WBAUnofficial
The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid (/showthread.php?tid=24684)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - backsidebaggie - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry bb but you don't make sense with what you are saying. On one hand you say you don't look at it very deeply anymore and on the other hand you say that you know enough to state that the vaccines haven't been very effective. Then to support your statement you quote Australia as an example of where they have a high vaccination rate and cases are 'through the roof'. When we dive into that it shows that Australia has half the number of cases of the UK and by your own admission very little natural immunity, they also have a current death rate which is half the rate of England - how can this be with so little natural immunity. The answer is very simple in that the vaccine does work and it is very effective in slowing transmission, if it wasn't a country with little to no natural immunity, and completely reliant on the vaccine would be in a much worse position than a country, such as the UK, with lots of vaccinations plus the natural immunity.

The vaccines have been around ages. It’s possible to have an opinion on them without thinking about covid much anymore.

I don’t think they’ve been very good in relation to transmission. Way less than most people hoped. Some effect? Yes. But not brilliant at all.

I think they’ve seriously cut severe cases, hospitalisations and deaths in the individuals that take them.

I really don’t think this is a controversial opinion, in fact I think many think the same.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - Birdman1811 - 03-22-2022

Many people thinking the same doesn't make it true.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - baggy1 - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 09:39 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry bb but you don't make sense with what you are saying. On one hand you say you don't look at it very deeply anymore and on the other hand you say that you know enough to state that the vaccines haven't been very effective. Then to support your statement you quote Australia as an example of where they have a high vaccination rate and cases are 'through the roof'. When we dive into that it shows that Australia has half the number of cases of the UK and by your own admission very little natural immunity, they also have a current death rate which is half the rate of England - how can this be with so little natural immunity. The answer is very simple in that the vaccine does work and it is very effective in slowing transmission, if it wasn't a country with little to no natural immunity, and completely reliant on the vaccine would be in a much worse position than a country, such as the UK, with lots of vaccinations plus the natural immunity.

The vaccines have been around ages. It’s possible to have an opinion on them without thinking about covid much anymore.

I don’t think they’ve been very good in relation to transmission. Way less than most people hoped. Some effect? Yes. But not brilliant at all.

I think they’ve seriously cut severe cases, hospitalisations and deaths in the individuals that take them.

I really don’t think this is a controversial opinion, in fact I think many think the same.

So a simple couple of questions - how come Australia doesn't have higher transmission rates? What is holding back the transmission?


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - backsidebaggie - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 10:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 09:39 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry bb but you don't make sense with what you are saying. On one hand you say you don't look at it very deeply anymore and on the other hand you say that you know enough to state that the vaccines haven't been very effective. Then to support your statement you quote Australia as an example of where they have a high vaccination rate and cases are 'through the roof'. When we dive into that it shows that Australia has half the number of cases of the UK and by your own admission very little natural immunity, they also have a current death rate which is half the rate of England - how can this be with so little natural immunity. The answer is very simple in that the vaccine does work and it is very effective in slowing transmission, if it wasn't a country with little to no natural immunity, and completely reliant on the vaccine would be in a much worse position than a country, such as the UK, with lots of vaccinations plus the natural immunity.

The vaccines have been around ages. It’s possible to have an opinion on them without thinking about covid much anymore.

I don’t think they’ve been very good in relation to transmission. Way less than most people hoped. Some effect? Yes. But not brilliant at all.

I think they’ve seriously cut severe cases, hospitalisations and deaths in the individuals that take them.

I really don’t think this is a controversial opinion, in fact I think many think the same.

So a simple couple of questions - how come Australia doesn't have higher transmission rates? What is holding back the transmission?

The limited effect they’re having on transmission?

I could ask why vax passports did nothing in Europe. (Which were based on vaccines cutting transmission). There’s so many factors it’s difficult to say. 

I don’t think they’re been very effective in that respect, and I think many people think the same. But maybe we have a different idea of what effective looks like, and that’s the difference here.

Article from the BMJ - depends what you class as good at stopping transmission.

https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o298

That’s my fill of covid for the year now. I’m sat in a busy office where transmission is rife! Wink


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - Birdman1811 - 03-22-2022

https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o298

British Medical Journal says they are effective. Non infected people can't transmit the virus. Vaccine prevents infection, therefore is effective at lowering transmission.

It's a respiratory virus, they are extremely hard to stop so long as people are mixing.

Somehow I take what the BMJ says over Dave down the pub.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - backsidebaggie - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 11:12 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o298

British Medical Journal says they are effective. Non infected people can't transmit the virus. Vaccine prevents infection, therefore is effective at lowering transmission.

It's a respiratory virus, they are extremely hard to stop so long as people are mixing.

Somehow I take what the BMJ says over Dave down the pub.

That’s a bit selective tbh. There’s also parts of that article saying they’re poor at it. Particularly with omicron. But anyway, depends what you class as effective. Simple as that.

No idea who Dave in the pub is Wink


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - Birdman1811 - 03-22-2022

No it says poor at lowering viral load in infected persons. That is a shame.

However all medical literature backs up that they are effective at lowering transmission. However, like flu, like colds, like all respiratory viruses, actually stopping transmission without stopping people meeting up is nigh on impossible. We all breath, cough, sneeze and talk. Why masks are so crucial.

The average person can't do statistical analysis well enough to read and understand data, regularly I get someone saying they've 'seen the data', so I ask if they even know how to do something as basic as Linear Regression with that data. Rarely do people even know what that means, let alone how to do it.

So I don't take 'what most people think' with much importance truth be told.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - backsidebaggie - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 11:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: No it says poor at lowering viral load in infected persons. That is a shame.

However all medical literature backs up that they are effective at lowering transmission. However, like flu, like colds, like all respiratory viruses, actually stopping transmission without stopping people meeting up is nigh on impossible. We all breath, cough, sneeze and talk. Why masks are so crucial.

The average person can't do statistical analysis well enough to read and understand data, regularly I get someone saying they've 'seen the data', so I ask if they even know how to do something as basic as Linear Regression with that data. Rarely do people even know what that means, let alone how to do it.

So I don't take 'what most people think' with much importance truth be told.

I think it depends on what we class as effective. I and many others had hoped it would mean it didn’t go through fully vaccinated households, which happens in most cases from what I can see.

If masks are crucial we’re done for in Birmingham, barely one in site at work, shops etc now.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - baggy1 - 03-22-2022

(03-22-2022, 11:03 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 10:32 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 09:39 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-22-2022, 08:52 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry bb but you don't make sense with what you are saying. On one hand you say you don't look at it very deeply anymore and on the other hand you say that you know enough to state that the vaccines haven't been very effective. Then to support your statement you quote Australia as an example of where they have a high vaccination rate and cases are 'through the roof'. When we dive into that it shows that Australia has half the number of cases of the UK and by your own admission very little natural immunity, they also have a current death rate which is half the rate of England - how can this be with so little natural immunity. The answer is very simple in that the vaccine does work and it is very effective in slowing transmission, if it wasn't a country with little to no natural immunity, and completely reliant on the vaccine would be in a much worse position than a country, such as the UK, with lots of vaccinations plus the natural immunity.

The vaccines have been around ages. It’s possible to have an opinion on them without thinking about covid much anymore.

I don’t think they’ve been very good in relation to transmission. Way less than most people hoped. Some effect? Yes. But not brilliant at all.

I think they’ve seriously cut severe cases, hospitalisations and deaths in the individuals that take them.

I really don’t think this is a controversial opinion, in fact I think many think the same.

So a simple couple of questions - how come Australia doesn't have higher transmission rates? What is holding back the transmission?

The limited effect they’re having on transmission?

I could ask why vax passports did nothing in Europe. (Which were based on vaccines cutting transmission). There’s so many factors it’s difficult to say. 

I don’t think they’re been very effective in that respect, and I think many people think the same. But maybe we have a different idea of what effective looks like, and that’s the difference here.

Article from the BMJ - depends what you class as good at stopping transmission.

https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o298

That’s my fill of covid for the year now. I’m sat in a busy office where transmission is rife! Wink

What have vax passports got to do with anything? And why are you keeping referring to 'stopping' transmission - nobody anywhere is talking about stopping, we are talking about reducing transmission.

From the BMJ article you are linking there appear to be some key things that you are ignoring - The vaccine helps you avoid contracting the virus, however if you do contract it the onward transmission is very similar. The problem you appear to be having is you are focussing on the 2nd part of that point rather than all of the point.

In simple numbers it is saying if there are 100 people and 80 are vaccinated (UK vaccination is about 80%) then some of those vaccinated will still transmit the virus. So lets take the figure quoted from 1 dose of the vaccine as reducing transmission by 40-50%, and include that.

Of the 80 vaccinated - 50% of that will still transmit that means 40 individuals will transmit it added to that the 20 that aren't vaccinated therefore 60 of the original 100 will still transmit the virus therefore transmission will have been reduced by 40%. And that is from 1 dose only, 2 doses and boosters will improve that number. 

So again tell me where this notion is that vaccines don't reduce the transmission significantly. 40% after 1 dose alone and higher with more than 1 dose is significant IMO. Whether you agree or not jabs are good to reduce the transmission, they are. In both of the example you have linked (Australia and BMJ article) I can clearly show you why they are good for us all to encourage more uptake.

The alternative is that we keep on going through a cycle of restrictions when it gets bad.


RE: The Illness Formerly Known as Covid - Duffers - 03-22-2022

Shall we just set up a Covid bored where people can have the same fucking arguments over and over again?