WBAUnofficial
Players - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Players (/showthread.php?tid=23796)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Players - clem4england - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.
I am not sure the dictator approach works any more. Maybe with the right players but it seems like the world has moved on and the autocratic managers have been squeezed out. Presumably because players don't respond any longer.


RE: Players - Johnnykayeengland - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 12:31 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.
I am not sure the dictator approach works any more. Maybe with the right players but it seems like the world has moved on and the autocratic managers have been squeezed out. Presumably because players don't respond any longer.
I agree Mr Clem.
I've no idea whether Val has "lost the dressing room", but I have noticed the odd occasion in a break of play and players were not seemingly taking notice of him...
If that's the case then he's had it, sooner or later.
Managers need to listen.


RE: Players - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 12:31 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.
I am not sure the dictator approach works any more. Maybe with the right players but it seems like the world has moved on and the autocratic managers have been squeezed out. Presumably because players don't respond any longer.

I've posted before that I believe players should be allowed to express an opinion and coaches should give credence to the comments of their senior players - let's face it Snods has played a lot more football than Val. That's how it goes in the modern workplace, you enrol people into your way of doing things, not bully them.

Puts me in mind of the airline pilot who didn't know which engine was on fire, so he guessed (wrongly as it happens, 47 people died). The passengers and cabin crew knew which engine was on fire because they could see it. Pilot never asked, they never told him.


RE: Players - Johnnykayeengland - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 09:32 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 04:59 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 01:57 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 01:45 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Anyone remember when Meggo ripped through 30 years of malaise?

It needs that now, and Val may have the attributes to do it, but we live in different times.

Maybe like Megson, Val is the man to sort these tossers out!

Val put Livermore back in and made him undropable. The old bad apples need to be dumped. We know who they are. Sadly they tarnish new / fresh players and the cycle starts all over again.
Val had his chance and blew it.

But do we know who they are? I'd say Livermore, Bartley and Phillips are introspective characters, wrapped up in their own issues, be it football or real life. They probably don't set the agenda, despite their seniority. I guess Johnstone has something of the Billy Big Boots about him nowadays. Sawyers seemed hugely influential and maybe at the centre of the anti-Sam backlash after the Bilic sacking. Robinson seems the kind of live wire who would stir things up, also maybe Ajayi has reacted against being dropped (he said in an interview that he'd never been out of the team before). But this is all surmise, because we don't know, except for the ITKers who tantalise us.

Where do the new signings fit in, Mowatt especially? Are they aligned with Val, is there a rift in the squad? And Snods has only been there 12 months - has he become the ringleader? I don't believe any coach should freeze a player out, it's a sign of weakness not strength, but it's also wrong when players react so obviously to a situation involving another player (Johnstone) by putting in a lacklustre performance. I'm sure they were punishing Ismael, which is completely unacceptable. Are they even doing it deliberately, or just strolling around like sulky teenagers expecting someone else to make things happen?

The whole situation smells very much like the last days of Don Howe, Bobby Gould and Tony Pulis. As though a change of manager is now inevitable, so the players are just waiting for it. I'm not sure how we get out of this.
Some good points. I don't know what is going on any more than you or anyone else. But it's beginning to smell a bit!


RE: Players - UCEbaggie - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 12:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 12:31 PM)clem4england Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.
I am not sure the dictator approach works any more. Maybe with the right players but it seems like the world has moved on and the autocratic managers have been squeezed out. Presumably because players don't respond any longer.

I've posted before that I believe players should be allowed to express an opinion and coaches should give credence to the comments of their senior players - let's face it Snods has played a lot more football than Val. That's how it goes in the modern workplace, you enrol people into your way of doing things, not bully them.

Puts me in mind of the airline pilot who didn't know which engine was on fire, so he guessed (wrongly as it happens, 47 people died). The passengers and cabin crew knew which engine was on fire because they could see it. Pilot never asked, they never told him.

Depends what you mean about "Snods" having played a lot more football than Ismael. VI has won two Bundesliga titles, played for Bayern Munich and played in the Champions League. Snodgrass hasn't ever ascended to those heights I don't reckon.


RE: Players - Tom Joad - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 09:06 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 08:42 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Don't rewrite history.
We looked a superb team under BFS on 2 occasions.
We looked dreadful for a dozen matches.
And we achieved mediocrity for the rest.

I'm not. We were good for a couple of games. We were awful for a dozen games whilst he sorted out the fitness issues that Bilic left and had to wait to sign some players to make us good and we looked a PL side that could compete for the rest. Out of all those out of work I'd have him back immediately.

Point is we only looked a decent side once he'd replaced half the team. Whoever gets the job after Val will have the same problem.

This is it. Big Sam switched them this way then that, and then went out and got some players that made a game of it. Maybe, it isn't the manager?


RE: Players - Sliced - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.

Given he once got fined 30K for abusing drug testers I would take what you've heard with a substantial pinch of salt


RE: Players - BurleyBaggie - 01-28-2022

(01-28-2022, 10:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: From what I've been told, by someone who I know has connections at the club, (I do not), was that all Snodgrass dis was question the tactics as we were often getting overrun in midfield, it was in a group session where tactics were being discussed, so perfectly acceptable, but Val just abruptly shut him down completely. This then triggered the disagreement that led to him being bombed.

If, this is true, and I've no reason to doubt it, but it is anecdotal, then two things arise.

1) Val is so intrinsically ingrained in his approach that no-one else is allowed an opinion, including those that are expected to carry it out.
2) Any other player / coach who has concerns will keep their head down and mouth shut and just go along with it, albeit with a negative mindset.

This is all well and good if it's felt we need a dictatorial manager, who has complete autonomy and does not bow to player rule. If, however, said approach is not working and the players are not on board, then the manager has isolated himself and at the end of the day will be the one who pays the price.

Personally, I agree with Snodgrass and it is an ongoing issue with us being overrun, yet is never addressed, not in the starting formation, or via the use of subs and it will be the thing that, eventually, gets Val the boot.
The good news is that it is easily fixed so, provided Val doesn't leave his blinkers on the desk, the new bloke will at least have a fighting chance.

That’s not strictly true. 

The issue arose in video analysis regarding the goal. Val, well his team, suggested the mistake wasn’t the stray pass it was the fact the ball didn’t go forward as per the tactics. 

It was Snoddy that got defensive and communicated his pass was a failure in having too few in midfield. He was allowed to express his point.  

The issue came, as I was told, was that he refused to accept his mistake or that he should’ve passed it forward. That he believed the fault was not having the extra man. 

Ultimately, it’s a game of tactics, if he wouldn’t do what the coaching team wanted he gets bombed. And so he did…


RE: Players - Sliced - 01-29-2022

(01-28-2022, 09:33 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 09:30 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 08:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Even though it's clear now that Val will not be seeing out his project, whatever your thoughts on that, losing the fans and dressing room is never good.

Our players are an absolute disgrace from stuff working through football circles, absolutely lazy, entitled, self-centred snakes that don't deserve to be at this club, with very, very few exceptions.

Don't let any anger at the manager let these serial losers off the hook either. Maybe 2 or 3 current senior pros deserve any form of contract renewal at the club, the rest should be allowed to go for free, for the good of the club overall. Val won't be the last manager they see off, Allardyce saw through them very well, if he had his way, we'd have got rid of almost everyone in the summer and rebuilt completely, very few would have survived his cull, and he was in the right.

I haven't heard this, but if it's true then we have a real issue. The squad at its most focused would struggle to get promoted, if they are arsing about then we have absolutely no chance.

If we get a manager in like Bilic who let's them do half days, and train as and when they like, and treats it like a Sunday League team, then they'll be happy.

Of course, it's a recipe for disaster long term.

Absolutely. 

It’s taken over a year to flush that lack of fitness out of the club. Unfortunately we also flushed out our best player too.


RE: Players - Hopalong - 01-29-2022

(01-29-2022, 12:06 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 09:33 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-28-2022, 09:30 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-27-2022, 08:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Even though it's clear now that Val will not be seeing out his project, whatever your thoughts on that, losing the fans and dressing room is never good.

Our players are an absolute disgrace from stuff working through football circles, absolutely lazy, entitled, self-centred snakes that don't deserve to be at this club, with very, very few exceptions.

Don't let any anger at the manager let these serial losers off the hook either. Maybe 2 or 3 current senior pros deserve any form of contract renewal at the club, the rest should be allowed to go for free, for the good of the club overall. Val won't be the last manager they see off, Allardyce saw through them very well, if he had his way, we'd have got rid of almost everyone in the summer and rebuilt completely, very few would have survived his cull, and he was in the right.

I haven't heard this, but if it's true then we have a real issue. The squad at its most focused would struggle to get promoted, if they are arsing about then we have absolutely no chance.

If we get a manager in like Bilic who let's them do half days, and train as and when they like, and treats it like a Sunday League team, then they'll be happy.

Of course, it's a recipe for disaster long term.

Absolutely. 

It’s taken over a year to flush that lack of fitness out of the club. Unfortunately we also flushed out our best player too.

Plus we lost the four on loan.  So half the first choice outfield team.   They were replaced with Mowatt, Livermore, Grant, Hugill and Phillips/Robinson.