David Wagner
Corberan

What do we want? What do we need?

Or are we willing/able to pay compensation to bring in somebody already in a job?

Enzo Maresca
Steve Clarke
Critchley
Mark Robins

Steve Cooper could well become available very soon.

One thing is clear - once Bruce goes we are very close to equalling Watford’s 16 managers in 10 years. This simply cannot go on. The whole club needs a re-set and that won’t happen under Lai. Short-termism is probably now unavoidable. What a mess.

But let’s be frank. This is a very decent but under-performing squad. We clearly have some squad deficiencies but any decent coach will get a much better tune out of this squad than we are getting right now.


RE: So who do we want to replace Bruce? - Woodman scoreboard - 10-02-2022

I would go for critchley personally or the Ipswich manager they play some decent stuff