RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 04-10-2022
(04-10-2022, 08:12 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Johnstone, 3 - Appalling attitude, why are we keeping him fit when he should be banished to train on his own?
TGH, 5 - Struggled but soldiered on and was visibly frustrated. Why he’s been moved out of the middle is a mystery.
Townsend, 2 - Garbage. Absolutely terrible.
Clarke, 4 - It’s all very well marauding trying to attack, but you’re there to defend.
Bartley, 3 - Feckless
Semi, 5 - Puts it in to be fair to him, not a good day.
Mowatt, 2 - In hiding. Coward. Might want to lose some weight.
Livermore, 4 - His legs have gone, trying to do Mowatts running too and it’s making him look worse than he is.
Molumby, 5 - Tried, wants to attack. Physically weak.
Grady, 2 - Lazy, disinterested, sulky.
Carrol, 5 - Feeding off scraps
Subs - I’d walked out by then.
Pretty much in agreement with these except I'd put Livermore up to 5. He actually did do his job, along with TGH and Carroll but was let down by shirkers. (Predictive text chose Shirley's and maybe I ought of left it at that!). Reach also came on and had a clear plan to get to the goal line and cross, it nearly worked. Its unpopular to back Jake and Reach but anyone that couldn't see they gave 100% is too biased to admit it. I'd like to see Reach given Townsends shirt next game.
RE: Ratings - richbaggie - 04-10-2022
(04-09-2022, 06:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 3 Static for the 3rd, zero interest, first down the tunnel
TGH 3 Sjoke left back who is a good player had him on toast all day, plenty of effort and passion but struggled today, for those saying he’s not a wing back…that’s exactly where he plays
Townsend 2 Disgusting performance and one of the biggest parasites to down tools months ago
Clarke 3 Ropey afternoon after so impressive v Bournemouth
Bartley 2 Stinker, switched off for 2nd and poor throughout
Semi 4 Just about passable but uncomfortable on the ball at the best of times
Mowatt 2 Terrible, looked leggy from the off and game passed him by
Livermore 3 Tried. It just not very good, comical OG summed up the season
Molumby 5Plenty of effort and tried to break the lines at times, no confidence on the ball though, often went sideways when a forward pass was on
Grady 2 Ineffective until withdrawn but tactic completely wrong
Carrol 5* Actually gives a shit, put himself about, won his headers and caused problems, criminally under used 8n the first half
Subs
Robbo 3 Thought he was lazy today and I’ve defended him against others, tidy but no desire
Grant 3 Little impact
Reach 3 He’s dog shit but at least he tries, should be in ahead of Townsend on that alone
As for Bruce I’ve been banging on for weeks on here, Grady behind 2 strikers is our best set up, we did it 2nd half with Robbo there and at least we created a little
Why oh why are we playing that system at home against a side 15th? Such a negative, stand off start to the game when we should be flying out the blocks, that is down to the manager I’m afraid
Terrible, terrible afternoon
Cuzer
You're defence of Robinson has surprised me this season Cuz. I've not disliked a player more than him in a long time. He has ability, of that I have no doubt. He can sometimes pick a pass, sometimes has great movement, sometimes finishes well, sometimes tries to show passion. But you've spotted the key word here I'm sure.
He does and says things for show, to give impression he cares. The bloke is an absolute fraud who takes the piss with his sometimes ways. I fucking hate the cunt and I can count on one hand how many times in 50 years I've felt that. He epitomises where we are now as a club.
RE: Ratings - Birdman1811 - 04-10-2022
(04-10-2022, 10:03 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-09-2022, 06:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 3 Static for the 3rd, zero interest, first down the tunnel
TGH 3 Sjoke left back who is a good player had him on toast all day, plenty of effort and passion but struggled today, for those saying he’s not a wing back…that’s exactly where he plays
Townsend 2 Disgusting performance and one of the biggest parasites to down tools months ago
Clarke 3 Ropey afternoon after so impressive v Bournemouth
Bartley 2 Stinker, switched off for 2nd and poor throughout
Semi 4 Just about passable but uncomfortable on the ball at the best of times
Mowatt 2 Terrible, looked leggy from the off and game passed him by
Livermore 3 Tried. It just not very good, comical OG summed up the season
Molumby 5Plenty of effort and tried to break the lines at times, no confidence on the ball though, often went sideways when a forward pass was on
Grady 2 Ineffective until withdrawn but tactic completely wrong
Carrol 5* Actually gives a shit, put himself about, won his headers and caused problems, criminally under used 8n the first half
Subs
Robbo 3 Thought he was lazy today and I’ve defended him against others, tidy but no desire
Grant 3 Little impact
Reach 3 He’s dog shit but at least he tries, should be in ahead of Townsend on that alone
As for Bruce I’ve been banging on for weeks on here, Grady behind 2 strikers is our best set up, we did it 2nd half with Robbo there and at least we created a little
Why oh why are we playing that system at home against a side 15th? Such a negative, stand off start to the game when we should be flying out the blocks, that is down to the manager I’m afraid
Terrible, terrible afternoon
Cuzer
You're defence of Robinson has surprised me this season Cuz. I've not disliked a player more than him in a long time. He has ability, of that I have no doubt. He can sometimes pick a pass, sometimes has great movement, sometimes finishes well, sometimes tries to show passion. But you've spotted the key word here I'm sure.
He does and says things for show, to give impression he cares. The bloke is an absolute fraud who takes the piss with his sometimes ways. I fucking hate the cunt and I can count on one hand how many times in 50 years I've felt that. He epitomises where we are now as a club.
Totally, and utterly agree. Wilder wanted rid for a reason, we've seen why now.
RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-10-2022
(04-09-2022, 09:12 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: He was being marked by Ajayi who just stood and watched him. Bartley was the only defender to react but was never going to get near him. Totally down to Ajayi.
Interesting that the Brum Mail made Ajayi top scoring Albion player with 6. That's not what Bartley was thinking when he turned round and confronted Ajayi after the second goal went in. I don't quite get why Bartley isn't saying, "Boss, he's effing done it to us again. How many times?" But maybe Semi is the man, no-one messes with him.
Watching the highlights for their third goal, the players streaking back were Reach, Molumby, Bartley and Carroll (yes, Carroll, he nearly got there too). As the camera panned round after the ball hit the net, you could see Clarke jogging gently back over the halfway line. Ajayi, as usual, was nowhere to be seen. Clarke and Ajayi seem to think that if they race up the field and get involved in attacks, it doesn't matter how bad their defending is. Is this the game Bruce wants them to play? Replacing poor old Barts with O'Shea will just mean that O'Shea looks bad every week.
RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 04-10-2022
Not for me Rich, you either believe the bloke or think he does things for show, why would he do things for show?
We're shite and lose and he comes and thanks the fans for coming, he doesn't have to do this and the easy option is to fuck off down the tunnel, see SJ amongst others
He was last off the pitch v Bournemouth, pictures with fans in the East Stand, gives his shirt away every game etc, kids appreciate it and for some it makes their day, long may that continue
On the pitch he's under achieved yes, but jesus haven't they all
We love a spacegoat up B71 and Robbo is this seasons for definite
Cuzer
RE: Ratings - EastMidsBaggie - 04-10-2022
KRO Wrote:Were you really this bad again?
Btw Blues were shocking yesterday. Bullied at times by a Forest team in third gear at most. What has passed a lot off is Bowyer and some players saying we were the better side. Absolute oss shit comments
Much like you it seems when we go behind some wave the white flag.
Yes, we really were !
No drive, no fight and plenty of players hiding or couldn't be bothered to concentrate or push themselves against a very ordinary Sjoke side.
I see the Villa loanee was giving your lot the big 'I am' after the first goal ! Surprised there wasn't a pitch invasion!
Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Albion player pass backwards more than Molumby. How we’ve paid money for him I just don’t know. Sums up our recruitment, awful
Mowatt not much better - just hides and doesn’t look fit
That midfield 3 was never going to work, all too similar, none of them even face forward when they receive the ball
Shocking thing is, we are lumbered with Molumby now and wasting decent budget on him.
Sad, sad times.
Birdman1811 Wrote:At Barnsley Mowatt was a leader, a battler and pretty much key to their over-achievement. Apparently he isn't well-liked in the squad, never guessed because he quickly became exactly like the fucking rest of them.
We said that yesterday.
Where's he gone (did show flashes midweek) ?
I thought we could have had one of the best midfielders in the league judging on the opening games !
That player has long gone (bit like Grady) and no idea how we get him back or why he's not so mediocre to poor.
Tom Joad Wrote:TTM2 Wrote:Johnstone, 3 - Appalling attitude, why are we keeping him fit when he should be banished to train on his own?
TGH, 5 - Struggled but soldiered on and was visibly frustrated. Why he’s been moved out of the middle is a mystery.
Townsend, 2 - Garbage. Absolutely terrible.
Clarke, 4 - It’s all very well marauding trying to attack, but you’re there to defend.
Bartley, 3 - Feckless
Semi, 5 - Puts it in to be fair to him, not a good day.
Mowatt, 2 - In hiding. Coward. Might want to lose some weight.
Livermore, 4 - His legs have gone, trying to do Mowatts running too and it’s making him look worse than he is.
Molumby, 5 - Tried, wants to attack. Physically weak.
Grady, 2 - Lazy, disinterested, sulky.
Carrol, 5 - Feeding off scraps
Subs - I’d walked out by then.
Pretty much in agreement with these except I'd put Livermore up to 5. He actually did do his job, along with TGH and Carroll but was let down by shirkers. (Predictive text chose Shirley's and maybe I ought of left it at that!). Reach also came on and had a clear plan to get to the goal line and cross, it nearly worked. Its unpopular to back Jake and Reach but anyone that couldn't see they gave 100% is too biased to admit it. I'd like to see Reach given Townsends shirt next game.
Agree that the TGH score was a bit generous as he really struggled and has, understandably due to lack of experience and playing with this bunch,, really levelled over the past few months.
Let's hope his drop in form is temporary and the promise continues.
RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-10-2022
(04-09-2022, 06:47 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Albion player pass backwards more than Molumby. How we’ve paid money for him I just don’t know. Sums up our recruitment, awful
Mowatt not much better - just hides and doesn’t look fit
That midfield 3 was never going to work, all too similar, none of them even face forward when they receive the ball
I'm genuinely surprised that both you and EastMids keep harping on about Molumby. Firstly, I thought he did OK yesterday, certainly later on when Livermore was hiding, he moved the ball around well in that spell when we were pressing for the equaliser. Secondly we aren't in this mess because we signed underwhelming players like Mowatt, Molumby and Reach, it's because we still have underwhelming players like Johnstone, Ajayi, Bartley, Furlong, Townsend, Livermore and Phillips. These guys have mostly weaselled their way into Bruce's affections and are rewarding him with abysmal performances, as they have done for three previous managers.
RE: Ratings - TTM2 - 04-10-2022
(04-10-2022, 10:03 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-09-2022, 06:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 3 Static for the 3rd, zero interest, first down the tunnel
TGH 3 Sjoke left back who is a good player had him on toast all day, plenty of effort and passion but struggled today, for those saying he’s not a wing back…that’s exactly where he plays
Townsend 2 Disgusting performance and one of the biggest parasites to down tools months ago
Clarke 3 Ropey afternoon after so impressive v Bournemouth
Bartley 2 Stinker, switched off for 2nd and poor throughout
Semi 4 Just about passable but uncomfortable on the ball at the best of times
Mowatt 2 Terrible, looked leggy from the off and game passed him by
Livermore 3 Tried. It just not very good, comical OG summed up the season
Molumby 5Plenty of effort and tried to break the lines at times, no confidence on the ball though, often went sideways when a forward pass was on
Grady 2 Ineffective until withdrawn but tactic completely wrong
Carrol 5* Actually gives a shit, put himself about, won his headers and caused problems, criminally under used 8n the first half
Subs
Robbo 3 Thought he was lazy today and I’ve defended him against others, tidy but no desire
Grant 3 Little impact
Reach 3 He’s dog shit but at least he tries, should be in ahead of Townsend on that alone
As for Bruce I’ve been banging on for weeks on here, Grady behind 2 strikers is our best set up, we did it 2nd half with Robbo there and at least we created a little
Why oh why are we playing that system at home against a side 15th? Such a negative, stand off start to the game when we should be flying out the blocks, that is down to the manager I’m afraid
Terrible, terrible afternoon
Cuzer
You're defence of Robinson has surprised me this season Cuz. I've not disliked a player more than him in a long time. He has ability, of that I have no doubt. He can sometimes pick a pass, sometimes has great movement, sometimes finishes well, sometimes tries to show passion. But you've spotted the key word here I'm sure.
He does and says things for show, to give impression he cares. The bloke is an absolute fraud who takes the piss with his sometimes ways. I fucking hate the cunt and I can count on one hand how many times in 50 years I've felt that. He epitomises where we are now as a club.
Absolutely spot on.
Summed up by his disgraceful performance at Blues where he decided to get involved in the pushing and shoving with Carroll which was absolutely nothing to do with him, simply because it was right next to our fans.
He then came over to give his shirt away and tried to clap us, think he got more than he bargained for as he was told in no certain terms what he is.
A fraud and a coward. Complete con man.
RE: Ratings - EastMidsBaggie - 04-10-2022
Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Albion player pass backwards more than Molumby. How we’ve paid money for him I just don’t know. Sums up our recruitment, awful
Mowatt not much better - just hides and doesn’t look fit
That midfield 3 was never going to work, all too similar, none of them even face forward when they receive the ball
I'm genuinely surprised that both you and EastMids keep harping on about Molumby. Firstly, I thought he did OK yesterday, certainly later on when Livermore was hiding, he moved the ball around well in that spell when we were pressing for the equaliser. Secondly we aren't in this mess because we signed underwhelming players like Mowatt, Molumby and Reach, it's because we still have underwhelming players like Johnstone, Ajayi, Bartley, Furlong, Townsend, Livermore and Phillips. These guys have mostly weaselled their way into Bruce's affections and are rewarding him with abysmal performances, as they have done for three previous managers.
He's a very average player and not the kind of midfielder we need if we are keeping Mowatt and Livermore so , I suppose he's a victim of that.
We need some creativity in the area and I really don't see that from him. He's doing lots of running around, back and side passes; but that's all that the other two do. I don't see any threat from him in and around the opponents box (1 goal all season ?) or an ability to shoot on target ?
RE: Ratings - KRO - 04-10-2022
(04-10-2022, 10:31 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: KRO Wrote:Were you really this bad again?
Btw Blues were shocking yesterday. Bullied at times by a Forest team in third gear at most. What has passed a lot off is Bowyer and some players saying we were the better side. Absolute oss shit comments
Much like you it seems when we go behind some wave the white flag.
Yes, we really were !
No drive, no fight and plenty of players hiding or couldn't be bothered to concentrate or push themselves against a very ordinary Sjoke side.
I see the Villa loanee was giving your lot the big 'I am' after the first goal ! Surprised there wasn't a pitch invasion!
Sometimes you just know what’s going to happen and take your medicine. I give it so have no problem taking it. How he beat Etheridge from that angle bothered me more than him giving it large.
|