RE: England v South Africa - rsbaggy2 - 09-12-2022
(09-12-2022, 07:41 AM)Fido Wrote: (09-12-2022, 06:50 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-11-2022, 10:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.
5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.
Here she goes again
I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?
The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it?
Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?
Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test
Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?
Cuzer First of all show a little respect. If you know how.
Seems no matter what i post you will reply with dergatory tones. I think I know why.
The first thing a captain does is try not to lose the series ... clearly Saffers batting was awful, the bowling was good on both sides and England will not waiver from Bazball. But if you can call that test cricket then it's differentt to how I see it. It's a matter of opinion so no need to be rude and condescending ... but that is your default setting it seems .
Even the commentators were critical of the approach tobatting. But of course you know better ...in all matters you are the font of all knowledge.
As for if India doing the same, I would be delighted they won but as an earlier post intimated you would worry how long this approach can be maintained when factors do not fall in your favour.
I think that's the difference though, RS. Stokes and McCullum are trying their best to find a way to win games on the front foot as opposed to blocking and eventually getting out and losing anyway. You're right, we'll have to see how this pans out on other climates but I would prefer we go out to win than not to lose otherwise, what's the point? To appease certain folk ... well done to England for winning the series (soon) from an awful first test.
My post was aimed at both sides but moreso to the Saffers. Their sides batting was weak and given the life granted to them by the bowling the approach to the 2nd innings was awful. Maybe they are just a poor batting side. But the approach WORLDWIDE to batting in tests has changed, as I said in my first post on this thread. Some have seen that as an attack on England but if you have an agenda you can see things any way you wish.
I do hope tests can become the battle of wills and minds as well as talent that they should be (IMO) and not the 2 day 3 day events they appear to be evolving into.
RE: England v South Africa - Fido - 09-12-2022
(09-12-2022, 08:04 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-12-2022, 07:41 AM)Fido Wrote: (09-12-2022, 06:50 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-11-2022, 10:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (09-11-2022, 06:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: A mockery of test cricket. I appreciate that conditions were favourable to bowlers, especially yesterday but the pathetic batting of the first 3 innings would have curdled Boycott's blood. Whilst not advocating his approach it seems worldwide test batting has succumbed to the saturation of limited over cricket.
5 day tests are a rarity and the art of test cricket is gradually wilting. A 4 innings test virtually done and dusted in 2 days! Farcical. Cricket as a whole is doing nothing to stop the erosion of the ultimate form of the sport by allowing more and more of the short form.
Here she goes again
I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?
The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it?
Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?
Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test
Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?
Cuzer First of all show a little respect. If you know how.
Seems no matter what i post you will reply with dergatory tones. I think I know why.
The first thing a captain does is try not to lose the series ... clearly Saffers batting was awful, the bowling was good on both sides and England will not waiver from Bazball. But if you can call that test cricket then it's differentt to how I see it. It's a matter of opinion so no need to be rude and condescending ... but that is your default setting it seems .
Even the commentators were critical of the approach tobatting. But of course you know better ...in all matters you are the font of all knowledge.
As for if India doing the same, I would be delighted they won but as an earlier post intimated you would worry how long this approach can be maintained when factors do not fall in your favour.
I think that's the difference though, RS. Stokes and McCullum are trying their best to find a way to win games on the front foot as opposed to blocking and eventually getting out and losing anyway. You're right, we'll have to see how this pans out on other climates but I would prefer we go out to win than not to lose otherwise, what's the point? To appease certain folk ... well done to England for winning the series (soon) from an awful first test.
My post was aimed at both sides but moreso to the Saffers. Their sides batting was weak and given the life granted to them by the bowling the approach to the 2nd innings was awful. Maybe they are just a poor batting side. But the approach WORLDWIDE to batting in tests has changed, as I said in my first post on this thread. Some have seen that as an attack on England but if you have an agenda you can see things any way you wish.
I do hope tests can become the battle of wills and minds as well as talent that they should be (IMO) and not the 2 day 3 day events they appear to be evolving into.
I didn't see it as any kind of attack, RS (I'm not Cuzer ). There have been many tests where we've set our stall out to force a draw and have failed abysmally and lost. Ted's right as well; playing what's in front of you doesn't necessarily mean wind-milling at every ball either but instead of thinking we won't get 300 in a fourth innings in a day so we'll block it out (which 9 times out of ten never works) so we may as well have a go at it, that's an approach I'm happier with. When it comes to it 5 days is the maximum time allowed to win a game; if you can do it in 3 then why not?
As for the SA batting it was weak but it did look a nightmare to be playing against yesterday, the way it was bobbing and weaving AOTS shops.
RE: England v South Africa - rsbaggy2 - 09-12-2022
(09-12-2022, 09:43 AM)Fido Wrote: (09-12-2022, 08:04 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-12-2022, 07:41 AM)Fido Wrote: (09-12-2022, 06:50 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (09-11-2022, 10:59 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Here she goes again
I’m sure If India had pulled this off you would be waxing lyrical?
The series is 1-1 and you’ve got 3 days to try and win a test match and the series, how the hell are you meant to approach it?
Needs must, if you’re 2-1 down in extra time you don’t keep playing around the back four do you FFS?
Massive credit to the team for winning the series, especially after being hammered in the first test
Im no real fan of ODI, 20/20, IPL or The Hundred, test cricket all day long for me but if you have to get a result in 3 days this is a massive mission accomplished in my book and as hard as it always is for you a bit of credit where credits due eh?
Cuzer First of all show a little respect. If you know how.
Seems no matter what i post you will reply with dergatory tones. I think I know why.
The first thing a captain does is try not to lose the series ... clearly Saffers batting was awful, the bowling was good on both sides and England will not waiver from Bazball. But if you can call that test cricket then it's differentt to how I see it. It's a matter of opinion so no need to be rude and condescending ... but that is your default setting it seems .
Even the commentators were critical of the approach tobatting. But of course you know better ...in all matters you are the font of all knowledge.
As for if India doing the same, I would be delighted they won but as an earlier post intimated you would worry how long this approach can be maintained when factors do not fall in your favour.
I think that's the difference though, RS. Stokes and McCullum are trying their best to find a way to win games on the front foot as opposed to blocking and eventually getting out and losing anyway. You're right, we'll have to see how this pans out on other climates but I would prefer we go out to win than not to lose otherwise, what's the point? To appease certain folk ... well done to England for winning the series (soon) from an awful first test.
My post was aimed at both sides but moreso to the Saffers. Their sides batting was weak and given the life granted to them by the bowling the approach to the 2nd innings was awful. Maybe they are just a poor batting side. But the approach WORLDWIDE to batting in tests has changed, as I said in my first post on this thread. Some have seen that as an attack on England but if you have an agenda you can see things any way you wish.
I do hope tests can become the battle of wills and minds as well as talent that they should be (IMO) and not the 2 day 3 day events they appear to be evolving into.
I didn't see it as any kind of attack, RS (I'm not Cuzer ). There have been many tests where we've set our stall out to force a draw and have failed abysmally and lost. Ted's right as well; playing what's in front of you doesn't necessarily mean wind-milling at every ball either but instead of thinking we won't get 300 in a fourth innings in a day so we'll block it out (which 9 times out of ten never works) so we may as well have a go at it, that's an approach I'm happier with. When it comes to it 5 days is the maximum time allowed to win a game; if you can do it in 3 then why not?
As for the SA batting it was weak but it did look a nightmare to be playing against yesterday, the way it was bobbing and weaving AOTS shops.
|