RE: Ingerlund - Swagbaggie - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 06:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:28 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: Depends whether you consider being better than we have been in years criticism worthy.
England fans are little better than Seals when it comes to entitlement and delusion. Just as they think they deserve to win everything because they won the big cup once, English fans are exactly the same. That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
This generations players aren't in the same universe as some of the other squads in world football.
How many of today's starting 11 would get on France's bench, never mind first team. 2-3 maybe?
That is also possibly/probably true - but it isn't what I said.
The abilities of this squad - limited though they may be - will be wasted on GS.
Anyway we will see when it matters in November and we can listen to the 'Tacticians' BS until then.
So what would you class as not wasted? What would Southgate have to achieve? Oh look 'Can't make the play-offs is Bobbins' boy has pitched in when he feels he has a few mates to help!
As I said I regard Southgate as very lucky so far.
He now has a better and younger squad available to him BUT I see less players that might get him out of the shit with a bit of total piece of class.
He needs to step up now and develop a consistent and progressive strategy to show this group is not wasted.
There is no 'succession' value either.
He is reliant on the coaching many are getting at City, 'pool etc and he needs to show that he is worthy of that opportunity.
I don't see that at all.
(06-04-2022, 06:34 PM)Duffers Wrote: It’s a myth that sides swashbuckle their way through tournaments, there are the odd exceptions (France 18 for example) but in plenty of occasions they are won by sides who buckle down and keep it tight. Examples? Sure::
Italy 21 - Played good stuff in the groups but ground their way through every knockout game. Fun fact. We scored more than them in the knockouts.
Portugal 16 - Bored their way to glory through being impossible to score against.
Greece 04 - See above but with added set pieces.
Spain - Tikki takka’d their way to three straight tournaments but were hardly thrilling to watch. Think they won every game in the 2010 WC 1-0.
There is many more than that. France in '98.
Italy 2006. Brazil 2002. and more.
But they also needed luck.
It meant that simpletons like 'Big Phil' - Jacquet - Costa Santos are tournament winners!
Southgate hopefully hasn't used all his luck up because his talent won't make up for it.
RE: Ingerlund - Big Daddy Cool - 06-04-2022
Southgate has done a good job. But I would like to see what a Graham Potter could do with these players.
RE: Ingerlund - Swagbaggie - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 06:37 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:36 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (06-04-2022, 05:56 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 05:55 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (06-04-2022, 05:37 PM)Duffers Wrote: He also took us further in back to back major tournaments since Alf Ramsey.
And we won...?
A silver medal. Which is more than we’ve won in a very long time.
Would you like me to draw you a diagram?
So you spout your usual bollox about Guardiola not winning certain trophies yet the same doesn't apply to the failed Boro manager Southgate?
And football isn't the Olympics. Silver medals... dear me.
Southgate didn’t spend a billion quid.
Again, diagram? No but unlike almost any other manager he has Billions of pounds worth of players at his disposal and turns out a team that play like that tonight.
RE: Ingerlund - Duffers - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 06:45 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:28 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
This generations players aren't in the same universe as some of the other squads in world football.
How many of today's starting 11 would get on France's bench, never mind first team. 2-3 maybe?
That is also possibly/probably true - but it isn't what I said.
The abilities of this squad - limited though they may be - will be wasted on GS.
Anyway we will see when it matters in November and we can listen to the 'Tacticians' BS until then.
So what would you class as not wasted? What would Southgate have to achieve? Oh look 'Can't make the play-offs is Bobbins' boy has pitched in when he feels he has a few mates to help!
As I said I regard Southgate as very lucky so far.
He now has a better and younger squad available to him BUT I see less players that might get him out of the shit with a bit of total piece of class.
He needs to step up now and develop a consistent and progressive strategy to show this group is not wasted.
There is no 'succession' value either.
He is reliant on the coaching many are getting at City, 'pool etc and he needs to show that he is worthy of that opportunity.
I don't see that at all.
Isn’t that what he has been doing though? What does that even mean? Just look at the number of talented young players he’s brought through to become regulars in the squad in recent years - Saka, Foden, Bellingham, James, TAA, Smith-Rowe, Rice, Mount… all players 23 or under who already have a significant number of caps. Is that commitment to bringing youth through not “progressive”?
Today was piss poor, absolutely no denying that, but such displays are very much the exceptions rather than the rule, yet it only takes one suck display for the anti-Southgate brigade to come crawling out.
As I’ve said, if we play like that in November then he’ll rightly be criticised, but is this level of vitriol really necessary at the moment?
RE: Ingerlund - Jack Halford - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:00 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Southgate isn't going anywhere, get used to him!
I don't follow England, so don't care, either way. But, there does seem to be a lot of criticism on Southgate.
Are the England team food enough to warrant such criticism?
Depends whether you consider being better than we have been in years criticism worthy.
England fans are little better than Seals when it comes to entitlement and delusion. Just as they think they deserve to win everything because they won the big cup once, English fans are exactly the same. That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
RE: Ingerlund - Duffers - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:00 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Southgate isn't going anywhere, get used to him!
I don't follow England, so don't care, either way. But, there does seem to be a lot of criticism on Southgate.
Are the England team food enough to warrant such criticism?
Depends whether you consider being better than we have been in years criticism worthy.
England fans are little better than Seals when it comes to entitlement and delusion. Just as they think they deserve to win everything because they won the big cup once, English fans are exactly the same. That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
Do you remember us labouring against Switzerland and then Scotland? Or scraping past Spain on penalties?
Nostalgia does interesting thing to perception…
RE: Ingerlund - Jack Halford - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 07:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: Depends whether you consider being better than we have been in years criticism worthy.
England fans are little better than Seals when it comes to entitlement and delusion. Just as they think they deserve to win everything because they won the big cup once, English fans are exactly the same. That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
Do you remember us labouring against Switzerland and then Scotland? Or scraping past Spain on penalties?
Nostalgia does interesting thing to perception…
Yes we laboured against Switzerland and the Scotland match was always going to be a local derby type game but we won.
Spain were 19 games unbeaten going into that game and we battered Holland.
I’m sorry but Southgate does not have the tactical nous of Venables.
I really hope he proves me wrong though.
RE: Ingerlund - TartanRug - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:04 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:00 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Southgate isn't going anywhere, get used to him!
I don't follow England, so don't care, either way. But, there does seem to be a lot of criticism on Southgate.
Are the England team food enough to warrant such criticism?
Depends whether you consider being better than we have been in years criticism worthy.
England fans are little better than Seals when it comes to entitlement and delusion. Just as they think they deserve to win everything because they won the big cup once, English fans are exactly the same. That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
I don't know if it's as simple as just 'taking the hand brake off'. It's always a balancing act, maybe being more attacking will make us more vulnerable at the back. I'd love to see us batter teams 4 or 5 nil every game and I know it's not exciting but it's better to be solid and consistent if you want to get through and potentially win tournaments
RE: Ingerlund - Duffers - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 07:57 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:17 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: That is bullshit. You are only saying that because you defend Southgate at every opportunity.
Tactics Schmactics.
At best he is lucky and IMO will waste this generation of players if he is allowed to stay in charge.
Put that to one side that was a very poor performance and under pre tournament conditions would be worrying but it isn't.
Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
Do you remember us labouring against Switzerland and then Scotland? Or scraping past Spain on penalties?
Nostalgia does interesting thing to perception…
Yes we laboured against Switzerland and the Scotland match was always going to be a local derby type game but we won.
Spain were 19 games unbeaten going into that game and we battered Holland.
I’m sorry but Southgate does not have the tactical nous of Venables.
I really hope he proves me wrong though.
I’m not really knocking Venables, Euro 96 was brilliant, but I’m not sure how one great performance and one defeat on penalties makes him any better than Southgate.
RE: Ingerlund - Jack Halford - 06-04-2022
(06-04-2022, 08:03 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:57 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:42 PM)Duffers Wrote: (06-04-2022, 07:37 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (06-04-2022, 06:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: Waste in what way? The players Southgate himself has brought into the squad? You can only get 11 on the pitch at any time and it’s not like FIFA where you can slap 11 attackers out there and hope. As I said further up, he’s got a system that gets results in tournaments, it’s taken us closer to winning anything than we have been in at least 30+ years. You can say “yeah he should have started Grealish/Foden/the latest hot thing” (Foden is becoming a regular starter now) but does Grealish fit the way Southgate plays? Does he have the discipline? Pep doesn’t seem to think so…
I defend Southgate because I believe the criticism he receives is ridiculous. Because the factually the best manager we have had in my lifetime in terms of tournament success. Because he came in and bombed out the old failures (Rooney, Walcott, Hart, etc) and played younger players who were there on merit. He actually made this England squad likeable. That’s more important to me than an actual trophy (which I would also love to see)
Genuine question, do you think that Southgate is a better coach than Venables?
Watch us dismantle an exceptionally good Dutch team in 96 again. Yes factually we have a Semi and Final under Southgate but he is nowhere as good a coach as Venables.
He is a very good man manager ( a lovely bloke having met him a number of times) and the players obviously like playing for him. We have an excellent crop of youngsters and I hope he’ll take the hand break off in the World Cup.
Do you remember us labouring against Switzerland and then Scotland? Or scraping past Spain on penalties?
Nostalgia does interesting thing to perception…
Yes we laboured against Switzerland and the Scotland match was always going to be a local derby type game but we won.
Spain were 19 games unbeaten going into that game and we battered Holland.
I’m sorry but Southgate does not have the tactical nous of Venables.
I really hope he proves me wrong though.
I’m not really knocking Venables, Euro 96 was brilliant, but I’m not sure how one great performance and one defeat on penalties makes him any better than Southgate.
I know you’re not but Venables had a great record as an innovative coach at home and abroad which in my view gives him the edge and is maybe what Southgate lacks, Time will tell.
|