![]() |
|
EU - Russia - UK - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: EU - Russia - UK (/showthread.php?tid=23607) |
RE: EU - Russia - UK - Remi_Moses - 03-02-2022 (03-01-2022, 10:32 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-01-2022, 05:35 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:(02-25-2022, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Poland & the Baltic States are members of NATO - Ukraine is not, in case it's escaped your attention. So it's OK for Russia to destroy a country. And it's nothing to do with NATO we have turned our back on Ukraine and are so frightened of Russian newks we refuse to bomb legitimate targets in Ukraine. Thanks for the clarification. You are correct it's nothing to do with NATO - EU - USA - UK the destruction of a country with 40 million people is bigger then that. RE: EU - Russia - UK - baggy1 - 03-02-2022 Remi, NATO are nothing to do with this. NATO are a group of countries that agree to defend each other if they get attacked. However, there are many other countries, individually or collectively, that could step in to engage with Russian military but that would require (or actually it would represent) a declaration of war against Russia by that country / or group of countries. That situation would mean Russia would be in a position to directly attack that country (they are at war). It would also mean that other nations could get involved for instance China when are comfortable with Russia's actions in Ukraine. Effectively what you are looking at is the ultimate moral dilemma, does a country's leader risk the lives of not just the military but also the civilian population that it represents to protect another countries military and civilian population. In an ideal world that would always be yes, and has been in the past (Iraq, Afghanistan etc) but this has the potential to escalate very quickly if they do engage. RE: EU - Russia - UK - Birdman1811 - 03-02-2022 We bomb anything in Ukraine. There is every chance Putin launches nukes at us. How the fuck does any leader do that? Whatever you think of our government, at least they aren't that stupid. Putin is a mad man, advised by people feeding his megalomania, telling him he's almost destinied to rebuild the old Russia he loved so dearly. And we've been cosying up to him amd his mates for years now. RE: EU - Russia - UK - Protheroe - 03-02-2022 (03-02-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:(03-01-2022, 10:32 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-01-2022, 05:35 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:(02-25-2022, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Poland & the Baltic States are members of NATO - Ukraine is not, in case it's escaped your attention. No, it's not OK. But neither is destabilising the entire western world by sending in a NATO expeditionary force into a country already at conflict with Russia. We missed several chances to throttle Putin economically over Georgia, Crimea and latterly Donbas. Now he has mainland Europe dependent on his gas, and a hair trigger on his nuclear button; hence the moral dilemma - due we abandon Ukraine militarily in order to preserve western civilisation as we know it and to gradually wean Europe off his fossil fuels, or do we create the conditions for the greatest conflict the world has ever seen. I know which side I'm on. RE: EU - Russia - UK - Ossian - 03-02-2022 Putin is employing the old 'Push out a bayonet' strategy - a turn of phrase supposedly first attributable to Lenin, but utilised by other subsequent Russian and Soviet leaders: Stalin, Kruschev and latterly Putin among them. Nobody can know for certain if he's a high stakes chancer, or a genuine, bona fide nut job. For all any of us know he could be terminally ill, delusional and irrational in any number of other ways. As always, he's left himself just enough wriggle room to claim that the west has deliberately misconstrued his comments. If he still does happen to have all his marbles (and his actions of late suggest otherwise) he's not going to want to get into a shooting match with NATO; he'll certainly be surrounded by others who would want to steer him away from that precipice. But we have to err on the side of caution and adopt the potential madman approach; however frustrating that might be. The sanctions will bite hard and need to be kept in place, possibly in perpetuity. The days of the west supplying Russia with hardware and technology with potential military applications need to be a thing of the past, however lucrative the contracts might have been. Obviously the same could be said of certain other régimes around the world. We shouldn't be helping the Russian economy and certainly not facilitating its military. Let Russia be the pariah state Putin's victim mentality seems to crave. RE: EU - Russia - UK - baggy1 - 03-02-2022 And there is another angle as well, I was speaking with a colleague in Moscow today who works closely with our team in Kyiv, she has been telling us stories of what is happening and she is appalled. A lot of the Russian people are aware of what is going on and are against it, we need to make sure we are not punishing them indefinitely because of Putin's actions - he, despite his power, is not Russia. Our best shot at this is through sanctions that do hurt enough to make the military think it's time for a change, the people alone won't be able to do this as they are censored as soon as they protest. RE: EU - Russia - UK - Remi_Moses - 03-02-2022 (03-02-2022, 02:14 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And there is another angle as well, I was speaking with a colleague in Moscow today who works closely with our team in Kyiv, she has been telling us stories of what is happening and she is appalled. A lot of the Russian people are aware of what is going on and are against it, we need to make sure we are not punishing them indefinitely because of Putin's actions - he, despite his power, is not Russia. I understand everything posters are saying, but we cannot be intimidated by a bully. And to leave the Ukraine to burn makes us as bad as Putin probably worse. Looking ahead Ukraine will fold in a few days time. The power will be switched off and we won't see the full scale of the atrocities being committed. The Ukraine people will never forgive us for turning our backs in their hour of need. The way people are thinking we better reverse the sanctions because if it's going to harm Putin he may just launch anyway. The very idea of allowing this obliteration to happen is wrong on every level. We could do so much, paint war planes in Ukrainian colours and go and blast the crap out of the military convoy's. Send unmarked drones over. Give Ukraine a sub with some tomahawk cruise missiles and let them do what they like with them. But we won't do anything because we are scared. There are no easy options in war. I hear nations say if he attacks a NATO country it's different. Because of a signature on a piece of paper. I say what about the signed declaration that the USA UK and Russia signed saying the would ensure Ukraine was protected if it gave up it's WMD. Signatures on paper and red lines don't count for much when war is underway. RE: EU - Russia - UK - Shabby Russian - 03-03-2022 (03-01-2022, 05:35 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:(02-25-2022, 02:16 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Poland & the Baltic States are members of NATO - Ukraine is not, in case it's escaped your attention. On Kuwait, from memory the war was sanctioned by the UN. On Afghanistan , this was the only time NATO'S article 5 was used. The military action by NATO was sanctioned because the USA had been attacked and they requested that NATO took military action to prevent further attacks . The odd war out was the second gulf war which was not sanctioned by the UN or NATO. RE: EU - Russia - UK - baggy1 - 03-03-2022 Thanks for clarifying the Afghanistan war Shabbs, I'd not got that down as a NATO operation. RE: EU - Russia - UK - WorcsWBA - 03-03-2022 I wonder why the Tories are dawdling over implementing sanctions against Russian oligarchs? Other countries seem to be getting their similar sanctions off the ground with alacrity.This "Government" is all talk and little action, and what action it does take typically ends up with a u-turn because it got things wrong. It's the most incompetent and corrupt government that I can ever remember (going back 50 years). |