RE: Erik Pieters - Lurker#3 - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 03:35 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: So when you think about it, not only are we not very good at signing players, we’re also not very good at developing youth either (and that’s on top of being not very good at renewing contracts). Good times!
arf...
RE: c - Fulham Fallout - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 09:26 AM)Peachy Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:41 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:29 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If he's that good then he's probably a bit over-qualified to be a bit part player for us? It's Townsend's shirt to lose, Bruce shows no sign of dropping him and if we need a left back to cover 5-10 games this season then we have Ashworth and Reach. At which point do these youngsters become part of the squad, small wonder we lose so many. Ashworth has shown nothing in his appearances so far to suggest he wouldn't be able to step up if needed.
Other than as a last resort, Bruce doesn't seem to want to give young players a chance in any circumstances.
That's my biggest criticism of Bruce up until now. It's a bit like Pulis was, and it means we'll never know if they're good enough, and you get stuck in the cycle of bringing in experienced players on their last pay cheque.
It takes a brave forward thinking Manager to give Youth a chance, and unfortunately short termism tends to be the strategy, meaning the younger players have to be exceptional to get a chance.
Agree. There are a lot of youth players getting their chances in this division this season. I am a firm believer you need young players to add that energy. Especially in a division where the games come thick and fast. As long as you are surrounding those players with experience and encouraging them to be brave then I believe thats the key to success.
I see our youth players get slaughtered on here after 1 cup game when they are thrown in a team with 11 changes. You see so many comments like " they are nowhere near ready" yet you see other youth team players at other clubs looking fantastic in the league. They are 100% not better players. The only difference is they are being given their chance in the league and given a number of games to bed in.
I understand that we are perceived to be a "big club" in this division. I am sure there is far less pressure on the managers of Rotherham, Luton and Wigan etc where they can play their kids with less fear of the repercussions but I really do feel we can do more to give our better kids more exposure to the championship.
That Hull game at home was a prime example. We were crusing that game towards the end. Perfect opportunity to bring on a couple of kids and give them a taste of it. I know coming on when a game is won is an easy introduction but its an introduction. Its a start and it breeds familiarity.
Lets face it we have been playing the "old pro's" now for the last 18 months and where exactly has it got us? Absolutely nowhere.
I am not advocating a team full of kids but I do feel we could do more. Heaven knows we might well need a lot of them next season and then where will we be? They won't be ready......
When we send the yoof out on loan to gain more experience <general response on here.. we need them, the squad is thin>
The yoof are given a game in a cup or a 10 min sub appearance <general response on here.. they aren't good enough, send them out on loan>
The yoof do well at a loan club <general response on here.. have we got a recall option>
The yoof don't perform well at a loan club <general response on here... not good enough get rid>
We sell yoof players <general response on here.... they should have been given a chance to force their way in to the first team
We don't look at young players in lower leagues <general response on here... We should be looking at lower league players>
We buy a player from a lower league <general response on here.. He isn't proven at this level, we should be looking at payers who have experience playing in the championship>
We sign a player with a fair number of championship games experience <general response on here.. we sould be looking at younger players>
You couldn't make it up. 
>
RE: Erik Pieters - Cunninghamismagic - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 03:38 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (09-05-2022, 09:49 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Shabby Russian Wrote:He has been available all summer . Why now? Do we need to make a few signings, any signings to appease the fans.
And any money we allocate to a contract for Pieters cannot be spent on another player in the January window.
Totally agree. With Townsend, Reach and Ashworth we are surely ok and have more pressing issues.
and Kelly, if he is fit
Townsend dreadfully out of form in the last 12 months. Reach is not a defender.
RE: Erik Pieters - Big Daddy Cool - 09-05-2022
Boooooo Bruce needs to play the youngsters, regardless if they are good enough or not. He shouldn't try and sign better players to improve the squad.
RE: Erik Pieters - Ted Maul - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 04:27 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Boooooo Bruce needs to play the youngsters, regardless if they are good enough or not. He shouldn't try and sign better players to improve the squad.
That's not what is being said though is it.
In a situation where we have Townsend, who although out of form is an alright Championship left back, Reach who can cover if needs be and also Ashworth who has performed well on his senior outings thus far. There is no need to sign an ageing bloke in decent wages when he's effectively taking Ashworth's place in the squad. If we're going to finish amongst the also rans this season, I'd sooner lean on the youngsters for a few games than someone Bruce scouted a decade ago.
If we were having this discussion about a potential first team left back during the summer window, I can't imagine there would have been anyone against it
RE: Erik Pieters - Sliced - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 04:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (09-05-2022, 04:27 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Boooooo Bruce needs to play the youngsters, regardless if they are good enough or not. He shouldn't try and sign better players to improve the squad.
That's not what is being said though is it.
In a situation where we have Townsend, who although out of form is an alright Championship left back, Reach who can cover if needs be and also Ashworth who has performed well on his senior outings thus far. There is no need to sign an ageing bloke in decent wages when he's effectively taking Ashworth's place in the squad. If we're going to finish amongst the also rans this season, I'd sooner lean on the youngsters for a few games than someone Bruce scouted a decade ago.
If we were having this discussion about a potential first team left back during the summer window, I can't imagine there would have been anyone against it
I think this is the main point. We've been led to believe that there's very little budget available for signings. If that's the case then left back is WAY down the priority list so why would we give a decent contract to Eric Pieters when we have no fit number 9's at all.
Since Dike got injured and Bruce openly stated "we really didn't expect to be in this position up front" we've seemingly tried to sign players in every position other than central striker, and he even sanctioned the sale of Robinson. It doesn't make sense.
RE: c - Beachboysbaggie - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 03:53 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (09-05-2022, 09:26 AM)Peachy Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:41 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:29 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If he's that good then he's probably a bit over-qualified to be a bit part player for us? It's Townsend's shirt to lose, Bruce shows no sign of dropping him and if we need a left back to cover 5-10 games this season then we have Ashworth and Reach. At which point do these youngsters become part of the squad, small wonder we lose so many. Ashworth has shown nothing in his appearances so far to suggest he wouldn't be able to step up if needed.
Other than as a last resort, Bruce doesn't seem to want to give young players a chance in any circumstances.
That's my biggest criticism of Bruce up until now. It's a bit like Pulis was, and it means we'll never know if they're good enough, and you get stuck in the cycle of bringing in experienced players on their last pay cheque.
It takes a brave forward thinking Manager to give Youth a chance, and unfortunately short termism tends to be the strategy, meaning the younger players have to be exceptional to get a chance.
Agree. There are a lot of youth players getting their chances in this division this season. I am a firm believer you need young players to add that energy. Especially in a division where the games come thick and fast. As long as you are surrounding those players with experience and encouraging them to be brave then I believe thats the key to success.
I see our youth players get slaughtered on here after 1 cup game when they are thrown in a team with 11 changes. You see so many comments like " they are nowhere near ready" yet you see other youth team players at other clubs looking fantastic in the league. They are 100% not better players. The only difference is they are being given their chance in the league and given a number of games to bed in.
I understand that we are perceived to be a "big club" in this division. I am sure there is far less pressure on the managers of Rotherham, Luton and Wigan etc where they can play their kids with less fear of the repercussions but I really do feel we can do more to give our better kids more exposure to the championship.
That Hull game at home was a prime example. We were crusing that game towards the end. Perfect opportunity to bring on a couple of kids and give them a taste of it. I know coming on when a game is won is an easy introduction but its an introduction. Its a start and it breeds familiarity.
Lets face it we have been playing the "old pro's" now for the last 18 months and where exactly has it got us? Absolutely nowhere.
I am not advocating a team full of kids but I do feel we could do more. Heaven knows we might well need a lot of them next season and then where will we be? They won't be ready......
When we send the yoof out on loan to gain more experience <general response on here.. we need them, the squad is thin>
The yoof are given a game in a cup or a 10 min sub appearance <general response on here.. they aren't good enough, send them out on loan>
The yoof do well at a loan club <general response on here.. have we got a recall option>
The yoof don't perform well at a loan club <general response on here... not good enough get rid>
We sell yoof players <general response on here.... they should have been given a chance to force their way in to the first team
We don't look at young players in lower leagues <general response on here... We should be looking at lower league players>
We buy a player from a lower league <general response on here.. He isn't proven at this level, we should be looking at payers who have experience playing in the championship>
We sign a player with a fair number of championship games experience <general response on here.. we sould be looking at younger players>
You couldn't make it up. 
>
Spot on
RE: c - Birdman1811 - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 03:53 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (09-05-2022, 09:26 AM)Peachy Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:41 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:29 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-05-2022, 08:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: If he's that good then he's probably a bit over-qualified to be a bit part player for us? It's Townsend's shirt to lose, Bruce shows no sign of dropping him and if we need a left back to cover 5-10 games this season then we have Ashworth and Reach. At which point do these youngsters become part of the squad, small wonder we lose so many. Ashworth has shown nothing in his appearances so far to suggest he wouldn't be able to step up if needed.
Other than as a last resort, Bruce doesn't seem to want to give young players a chance in any circumstances.
That's my biggest criticism of Bruce up until now. It's a bit like Pulis was, and it means we'll never know if they're good enough, and you get stuck in the cycle of bringing in experienced players on their last pay cheque.
It takes a brave forward thinking Manager to give Youth a chance, and unfortunately short termism tends to be the strategy, meaning the younger players have to be exceptional to get a chance.
Agree. There are a lot of youth players getting their chances in this division this season. I am a firm believer you need young players to add that energy. Especially in a division where the games come thick and fast. As long as you are surrounding those players with experience and encouraging them to be brave then I believe thats the key to success.
I see our youth players get slaughtered on here after 1 cup game when they are thrown in a team with 11 changes. You see so many comments like " they are nowhere near ready" yet you see other youth team players at other clubs looking fantastic in the league. They are 100% not better players. The only difference is they are being given their chance in the league and given a number of games to bed in.
I understand that we are perceived to be a "big club" in this division. I am sure there is far less pressure on the managers of Rotherham, Luton and Wigan etc where they can play their kids with less fear of the repercussions but I really do feel we can do more to give our better kids more exposure to the championship.
That Hull game at home was a prime example. We were crusing that game towards the end. Perfect opportunity to bring on a couple of kids and give them a taste of it. I know coming on when a game is won is an easy introduction but its an introduction. Its a start and it breeds familiarity.
Lets face it we have been playing the "old pro's" now for the last 18 months and where exactly has it got us? Absolutely nowhere.
I am not advocating a team full of kids but I do feel we could do more. Heaven knows we might well need a lot of them next season and then where will we be? They won't be ready......
When we send the yoof out on loan to gain more experience <general response on here.. we need them, the squad is thin>
The yoof are given a game in a cup or a 10 min sub appearance <general response on here.. they aren't good enough, send them out on loan>
The yoof do well at a loan club <general response on here.. have we got a recall option>
The yoof don't perform well at a loan club <general response on here... not good enough get rid>
We sell yoof players <general response on here.... they should have been given a chance to force their way in to the first team
We don't look at young players in lower leagues <general response on here... We should be looking at lower league players>
We buy a player from a lower league <general response on here.. He isn't proven at this level, we should be looking at payers who have experience playing in the championship>
We sign a player with a fair number of championship games experience <general response on here.. we sould be looking at younger players>
You couldn't make it up. 
>
Yep.
All of it is infuriating.
RE: Erik Pieters - Cheshire East Baggie - 09-05-2022
Another amazing thread. I do worry that some of you guys don't have enough going on in your lives.
It seems he's been training with us for a while. There's been no mention of contract talks. And most weeks the board is full of angst about how poorly Townsend is playing and how Reach isn't even a footballer never mind a left back. "Play the yoof" is the cry, until they play, and not very well at that.
Bottom line is, no-one at the club gives a tuppenny fuck what we think. Bruce will do what he thinks is right, we'll complain about it, some of us will be pleased if it works out and we challenge for promotion, others will be pleased if they can be proved right when we finish mid-table. But jeezus christ, this is boring!!
RE: Erik Pieters - Sliced - 09-05-2022
(09-05-2022, 05:27 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Another amazing thread. I do worry that some of you guys don't have enough going on in your lives.
It seems he's been training with us for a while. There's been no mention of contract talks. And most weeks the board is full of angst about how poorly Townsend is playing and how Reach isn't even a footballer never mind a left back. "Play the yoof" is the cry, until they play, and not very well at that.
Bottom line is, no-one at the club gives a tuppenny fuck what we think. Bruce will do what he thinks is right, we'll complain about it, some of us will be pleased if it works out and we challenge for promotion, others will be pleased if they can be proved right when we finish mid-table. But jeezus christ, this is boring!!
Close the site Birdie. Discussion is pointless because it doesn't have a direct impact on decisions made at the club.
You're literally on a message board. What were you expecting?
|