![]() |
|
£9.5 billion - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: £9.5 billion (/showthread.php?tid=25894) |
RE: £9.5 billion - Borin' Baggie - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 10:28 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-31-2022, 10:36 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They. Have. Not. Taken. On. Any. Risk. For. These. Profits. Are Geoffrey Howe and Margaret Thatcher Corbynistas as well then? My stance is exactly in line with what they would do based on the precedent they set when the exact same thing happened in 1982 due to externalities to oil extraction causing the price of North Sea oil to rise. You can't be ideologically rigid when shit hits the fan Proth, thought this was made clear when Whiggist rigidity on intervening in the market exasperated the Irish famine. Also, I'm not on about consumer businesses, I'm on about the global energy traders and extractors. I'm well aware of the razor thin margins of consumer businesses at the moment in their purchasing of energy based on current futures pricing - in fact I'm pretty sure you know that as well seeing as I spelt that out using British Gas as an example on the politics board and you agreed. Centrica (operations independent from British Gas), BP and Shell are raking money in as their outgoings have remained static whilst their revenue have gone up massively due to gas price instability caused by a war. That requires a market correction as otherwise how the hell are people going to pay their bills this winter? Either they're encouraged to sell below market rate (never going to happen) or their profits are used to adjust the market on the demand side domestically. Ultimately though we would be somewhat along the way to shielding consumers from this had the government done what I have been telling BEIS and their predecessors DECC to do for the last 7 years in aggressive insulating property schemes to reduce gas demand on heating. I even brought up a potential squeeze on gas supplies as a result of Russian aggression and they brushed it off, they ignored mine and many other people's warnings over our dependency on gas. RE: £9.5 billion - Protheroe - 08-02-2022 The Exchequer is already bringing in higher revenues from these firms precisely because of the increase in the market price. It's the same for VAT on petrol and diesel. How much is enough? Macron's government is resisting calls for a Windfall Tax on TotalFina, Italy has imposed a Windfall Tax that is more to do with transitioning away from Russian energy than acute assistance to consumers. I agree that vulnerable consumers need help, but the rest of us cannot expect not should we receive yet another bailout on top of the ones we received from the GFC and Covid. The £30 billion in fiscal wriggle room that the two ridiculous protagonists for Tory Leader are busily spunking on tax cuts should be invested in acute assistance and an insulation programme for the hardest hit. It would even be a vote winner. RE: £9.5 billion - Borin' Baggie - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 11:33 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The Exchequer is already bringing in higher revenues from these firms precisely because of the increase in the market price. It's the same for VAT on petrol and diesel. How much is enough? It is enough when British consumers are sufficiently shielded from the market instability to the most extent that can be practical. I also want to reduce VAT on petrol and diesel for that very same reason using the justification that the tax receipts from VAT for petrol and diesel have gone up due to inflation. RE: £9.5 billion - Protheroe - 08-02-2022 You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. RE: £9.5 billion - SophLad - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. I think, if as predicted gas bills go to £500 a month, there aren't many who would not justifiably be offered at least some protection. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-27/uk-energy-bills-are-set-to-top-500-per-month-as-russia-cuts-gas RE: £9.5 billion - Protheroe - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 12:27 PM)SophLad Wrote:(08-02-2022, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. There are millions of people in this country who've benefitted from 14 years of government-backed asset price inflation - largely unearned wealth (including me and many others on here). Gordon Brown wrongly bailed out my IceSave and Kaupthing losses by 100%. Rishi Sunak has spunked untold £billions on untargeted Covid support (and fraud). There will be millions of people not in genuine need, who might "struggle a bit". There's plenty of us on here grew up without a car in the family, a colour telly, a foreign holiday, restaurant meals etc in the 70s and 80s. When did we become so fucking entitled? The difference between the price cap now and October for me is the cost of taking the family out for dinner somewhere half decent. I'll take them out for dinner on one less occasion per month. There will be people in real destitution. That is where the assistance ought to go. RE: £9.5 billion - Borin' Baggie - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. Looking at the current gas and electric futures, the projected cap rise and projections into 2023 into the projected average gas and leccy prices by the end of 2022 a lot more people are going to be pushed into the position of choosing between heating and cooking this winter than just those at the bottom and this government is sticking it's fingers in it's ears going lalalalalalalala trying to pretend it's not happening. The longer we wait the more people the targeted support will need to apply to. RE: £9.5 billion - Derek Hardballs - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 12:50 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(08-02-2022, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. Yep, this. However helping people does fundamentally go against the basic instincts of this government and tank and file Conservative members which may explain their reticence unless they feel it will act as a bribe for the next election. RE: £9.5 billion - SophLad - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 12:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(08-02-2022, 12:27 PM)SophLad Wrote:(08-02-2022, 12:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You seem to be suggesting that we ALL need to be "shielded from the market instability". I'm afraid I just don't agree with that. I agree with a tiered approach to support (as if anyone could administer it!) but when a bill rises from £150 to £500pcm then the thresholds for tiered support needs to be dropped to include those who will no longer be able to choose to go out for a meal feed their kids healthy meals AND heat their homes. Maybe employers could administer it based upon salary? Interesting that Lizzo is promising to cut the junk food tax. A tacit acknowledgement that the first to lose out in tough times are the poor and unhealthy or just desparate electioneering? Also, asset based inflation doesn't benefit the holder until the asset is released (potentially with additional CGT paid). Unless you're proposing people remortgage in order to heat their homes? RE: £9.5 billion - Protheroe - 08-02-2022 (08-02-2022, 01:06 PM)SophLad Wrote: I agree with a tiered approach to support (as if anyone could administer it!) but when a bill rises from £150 to £500pcm then the thresholds for tiered support needs to be dropped to include those who will no longer be able to choose to go out for a meal feed their kids healthy meals AND heat their homes. Maybe employers could administer it based upon salary? Then I think we agree on targeted support. As far as benefitting from asset price price inflation is concerned I do think people need to take a good look in the mirror before they ask for a bung. My domestic mortgage currently has a real interest rate of minus 10.5% v RPI, the various BTL mortgages we have are minus 10%. Every day that passes writes down the real value of the capital owed. Inflation in that sense is a huge boon to those with asset backed fixed-rate leveraged debt. Forgive me if I sound like a bleeding heart Socialist for a moment, but given the fact that my own home has "earned" nearly as much as me for the past two years I don't think I'm in the position to ask for a handout. You can't, in my opinion, benefit from the market and deranged government policy on one hand - then expect insulating from the market and deranged government policy on the other hand. It's just not fair. |